Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: rees on November 01, 2009, 10:34:18 PM

Title: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: rees on November 01, 2009, 10:34:18 PM
Well, I bought the Paddy Clancy C#/D on eBay this evening, or at least I thought I did.  ???

A few minutes after the auction ended, the seller informed me that he had sold the instrument to someone else this very day but had not had time to cancel the auction.

Seller i.d. is "lomanspark" based in Berlin. Treat with caution.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: graememackay on November 01, 2009, 10:52:48 PM
There's nothing worse than not getting what you thought you bought!

It's happened to me a couple of times, normally when it's a complete bargain and the seller ain't happy about the amount.  But that's never the excuse they give you of course.

my best one was..."You live in Inverness, that'll be £100 more to deliver it, it's an offshore island"   ??? Although it didn't say that in the delivery terms! Needless to say, I didn't get the item.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Keithypete. on November 01, 2009, 11:05:31 PM
Rees, sorry to hear you got turned over re the Paddy Clancy. It seemed 'too good to be true' at that price. I asked the seller why they were selling and if there was a reserve, through e-bay's own message service. In the reply the seller said he/she thought the reserve of £1200 was 'pretty reasonable', and that their 4 voice Gaillard had been restored. I nearly bought a similar one off e-bay a few weeks ago which went for more sensible money, but there were problems of a different nature with that one.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: rees on November 02, 2009, 12:14:32 AM
It certainly was a bargain price and I don't blame the seller for not wanting to let it go for that amount, but at least he could have owned up to the fact.

Ah well, some you win and some you don't. I'll plod on with the old Double Ray C#/D which I am very fond of and perhaps I'll find an Old Grey Paolo in a car boot sale next week.

Always look on the bright side of life, tee tum, tee tum tee tum tee tum.  :|glug
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Gandy on November 02, 2009, 10:24:33 AM
That stinks, after all your bid is supposed to be binding but the sellers are left free to cop out if they think they're not getting the value they want.   In my experience Ebay doesn't give a stuff, and you often see listings where the seller explicitly says he'll end the listing early if he sells elsewhere.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Theo on November 02, 2009, 11:08:10 AM
I think ebay is much less of a fun place now, and the fees are higher now, so there is more incentive to do a deal privately to avoid the fees.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: strad on November 02, 2009, 11:44:25 AM
THREAD DRIFT

Graeme, Inverness is on an offshore island together with the rest of Scotland & England & Wales.
 :P :|glug

Nigel
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: graememackay on November 02, 2009, 11:50:31 AM
Yes, we are all on an island off the coast of Shetland. 
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: strad on November 02, 2009, 12:01:06 PM
How come I've got "Quote", "Modify" & "Remove" at the top of my post while Graeme only has "Quote"?
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Theo on November 02, 2009, 12:02:40 PM
Because you can edit your own post but not other peoples, and you can quote other peoples posts in yours.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: graememackay on November 02, 2009, 12:08:36 PM
It's ok he's new  ;D
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Theo on November 02, 2009, 12:15:12 PM
It's ok he's new  ;D

And, guessing from his handle, a fiddle player.  >:E
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: graememackay on November 02, 2009, 12:27:39 PM
Got it in one!  But he does play a B/C melodeon so I'm letting him off
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Eddie Smyth on November 02, 2009, 12:37:18 PM
Hi to all you guys that are discussing the alleged irresponsible eBayer.
I am the so called irresponsible eBayer and
I would like to put a few things straight here.

The accordion was advertised elsewhere(here on melodeon.net for example), i cant put this in my ebay listing or they will remove it as they have done before.
I was contacted on Sun with an offer for the accordion and i accepted that offer, as there is a 12 hour deadline with ebay i was then unable to cancel the listing  before it ended. I dont need to find excuses if i have no wish to sell the instrument.

I can of course accept that some of you may have had bad experiences on eBay as i have had myself but please dont tar us all with the one brush. You can of course treat any ebayer with caution but if you check my i.d .''lomanspark''  you will of course see that out of 130 dealings  i have a 100% rating.

Anyone looking for a Mengascini 2 Row. 21 Buttons. B/C. dry tuned. Hand made reeds. Beautiful Box. can send on pics if required.
You are of course more than welcome to treat seller with caution.



Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: triskel on November 02, 2009, 12:49:15 PM
"You live in Inverness, that'll be £100 more to deliver it, it's an offshore island"   ???

Sounds like he didn't know his Highland from his Island...  ::)
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: waldoB on November 02, 2009, 12:51:25 PM
Like many I've had good and bad experience with eBay, three  boxes I returned were refunded by PayPay. Two of them I put down to ignorance on the part of the vendor. The third one a very beat up old Hohner was sent instead of the pristine Paolo Soprani advertised. The seller, who showed a 300 plus 100 percent feedback had his account closed by eBay. He was from Berlin.........
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: triskel on November 02, 2009, 12:56:42 PM
A few minutes after the auction ended, the seller informed me that he had sold the instrument to someone else this very day but had not had time to cancel the auction.

I wonder what would have happened if your bid was higher than the price he'd accepted earlier?  ???
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Gandy on November 02, 2009, 12:59:07 PM
er.
I am the so called irresponsible eBayer
Brave of you to pop up here and defend you practices, but I do not agree.   I assume that you would not be happy if the winning bidder had dropped out after the sale, saying for example that he'd found another one elsewhere and therefore no longer wanted to deal with you.   In fact your practice is specifically prohibited by
Ebay's rules which you can find here ...   http://pages.ebay.co.uk/help/sell/end_early.html

Regarding feedback - since you're canceling the deal each time, none of the bidders in Rees' position are able to place feedback.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: theSmoiler on November 02, 2009, 01:03:56 PM
Hi to all you guys that are discussing the alleged irresponsible eBayer.
as there is a 12 hour deadline with ebay i was then unable to cancel the listing  before it ended. I dont need to find excuses if i have no wish to sell the instrument.



I haven't used eBay to sell anything for years, now, and, perhaps I'm being 'thick' here (if so please tell me) ...but, isn't that the whole point? ie that it is against the rules to cancel within the last 12 hours - when the Seller can, conceivably, by that point see how the auction and price is likely to go?

Just my thoughts on reading that above - that it is a bad practice, which eBay is intentionally seeking to avoid, to do what was done.

Edited: cross-posted with Gandy, above, who makes the same point I think.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: graememackay on November 02, 2009, 01:18:32 PM
I reckon you should have directed your buyer to the auction where all is fair
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Gandy on November 02, 2009, 01:33:39 PM
... it is against the rules to cancel within the last 12 hours - when the Seller can, conceivably, by that point see how the auction and price is likely to go?

Its against the rules to cancel at any time, except for certain specific reasons.  Selling for a better price elsewhere is not one of those reasons.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: TomB-R on November 02, 2009, 01:49:34 PM
The seller, who showed a 300 plus 100 percent feedback had his account closed by eBay. He was from Berlin.........

Errr, let's not forget the berlin area does have a population of over five million people....


Assuming that lonanspark sold the item, due to it bing advertised elsewhere, in the last twelve hours as as they said, the sale is nevertheless shown as completed.
What's the feedback position given that the item is shown as sold?

http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Paddy-Clancy-Button-Accordion-C-D_W0QQitemZ160372538975QQcmdZViewItemQQptZUK_MusicalInstr_Keyboard_RL?hash=item2556f2be5f


Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Sandy on November 02, 2009, 02:21:52 PM


The accordion was advertised elsewhere(here on melodeon.net for example), i cant put this in my ebay listing or they will remove it as they have done before.



Exactly. That's what makes you an irresponsible ebayer !!
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Bananayogi on November 02, 2009, 02:27:22 PM
Quite honestly, I think Rees is being kind calling you 'irresponsible'!

There are ways of ensuring that you don't sell for less than you want on Ebay. Set a start price or buy it now price you would accept, or set a reserve. Or at the very least only accept an offer off Ebay if there have been no bids, or bids that have not reached your reserve.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: pete /acorn on November 02, 2009, 03:23:41 PM
Hi,
I've had listings like this before,valuable item with no reserve,then if you check bid history states private listing,what I've found in past they disappear before auction end or when you bid price keeps on going up as though someone associated with seller is bidding against you.
For this reason I only bid in last few seconds.
In this case I would actually report seller to ebay and pass on to ebey the sellers words from this forum,could well find account suspended.

Pete

Check his feedback,obviously a dealer or serious case of MAD and coming to terms with addiction and getting rid   >:E
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: graememackay on November 02, 2009, 03:26:56 PM
I do like a good witch hunt.  Where's my pitch fork!  >:E
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: rees on November 02, 2009, 03:27:49 PM
Hmmmm, green writing. Now that is suspicious.  ;)
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: theSmoiler on November 02, 2009, 05:52:19 PM
I notice (above the blue description) that on 26 Oct. the Seller revised some information. Clicking on this shows that he added the words 'Minimum bid price'. But, according to eBay's stated guidance for revisions, it seems you can't suddenly change something like this ie presumably implying a Reserve - because eBay says you can't alter the stuff in the Grey boxes. As Rees' bid price appears in a grey box, then I'm presuming you can't alter pricing stuff like that. In which case, this is direct contravention - and basically, failure to supply the goods as offered. If I have read the Terms correctly, then write this as Feedback on his page, and report to eBay.

If Seller hasn't actually sold the box elsewhere...then he may wish to think about letting Rees have it for his Bid price after all, and putting any mistakes he has made down to experience.

Diane

Diane
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Keithypete. on November 03, 2009, 01:49:51 PM

If Seller hasn't actually sold the box elsewhere...then he may wish to think about letting Rees have it for his Bid price after all, and putting any mistakes he has made down to experience.




This is not likely to happen. Nor is e-bay likely to go to Berlin and uplift the 'box and take it to Wales. They - e-bay - are not consistent. I have seen several auctions clearly stating that they have advertised the item elsewhere and they have run their course. Personally I wouldn't risk listing an item like the one in question without a reserve. I once convinced a car-booter that a Club melodeon was knackered because  the club button played the same in & out, went on to make a killing on said auction site, but from an outlay of £35 - no real risk. Maybe the next Paddy Clancy 'box on e-bay will have better karma ???
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: melodeon on November 03, 2009, 04:51:02 PM
the term   "opportunist" seems to apply here

ethics has a great deal to do with business.. and matter of fact precludes me from purchasing from certain individuals

I am not an E bay fan... though I have an account I have never bought anything..

nevertherthe less I will add this seller to my list of "pox on your house" hustlers...

Rees.. this seller owes you the box for the purchase price.. and an apology to you and this group for an attempted
and clumsy masking and manipulation of the facts ,and of course for  his lack of moral fibre

just my opinion

Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Alison Scott on November 03, 2009, 04:52:05 PM
This is not likely to happen. Nor is e-bay likely to go to Berlin and uplift the 'box and take it to Wales. They - e-bay - are not consistent. I have seen several auctions clearly stating that they have advertised the item elsewhere and they have run their course. Personally I wouldn't risk listing an item like the one in question without a reserve.

I do have a (single) counter example to that; I have a friend who bought a rare and valuable item on US eBay, as part of a job lot of related things that were advertised generically as Victorian {whatevers}. My friend spotted the rare and valuable item in the photos, put in a suitably high snipe bid, won the lot and paid immediately. The seller then tried to back out, but the US equivalent of a sternly worded solicitor's letter did the trick and my friend got the item.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: stevejay on November 03, 2009, 07:31:44 PM
Simultaneous listings in ebay and a forum like this are often forbidden.. Mandolin Cafe for example so this exact scenario does not happen... Hedging your bets can cause problems for sure. Smart for the seller, but not entirely ethical.

I once purcased something after an auction closed with no winners. Big problem because item was not as described and I had no Ebay protection.

Ebay is not a bad thing, you just have to proceed with caution and yes, sometimes throw the dice a bit.

I feel badly for Rees, but I have to tip my hat to the seller for having the courage to step forward with an explanation. It may not be accepted, but it's better than ducking for cover. At the end of the day, nobody was financially hurt, disappointed, but not scammed.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: forrest on November 03, 2009, 10:41:23 PM
  Reality check here folks... *eBay is not foolproof* :o. They have instituted rules, many of which can be subverted, and some which may trap a buyer or seller into a dis-advantageous position.

   One particular rule is that sellers may not revise a description on their listing if it has bids.
 I have encountered that myself. In that particular case, my only correct and ethical choice was to contact all bidders, explain the situation, close the auction early, and re-list the item.
  
I have also been faced with the same situation  Rees has just encountered. Yes, it is disappointing, but as was mentioned by another, no financial loss, only some surmountable (hopefully) heartbreak :'(. I do not condone the practice of simultaneous listing of an item. If the seller did indeed receive an offer prior to the close of the auction, there is no real way to know if this occurred or not, one must simply roll with it. He certainly should have, out of courtesy, closed the auction early and notified all bidders.

   Also,  eBay actually provides a mechanism for allowing a seller to renege on a completed transaction! Of course this involves opening a dialog between the parties involved, ....etc.
   In Rees's case, the seller may not have broken rules, but merely acted in a less than thoughtful manner, which is no surprise in the marketplace these days.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Keithypete. on November 04, 2009, 01:37:03 AM
Hi to all you guys that are discussing the alleged irresponsible eBayer.


Anyone looking for a Mengascini 2 Row. 21 Buttons. B/C. dry tuned. Hand made reeds. Beautiful Box. can send on pics if required.
You are of course more than welcome to treat seller with caution.






I'm interested in the Mengascini. Which model is it? Would you be willing to to post it to my private P.O. box number so I can have a look at it. I'll be really careful with it. Don't forget to include a return address in case I don't want it after all & have to send it back. Cheers. :|glug
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Concertina on November 06, 2009, 02:47:05 AM
I once won a concertina from Ireland for a pretty good price.  The seller e-mailed me to say he took it out of the trunk of his car and a truck ran over it..............
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Martin J on November 06, 2009, 07:11:24 PM
I once won a concertina from Ireland for a pretty good price.  The seller e-mailed me to say he took it out of the trunk of his car and a truck ran over it..............
My seller dropped the student 1 I had won whilst packing it and it shattered into many pieces.  He was very sorry !!!!!!!!!
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: EeeJay on November 10, 2009, 12:42:29 PM
Simultaneous listings in ebay and a forum like this...

Notwithstanding simultaneous listings on eBay, so it seems...

Item #160376944897 (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Mengascin-Button-Accordion-B-C_W0QQitemZ160376944897) and Item #160376761443 (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Mengascin-Button-Accordion-B-C_W0QQitemZ160376761443)

Perchance, this is the same box...?

Ed J
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Keithypete. on November 10, 2009, 01:29:35 PM
We seem to have got the bases covered - I have posted here also:  http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,2895.0.html  


Simultaneous listings in ebay and a forum like this...

Notwithstanding simultaneous listings on eBay, so it seems...

Item #160376944897 (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Mengascin-Button-Accordion-B-C_W0QQitemZ160376944897) and Item #160376761443 (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Mengascin-Button-Accordion-B-C_W0QQitemZ160376761443)

Perchance, this is the same box...?

Ed J

Even if its not the same box its the same seller that Rees had problems with.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: rees on November 10, 2009, 02:31:00 PM


Simultaneous listings in ebay and a forum like this...

Notwithstanding simultaneous listings on eBay, so it seems...

Item #160376944897 (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Mengascin-Button-Accordion-B-C_W0QQitemZ160376944897) and Item #160376761443 (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Mengascin-Button-Accordion-B-C_W0QQitemZ160376761443)

Perchance, this is the same box...?

Ed J

Even if its not the same box its the same seller that Rees had problems with.

Very, very interesting.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: theSmoiler on November 10, 2009, 03:31:53 PM

Very, very interesting.

Now, I hardly think this is in the spirit of eBay! - putting it up for auction on 2 different country's sites, so there are 2 sets of bidders, and one auction is going to end before the other! (so seller can then say he 'sold it elsewhere'). Presuming times on the different sites are adjusted for GMT - so what appears as a 3 hour difference in end times, is in fact so?

Did you not put up any Negative feedback for your last 'Winning Bid', Rees?
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: melodeon on November 10, 2009, 06:06:29 PM
How admirable of the seller to anonimously post here to offer an "explanation"

he owes Rees the box as described at the agreed price

Perhaps it is time for someone to post their experiences with him and get that 100% approval down where it belongs
  


                             " WON "
what an interesting concept for buying something sight unseen
at a price higher  than anyone else is willing to pay
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: old geezer on November 11, 2009, 10:09:19 AM
is this another...
although he has 100% Positive feedback
"genuine HOHNER ACCORDION antique mint condition"
"I have this item advertised else were and reserve the right to end auction early if needed"
"rare antique Hohner accordion"
"i dont know to much about this but it looks very appealing to the eye"
"markings are on the wooden part (M/E)"
is this a key that I'm unaware of?

ebay # 230394893234
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: triskel on November 11, 2009, 03:17:11 PM
Seller i.d. is "lomanspark" based in Berlin. Treat with caution.

I had problems with this seller (Eddie Smyth) too, back in March 2007.

I paid £245 (+ postage) for a pre-war Hohner that he claimed had been fitted with Cagnoni reeds to convert it to B/C tuning, but when it arrived it contained the reedblocks and rusty/out of tune reeds from a 1950s Black Dot.

He did give me a partial refund, but it was very short of what it would cost to make it "as described"...  >:(

I wouldn't deal with him again.  :(
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Gandy on November 11, 2009, 04:18:48 PM
Seller i.d. is "lomanspark" based in Berlin. Treat with caution.

You really should leave him stinking feedback on that deal.  It's listed as "Sold" on Ebay so it should be possible.  Since his feedback score's not huge a negative will make a difference.   Remember that a seller now can't leave negative feedback for a buyer so he can't post anything malicious about you.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: stevejay on November 11, 2009, 04:45:20 PM
Wow, sometimes what goes around really does come around :-\
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: triskel on November 11, 2009, 05:12:49 PM
Wow, sometimes what goes around really does come around :-\

I guess this thread is the ultimate in "eBay feedback"!

For that matter (and especially considering my experience over so-called "Cag Mach" reeds in the Hohner), I'd wonder if the Mengascini he's selling (in two parallel auctions) really does have "Hand made reeds" as he claims - that model normally comes fitted with Dural ones...
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Steve_freereeder on November 11, 2009, 11:53:53 PM
I guess this thread is the ultimate in "eBay feedback"!
Is it possible to include a link to this thread in the eBay feedback text? That ought to scupper him.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Andrew Culwell on November 12, 2009, 04:34:17 AM
Not that I'm overly sympathetic to this guy since he is actually a pretty experienced "ebayer" by his feedback.  I however am not so experienced.   I started my ebay ventures by placing a 400.00 Hedwitschak Bodhran without a reserve as one of my first auctions.  That was a mistake by the way.  However I ended up honoring the sale and only recieved 150.00 bucks for it.  My mistake was a costly and a valuable lesson. I now only sell with reserve prices if I sell anything of value. 
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Martin J on November 12, 2009, 05:48:36 PM
A note to admin@ebay siting this thread and giving the url may get read although I suspect their interests and ours are diametrically opposed.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Fungusface on November 13, 2009, 12:02:34 PM
Hi Graham thats funny Inverness is an Island, a computer place in England told me Carriage to me would be dearer as Fife is an Island in Scotland you have to pay a toll onto Forth bridge  and further north another toll at the Tay to get off it.I didnt bother buying the PC, pointless arguing.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Gandy on November 13, 2009, 03:47:25 PM
is this another...
although he has 100% Positive feedback
"genuine HOHNER ACCORDION antique mint condition"
"I have this item advertised else were and reserve the right to end auction early if needed"
"rare antique Hohner accordion"
"i dont know to much about this but it looks very appealing to the eye"
"markings are on the wooden part (M/E)"
is this a key that I'm unaware of?

ebay # 230394893234
I queried that item to Ebay and among their response was the following, although by that time the auction had ended  ...

"Please note that such listings breaches our policy on binding bids. When sellers list an item, they're committing to sell it to the winning bidder. When someone bids on their listing, they're committing to buy it from the sellers if theirs is the highest bid. Sellers are not allowed to indicate in your listing that you may alter or not fulfil this contract."
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: graememackay on November 15, 2009, 02:31:08 AM
Hi Graham thats funny Inverness is an Island, a computer place in England told me Carriage to me would be dearer as Fife is an Island in Scotland you have to pay a toll onto Forth bridge  and further north another toll at the Tay to get off it.I didnt bother buying the PC, pointless arguing.

Can't use the toll excuse anymore.  Most carriers charge more when they have to subcontract to local firms to deliver to remote places, which is understandable.  But Inverness is in the middle of a big bit of tar called the A9.  Not very remote.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Gandy on November 15, 2009, 09:53:29 AM
But Inverness is in the middle of a big bit of tar called the A9.  Not very remote.

There's a large national mail order outfit, Gael Force, in Inverness.  They charge standard postage throughout the UK, not "Lowland surcharge" or international rates for delivery to England.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: graememackay on November 15, 2009, 12:33:03 PM
But Inverness is in the middle of a big bit of tar called the A9.  Not very remote.

There's a large national mail order outfit, Gael Force, in Inverness.  They charge standard postage throughout the UK, not "Lowland surcharge" or international rates for delivery to England.

Yeh we're a sensible bunch
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Theo on November 15, 2009, 12:37:43 PM
Don't they charge more for deliveries south of Middlesborough?   
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Keithypete. on November 16, 2009, 01:49:17 PM
Don't they charge more for deliveries south of Middlesborough?   


My car got broken into in Middlesborough years ago - the discerning thieves stole my radio/casette player, which had a Dougie Pincock tape in, but left the Pokerwork on the back seat. It was worth more than the car - LOL.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: EeeJay on November 24, 2009, 10:55:16 PM
Coming around again... ::)

Item #160381162489 (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Paddy-Clancy-Button-Accordion-C-D_W0QQitemZ160381162489)

Ed J
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: graememackay on November 25, 2009, 12:41:44 AM
The phantom menace
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: triskel on November 25, 2009, 02:09:48 AM
Coming around again... ::)

Item #160381162489 (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Paddy-Clancy-Button-Accordion-C-D_W0QQitemZ160381162489)

It seems Eddie hadn't sold the box before the end of the previous auction then, and I see he doesn't have 100% positive feedback any more either, since Rees has left him a negative (dead right!) and commented "Irresponsible, to say the least - failed to supply the goods as offered. Beware!"

I wish I hadn't been so kind with what I left him myself now (two years ago), since what I haven't mentioned previously is that his feedback at the time revealed he'd just bought an old Black Dot - presumably the "donor" for the reeds and blocks I got, instead of the "Cag Mach" reeds he claimed were fitted in the box I bought. He deserved the exact same feedback off me!  ::)
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: rees on November 25, 2009, 09:43:10 AM
Coming around again... ::)

Item #160381162489 (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Paddy-Clancy-Button-Accordion-C-D_W0QQitemZ160381162489)

Ed J

He told me he'd sold it to someone else, so he was lying after all.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Hello on November 25, 2009, 10:14:17 AM
I once convinced a car-booter that a Club melodeon was knackered because  the club button played the same in & out, went on to make a killing

Not exacty the most honourable of practices either...
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: pete /acorn on November 25, 2009, 10:16:12 AM
Rees,
If you open a case in ebay resolution centre you may get some redress..

Pete
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: theSmoiler on November 25, 2009, 10:49:31 PM
Rees, is this defo exactly the same box as you bid on? in which case, can I be wicked and ask him THE question? ie perhaps 'innocently' as if I'd remembered seeing the same one as 'sold' previously...or, perhaps not so innocently (do eBay have to print Buyers' questions, I wonder, for all to see? in which case, he would be shamed publicly, and wouldn't be able to wriggle out of it). Alternatively, I see there is a Report this Item button on the right hand side...

Diane
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: triskel on November 25, 2009, 10:55:42 PM
... (do eBay have to print Buyers' questions, I wonder, for all to see? in which case, he would be shamed publicly, and wouldn't be able to wriggle out of it) ...

I'm afraid that wouldn't work Diane, the displaying of questions is up to the seller.  :(
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: rees on November 25, 2009, 11:38:55 PM
Cheers Dianne, but I've already asked the question. here's how it went:


Hallo lomanspark,

Hmmm, I thought you said you'd sold it!

- rees9
...............................................................
Dear rees9,

yes i had but unfortunately the buyer cant get the hang of the C#/D and he has returned it to me on condition he buys the B/C from me. No big deal as i have plenty of boxes and no big secret involved. Kind Regards

- lomanspark
..................................................................
Hallo lomanspark,

Oh good. So you are now able to honour my original purchase.

- rees9
..........................................................................................
Dear rees9,


You should probably discuss that with your colleagues at melodeon.net

Kind Regards
- lomanspark
...................................................................
Discuss  >:E
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: triskel on November 26, 2009, 12:01:12 AM
Dear rees9,


You should probably discuss that with your colleagues at melodeon.net

Kind Regards
- lomanspark
...................................................................
Discuss  >:E

He didn't say anything about my Cagnoni reeds did he?  ::)
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: melodeon on November 26, 2009, 12:14:55 AM
Let's discuss:

The seller owes Rees the box at the original agreed upon price

Also,  this seller needs to be well known to the box world,  when the opportunity arises, suggest they read this thread.

This is what I would call pathologic.. absolutely no conscience in my opinion.  He could be selling lampshades or colostomy bags with the same amount of "enthusiasm" as the end game seems to be .. to he!! with ethics.. the goal is money

Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: HallelujahAl on November 26, 2009, 08:34:24 AM
Not sure I'd be comfortable about continuing to deal with someone who'd treated me in such a cavalier fashion. This person has rightly been brought to our attention as someone who cannot be trusted. A fact for which I am grateful to this forum.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Owen Woods on November 26, 2009, 02:12:00 PM
Definitely one to be avoided then!
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: EeeJay on November 26, 2009, 03:18:12 PM
You should probably discuss that with your colleagues at melodeon.net

Methinks this 'ere seller regards us as a 'talking shop'...  OK then... mud sticks... >:E

Notice it's listed as another Paddy Clancy box? Now, does this mean as distinct from the last one that was notionally sold, or the last one that was actually sold?

Rees - report it to eBay. 'Nuff said. Besides reneging on the original sale, now apparently trying to pass it off as 'another' one...

Words fail me... ::)

Ed J

P.S:- Hmmm... consults Google.... Paddy Clancy box... Berlin... is this (http://www.tailteann.com/) yer fella?
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Martin J on November 26, 2009, 07:02:41 PM
Dear rees9,
You should probably discuss that with your colleagues at melodeon.net
Kind Regards
- lomanspark
...................................................................
Discuss  >:E
Consider it discussed Rees.  Now lomanspark, the colleagues of melodeon.net believe you should honour your original agreement.  As you are obviously following our opinions with interest please let us know when you will fulfill your obligations to Rees.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on November 26, 2009, 08:47:47 PM
Yes. Do.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: theSmoiler on November 26, 2009, 11:41:04 PM
Besides reneging on the original sale, now apparently trying to pass it off as 'another' one...

Words fail me... ::)

Ed J

P.S:- Hmmm... consults Google.... Paddy Clancy box... Berlin... is this (http://www.tailteann.com/) yer fella?

I see the Seller has removed the ability for anyone to view the item which Rees has left Feedback on...ie so we can no longer compare it in detail to the box now offered.

If I was wanting to buy a box on eBay and checking out someone's Feedback, then I might just consider that rather suspicious...

Also, presumably these boxes are hand-made by a small concern, and quite prized? eg like an Oakwood over here? in which case, to get hold of not 1, but 2 secondhand, in a matter of weeks...how likely is that?
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: rees on November 27, 2009, 01:31:15 AM
If you read his reply to me (above) he readily admits that the (alleged) buyer returned the box and he is offering it for sale again.

Item number for the first auction was 160372538975
Item number for the second auction is 160381162489

You will see that the photos are identical.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: triskel on November 27, 2009, 02:17:26 AM
... this seller needs to be well known to the box world ...

I'm not going to give the information out publicly, but if anybody really needs it (maybe if they're unsure about the bona fides of somebody selling a box in Berlin?) I can provide his name, email and last-known address...

Meanwhile, I wish I hadn't accepted his explanation regarding my eBay problems with him in 2007, which I now believe to have been false.  >:(
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Keithypete. on November 27, 2009, 04:14:15 AM
I once convinced a car-booter that a Club melodeon was knackered because  the club button played the same in & out, went on to make a killing

Not exacty the most honourable of practices either...


   I don't think 'honourable' comes into it. We agreed a price, cash was handed over, 'box was taken away. A more satisfactory outcome than we have here. Had the seller done his homework he could have avoided having had his leg lifted. I doubt he made a loss on it anyway - probably got for nothing or next to nothing. 'I'll give you a tenner for that old accordion, its a bit knackered, not much call for them nowadays, I'm doing you a favour.' You know the sort of thing. Ever bought a second hand car?
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Steve_freereeder on November 27, 2009, 08:11:39 AM
I'm not going to give the information out publicly, but if anybody really needs it (maybe if they're unsure about the bona fides of somebody selling a box in Berlin?) I can provide his name, email and last-known address...

Meanwhile, I wish I hadn't accepted his explanation regarding my eBay problems with him in 2007, which I now believe to have been false.  >:(
Couldn't you send the name, email and last-known address, together with the URL for this thread and a letter of complaint, to Ebay? But perhaps you've done that already....
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Martin J on November 27, 2009, 10:04:56 PM
I'm not going to give the information out publicly, but if anybody really needs it (maybe if they're unsure about the bona fides of somebody selling a box in Berlin?) I can provide his name, email and last-known address...
We are a strange lot.  A man proves himself to have no personal integrity, his behaviour borders on criminal and somehow we feel it would be unfair to disclose information about him.  If there is any doubt about his identity then I agree whole heartedly but if your are sure it's him then shout his name from the roof tops.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Theo on November 28, 2009, 08:35:41 AM
I've removed two posts with links to websites other than ebay which identify an individual person who might be the same person as the ebay seller at the centre of this discussion.  This is getting into tricky areas and is quite unnecessary.  Reporting questionable ebay activity is a valuable service to the community, but please lets keep it to ebay details only please people! 

Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: HallelujahAl on November 28, 2009, 10:46:12 AM
fair enough comment Theo.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on November 28, 2009, 04:40:26 PM
And let's not forget the current concern on "Libel Tourism".  :(
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: EeeJay on November 28, 2009, 09:21:00 PM
I've removed two posts with links to websites other than ebay which identify an individual person who might be the same person as the ebay seller at the centre of this discussion.

OK - moderator's absolute prerogative.

BTW, Steve C has already published the seller's name on page 3 - one would assume this is also subject to censure? :-\

Ed J
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Andrew Culwell on November 28, 2009, 09:32:12 PM
So here is the Mengascini that he is shopping on Ebay.  Anyone wanna risk it?

http://cgi.ebay.com/Mengascin-Button-Accordion-B-C_W0QQitemZ160379899322QQcmdZViewItemQQptZKeyboards_MIDI?hash=item2557630dba
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: boxlad on November 28, 2009, 11:45:30 PM
Quote
Insert Quote
Quote from: Theo on Today at 08:35:41 AM
I've removed two posts with links to websites other than ebay which identify an individual person who might be the same person as the ebay seller at the centre of this discussion.

OK - moderator's absolute prerogative.

BTW, Steve C has already published the seller's name on page 3 - one would assume this is also subject to censure?

The guy has a Youtube link of the box being played at the end of the ebay listing so he has in effect named himself! If I was Stephen or Rees I would be quite angry at this guy. He needs to be named and shamed and ebay should remove the likes of that con-artist from their site permanently.   
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Gandy on November 29, 2009, 09:27:15 AM
If you read his reply to me (above) he readily admits that the (alleged) buyer returned the box and he is offering it for sale again.

Item number for the first auction was 160372538975
Item number for the second auction is 160381162489

You will see that the photos are identical.
How much is the box worth to you?  If you took him up on the offer to sell at the original price, you'd have some protection from Paypal I think.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: pete /acorn on November 29, 2009, 10:37:44 AM
Hi,
I think we are all in agreement that this e bay seller is someone who has very few screwples and really doesn't realise that trading on ebay you are entering into a legally binding contract however if no one pursues this then its like a guard dog without teeth.

There are correct procedures in place to pursue this because this bloke is clearly in breech of contract however the only person who can trigger this is Rees,then it is up to ebay.  This can actually take quite a time and unless someone goes legal or the seller gets a bout of conscience then not much can be done.

It is now very clear who this seller actually is from the you tube link,especially when from that you look a his facebook link his photo shows him playing the box in question so we will all be able to avoid trading with him but I would like to bet, if a real bargain came up for sale by this seller, some melnet member would take a punt.

At the end of the day Rees has not lost any money and has not bought a pig in a poke.this seller has had his reputation tarnished and has had it made very clear from input above that you can not always get away with dodgy trading so who actually is the worst off,Rees or Lomanspark


Pete
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: rees on November 29, 2009, 02:48:21 PM

Anyone who spotted steve freereeder's post early this morning before it was (quite rightly) removed by administration, will have noticed that the seller already has his knickers in a twist about this issue and melnet is not flavour of the month in his house.

I am a professional accordion dealer with an eye for a bargain.  Some auctions you win and some you lose, so it's water off a ducks back to me. I did win this particular auction fair and square but I quite understand the seller's reluctance to let the item go at half the true value. Having said that, he did list it without a reserve and he did fail to supply the goods as advertised on completion of the auction thereby contravening eBay rules. Subsequent communication with the seller resulted in the waffle that I have previously posted.

I left negative feedback as follows: (Irresponsible, to say the least - failed to supply the goods as offered. Beware!) thus blotting his 100% positive record. His reply (Goods were already sold elsewhere, sadly these things happen). The instrument has now been re-listed and further contact with the seller resulted in more waffle also previously posted here..

I later received a request from eBay to withdraw the negative feedback which I declined on the grounds that the feedback was accurate.

I thank you all for your help and concern but I do not in any way expect to receive this fine instrument. I am a great believer in the eBay system which is based on honesty and trust so I have therefore opened a dispute in the eBay Resolution Centre.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Steve_freereeder on November 29, 2009, 03:13:07 PM
Anyone who spotted steve freereeder's post early this morning before it was (quite rightly) removed by administration,
Hi Rees,
Actually, I removed it myself - I had second thoughts about the wisdom of posting what I did, especially in the light of Theo's earlier plea for restraint.

I wish you well in your quest for satisfaction on this matter. I think you have been shabbily treated.
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Gandy on November 29, 2009, 04:21:17 PM
I later received a request from eBay to withdraw the negative feedback which I declined on the grounds that the feedback was accurate.

That shows you touched a nerve !
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: an bosca ceoil on November 29, 2009, 04:52:48 PM
I think you will find that these requests are generated automatically if you give Negative or even Neutral feedback in the hope that the dispute can be amicably resolved. Not very likely in this instance?
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: rees on November 29, 2009, 06:17:43 PM
Anyone who spotted steve freereeder's post early this morning before it was (quite rightly) removed by administration,
Hi Rees,
Actually, I removed it myself - I had second thoughts about the wisdom of posting what I did, especially in the light of Theo's earlier plea for restraint.

I wish you well in your quest for satisfaction on this matter. I think you have been shabbily treated.

Cheers Steve, I'm glad you did post it and I was online early enough to spot it, but in the long run, best removed. It certainly gave me a good laugh.  :D
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Owen Woods on November 30, 2009, 12:41:05 AM
I missed out, evidently :(
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Morrisbox on November 30, 2009, 08:00:32 PM
Quote
I am a great believer in the eBay system which is based on honesty and trust

Well said Rees.  I have dealt with some really pleasant, honest people on ebay, I've bagged some real bargains, some really nice items.  I have also, of course, paid over the odds when I should have known better, or read the lot description a little more closely.  It is a shame that there are the slightly less decent people out there in ebay, but then that is life in general isn't it? 

Ebay is not much different to any other auction - buyer beware, but you can often be very pleasantly surprised (a year or so back I bought a Tommy at a local auction house for very reasonble money, in as new condition, with another Castagnari and one of the nicest Pokerworks I'd ever seen, regret not bidding on those now!). 

Good luck with your dispute Rees, you deserved better

Trevor
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Keithypete. on December 12, 2009, 03:07:20 PM
....and again: 160385373747 - ebay item number???
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: Johnjo on December 30, 2009, 03:49:43 PM
...and he's back again:
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Mengascin-Button-Accordion-B-C_W0QQitemZ160390603044QQcategoryZ16218QQcmdZViewItemQQ_trksidZp4340.m263QQ_trkparmsZalgo%3DSIC%26its%3DI%26itu%3DUCI%252BIA%252BUA%252BIEW%252BFICS%252BUFI%26otn%3D3%26ps%3D63 (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Mengascin-Button-Accordion-B-C_W0QQitemZ160390603044QQcategoryZ16218QQcmdZViewItemQQ_trksidZp4340.m263QQ_trkparmsZalgo%3DSIC%26its%3DI%26itu%3DUCI%252BIA%252BUA%252BIEW%252BFICS%252BUFI%26otn%3D3%26ps%3D63)
Title: Re: Warning - irresponsible eBayer
Post by: triskel on January 01, 2010, 12:51:16 PM
...and he's back again:
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Mengascin-Button-Accordion-B-C_W0QQitemZ160390603044QQcategoryZ16218QQcmdZViewItemQQ_trksidZp4340.m263QQ_trkparmsZalgo%3DSIC%26its%3DI%26itu%3DUCI%252BIA%252BUA%252BIEW%252BFICS%252BUFI%26otn%3D3%26ps%3D63 (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Mengascin-Button-Accordion-B-C_W0QQitemZ160390603044QQcategoryZ16218QQcmdZViewItemQQ_trksidZp4340.m263QQ_trkparmsZalgo%3DSIC%26its%3DI%26itu%3DUCI%252BIA%252BUA%252BIEW%252BFICS%252BUFI%26otn%3D3%26ps%3D63)

And still having problems deciding what kind of reeds the box he's selling has, I see.  ::) They're listed both as "Tip a Mano reeds" and as "Handmade reeds" in the same description, though in my experience that model only comes with Dural ones (though it does sound very good with them).

Oh, and "todays price  1900 euros" ??? - I'll sell you a new one for 1300...
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal