Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Pete Dunk on August 21, 2022, 12:43:12 PM
-
I have a Garmon/Garmoshka, a Russian diatonic button accordion in the key of A that I am about to (attempt to) restore. The Russian DBA differs from the more familiar Western European style DBA/melodeon/button box in a number of ways, not least of which is that it is unisoric throughout. A couple of layout diagrams found on Wikipedia might help here. The first few posts in this thread will be relatively short as pictures help to decribe the box and its' innards far better than anything I can put into words.
The layout diagrams use sol fa, in this case Do = A. The octaves of the various notes will be shown in a pic of the existing tuning scheme to be posted shortly.
-
Bass end.
-
The Garmoshka.
-
Opening the box up gave me a few surprises, a combination of innovative design (my observation based on my limited experience) and crude execution. Before we get down to the nitty-gritty, let's take a peek inside. First surprise was the reed blocks, made from plastic. My initial reaction was to recoil in horror but actually they are pretty cool and really well made. 13 reed pairs on the outer row and 12 on the inner row, the chamber sizes are carefully tapered and the bottom ports are huge allowing much better access to the inside reed from below. The waxing is a bit of a horror show because the wax is way too soft and the plates can be moved around at room temperature. Don't try to flip the inner reed out when tuning because you'll pull the plate straight off the block!
-
More pics.
-
The blocks are mounted on fairly thick, firm rubbers gaskets.
-
Inside the bass end.
-
The ends of the reed blocks have little 'pips' to locate the simple hold down brackets, a surprising small detail.
-
It looks quite...effectively made, apart from what I assume to be post-manufacture fettling. Using what seems to be something like bee's wax for the job was mentioned in a recent discussion. This could be good (erm, bad) example of why not to do that.
Are you at all tempted to turn it into a melodeon with a small unisoronic (stradella) bass system?
-
It’d won’t be beeswax, it would be quite hard at room temperature. Proper accordion wax is actually somewhat softer than beeswax.
-
It’d won’t be beeswax, it would be quite hard at room temperature. Proper accordion wax is actually somewhat softer than beeswax.
Showing my ignorance again, sorry. I always assumed beeswax was softer. Rule 1: Check your facts before sticking your neck out.
Still sounds like the wrong stuff, though.
-
Are you at all tempted to turn it into a melodeon with a small unisoronic (stradella) bass system?
Not really, the bass isn’t laid out anything like a 24 button stradella, it’s a tonic sol fa bass melody row with a few chords and other bass notes to suit the diatonic key thrown in by the look of it. The waxing is much better in the bass end but loads of the valves are shot. Pics later.
-
Well, there's certainly plenty of airflow space on the reedblock soles! This is all very interesting Pete, thanks for posting about it.
-
I recently worked on a PA that was made entirely from plastic. The reed blocks moulded plastic, very similar to yours, sitting on a rubber gasket (though they were held there with bolts). It was an GDR made thing. The bass machine mech was all plastic, as was the casing.
-
A couple of months ago I replaced the bellows gaskets on a 120 bass five row five voice (LMMMH) Ukrainian Bayan. That had plastic reed blocks bolted in on rubber gaskets but the casework was celluloid covered wood and the bass mech was metal. The blocks in this one looked very similar to the garmoshka too, same light grey plastic with very thin walls.
Speaking of the garmon, here's another series of pics. I removed the treble grille to have a look at the pallets and the key mechanism/springs. The pallets are metal with a raised centre, a leather disc is glued to the pallet under the lever arm and then another leather disc is glued on top. This allows a slight movement so the pallet is self levelling, rather like concertina pads. The key mech is accessed by removing a plate at the back of the keyboard, the mech is entirely recessed and fastened into the keyboard itself with no access to the axle without dismantling the whole thing. There is a possible workaround but I wouldn't attempt it unless I had to, let's hope a spring never goes!
-
Next pic
-
There is plenty of room around the buttons so perhaps the mech could be unscrewed from the keyboard and swung out to access the axle without taking the key tops off, might be awkward though!
-
Close up of the pallet attachment.
-
Bass reed block.
-
Bass octave reeds
-
Bass reed block ports
-
The other bass end block with chord notes etc.
-
Bass end with blocks out. We'll look at the bass mech another time.
-
Almost forgot, here are the charts showing the tuning of the two treble blocks, these were taken with the blocks out of the box. Incidentally I did do a comparison measurement of one block in the box and the results were virtually identical which surprised me.
-
Final pic for the time being, this is the bass mech and it's a real dog's breakfast. The arms behind the buttons are very thin and flexible and there is no overall framework guiding the arms or joining the various components within the mechanism together. Dismantling this to get at the pallets and reface them would be a nightmare.
-
The Bayan I worked on had a similar bass machine construction (but much bigger). The top half unclipped and came off (great!). The bottom half was more like yours (though it was a Stradella converter system so a bit more complex). No problem, thinks I, I’ve stripped lots of bass machines. But… the pipe connectors were like yours, wire with the ends bent over… in other words they are a one time assembly, not designed to be pulled apart. But I needed to get everything out to get at the metal palettes, to replace the pads, where the foam sandwich had disintegrated.
The problem I encountered is getting the bent wire connectors off (I used a small brass tube as a sort of wrench). The slightest kink in the wire and it won't slide off the locating hole…plus they are brittle and will break if you bend them more than a couple of times (eek). I got about a third of the way across and decided it was too risky (there were a *lot* more connectors than yours…and this was a clients instrument). So I stopped and reassembled. But getting the wire to bend back in exactly the same spot was very tough…and the slightest deviation then threw out the alignment. I still have nightmares about it. Eventually, after much work I got the whole thing back together and working. I then replaced the pallet facings with tweeezers and by going in from the reed block side. I learned a lot during that particular job… Bayan bass machines can be tricky to take apart.
-
Fortunately the pallets all seal well enough although they are a bit clacky, had they have been shot I would now be dismantling the box for parts!
I had intended to pre-tune the treble reeds before stripping them off the blocks to re-valve and wax back in but the poor adhesion makes that more or less impossible. None of the reeds are marked to indicate the ‘outside’ of the plate, given that they are unisoric is that an issue? Should I mark the plates as I take them off? I only ask because it is normal to see plates marked in this way and I see no reason why this would be done as a matter of course if it has no purpose.
-
Unisonoric reeds need to be kept the same way up unless you can tolerate less than perfect tuning. Turning the plate over can cause small changes of pitch.
-
If you forget to label them, the little residue of wax at the foot of the reed denotes the outside. Even after they are cleaned there is normally a little stain.
-
Thanks Theo and Roger, I have a nice sharp engineer’s scribe so I can mark them with a diagonal slash in the Italian style although a dot from a centre punch would probably be quicker. I thought about dotting them with a black marker but I’m probably going to use a fairly strong solvent to get every scrap of the old wax off the plates and that would remove spirit ink no problem! I can’t use solvent like that on the plastic blocks though so maybe I will clean those up first and find a method that is effective without resorting to acetone or cellulose thinners. WD40 is probably the way to go as it is very effective at removing sticky stuff and doesn’t attack plastics.
I’ve read plenty of discussions about reed plate cleaning in sonic cleaning baths in the past but opinions always seem divided and the consensus inconclusive. I wonder how many pro repairers have them and use them regularly?
-
I have an ultrasonic cleaning bath that I have tried for cleaning reeds. I don’t use it anymore for several reasons.
1 you still have to scrape and brush by hand to remove most of the attached residue and rust.
2 when the reeds come out of the bath they have to be dried immediately to prevent a flash coating if rust on the reeds that can form within a very short time
3 it’s quite time consuming loading the bath with hot water and keeping it it hot enough to enable wax removal.
4 less seriously the bath can remove the blue coating from the reed surface. Only cosmetic I know but it doesn’t seem right!
-
Thanks for refreshing my memory Theo. I couldn’t remember the details but I do remember thinking that it sounded like there was little to be gained and I didn’t like the idea of removing the bluing from nice reeds either.
-
I entirely echo Theo’s account. I now use the bath only to clean my glasses…or metal watch straps…
I use a Garryflex block (or similar) to clean reeds (it’s like an abrasive rubber/eraser) and a wire brush for the rivet end, and a small screw driver for scraping.
-
I have begun tuning the LH end starting with the row of low notes and it is really messing with my head. Unlike anything I’ve worked on before the order of the buttons on the outside bears no relation to the port that opens under the block, so button one at the chin end opens port seven (out of eight) at the knee end of the block. I had to take the block back out and make a chart mapping it out before I could get started. The chord block promises to be a right barrel of laughs. I’m beginning to dislike this box.
-
A good tip in this situation is to lay a strip of masking tape along the reed block and write the note names on it
-
I had a chart with the block layout Theo, my problem was that I didn’t know which button to press to make the notes sound in the box so I had to map that out before I could tune the notes in order. All done now though, moving on to the ‘chord’ block next.
-
I would do it the other way round. Start at the end of the row of buttons, sound the first button, your tuner will tell you the note, adjust if required, then move on to the next button and repeat.
-
I’ll have to put that down to my lack of experience and a broad streak of caution Theo. The bass end blocks are tuned and back in, I haven’t got my head around the button layout at all yet but I have sounded every button and there are no horrible noises coming out. I’ve now moved on to the treble end, stripped the reeds off both blocks cleaned the wax off the plates (horrible sticky mess). The blocks (plastic of course) were soaked in warm water and a strong solution of a well known washing up liquid, a light scrubbing with an old toothbrush and they are gleaming. I’ve no idea what a wooden block weighs (I’ll check next time I have one cleaned up for rewaxing) but these weighed 50 & 51 grams, pretty light. Work continues, photos to follow.
-
Photos of the treble end reed work.
-
Block after stripping and narrow gaps between reed plates.
-
Scraping the wax off the blocks and the inside face of a reed plate showing how much wax was on the back of the plates.
-
Blocks after cleaning and the little recess across the bottom of the blocks for the reed plates to sit in.
-
Ready to start waxing.
-
All waxed in now, the chamber edges were quite narrow making waxing the long joints difficult with the plates in place so I dipped the bottom edge of the first plate into the wax and set it in place. Then I quickly waxed along the long edge of the first reed and set the next plate in the molten wax beside it, I continued in the same fashion until all of the plates were in place on one side of the block. I then waxed along the top and bottom of the plates, turned the block around and did the same on the other side. The waxing is still far from perfect but so much tidier than my first attempts several years ago, it took a long time to get the hang of using the strange little wax spoon I have but I'm very pleased with it now.
Tuning has started but it may take a while as the reeds are all well off pitch and completely inconsistent, +23 cents here -19 cents there. I'm getting plenty of practice flipping the inside reeds out . . . ::)
-
Initial tuning is now completed, I’ll leave it for a couple of days and then give it a brush up tuning. The tuning was literally all over the place but generally quite sharp with the odd exception including one inside reed 40 cents flat. Treble end C# and G# reeds tended to be roughly at pitch, something like 10-15 cents flatter than average by comparison to the rest. Given that the box is in A this would suggest that something similar to Cajun tuning was used but that’s just a guess.
-
As you can imagine I'm following this with interest.
The reedblocks and use of plastics are similar to Weltmeister but that gasketing is more like Armitage Shanks
The wax, I agree was horrible. Slimy and too easy to manipulate. You have vastly improved it now.
When it's finished, all you have to do is learn a completely new system!!
-
When it's finished, all you have to do is learn a completely new system!!
I had the instrument for a while before passing it to Peter and it was surprisingly easy to make sense of the right hand. It felt a bit like row-crossing when playing a tune in Em on a 4th apart box.
-
The reedblocks and use of plastics are similar to Weltmeister but that gasketing is more like Armitage Shanks.
Bog standard then! I’ll try and get over to see you in the next two weeks and bring it along. I doubt I will learn to play this system properly, it doesn’t really appeal and the bass end is pretty bizarre. The general standard of engineering suggests this box will never be a great player and finding a better quality Garmon would be difficult. It will be fun to mess around with for a while though.
Because I was eager to see if the box could be made playable I simply retuned the bass end and replaced the worst valves as the waxing there was much better and set solid, if I was to decide to have a proper go I would overhaul the bass end too. They aren’t dreadful, but now I have it playing I will replace the thin leather bellows gaskets to cure the slight leaks.
-
I had the instrument for a while before passing it to Peter and it was surprisingly easy to make sense of the right hand. It felt a bit like row-crossing when playing a tune in Em on a 4th apart box.
It actually makes a lot of sense to an English concertina player but forget about the bass end!