Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Chris Marriott on August 25, 2022, 08:36:00 PM
-
I more or less gave up the melodeon a year ago to concentrate on the piano accordion because I considered it to be a much more versatile instrument. I still hold that view, and I love playing the PA, but for English folk music I've come to realise that the melodeon is a much more natural "fit" to the music, and hence I've restarted the process of learning to play the melodeon, which I'm thoroughly enjoying.
I have discovered one interesting and unexpected side-effect of spending time playing the PA. On my first attempt at the melodeon I just could not play the basses with all four fingers - I didn't have the strength or control in my little finger to use it, particularly for the inside C basses, so I played with three fingers. After a year of playing the accordion stradella bass, however, where you basically have to use all four fingers, coming back to the melodeon I found myself naturally and comfortably playing with all four fingers: the year's exercise with the PA has obviously strengthened my little finger to the point where it now "works" for me on the melodeon.
PAs are good for something, after all ;).
-
Now we're going to have to see a demonstration! Good to have you back.
-
My own melodeon bass playing is certainly influenced by having been a PA and B/C/C♯ player before.
A lot of what I do with the basses was quite consciously based on what's possible with a PA or button accordion, and influenced by John Kirkpatrick, and when I switched to two row melodeon I didn't see why I shouldn't make the maximum use of the basses that the limitations of the instrument would allow.
Not that I use four fingers very much; I'm more of a 3 finger bass player using the little finger only when necessary for a run of notes, but I suppose the experience of playing Stradella basses has helped with finger strength and co-ordination when I do.
-
It was playing bass runs on the PA, where you really need to use the little finger for the counterbass row, that got me using the little finger. It was really hard at first, but the more I played, the easier it got.
-
It was really hard at first, but the more I played, the easier it got.
You can post this in every thread!
-
Not that I use four fingers very much; I'm more of a 3 finger bass player using the little finger only when necessary for a run of notes, but I suppose the experience of playing Stradella basses has helped with finger strength and co-ordination when I do.
And the Anglo concertina perhaps? I acquired an Anglo last week and have been working on getting started with it and I can definitely say it will teach your left hand little finger to pull its weight with bass notes!