Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: PeterBRC on August 26, 2022, 09:31:35 PM
-
As a newcomer I am interested in members comment on Sharon Shannons use of bass buttons . it seems very different to how I am learning use of bass , she is a wonderful player , so fluid and fast but how is her bass achieved , she seems to just sort of flap the basses with the fingers . is it down to Irish style , has it any place in the English Folk playing could I incorporate it in my playing ( sort of ! )
Correct number of melodeons to own. ...What you have plus just 1 more to make things perfect
Peter
-
As I understand it she does not play the basses at all, the 'flapping' action is a method of adding pulses to the music
-
How very interesting I never thought of that !
-
It seems to me that the LH chords in Irish playing are used more as an emulation of the pipe regulators than the typical bass/chord work in the rest of the accordion world. Joe Burke is a sterling example.
-
Sharon Shannon does play basses sometimes.
-
I'd forgotten how good she is.Totally musical. Thanks for reminding me she was out there
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mkrCS8z0v_w
-
A nice example of Irish style basses here from Jackie Daly. Very much about the off-beat:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gg7d0vuPSNw (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gg7d0vuPSNw)
Paul Young does this style effectively in his videos of Irish tunes.
Sharon uses both hands on this one. ;)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qOEM-XOq2cs
-
has it any place in the English Folk playing could I incorporate it in my playing ( sort of ! )
I certainly does no harm to make the basses nice and crisp. The problem with so much "oompah" accompaniment is that it is often turgid, with the "oom" and "pah" being given equal value and with no gaps between them. Playing the basses crisply can breathe more life into the music. However the secret to bass playing, in my opinion, is to mix it up - play crisply, but also hold down chords, and perhaps sometimes don't play at all for a phrase. Just play the root buttons, or just the chord buttons. On a D/G you can play drones on C and D. You can also mix up the chords with substitutions and cross-fingerings. All these can add interest and life to the music, but if overdone they can also kill it. Always remember the bass is there to support the melody, and if playing for dancing to give lift to the dancers.
When I'm learning a tune, once I've got the basics down I then think first about how to play the left hand and then work out how to play the melody to fit the bellows changes that imposes.
-
I started our by doing ‘om pah’ and ‘um pah pah’ in the 80’s and was very unstatisfied. I was a dancer in those days and basically it
doesn’t ‘inform the feet’. Unless perhaps you are a German conscript marching to the military band. Even they do better than that.
I finally got to a course in the Isère valley in 1995, That truly freed up my left hand, and lightened my touch on the right too . Stéph
Milleret’s excellent advice was “anything except UM Pah Pah†🤔. I couldn’t … actually go back to doing it it now.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nzuHY1RXcqg
I could rattle on yet again about pressing bases and chords together, and using the end of a note as a rhythm event, but Clive has
just posted this waltz as potential tune of the month. It is an absolute masterclass in how to play the left end! 👍
-
I started our by doing ‘om pah’ and ‘um pah pah’ in the 80’s and was very unstatisfied.
...
I finally got to a course in the Isère valley in 1995, That truly freed up my left hand, and lightened my touch on the right too . Stéph
Milleret’s excellent advice was “anything except UM Pah Pah†🤔. I couldn’t … actually go back to doing it it now.
...
I could rattle on yet again about pressing bases and chords together, and using the end of a note as a rhythm event, but Clive has
just posted this waltz as potential tune of the month. It is an absolute masterclass in how to play the left end! 👍
This brings me to the question that I keep struggling with; how to develop the left hand. There don't seem to be any guides to do that, and watching people play online doesn't seem to help (for various reasons, sometimes because they are cross-rowing lots on a box with 2.5 or 3 rows, other times because you can't see what they are doing, etc.). I might have to do a thread on this; how to develop the left-hand on a simple tune beyond oom-pah.
-
We often start playing two-row as 2 one-rows and progress(sic) to treating the RH as a single keyboard. Likewise, we may see it as having two sides (RH melody, LH bass/chord). With luck, listening and good role models one should be able to transcend the duality and reach the realm of one single instrument.
https://youtu.be/i54qSbHAKRk
-
Back to the topic, Sharon Shannon didn’t play any basses at all when I met her in Galway. It was a strange, eclectic session with a lot of excellent foreign musicians, (eg Japanese) playing Irish stuff in exotic keys eg F major. John O’Halloran was very entertaining on his one row. In D 👍
At the end of it the old fella next to me said “dat’s a fine accordion you’ve got, you should show it to the lady on the other side†… who had been playing very competent irish whistle for the 3 hours. I pointed that out to him 🤔
Oh that’s our Sharon Shannon. She’s not bad on the accordion either. 😳
-
I might have to do a thread on this; how to develop the left-hand on a simple tune beyond oom-pah.
Good idea! Please do…
I think possibly the best Irish players play in such a way that you don’t necessarily realise the accompaniment isn’t there, like the tune contains the rhythm and harmonic progression within it. Having said that, as a listener I do have a leaning towards the C#/D style which lends itself more readily to left hand accompaniment I guess, and Jackie Daly does this exceptionally well, to my ears…
-
I think possibly the best Irish players play in such a way that you don’t necessarily realise the accompaniment isn’t there, like the tune contains the rhythm and harmonic progression within it.
The Sharon Shannon example posted above has quite a lot of RH harmony, in odd chords for emphasis somewhat in the style of pipe regulators.
But you are right - the rhythm is also in the tune, as it should be for any instrument and any style, whether or not you have chords and basses.
-
Not specific to Sharon Shannon, but I've got a free PDF book available on my approach to learning the basses on the B/C box:
http://michaeleskin.com/box.html
-
Back to the topic, Sharon Shannon didn’t play any basses at all when I met her in Galway.
;D she didn't play any basses when I saw her either but her playing was so good and had such a driving rhythm it was a while before I realised that she was only playing the right hand side :|||: the big bath sponge padding to protect the wrist on the bass side looked really comfortable ;D