Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: jarviw on September 03, 2022, 03:02:10 PM

Title: Playing along the row
Post by: jarviw on September 03, 2022, 03:02:10 PM
So I have been playing for a few months now, mostly French style across the rows, which I find very intuitive. But I see the English/Irish style playing along the row with a lot more bellow reversal. I feel I should at least learn a few songs and practice the different style.
Any recommendations for fun little songs I should learn? I don't necessarily need tabs as I can read music just fine, although it may be helpful so I don't revert to my default across the row playing. Thanks!
Title: Re: Playing along the row
Post by: GBbox on September 03, 2022, 04:37:52 PM
The Irish players play chromatic instruments - aka button accordions – and how much they play across the rows depends on their tuning. At risk to oversimplify: on a B/C accordion, to play in D and G, you have to play across the rows. In other words, less bellows work, and changes of the bellows direction unrelated to the accented notes. On a C#/D accordion you can mainly play on the D row, and use the C natural of the C#  row to play in G, and the G# of  the C# row to play in A. A lot  more bellows work. And note that the Irish button accordion players use the basses and chords sporadically, if at all.

Since you say that you have been playing mostly French style so far, I assume you are playing a G/C box. The English players in general play the D/G. This imply that the English players usually play on the upper part of the RH keyboard, while the French players play usually on the central/lower one.  Whether this actually makes a real difference in the end is debatable, but  no doubt the lower full octaves on a melodeon can be played using four buttons, while the upper ones are spread over five.

Anyway, to identify the press and draw (mainly on one row) approach with the English melodeon style is misleading. A number of the French early revival melodeon players mainly played mainly press and draw, although it's true that since the mid-eighties the leading ones turned to play systematically across the rows to exploit the full harmonic potential of the two row instruments. Again, please note that there is a huge difference between the playing across the rows and the cross rows style approaches.

As an example of a French press and draw oriented player I suggest you to listen to the seminal solo LP Accordeon Diatonique, recorded by Jean Blanchard in 1977. The album was later reprinted in digital format ( MW Records, 2000), but you don't need to find the vinyl or the CD, as you can listen to the tracks in streaming (Spotify, Dezeer...).

In other words: if you already play some French tunes across the rows, simply learn them again using just one ;)!
Title: Re: Playing along the row
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on September 03, 2022, 05:18:43 PM
...I assume you are playing a G/C box. The English players in general play the D/G. This imply that the English players usually play on the upper part of the RH keyboard, while the French players play usually on the central/lower one...


 ??? My impression from various sources and experience of playing DG MM is exactly the opposite of that.
Oh, are you talking about distance from the ground, not pitch?
Title: Re: Playing along the row
Post by: GBbox on September 03, 2022, 05:33:06 PM


 ??? My impression from various sources and experience of playing DG MM is exactly the opposite of that.
Oh, are you talking about distance from the ground, not pitch?

Upper part = top - lower notes in pitch
Lower part = bottom - higher notes in pitch
Title: Re: Playing along the row
Post by: jarviw on September 03, 2022, 05:33:31 PM
The Irish players play chromatic instruments
Good point! I actually played chromatic harmonica C/C#, so I am familiar with the idea behind B/C or C#/D. But that said, they still play push-pull mostly right? (more just the style?)


Since you say that you have been playing mostly French style so far, I assume you are playing a G/C box. The English players in general play the D/G. This imply that the English players usually play on the upper part of the RH keyboard, while the French players play usually on the central/lower one.  Whether this actually makes a real difference in the end is debatable, but  no doubt the lower full octaves on a melodeon can be played using four buttons, while the upper ones are spread over five.

I really started out on the GCF box, which allowed me to play the full C scale on both directions. I kind of learned to decide the bellow direction based on the bass chord first and then phrasing. GC box with the F/F allowed me to play it according the tabs (which is often easier, since the music was written for a GC box). 
But as to English music written for D/G, well, I can always transpose the music :)

Anyway, to identify the press and draw (mainly on one row) approach with the English melodeon style is misleading. A number of the French early revival melodeon players mainly played mainly press and draw, although it's true that since the mid-eighties the leading ones turned to play systematically across the rows to exploit the full harmonic potential of the two row instruments. Again, please note that there is a huge difference between the playing across the rows and the cross rows style approaches.

As an example of a French press and draw oriented player I suggest you to listen to the seminal solo LP Accordeon Diatonique, recorded by Jean Blanchard in 1977. The album was later reprinted in digital format ( MW Records, 2000), but you don't need to find the vinyl or the CD, as you can listen to the tracks in streaming (Spotify, Dezeer...).

In other words: if you already play some French tunes across the rows, simply learn them again using just one ;)!

That's a very nice note on the history! Honestly I would really enjoy reading more posts on the musicology of melodeons!
But yes, I guess I could play the tunes I have learned and just play them on one row :D (well, won't be able to do the bass the same way, but practice is practice!)

Still though, recommend me some English tunes! Andy Cutting doesn't count here :D
Title: Re: Playing along the row
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on September 03, 2022, 05:42:56 PM
...they still play push-pull mostly right? (more just the style?)...

...Still though, recommend me some English tunes! Andy Cutting doesn't count here :D

As I understand it (speaking as a DG/CF player), it's not so much the style as playing the way the instrument dictates. Apart from the "magic" notes (B and E on a BC), notes are only available in one direction. The style is more a result, than a choice

If Andy doesn't count, check out Squeezy (John Spiers).
Title: Re: Playing along the row
Post by: Anahata on September 03, 2022, 06:43:57 PM
So I have been playing for a few months now, mostly French style across the rows, which I find very intuitive. But I see the English/Irish style playing along the row with a lot more bellow reversal. I feel I should at least learn a few songs and practice the different style.
Any recommendations for fun little songs I should learn? I don't necessarily need tabs as I can read music just fine, although it may be helpful so I don't revert to my default across the row playing. Thanks!

You could do worse than Lester's Tune-a-Day (https://lesters-tune-a-day.blogspot.com/) - mostly English, lots of them, music and video, definitely played in push-pull style!

I also have an online index to all my YouTube videos, with music for most of them: https://maryanahata.co.uk/music.php which you might find useful. Some other instruments, songs and foreigners, but mostly English tunes!
Title: Re: Playing along the row
Post by: jarviw on September 03, 2022, 08:01:41 PM
Thanks Anahata! That's exactly what I was looking for! Why didn't I check out Lester's site before!?

Thanks Greg for recommending John Spiers! Surely I read about him a couple times but really just now checked his videos out! Very nice and beautiful work!
Title: Re: Playing along the row
Post by: GBbox on September 03, 2022, 08:05:41 PM

I really started out on the GCF box, which allowed me to play the full C scale on both directions. I kind of learned to decide the bellow direction based on the bass chord first and then phrasing. GC box with the F/F allowed me to play it according the tabs (which is often easier, since the music was written for a GC box). 
But as to English music written for D/G, well, I can always transpose the music :)
...

Still though, recommend me some English tunes! Andy Cutting doesn't count here :D

Yes, the G/C/F box is not a G/C with an additional row to play in F and four additional buttons at the bottom of the LH keyboard, but a C/F instrument with an additional row to play in G and four additional buttons at the top of the LH keyboard. On it you can play all the tunes you have learned on a C/F, but you'll have to re-learn most of the ones learned in C on a G/C box, because the F chord on it is mainly played on the pull.

This is the reason why the G/C/F is now the standard instrument for the Norteno players. The players of the older generations used the C/F they had inherited, along with the repertoire, from the German immigrants, so  the three row brought with it an added value. And this is the reason the G/C/F is ignored by the French players. On a 2 ½ or 3 row G/C based instrument you can play in a number of different keys – especially using the harmonic minor scales – but you can still play all the tunes learned on the 2 row G/C box.

About your last request, my suggestion would not be of some English tunes, but rather of an English player. For what it could matter, since I'm not an English player myself!. Look at your Inbox, I'll PM you.
Title: Re: Playing along the row
Post by: Becci Pamely-Bast on September 04, 2022, 07:43:14 AM
 My instinct is to play across the rows too, and I have been learning a lot of French music, which suits that way of playing very well. A few months ago, the Tune of the Month on here was a Morris jig called “Lumps of Plum Pudding” and I had to force myself away from my tendency to cross the rows all the way through as it sounds so much better with the push-pull sound. That’s my recommendation (:)
Title: Re: Playing along the row
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 04, 2022, 08:49:45 AM
It seems to me there are two schools of thought amongst English players.
Those who play along the rows and consider it as having two one -row melodeons bolted together.

Those who cross rows. I think of the keyboard as containing all the notes of the key of G and all the notes from the key of D and I pick and choose the note from whichever row to suit to play the tune and give me the choice of basses and chords I want.
... though others may well disagree!
Title: Re: Playing along the row
Post by: Julian S on September 04, 2022, 09:15:52 AM
They are not mutually exclusive !
I often mix and match - cross row phrases and push pull. It all depends on the tune.

Julian
Title: Re: Playing along the row
Post by: Squeaky Pete on September 04, 2022, 09:59:46 AM
That's exactly right Julian.
Title: Re: Playing along the row
Post by: CAB on September 04, 2022, 10:04:06 AM
They are not mutually exclusive !
I often mix and match - cross row phrases and push pull. It all depends on the tun

Exactly. I used to cross rows to reduce bellows changes but came to realise it was sometimes useful to cross to the other row for a whole phrase, still playing press and draw to maintain some bounce while letting me play the chord I want.
Title: Re: Playing along the row
Post by: Andy Next Tune on September 04, 2022, 10:04:52 AM
A lot of the 'English-style' comes from the effective use of the bellows to accentuate notes and rhythm, and to 'lift' the dancers. The bellows delivers that 'English'  bouncy style, not on-the-row vs cross-row playing.

The bellows are the box player's equivalent of the violin's bow.


Title: Re: Playing along the row
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on September 04, 2022, 10:59:45 AM

Thanks Greg for recommending John Spiers! Surely I read about him a couple times but really just now checked his videos out! Very nice and beautiful work!

John is a top player. Highly recommended. He is top man round these parts, as well. This site is his fault  :D.
Title: Re: Playing along the row
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 04, 2022, 01:03:13 PM
Julian, yes absolutely right, not mutually exclusive.
I also mix and match to fit a tune.
Yes there are two schools of thought, but in reality use a bit of both as and when you desire.

Andy also makes a great point, it's the bellows that gives lift into a tune.
Title: Re: Playing along the row
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 05, 2022, 05:09:05 PM

   through the 18 months or so that I was commuting to Paris, my Parisienne friend, also a Melodeon player, was absolutely amazed at
   how good tunes started when played “on the row” with that much more percussive attack. It suits English country dance music very
   well, and isn’t all that bad when you play strongly phrased French music such as a bourrée, stepped mazurka or French style polka.

    More laconic, phrased all settled French dance music is better cross-rowed. You may then explore it’s subtlety.

    Good luck with singing. Not many manage that,  and in my own case I tend to breathe with the bellows 🥴. I do all my songs against
    either right-hand chords, or cross-towed stuff, in the main arpeggios with twiddles.

    So both are correct. Are you sure you have interpretation decisions to make and should be sensitive to the song or melody itself in
    what you do. And to a slight extent to your audience. That is to say that you should learn both styles.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal