Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Ben Prout on August 11, 2022, 02:55:20 PM

Title: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Ben Prout on August 11, 2022, 02:55:20 PM
I'm 19, so not really able to buy a bunch of tools and just have a go in my shed...we don't have a shed!

Does anyone have any idea how I could get into melodeon repair with guidance, I don't really trust myself to take it from a book, and I'm not particularly handy but I'm very passionate about these instruments and it'd be a great skill to have.
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Brian Wyneken on August 11, 2022, 06:00:47 PM
I dabble in repair (and am pretty cautious about it). The sources that I used to get started are Rich Edwards "Kitchen Table Melodeon" (YouTube)and Lester Bailey's website. I did buy a broken-down accordion for the bellows to make a simple tuning table, and I think my total investment in tools is pretty modest. Rich goes through the tools and materials in one of his videos.

A dedicated toolbox and any area for workspace can serve in lieu of a shed/shop, but it helps if others you live with are willing to cooperate in your pursuit.

Good luck!
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Theo on August 11, 2022, 06:10:45 PM
As a minimum you need a table or other work surface.  Ideally where you can sit with your knees under the table for comfort.  A bit of space to lay out parts is also quite important.  That can be a large tray that you can put away between sessions.
Tools you need to get started are quite modest.  A couple of good quality screwdrivers,  a puller for removing bellows pins. If you plan to try tuning you need a support plate, and a reed hook, both of which you can make.  You will also need a scratcher and at least one small high quality file, either diamond fine grit, or traditional Swiss needle file.
A tuning bellows is useful for your investigating reeds that don’t work but is not essential.   

Dive in, have a go, that’s how I started.
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on August 11, 2022, 06:48:46 PM
Buy the best quality tools you can nearly afford, as you need them. You won't regret it.
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Dennis Steckley on August 11, 2022, 07:17:35 PM
If you're on the US side of the pond, Scott Bellinger offers periodic workshops on repair.  I just completed one in May, and was quite satisfied.  Scott is here on melnet.

Dennis Steckley
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Andrew Kennedy on August 11, 2022, 07:56:20 PM
I don't know whether he still offers this service, but a few years ago I was talking to Pete Grassby about a repair and he offered (for a suitable price) to come to my house and show me how to do it.

I declined his offer.  I think this was after I put myself into A&E with a head injury whilst trying to change the exhaust on a Land Rover, but before I had to call the fire brigade after drilling through a gas pipe (after which I was officially relieved of diy duties).
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Andy Next Tune on August 11, 2022, 10:02:38 PM
Look out for and buy a very, very cheap old East German melodeon on eBay, or at a car boot sale, or wherever. Or ask in the Forum Buy & Sell whether someone has an unwanted/unfinished 'project box' sitting on a shelf which they'll donate to you.
Whatever you get, it will almost certainly need lots of work in different areas to get it even half playable.
Use it as your playground to learn about fixing air leaks, refacing pallets, tuning reeds, etc etc as you gather a few tools together, and before you touch a 'decent' box.

And the construction of those boxes is very similar to Hohner Pokerworks etc. You will learn a lot just taking them apart and putting them back together.

Charlie Marshall at CGM Musical Services is the go-to person for the assorted bits and pieces needed to fix up boxes. If in doubt, call him, he's very helpful and knowledgeable.

Lester's videos take you through almost every step in the process of bringing an old box back into a playable condition.

Finally, if in doubt, do ask. As well as the professional fettlers on this forum, there are many other members who have worked on their own melodeons and/or brought old ones back to life.

Have fun!!!


Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Graham Spencer on August 12, 2022, 07:35:32 AM
Look out for and buy a very, very cheap old East German melodeon on eBay, or at a car boot sale, or wherever. Or ask in the Forum Buy & Sell whether someone has an unwanted/unfinished 'project box' sitting on a shelf which they'll donate to you.
Whatever you get, it will almost certainly need lots of work in different areas to get it even half playable.
Use it as your playground to learn about fixing air leaks, refacing pallets, tuning reeds, etc etc as you gather a few tools together, and before you touch a 'decent' box.


Indeed - the first one I took apart came from a car boot sale and cost me £2.
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Anahata on August 12, 2022, 07:51:30 AM
Or an old piano accordion. Plentiful and cheap, and with lots of reeds to practise valving, waxing and tuning.
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Lester on August 12, 2022, 08:53:55 AM
Or an old piano accordion. Plentiful and cheap, and with lots of reeds to practise valving, waxing and tuning.
And one less PA in the world  :D
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Squeaky Pete on August 12, 2022, 09:19:50 AM
Everything that has been posted here is sound advice.
4 years ago I had little idea what to do and didn't want to spend on anything that I might ultimately not use.
Although I have a background in furniture design/making and have made and fettled Northumbrian small pipes since the 70s I was very much a beginner with free reeds. Now after much trial and error, and many hours (perhaps not wasted) I can strip a box and rebuild it the way I want and to sound like I want. There is still much I only half understand, but there will be someone here who has the knowledge.
I suppose I have spent £50 on dedicated gear I would not have used otherwise and most of this will last me out.
The most valuable thing is advice, and on here that is free.
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: dino.pafftti on August 12, 2022, 11:13:10 AM
As a minimum you need a table or other work surface.  Ideally where you can sit with your knees under the table for comfort.  A bit of space to lay out parts is also quite important.  That can be a large tray that you can put away between sessions.
Tools you need to get started are quite modest.  A couple of good quality screwdrivers,  a puller for removing bellows pins. If you plan to try tuning you need a support plate, and a reed hook, both of which you can make.  You will also need a scratcher and at least one small high quality file, either diamond fine grit, or traditional Swiss needle file.
A tuning bellows is useful for your investigating reeds that don’t work but is not essential.   

Dive in, have a go, that’s how I started.

What is a good file grit ??
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Lester on August 12, 2022, 11:22:13 AM
What is a good file grit ??
I use these (https://www.axminstertools.com/vallorbe-precision-swiss-saw-file-extra-slim-100mm-4-951038)
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Theo on August 12, 2022, 01:06:17 PM
For diamond files I use 600 grit file from Eternal Tools.
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Steve C. on August 12, 2022, 01:19:51 PM
OP:  take a look at Lesters How to Hot Rod Your Hohner YouTubes and then find that proverbial beat up, but not too beat up Pokerwork. A few improvised and purchased tools.  The whole lot could fit into a box one could set up and take down down on the dining room table!
[warning: your experience may vary regarding the dining room table]
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: dino.pafftti on August 12, 2022, 04:57:50 PM
thanks, Theo and Lester,  :||:
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Ben Prout on August 13, 2022, 09:39:35 PM
I'd like to say thank you for the outpouring of support and guidance, it's really encouraged me to have a go and tinker about. I have an old, busted, antique-shop piano accordion, surely there's no harm in taking it apart and seeing what's inside! I will certainly look at the resources provided and see where I go, thank you all very much.
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Rog on August 14, 2022, 08:03:41 AM
This is a great resource, based on PAs, but it is all transferable to melodeons. If you go through the whole site you get a pretty good guide to most areas of PA maintenance.
https://accordionrevival.com/

If you want to get some basic files that don’t cost an arm and a leg, I use Draper needle files a lot. Also the sharp point or corners on the files work very well as a scratcher, so you don’t (necessarily) need to shell out for a separate tool.
https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Draper-82577-Needle-File-Set-Precision-Jewellers-Small-Metal-Hand-140mm-6-Pack-/302669252633?mkcid=16&mkevt=1&_trksid=p2349624.m46890.l6249&mkrid=710-127635-2958-0
Finally, here's a short video showing how to use a hook to get at the inside reed. It’s filmed on my foot pedal operated tuning table, so I have both hands free.

https://youtu.be/FMuma-gFx88

You can make a hook with a piece of piano wire and a length of dowel. Or Charley Marshall sells them (though I found the radius on the hook just a bit too big for me, which is why I made my own).
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Chris Harris on January 20, 2023, 05:51:35 PM

Finally, here's a short video showing how to use a hook to get at the inside reed. It’s filmed on my foot pedal operated tuning table, so I have both hands free.

https://youtu.be/FMuma-gFx88

You can make a hook with a piece of piano wire and a length of dowel. Or Charley Marshall sells them (though I found the radius on the hook just a bit too big for me, which is why I made my own).

Hi, sorry YouTube video not available as it is private?
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Winston Smith on January 20, 2023, 06:44:43 PM
I'm sitting here wondering why I haven't seen this thread before now, I'm stumped!
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Scobarandbar on January 20, 2023, 09:01:17 PM
You may well have been getting in your final practice sessions in before Whitby… >:E
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: diatonix on January 20, 2023, 09:14:51 PM
It depends on one's goal. There is a huge difference between treating it as a private pastime and making it into a source of income. If the latter is the case,  buying fancy tools, watching a couple of youtube tutorials (most of which are, politely put, pathetic) and reading some books won't get you anywhere. Like any other profession it should be treated and respected as one, which means that one has to invest time (we are talking years), energy and passion. An apprenticeship at a workshop run by a professional  is a must and a minimum.
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Steve C. on January 22, 2023, 04:49:26 PM
Diatonix: true that.

In the long ago mists of time when I was attempting to become a piano tuner I must have tuned 10 or more pianos and then PAID someone else to retune them properly.
'Course each retune was a good lesson learnt the hard way.

Still on topic:

For those that have started out "amateur" and then moved to "for hire". 
How does one know thoughst art ready?  How many repairs does one have to do for friends at no charge before asking for pay?

S






Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Theo on January 22, 2023, 06:00:31 PM
It’s a conundrum.  When the friends you’ve done free repairs come back and offer to pay for the next job.  And when you are prepared to stand behind your work and give a guarantee of quality.
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Rog on January 22, 2023, 07:10:42 PM
It’s not a conundrum. I think Diatonix is wrong. In the UK we believe in general training and transferable skills.
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Pete Dunk on January 22, 2023, 11:23:16 PM
It’s not a conundrum. I think Diatonix is wrong. In the UK we believe in general training and transferable skills.


Isn’t it? As it happens I too disagree with diatonix on this occasion. Personally I would however hesitate to express an opinion on behalf of the whole of the UK for fear that just one person might disagree and that in this case I might actually be wrong.


Unimpressed of Kent.
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: boxcall on January 23, 2023, 12:59:20 AM
I mostly agree with diatonix and believe that skills need to be developed over time ( like any art / skill ) and with supervision of the more skilled , on hand training if possible is a plus! Some folks picking things up quicker than others . More passionate / invested maybe?
This is interesting because a friend ( pretty much begging) hand me an accordion to repair, I beg her to look elsewhere .
Don’t worry it’s a PA!!
Anyway I am no where near pro but think I have gotten good / decent results on a couple boxes I fixed up for myself.
But if time is money I will never make money doing it for money! Maybe with good training and a better all around set up.
I know when I’m done getting this small PA back in playing again. I will maybe make $2 an hour if that :) 
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: diatonix on January 23, 2023, 07:10:04 PM
Of course I don't expect everybody to agree with me. But again: It depends on one's goal. Either you remain an amateur and are happy with that or you aim to become a professional. Why should accordion repair be different from other professions? In my country it takes at least 4 years to become a certified automobile mechanic. Surely there is a reason for that. And don't tell me that accordion repair/tuning (and everything that comes with it) is a lesser challenge. By the way: During several years I was an instructor for accordion repair students preparing them for their official German certificate (4 years!). I think I know what I'm talking about.
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Theo on January 23, 2023, 09:37:33 PM
Unfortunately we brits as a nation are not good linguists, so there is a barrier to studying in Germany or Italy, and we don’t have any courses of our own.  So we sort of muddle through.  Perhaps it’s another national characteristic.  In my own case I could say I’m self taught, but I have taken every opportunity to watch others makers and repairers, talk to them and learn  from them.  Add to that countless hours of practice.  I’ve made many mistakes and have learned from the ones that I’ve detected, or that others have detected for me.
I’m still striving to improve.
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Stiamh on January 24, 2023, 02:20:43 AM
In my country it takes at least 4 years to become a certified automobile mechanic. Surely there is a reason for that.

Yes, of course. But has anybody ever died (or caused death or serious injury to others) as the result of playing an accordion maintained by an amateur?
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Winston Smith on January 24, 2023, 07:40:15 AM
"has anybody ever died"

Probably not, but in my own cases possibly the music may have been killed, or maimed in some way?
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Arnold on January 24, 2023, 11:19:31 AM
We plucky amateurs are really only a danger to ourselves. I was once almost mortally wounded attempting to remove a bellows pin from a Hohner 1040. Owing to my good fortune, my severed arm turned out to be merely but a flesh wound…

Still, perhaps best leave it to the pros!..  :D
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Squeaky Pete on January 24, 2023, 11:57:01 AM
The only thing to do (UK anyway) as far as I can see is to just have a go.
An autopsy on a dead PA will teach you a lot and yield huge amounts of useful bits for future Frankenstein projects.
There is so much advice freely given in places like Melnet and generally online and if there is something specific you don't understand, ask. It's what I do.
Without a dedicated course and no apprenticeships it's going to be self teaching. As Theo says you learn from your mistakes, so make mistakes and learn.
Fettle an old box with the intention of selling it on. You will have in the back of your mind that someone good is going to delve inside it one day, maybe to repair a broken spring, so you want it to look right as well as play and sound right. So go slowly and carefully.
The feeling when someone lets you know a few weeks later how pleased they are is a great incentive.
If you've taken a week to do a 3 hour job to achieve this, it really doesn't matter as it's the start of the learning curve, as long as you have used the time to do a proper job. Next time you might do a 5 hour job in a week. In a year a 5 hour job might take a day and you are starting to get there but there is no short cut to spending time learning to do proper work quickly.
I have no intention of becoming professional. I'm retired and enjoy pottering. I fix up old boxes and sell them so I can buy more old boxes. Local players come to me for odd repairs and some tuning problems which is nice, but I don't want to be under time pressure to get a faulty box back to the player for a gig.
So That will get you to a stage where you if you want to be a professional it's a dilemma. Go abroad for a dedicated course or work up enough experience while doing something else that pays the bills?
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: diatonix on January 24, 2023, 12:29:00 PM
In my country it takes at least 4 years to become a certified automobile mechanic. Surely there is a reason for that.

Yes, of course. But has anybody ever died (or caused death or serious injury to others) as the result of playing an accordion maintained by an amateur?

Ok, since you do not seem to get my point, let me re-phrase: In my country it takes at least 4 years to become a certified baker, house painter or interior architect. Let me know if it is still not clear.
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Arnold on January 24, 2023, 12:46:28 PM
Me: guiltily tucking in to home baked cookie on my lunch break  :|bl
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Stiamh on January 24, 2023, 01:05:53 PM
In my country it takes at least 4 years to become a certified automobile mechanic. Surely there is a reason for that.

Yes, of course. But has anybody ever died (or caused death or serious injury to others) as the result of playing an accordion maintained by an amateur?

Ok, since you do not seem to get my point, let me re-phrase: In my country it takes at least 4 years to become a certified baker, house painter or interior architect. Let me know if it is still not clear.


I don't think you get my point, either. Happy Tuesday to you.
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Jozz on January 24, 2023, 02:09:19 PM
Yes, of course. But has anybody ever died (or caused death or serious injury to others) as the result of playing an accordion maintained by an amateur?

https://www.accordionists.info/threads/killer-accordion.8258/

 :Ph
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Winston Smith on January 24, 2023, 06:20:29 PM
It would seem that diatonix is meaning a proper apprenticeship, like we used to have for tradesmen in England before the country's standards went all to pot. I don't think that apprenticeships are a 'thing' any more, as everyone just learns about doing things with computers etc. Hence real tradesmen can charge as much as they like for the skilled work they do, whilst those that cannot afford to pay them follow YouTube videos and try to do it themselves.
I come across this sort of 'dilutie' type of thing all the time, where I am now. So much so that I've had to learn the basics of every building trade skill known to man! How many other colour blind electricians do you know?
There are a great many situations where knowledgeable folk 'teach' for money, but even they are generally self-taught without any particular qualification, for teaching or otherwise.
This discussion will get us nowhere, I fear.
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Pearse Rossa on January 24, 2023, 07:29:34 PM
During several years I was an instructor for accordion repair students preparing them for their official German certificate (4 years!).

Is there a professional body or competent authority empowered by the state to validate/support
accreditation of this certificate?
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: -Y- on January 24, 2023, 10:34:48 PM
I agree with diatonix. But I know it's not possible everywhere to have a proper training with professionals. Even when you have a somewhat official training (like the one I'm currently following this year), it's not guaranteed that it'll be long enough (in France, there is no "official" way of having a training as long as the Germans do, for instance, but there's still a school, and even if it lasts only one school year it's always better than nothing).
Of course as others said, there are some countries where you can't really do that, so you either have to go abroads to learn, or find and established tuner that will want to teach, or be on your own (in that respect the support on this forum is great). And while I also agree with diatonix that it depends if you want to make this your profession or not, I also understand that it's not either easy or even possible to be properly trained, depending on the country you live in.
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Arnold on January 25, 2023, 12:52:07 PM
In the UK (or at least my part of south east England) the accordion of any sort is very much a niche instrument, with very little general public awareness, except mostly an association with French cafe music. In over 20 years of involvement in music education for example, I have never known, or even known of, an accordion student. It would therefore I think not be viable to run officially accredited apprenticeships in accordion repair and so on over here… Still, thankfully it seems that each region has someone who is up to the task!..
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on January 25, 2023, 05:55:57 PM
Every year, I get a catalogue of adult and community vocational and non-vocational courses offered  my local authority. I have done a few in my time and found them very rewarding.

How I wish freed reed instrument fettling, especialy specialising in melodeons was one of them. I know they were open to approaches by people with appropriate skills. I wonder if they still are. Could be a bit of income for a working or retired fettler. I, for one, would travel the length of the county, or more, for a course run by Microbot.

[erm, as I would for a course run by any of the fettlers round this site, if they were more local.]

Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Jozz on January 26, 2023, 09:41:20 AM
I'm 19, so not really able to buy a bunch of tools and just have a go in my shed...we don't have a shed!

Does anyone have any idea how I could get into melodeon repair with guidance, I don't really trust myself to take it from a book, and I'm not particularly handy but I'm very passionate about these instruments and it'd be a great skill to have.

if you want to go the school route maybe (like in my country) you can apply for the luthier minor at 'instrument builders school' and they let you branch out into a custom accordion/melodeon major - this will often involve a special tutor and examination setup because students and staff are so few - the main benefit is that you will have access to the workshop and get 3d modelling software freebies
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on January 26, 2023, 10:46:48 AM
You could move to Italy

https://www.accordioncraftacademy.com/en/courses/course-for-accordion-repairers-tier1

Maybe it's time to brush up on your Italian.
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: baz parkes on January 26, 2023, 10:50:50 AM
Winston asked How many other colour blind electricians do you know?

I believe there's at least one other on the forum (:) :|glug
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: diatonix on January 30, 2023, 10:49:13 PM
During several years I was an instructor for accordion repair students preparing them for their official German certificate (4 years!).

Is there a professional body or competent authority empowered by the state to validate/support
accreditation of this certificate?

Yes of course: The German Handwerkskammer.
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Winston Smith on January 31, 2023, 07:11:59 AM
Being the devil's advocate (just for a minute!); who taught the originators of 'The German Handwerkskammer'?
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Peadar on January 31, 2023, 09:29:53 AM
Being the devil's advocate (just for a minute!); who taught the originators of 'The German Handwerkskammer'?
Across Europe  (including England and Scotland) we can trace the development of trades and professions to the medieval craft guilds and universities.

The real distinction historically (18th-20th century) made between trades and professions (a British distinction which may not be valid in Germany) is that the application of manual skill is the hallmark of a trade and the application of academic knowledge is the hallmark of a profession.

I know little of the German education system, but I do know that in the early 1980's the standard of education expected in the German graduate professions was normally a post graduate doctorate, while in the UK an ordinary degree was the standard. Germany has a much longer tradition of higher/further education in trades than Britain has. We only set out a plan for a national network of technical colleges to support apprenticeships in the 1940's. 
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Winston Smith on January 31, 2023, 11:21:58 AM
Thank you Dear Peader, that was certainly a good answer to the straightforward question. Perhaps if pursued my formal education until I'd taken even my mock GCE's, I'd have been able to somehow make it plain that my question was, in fact, rhetorical?
The point I was trying to make was that there always has to be one person (at the beginning) who is self-taught, and that any subsequent 'qualification' stems from his/her trial and error (or other method of) experimentation. The perceived need for such a qualification may develop because of safety concerns for either the repairer or the user/public, or to ensure that the integrity of the object in maintained, or in order to safeguard the livelihood of the repairer and his fellows by keeping out those of whom they don't approve, for whatever reason.
For instance (and to get back to accordions before I'm warned off!) who first dared to take apart Mr Demians contraption when it went wrong? Was it with his consent? Did Mr Demian give him adequate training, etc etc?
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: -Y- on January 31, 2023, 11:59:40 AM
The point I was trying to make was that there always has to be one person (at the beginning) who is self-taught, and that any subsequent 'qualification' stems from his/her trial and error (or other method of) experimentation.
That is perfectly true, but then we also do not have to reinvent the wheel each time we want to build a cart, do we?
Experimenting and finding stuff is interesting, makes for a good hobby, but if you want to provide a service, I think it's another matter entirely. Mind you, even professionally trained tuners/repairers continue to learn things about their craft all their life.
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Pearse Rossa on January 31, 2023, 12:27:45 PM
During several years I was an instructor for accordion repair students preparing them for their official German certificate (4 years!).

Is there a professional body or competent authority empowered by the state to validate/support
accreditation of this certificate?

Yes of course: The German Handwerkskammer.

Thank you for the reply. That sounds like an excellent system! I would imagine that a similar
qualification is available in Italy, but what other countries, if any, offer such courses I wonder?
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on January 31, 2023, 12:37:07 PM
...there always has to be one person (at the beginning) who is self-taught, and that any subsequent 'qualification' stems from his/her trial and error (or other method of) experimentation...

I imagine the original expertise came through an apprentiship system, with craftsmen who were working in accordion manufacture teaching their trade to subsequent generations. When the technical colleges (supported by the handwerkskammer?) were looking for people to become trainers they will have recruited skilled people  from industry and trained them as educators.

That's how I started out back in the mid 70s. Our system was very similar to the German system, in some ways, if you wanted to be trained as  a builder or a carpenter, etc., but it didn't include accordion fettling.

Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Winston Smith on January 31, 2023, 02:09:02 PM
"professionally trained tuners/repairers continue to learn things about their craft all their life."

Exactly!
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Theo on January 31, 2023, 02:46:19 PM
"professionally trained tuners/repairers continue to learn things about their craft all their life."

Exactly!

And occasionally a college trained person can be under the mistaken belief that they know it all, and then remain mediocre at best.  Thankfully this is quite rare.
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 31, 2023, 02:51:18 PM
I've been finding this an interesting discussion, and I think it reflects a very broad cultural difference between us in the UK and the Continent.
We in the UK seem to have a very different take on the whole concept of the melodeon/diatonic button accordion.
The melodeon here has a very limited and niche existence evolving around our folk world ( which again is seen as a small non mainstream group of people ).
We are starting to organise teaching and learning, but from what I gather we are miles behind our European cousins who treat it as a 'real' instrument that one can take seriously and go to musical institutions and learn to play .

Consequently, with any 'real' instrument you have people who can repair or make from scratch with a formal way of learning those repairing and instrument making skills.


Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 31, 2023, 04:41:55 PM

   Most, if not all of the music teachers in France will be diplomatisé and Mustradem used to offer a different rate on their 1 week courses for  formation coninue = in job training.  I suspect that having a diploma might be true of makers and repairers/tuners. eg Bertrand Gaillard is a trained cabinet maker. France is … like that.

   
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 31, 2023, 05:05:03 PM
Before I started playing melodeon I remember friends talking about a gentleman called Ivor Hyde, renown in the South West for his melodeon tuning and repairing. Though apparently still working into his old age he is sadly no longer with us. Another friend told me he was 'Hohner trained'.
Whilst absolutely not distracting from our skilled fettlers currently working now, perhaps we did have some formally trained people in the past?

I've had the pleasure of attending some workshops run by a Belgian lady of stunning musical ability and formal music background. Her skills were way beyond 'folk music' and exhibited an incredible knowledge of music. I suspect you're absolutely correct there Chris.
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: rees on January 31, 2023, 07:53:20 PM
I'm not sure if I've got this right but I seem to remember Ivor Hyde telling me that he trained at Clinkscale Accordions in Scotland.
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 31, 2023, 09:01:23 PM
Ah maybe Rees, it was only second hand info. I had.
Sounds like he had some formal training though.
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: rees on January 31, 2023, 09:22:19 PM
One thing I remember about Ivor - he would never reach into a box of plastic valves with his fingers, he always used a plastic tweezers.
Less risk of damaging the valves (handy hint!)
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Theo on January 31, 2023, 09:27:59 PM
Also makes it easier to pick up a single valve instead of a small handful.
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Blenchy on June 26, 2023, 09:58:54 PM
Not sure how helpful this'll be but my first instrument repair was on a very cheap and cheerful nameless 8 bass piano accordion. I think it was 20 quid on Ebay. Rattling brass reeds, reeds not speaking, clacking percussive pallets, out of tune reeds and much much more. It took a lot of forum searching and YouTube watching to find fixes for each individual issue I found and I had a go at fixing each bit. I made many MANY mistakes but learnt and awful lot! So if you can afford to, I'd say buy a cheap beat up box and see what you can fix!

I think Theo summed up what tools and space you need better than I could. I still sometimes use a tray on my desk when its too cold for the shed.

Hope you find this encouraging!  ;D
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Theo on June 27, 2023, 09:26:59 AM
That’s petty much how I started too Blenchy,  only my first old wreck was a Hohner Liliput,  also cost £20.  I found it in the small ads in the local paper.  That shows how long ago it was!
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Mazelman on June 27, 2023, 04:39:05 PM
I'm 19, so not really able to buy a bunch of tools and just have a go in my shed...we don't have a shed!

Does anyone have any idea how I could get into melodeon repair with guidance, I don't really trust myself to take it from a book, and I'm not particularly handy but I'm very passionate about these instruments and it'd be a great skill to have.

if you want to go the school route maybe (like in my country) you can apply for the luthier minor at 'instrument builders school' and they let you branch out into a custom accordion/melodeon major - this will often involve a special tutor and examination setup because students and staff are so few - the main benefit is that you will have access to the workshop and get 3d modelling software freebies

I'm essentially doing this right now, but taking a slightly different route. I'm doing a 4 year woodworking furniture makers course, which requires you to pick a specialisation after 2 years, with one of the options being instrument making. Considering most teachers only have luthier experience, you're encouraged to seek out specialists on whichever instrument you want to make. I was able to do an officially licenced internship with Karel van der Leeuw, learning to do fettling and tuning for the past 10 weeks.

I cannot recommend doing something similar enough (if you're able to). I learned a ton from taking apart and repairing small things on my Hohners myself, but having a master to learn from saves you from having to personally reinvent the wheel every step of the way.
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Winston Smith on June 27, 2023, 07:35:39 PM
"saves you from having to personally reinvent the wheel every step of the way."

I'm finding that that's at least half the fun! (About 8 years in so far, lol.)
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Gonk on June 27, 2023, 08:21:49 PM
The first instrument I tuned was a $20 melodica.  Easy to tune with the reeds still in the instrument, so you can test the pitch as you go.  And you can try wild experiments if you want, like tuning the whole thing up a half step, or to just intonation.  If all goes well you will have reduced the number of out-of-tune melodicas in the world, which may not cause the gates of heaven to fling open but is a good deed nonetheless...
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Ben Prout on June 27, 2023, 10:51:47 PM
I'm 19, so not really able to buy a bunch of tools and just have a go in my shed...we don't have a shed!

Does anyone have any idea how I could get into melodeon repair with guidance, I don't really trust myself to take it from a book, and I'm not particularly handy but I'm very passionate about these instruments and it'd be a great skill to have.

if you want to go the school route maybe (like in my country) you can apply for the luthier minor at 'instrument builders school' and they let you branch out into a custom accordion/melodeon major - this will often involve a special tutor and examination setup because students and staff are so few - the main benefit is that you will have access to the workshop and get 3d modelling software freebies

I'm essentially doing this right now, but taking a slightly different route. I'm doing a 4 year woodworking furniture makers course, which requires you to pick a specialisation after 2 years, with one of the options being instrument making. Considering most teachers only have luthier experience, you're encouraged to seek out specialists on whichever instrument you want to make. I was able to do an officially licenced internship with Karel van der Leeuw, learning to do fettling and tuning for the past 10 weeks.

I cannot recommend doing something similar enough (if you're able to). I learned a ton from taking apart and repairing small things on my Hohners myself, but having a master to learn from saves you from having to personally reinvent the wheel every step of the way.

This has DEFINITELY sparked my interest, where is it you're doing this?
Title: Re: How would a student get into fettling/melodeon repair?
Post by: Mazelman on June 29, 2023, 11:22:08 AM
That's the tricky part: I'm Dutch and doing this in the Netherlands. I have no idea if there's a similar path out there in the UK that could work for you aswell. I think the most important factor is finding an experienced fettler (within a reasonable commuting distance) who is willing to teach you the trade. No idea if it's possible to do that in the same way as I did by making the established tradeschool-apprenticeship system work for you.

I initially didn't set out to pursue this exact path when I enrolled in trade school, I was mostly interested in other kinds of woodworking.  I also don't expect to be able to sustain myself with fettling and/or building melodeons and accordions (immediately) so it's nice to receive broader education that will at least leave you with a backup plan. People will probably always want custom kitchens and bookshelves for the foreseeable future.
Do you have any particular goals in mind of making this your carreer or are you looking to mainly do it for the fun? (which it is!)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal