Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Tune of the Month => Topic started by: Clive Williams on September 01, 2022, 11:09:31 AM
-
Following on from Greg's most excellent suggestion, this month any tune that changes key. It could be change from D to G, or perhaps from major to minor, play the same tune changing into a new key as you go, or perhaps... interpret as you wish! Lots of possibilities....
-
Walter Bulwer's No.1 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pgtJR6HqzGs)
Walter Bulwer's No.2 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gw1fYu--9ws)
-
Here's one I prepared earlier
https://youtu.be/jqMLGUIoSqg
and another...one for you Q AKA Threepenny Bit...
https://youtu.be/CziH5MNXbJg
-
Ah thanks Baz, that's stirred up some memories!
Dunno where Paul is now, but his tunes lingers on 👍
Q
-
Jenny Lind is the only one I know that does that.
SJ
-
The Bluebell Polka springs to my mind. Great tune which I have only started to play recently. I may someday get it to sound right.
-
... It could be change from D to G, or perhaps from major to minor, or perhaps... interpret as you wish! Lots of possibilities....
My suggestion also included doing a Eurovision and modulating the tune into a different key a la Mr Cutting.
-
Jenny Lind is the only one I know that does that.
SJ
Rochdale Coconut Dance
-
Jan Mijne Man in Em, Am and Bm
-
Two I prepared earlier for other themes of the month. I've fortunately improved my playing since then
The Dancing Dustman which is now a standard at our sessions and Memories of Uppsala (Uppsalaminnen) which is also becoming more widely played.
https://youtu.be/TKuWxbnCJGs
https://youtu.be/3KfThqod03U
-
Here's one we did earlier: Orränsgsvalsen (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EBMKJs5dyf4) from Sweden which goes from G to D.
And one I did on a Pokerwork long ago: The Crystal Wedding (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XD6B7EfVkAQ) by Brian Peters, which goes from D to G.
-
Stow Quickstep
https://youtu.be/461IsbxROaQ
-
Written by the inestimably talented Martin Ellison of this parish. From 1986 Plant Life's English Melodeon Players A Small Fee.
https://youtu.be/XZclnKfW2ks
-
Proper new one now:
The Redowa Polka (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p4eN46cLyM4)
The third section goes into C and needs an F chord if it's to be played properly, so I enlisted my good lady wife on keyboard to supply the correct harmonies.
-
Proper new one now:
The Redowa Polka (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p4eN46cLyM4)
The third section goes into C and needs an F chord if it's to be played properly, so I enlisted my good lady wife on keyboard to supply the correct harmonies.
Thank you. The ‘nearest chord I’ve got’ approach is a bad thing.
-
https://youtu.be/-sl5WGn7Zq4
La Marianne
-
https://youtu.be/-sl5WGn7Zq4
La Marianne
If (like me) you thought that was posted to the wrong thread, follow the link and you'll be in for a treat (:)
-
Beautifully executed, Janneke. A rare treat, indeed.
-
Wonderful indeed, thank you Janneke!
-
Smarlon Sbrando (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PD3oPgkxZi0)
A traditional Italian dance tune I got from a Tiger Moth album.
-
https://youtu.be/gi9MKJUqBTs
A four tune trio of La Russe, Bal Limousine, and Spirit of the Dance, with a 'bonus out-take' of Le Jeamber. A couple of rusty (chest)nuts, and a couple from a current workbook. (French music is not my metier, 'ophiles please forgive.) Ambiguity cf change of key uncertain at times.
Possibly worthy of a teabreak.
Best regards from Suffolk
Bill
-
I already sent a tune under another topic, that is changing the keys:
Curly Headed Ploughboy
https://youtu.be/0fP_RLJ2HmQ
I used a Melodeon in CG because I didn't expect the size of the event and wanted to stay in the background a bit with a lower-sounding instrument. That was probably a mistake.
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=28528.0
-
I don't seem to have done this before - I'm quite surprised because I first learned it at an Andy Cutting workshop getting on for 30 years ago. 30 years, ladies and gentlemen and still in the repertoire. Played in Em fingering first, then a natty switch to Bm fingering where the tune sits just as nicely, and lets you put a wacky chord in last time through. I call this Rose and Crown, which is what the Late Night Band (who collected it from somewhere in France) call it - that's a name they gave it though; the original name is unknown. Blowzabella "recently" recorded it as 'A minor mazurka', and if they can't find out the original name, I doubt anyone else can.
https://youtu.be/06qcrc8duIg
Played on a C/F Hohner Club, so we're actually in D minor, then A minor.
-
Here's Impudence Schottische from a while ago.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rfuQBc5G3Cw (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rfuQBc5G3Cw)
-
Smarlon Sbrando (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PD3oPgkxZi0)
A traditional Italian dance tune I got from a Tiger Moth album.
Should anyone else be interested, the correct name of this tune seems to be Sbrando del Roero. Follow the link for a video of locals from Piedmonte playing the tune and performing the dance it accompanies: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KVgQzwclJN4&ab_channel=cornajass
-
Smarlon Sbrando (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PD3oPgkxZi0)
A traditional Italian dance tune I got from a Tiger Moth album.
Should anyone else be interested, the correct name of this tune seems to be Sbrando del Roero. Follow the link for a video of locals from Piedmonte playing the tune and performing the dance it accompanies: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KVgQzwclJN4&ab_channel=cornajass
Yes - Roero is in north-east Piedmont.
I've seen it danced in Aosta (we didn't attempt it !)and heard it played there by Tre Martelli who evidently started playing it back in the 1980s.
Julian
-
Martin - cracking tune, and well played as ever.
Is there any dots for the Impudence Scottische?
-
Uncle’s Jig from Bob Cann
https://youtu.be/uFLp9JwdZjk
-
I was inspired to record this after dancing to the wonderful Topette !! version on Sunday afternoon, but I can't decide what key to play the tune in ! So it's in Em then Am.
'Meatballs, Whisky and Beer' - by Ola Backstrom.
https://youtu.be/vm2x6RL3tYA
Julian
-
Polkas often seem to do the modulation thing. Here are a couple. The Maids of Ardagh goes from D to A and the Kerry no. 1 from G to Am.
(Trying to squeeze a few more tunes out of the Stefania before moving it on to the next lucky owner.)
https://youtu.be/Ne9L5VSEgg4 (https://youtu.be/Ne9L5VSEgg4)
-
Found this one in "Paul Hardy’s Basic Tunebook 2021"
Played on my A D melodeon.
Hunt the squirrel
https://youtu.be/egJmEyZAaqA
-
Polkas often seem to do the modulation thing. Here are a couple. The Maids of Ardagh goes from D to A and the Kerry no. 1 from G to Am.
https://youtu.be/Ne9L5VSEgg4 (https://youtu.be/Ne9L5VSEgg4)
Lovely set of lively tunes and very well played
The 1st tune is a variation of one I play, known as Let's have a ceilidh.
-
Martin - cracking tune, and well played as ever.
Is there any dots for the Impudence Scottische?
Hello Thrupenny, thanks for kind words. I haven't seen any dots and a Google search only brought up sheet music available to buy I'm afraid.
Martin
-
Hi Martin, that's exactly what I found when searching, so thought I'd ask. Thanks for looking.
Cheers
Q
-
Martin - cracking tune, and well played as ever.
Is there any dots for the Impudence Scottische?
Hello Thrupenny, thanks for kind words. I haven't seen any dots and a Google search only brought up sheet music available to buy I'm afraid.
Martin
This any good? https://digital.lib.sun.ac.za/handle/10019.2/19501 (https://digital.lib.sun.ac.za/handle/10019.2/19501) Biggish download but actual music starts on 3rd page. Page 3 attached as an example.
Great tune!
-
Oh well dug out CAB, thank you so much!
That's my next homework then, trying to sort that lot out :Ph
-
Does this tune change key ? The right hand stays the same, but in a workshop led by Paul Hutchinson at Halsway Manor using this tune arrangement he showed how the choice of chords can make such a difference...
'Cam Ye Oer Frae France'
https://youtu.be/A0U6Q5CDbHY
I certainly like to vary my chords but it can be problematic when playing with other people ::)
Julian
-
Does this tune change key ? The right hand stays the same, but in a workshop led by Paul Hutchinson at Halsway Manor using this tune arrangement he showed how the choice of chords can make such a difference...
'Cam Ye Oer Frae France'
https://youtu.be/A0U6Q5CDbHY
I certainly like to vary my chords but it can be problematic when playing with other people ::)
Julian
Nice tune!! I wouldn't be concerned about classifying it...just jump in and keep going. Definitely going on my to learn list.
-
Good stuff Julian, I like that!
-
Thanks Dick and Q.
Who remembers the Steeleye Span version all those years ago ?
Julian
-
"Who remembers the Steeleye Span version all those years ago ?"
I certainly do. It's on one of my Spotify playlists which I listen to regularly. But your version has slightly different notes here and there. To be expected I suppose, after all; it is folk music!
-
Thanks Dick and Q.
Who remembers the Steeleye Span version all those years ago ?
Julian
I just listened to it, again (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8NrHkf7rB34)
Between the two (yours and theirs), their version is more produced, but I prefer your approach. Is that from JK's workshop? it works really well.
[in the way it flows, as well as the harmonies]
-
It's Paul Hutchinson's version more or less, Greg and Winston. Three different sets of chords - firstly based around Em, then C, and Am (which doesn't sit so well but I like the impact !)
I've come across other versions of the tune - with different names - 'Lang Stayed Away', 'Jack Lintels' and 'Keys to the Cellar' come to mind.
Julian
-
It's Paul Hutchinson's version more or less, Greg and Winston. Three different sets of chords - firstly based around Em, then C, and Am (which doesn't sit so well but I like the impact !)
Thanks Julian. It's an odd thing, I've known this tune for a long, long time and tried it out on a few instruments, but I've never really liked it. After hearing you play it here, I agree with Dick. Definitely one for the to learn list.
-
Does this tune change key ? The right hand stays the same, but in a workshop led by Paul Hutchinson at Halsway Manor using this tune arrangement he showed how the choice of chords can make such a difference...
'Cam Ye Oer Frae France' https://youtu.be/A0U6Q5CDbHY
I certainly like to vary my chords but it can be problematic when playing with other people ::) Julian
Thank you for the link. I remember them doing it at Cambridge festival in 1974. A superb arrangement. Listening the track through they are in C Minor, and I cannot hear an A/Ab note in there. So it is essentially pentatonic, ambiguous with respect to C minor Aeolian, or Dorian. That is why it is so ‘open’, and why for example you might to use eg F major, or minor as its sub-dominant.
In D/G terms, tonic E the missing 6th note is C(±#) the chords choice would be Amaj, Am7, or a straightforward C. No it doesn’t change key. And no, different musicians playing different functional chords wouldn’t sound all that good 🥴
-
https://youtu.be/gBL5pgoqggk
Where have all the flowers gone?
(Bes, C and F keys)
(Soon my sister will sing this song, she is rehearsing)
-
Polka du Bas Berry played in G with the third part in C rather than the more usual D and G.
https://youtu.be/NQ2gytb93xQ (https://youtu.be/NQ2gytb93xQ)
and from the archive Homage a Jean-Paul Beaulieu https://youtu.be/D70sgolleo4 (https://youtu.be/D70sgolleo4). 3 keys for the price of 2.
Mitch
-
Here's one from 17 months ago, a somewhat heavy-handed early exploration of the C#D system. Chief O'Neill's Favourite starts off in D major but throws in the occasional C natural and then flirts with the minor for a bit at the start of the turn before coming home.
https://youtu.be/S8pF7So9HNI (https://youtu.be/S8pF7So9HNI)
-
Here is a fine wee Scottish, “l’Ecossaise†written by Philippe Prieur. First part in G, second part in C with an F bass/chord to mark the change. Played in my usual slightly clunky style but a lovely tune all the same. I learned it by ear so I don’t have any sheet music.
https://youtu.be/D6dBPh8BGFA
Maggie :|||:
-
Monfrina Le e Mi - an Italian fiddle tune from the Caffaro Valley which moves from D to G. Learnt from Jimbo although I believe it was originally imported by IanD. As with any tune I've learnt from Jim, this is a slightly simplified version!
https://youtu.be/mpAmKmVdM2I
I think this is the first time I've contributed to both Tune and Theme in the same month despite having been around a while! (:)
N
-
Squeaking, no, squeezing in before the end of the month. ;)
I have a handful of tunes I've written myself, and a significant proportion of them fit the theme so it took me a while to choose what to post. Here's a pair of jigs (Disturbing the Heron and Watery Jig): https://youtu.be/htJP6oAHjPQ
The first one starts in G major and ends up in D major in the second half. The second tune might not technically fit the theme as it's a modal change only. It hops between G major and D mixolydian, so while the scale doesn't change, the feel is quite different. Hope you enjoy.
-
Did you post the right link there, Becci? I get a straight-through duet in a minor key 🙂
G major => D mixolydian. It’s a modal ‘shift’, and also a changed tonic note.
… Begging the question whether Gmaj <=> G ‘minor’ counts as a ‘change of key’? I’d say yes 🤔
-
Did you post the right link there, Becci? I get a straight-through duet in a minor key 🙂
G major => D mixolydian. It’s a modal ‘shift’, and also a changed tonic note.
… Begging the question whether Gmaj <=> G ‘minor’ counts as a ‘change of key’? I’d say yes 🤔
That's interesting Chris, that sounds like one of my recent videos, but not the one I meant to post. Try this link instead? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=htJP6oAHjPQ (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=htJP6oAHjPQ)
I would also say Gmaj to Gm counts as a key change, yes.
-
...The second tune might not technically fit the theme as it's a modal change only. It hops between G major and D mixolydian, so while the scale doesn't change, the feel is quite different. Hope you enjoy.
The only rule is there are no rules ;D
That's a great tune well played.
-
Thanks a lot!
-
The only rule is there are no rules ;D That's a great tune well played.
I sense that this was the tongue in cheek, but actually there are quite a few rules, which is why sometimes the a chord feels totally wrong for a tune, and whereas it’s great with another. Generally it’s just a matter of identifying whether a ‘minor’ is aolian or dorian. Does the tune use C, or C#? Simple as that.
That isn’t to say that the Corps Melodistae are not some of the most eloquent and recalcitrant rule-breakers in music. In classical terms … “music enemy number one†😉
I once sat and watched Canada’s Philippe Bruno play the same tune in 3-4 different minor keys, under a tree. On a 1-row! Some of the notes in the variants … just weren’t there 🤔 but my ear still heard them. It was a spellbinding feat of keyboard prestidigitation.
Put another way, he played a great (and well known) tune very well indeed.
-
The only rule is there are no rules ;D That's a great tune well played.
I sense that this was the tongue in cheek, but actually there are quite a few rules, w
I was dead serious, but possibly ambiguous. To clarify: There are no rules in Theme of the Month, at least that's what Mr CW says. It's just an excuse to post a tune or two, or three...
You make some very good points, though.
-
"actually there are quite a few rules"
Then how can someone who doesn't know any of the rules manage to knock out tunes which aren't actually painful to listen to? (Or perhaps I'm completely deluded with regards to my own sub-standard efforts?)
-
Just trust your ear. The underlying musical structures ‘explain’ why things sound nice, but the layout of our instrument makes most of that happen automatically once you master what chord works with what row, in what direction. It is perfectly legal to fudge that. It only sort of goes wrong when you have several Melodeon’s all in the same room playing eg E dorian tune. Half of the bang a C chord, half fudge Am7 = C/Abass, half half play the correct pull A chord with its C#.
Not so pretty 🥴 but if you are content with that, or only play solo, by all means carry on. For me, getting the right chord has vastly improved accompaniment to my songs. That is eg dorian Em I now play pull Amaj, it’s a much cleaner sound.
But I had to actually think about that …
-
Just in time - here's a little Italian tune I picked up a few years back played - I think - in C and G on my trusty pimped Hohner D/G Pokerwork ~ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TuJEfOZG8So (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TuJEfOZG8So)
-
Thanks all - end of the month; next theme inbound! As ever, feel free to stick any late contribs on the end of this thread.