Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: strad on November 02, 2009, 05:15:39 PM
-
I'm getting on reasonably with the buttons located at the centre and low note end of the keyboard but am finding it less easy when the tune heads towards the high notes. What tunes/suggestions do you think will help me progress?
-
Try playing the tunes you know an octave higher. Save learning two things at once.
-
Try playing the tunes you know an octave higher. Save learning two things at once.
Yes, good advice, that's how I learned to cope with the dusty end.
-
Is it true that the dusty end of the melodeon is same fingering as RH of anglo concertina?
-
Is it true that the dusty end of the melodeon is same fingering as RH of anglo concertina?
Indeed it is (but you should already know that being a player of both) ;)
-
What tunes/suggestions do you think will help me progress?
Learn to play scales and arpeggios over two octaves, I found that very helpful for working out where to shift hand position, and how the fingering of the two octaves differs. D, G, Am and Em for starters, A and Bm when you feel more adventurous.
Next step - learn to play in octaves, every note played an octave above (or below) at the same time as where you usually play it. Has the additional advantage of making your playing louder so you can save the cost of buying a 4 voice box!
-
Try playing the tunes you know an octave higher. Save learning two things at once.
Yes, good advice, that's how I learned to cope with the dusty end.
Thanks, did I mention I'm running a workshop in March? ;D Strad is already signed up :Ph
-
Oh! Is that what I'm doing in March??
I'm transcribing (on my PC) some tunes I know really well to put them in the dusty area.
Hopefully that'll help.
Nigel
-
Yup, different fingering up there ??? The only answer is to just do it. I have used a combination of scale practice and tunes. Andy Cutting's Flatworld and incontinental mood were a big help. Eventually your fingers learn the way and you don't have to think about it any more.
-
Andy Cutting's Flatworld and incontinental mood were a big help. Eventually your fingers learn the way and you don't have to think about it any more.
I'm almost there with these tunes in the higher octave. Started L'inconnu d' Limoise yesterday and think it works quite well in both octaves. The only tune I play that hits the very top button is J Spiers Autumn Hornpipe.
Cheers
Sandy
(:)
-
Andy Cutting's Flatworld and incontinental mood were a big help. Eventually your fingers learn the way and you don't have to think about it any more.
I'm almost there with these tunes in the higher octave. Started L'inconnu d' Limoise yesterday and think it works quite well in both octaves. The only tune I play that hits the very top button is J Spiers Autumn Hornpipe.
Cheers
Sandy
(:)
Also recommend Mrs Saggs for trips around both the dusty end and cross rowing.
X: 218
T:Mrs Saggs
M:4/4
L:1/8
K:G
d|ga b4 a2|gf g4 bd'|
e'/f'/g' d'g' c'g'd'g'|g'2 f'e'f'd' e'f'|
g'2 d'2 c'bag|d2 c2 B2 d2|
eceg bagf|g4:||
G|AB c4 B2|AGDF Adfd|
ef g2 d2 cB|AG B2 AG A2-|
AB c4 B2|AGFA df a2|
gf g2 d2 cB|AG G4:||
-
Some of the versions of the Stony Steps hornpipe are good as they need a low C. This means playing it in the upper octave to be able to descend to the low notes. Have a look at any fiddle tunes which use the open low G string - these always require playing in the upper octave to facilitate the low notes (the Hardcore English book has plenty).
-
Started L'inconnu d' Limoise yesterday and think it works quite well in both octaves.
On my mp3 I'm playing the high version (with a lower register). A lot of those French tunes are usually played higher. In France the standard tuning is G/C, so about half an octave lower than D/G. Makes the lower notes a bit grumpy.
-
Next step - learn to play in octaves ... Has the additional advantage of making your playing louder so you can save the cost of buying a 4 voice box!
Not if you like the 8 voice sound of playing in octaves on that one. (:)
-
Next step - learn to play in octaves ... Has the additional advantage of making your playing louder so you can save the cost of buying a 4 voice box!
Not if you like the 8 voice sound of playing in octaves on that one. (:)
Note to self: remember earplugs if invited to play with Simon. ;D ;D
-
The way I remember things is that all the "out" notes are on pattern & all the "in" notes are another. These patterns don't change all the way up, they are just different to each other.
On b/c/c#, you can play in the key of A on all "out" notes. So I learned by using those notes then filling in the gaps in between with the odd brave "in" note.
granted it's a different story on the B/C, just thought I'd say :|glug
-
All the hints and comments have beeen gratefully received. Thanks everybody.
It looks like Graeme is trying to get me interested in a box with a third row! I
have enough problems lifting the one I've got. Though it might balance me when
I carry two. In another life I think I might learn the piccolo :|bl
-
its also worth remebering that when playing on the row the push pull sequence is exactly the same in both octaves i.e. blow suck, blow suck, blow suck, suck blow. the difference being that you move onto the next higher (towards your feet) button for the second note of each pair & come back one button for the last note. Theos advice to play scales right up the box & Graemes to play your existing tunes in higher are without a adoubt the best way of getting the hang of it. You can then make tunes more interesting by ocasionally slipping up or down an octave as a simple but very attractive variation. The 'fear' of the dusty end is irrational & severely limits the range of tunes ,particularly as some composers are most inconsiderate & think up tunes that sit accross both actaves.!
george ;D
-
I basically know where the notes are, it's just my manual dexterity seems to vary depending whereabouts on the buttons I'm playing, Grrrrrr! (No emote for frustrated!) Still, Ive excavated copies of The Sally Gardens, The Sligo Maid and O'Rorke's to practise on. The B part of all three are in the dusty area. It'll come if I keep at it (Did I really say that???)
-
All the hints and comments have beeen gratefully received. Thanks everybody.
It looks like Graeme is trying to get me interested in a box with a third row! I
have enough problems lifting the one I've got. Though it might balance me when
I carry two. In another life I think I might learn the piccolo :|bl
Still have my Gaelic if you fancy a purchase
-
All the hints and comments have beeen gratefully received. Thanks everybody.
It looks like Graeme is trying to get me interested in a box with a third row! I
have enough problems lifting the one I've got. Though it might balance me when
I carry two. In another life I think I might learn the piccolo :|bl
Still have my Gaelic if you fancy a purchase
good gaelics are hard to come by & handle very well & no , I'm not on commision!
george ;)
-
good gaelics are hard to come by & handle very well & no , I'm not on commision!
george ;)
There is one on ebay (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=120486137156) at the mo.
-
Good find theo. It's the 3 voice version. Good to see it in black. be interesting to see what it gets after the last one. There is a reserve on this one.
My Gaelic is the IVS with midi. Cracking spare box.
Anyway thread drift!!!
How about those higher octaves eh! Lets not forget the buttons bellow middle C too
-
the ebay one is the rare 3 voice (MMM) version - at least I thought they were rare but this is the second one thats cropped up on ebay recently - or is it the same one
george
-
I basically know where the notes are, it's just my manual dexterity seems to vary depending whereabouts on the buttons I'm playing, Grrrrrr! (No emote for frustrated!) Still, Ive excavated copies of The Sally Gardens, The Sligo Maid and O'Rorke's to practise on. The B part of all three are in the dusty area. It'll come if I keep at it (Did I really say that???)
Using your little finger? No? Ignore the rest of this message.
Yes? Ditch it. Just try playing the B parts of these tunes without using the 4th finger. Get your whole hand up at the dusty end. However absurd, illogical and counterintuitive you think the idea sounds, give it a good try, for a week or two, until you can handle all the shifts comfortably. Based on my own experience, and that of many others, there's a strong chance your playing of passages like these will improve dramatically.
I know George and Graeme won't agree with this suggestion, and I really have no wish to debate the whole idea again. (Really!) But give it a try: the great majority of Irish players essentially don't use the little finger. There are great ones that do, of course, and maybe you can join their ranks (though most of them seem to have started playing very young indeed). But if you can't, don't bang your head against a brick wall.
Cheers
Steve
-
I don't think choosing fingers is the problem, it's the back to front notes etc.
Steve is right....I do disagree.
But I'm not going to get into the debate, he's tryin to help.
Thats what great about this forum, everyone has their own little way of doing things. Listen to them all and work out your own path.
-
I got a bit lost in the little finger debate, but I think that the conclusion was that it depends how strong your little finger is. Was that right?
-
I got a bit lost in the little finger debate, but I think that the conclusion was that it depends how strong your little finger is. Was that right?
Whose conclusion? Opinions differ. As far as I'm concerned the only valid conclusion is your own, based on whether it works for you or not, and that's something you can't judge unless you give both approaches a proper trial.
Graeme, your gracious comment is appreciated.
Cheers
S
-
I've been following this thread with interest - I'm having the same problem with digital dexterity at the dusty end.
I am trying to use my little finger where it makes sense - i.e. high notes juxtaposed against low or mod range notes.
What I am wondering is, what is the best position for the hand if you want the little finger to come into play?
I see many players leaving the thumb on the edge of the fingerboard, to use the little finger in this I seem to have to drop my elbow and slant the hand diagonally down to the right to allow the pinkie to actually reach the note. It's too short otherwise.
Alternatively, I've seen players locate their thumb behind the fingerboard allowing the hand to be much flatter and moving the little finger into play. DTN does this http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O4UWBfkvkw4 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O4UWBfkvkw4) and he seems to play well.
So what do you think is the best way to use the hand to aid pinkie dexterity?
-
Look how this fellow does it - a bit of pinky-less dusty stuff early in this clip.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=erbFXptMpD4&feature=related
(And a glorious mistake at the 1:00 mark, taken in his stride with a winning smile.)
-
I've practised and have some success!
I can now do the smile and the foot tapping but the button pushing bit still eludes me!
But seriously, he's a thumb on the edge style and doing it well
-
What I am wondering is, what is the best position for the hand if you want the little finger to come into play?
try ( with thumb on edge of keyboard)arching fingers 123 so that the finger tips hit the buttons ( nails need to be kept short). The little finger then goes diagonally so that its end is in line with the tips of the other three. This is not an eexact science but is bradly speaking a hand position that if more or less adhered to enables full use of the little finger as & when required aacording to the par ticular bit of the particular tune. As otheres have said it even if you play mostly with 3 fingers it is useful to be able to bring in the little finger occasionally or as many do to use it regularly. This positioning of the hand works on boith BC & DG type boxes.
george
-
But seriously, he's a thumb on the edge style and doing it well
.. is there another way ???
Both my boxes have grooves down the edge.
I sort of assumed it was for my thumb ::)
-
it is a lot eaiser when there is a groove but not all boxes have them. The thumb on the edge isn't just to keep it out of the way, its like an anchor to keep your hand steady while you play, along with a pivot to send the other four fingers to each end of the box.
i was playing the other night at a gig, and realised one of the ways I learned about the higher and lower notes. Play octave doubles.
Choose an easy tune such as leaving lismore see video here http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PmzZbYeSFDU (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PmzZbYeSFDU) and play the whole tune with your pointy finger & pinky. Using both octaves. Won't sound very smooth but will help to realise where the notes are.
-
But seriously, he's a thumb on the edge style and doing it well
.. is there another way ???
Both my boxes have grooves down the edge.
I sort of assumed it was for my thumb ::)
I don't play with my thumb on the edge, as I find it very uncomfortable. Instead I have my thumb resting lightly on the underside of the fingerboard. I use two straps, so there is very little pressure needed with that hand, so I have all the mobility that I could wish for. Indeed I would prefer to tuck my thumb behind the rest of my hand than place it in the groove. I also have very big hands, so can reach the inner row with arched fingers perfectly easily in that position.
-
to use the little finger in this I seem to have to drop my elbow and slant the hand diagonally down to the right to allow the pinkie to actually reach the note. It's too short otherwise.
I'm not sure I understand. Why not just move your hand down the keyboard until the button is in reach?
-
perhaps eaasdale is a one strapper! using 2 straps greatly facilitates moving the hand up & down the keybord
george ;)
-
I got a bit lost in the little finger debate, but I think that the conclusion was that it depends how strong your little finger is.
It will get stronger if you use it. There aren't many piano players using only three fingers. ;)
-
playing whole tunes with just the little finger leaves it with no choice but to function properly! Another way is to procure an old underwood manual typewriter & learn to touch type on it, I did when in my teens and am sure its the main reason why I can get a fair amount of clout out of my little finger.
george`
-
More easily obtainable and portable little finger exercisers are widely available from your local hardware shop. Place in the palm of the hand and press down with the pinkie. Works for other fingers too. Keep one in your coat pocket and use time waiting in the bus queue to train your fingers.
-
More easily obtainable and portable little finger exercisers are widely available from your local hardware shop. Place in the palm of the hand and press down with the pinkie. Works for other fingers too. Keep one in your coat pocket and use time waiting in the bus queue to train your fingers.
I use one of these Gripmasters (http://www.gripmasterpro.com/bodygm.html), if you want to try don't be macho start on the light weight one!
(http://www.cleverjoe.com/articles/gripmaster.jpg)
-
I use one of these Gripmasters (http://www.gripmasterpro.com/bodygm.html), if you want to try don't be macho start on the light weight one!
The buttons on my melodeon don't require that much pressure anyway. ;)
-
I've been told that 20 minutes a day moulding plasticine will do the trick - enabling one to have pinkies rippling with the most amazing muscles imaginable. Don't know why new instruments don't come with a ball of the stuff as standard?
;D
-
I've been told that 20 minutes a day moulding plasticine will do the trick - enabling one to have pinkies rippling with the most amazing muscles imaginable. Don't know why new instruments don't come with a ball of the stuff as standard?
;D
Are you moulding it into fingers?
-
I got a bit lost in the little finger debate, but I think that the conclusion was that it depends how strong your little finger is.
It will get stronger if you use it. There aren't many piano players using only three fingers. ;)
Which is why it never occurred to me not to use it :P
-
Be aware that strong fingers are not necessarily dexterous ones.
-
I agree.
The music shop I once worked in used to sell gripmasters and the advice given to anyone wanting to buy one was that they're great if you're a rock climber or recovering from a stroke but your fingers need sensitivity, dexterity and good conditioning rather than great strength and the best way to achieve that is simply by playing more because things like gripmasters can't replicate the same range of movement and fine control and don't do much for your musicality either ....we didn't sell many.
Building up power in your fingers for playing instruments is a bit like training for running a marathon by doing loads of leg presses instead of actually running, it probably helps a bit at the start but it's no substitute for the real thing.
-
Be aware that strong fingers are not necessarily dexterous ones.
But neither do weak ones.
The advantage of the clothespeg is that it allows you to exercise one finger at a time, which should help you to develop better control of a wayward pinkie.
-
I got a bit lost in the little finger debate, but I think that the conclusion was that it depends how strong your little finger is.
It will get stronger if you use it. There aren't many piano players using only three fingers. ;)
Which is why it never occurred to me not to use it :P
A nice red herring, that. I might just as well say there are very few piano players who don't use their thumbs, so how come you're not all making as heavy use of the thumb as piano players?
Could the answer possibly be that pianos and melodjans are not quite the same instrument? ???
And if you watch piano players, you will see that the length of the keys is what makes it possible to use all the fingers easily. Small buttons in a straight line are a rather different matter.
Use your little fingers if you want to, of course, many great players do.
Just not many who play the tunes strad was looking for help with - Sally Gardens, Sligo Maid and O'Rourke's reel IIRC - well on a semitone box. ;) I know all you guys can, of course. >:E
-
A nice red herring, that. I might just as well say there are very few piano players who don't use their thumbs, so how come you're not all making as heavy use of the thumb as piano players?
Could the answer possibly be that pianos and melodjans are not quite the same instrument? ???
And if you watch piano players, you will see that the length of the keys is what makes it possible to use all the fingers easily. Small buttons in a straight line are a rather different matter.
Quite right, which is why the thumb is not used so much. No reason not to use the little finger though.
Just not many who play the tunes strad was looking for help with - Sally Gardens, Sligo Maid and O'Rourke's reel IIRC - well on a semitone box. ;) I know all you guys can, of course. >:E
You may well be right there, I wouldn't know :P
-
Could the answer possibly be that pianos and melodjans are not quite the same instrument? ???
And if you watch piano players, you will see that the length of the keys is what makes it possible to use all the fingers easily. Small buttons in a straight line are a rather different matter.
And looking at it the other way: piano players have to use much bigger physical stretches to get the same musical interval. I've not measured it but I would guess that octaves must be twice the physical distance on a piano as on a button box.
-
And if you watch piano players, you will see that the length of the keys is what makes it possible to use all the fingers easily. Small buttons in a straight line are a rather different matter.
Use your little fingers if you want to, of course, many great players do.
Of course it's a different instrument, but melodeon buttons are pretty easy to reach with your little finger. I agree that you don't really need to use your little finger, but it can be very useful if you do (for example playing higher melodies while your index finger is busy on the lower notes). A 'weak' little finger is too often used as an excuse to not even try it. As for most instruments it may be difficult to use it in the beginning, but with time and practice your little finger will get stronger.
-
I don't think the gripmasters were designed with box players in mind. I teach a lot of beginner guitar lessons and the reasoning behind them I can see is to build up the squeezing strength for your fretting hand. Its much much harder to produce a clean fretted note on a cheap beginner guitar with a huge action than it is to press a small plastic button against a spring.
I think if you play enough and work on tunes which exercise you in the right way then there is no need for a gripmaster. Press up's for bellows control anyone?
-
I'm reading all this with interest. Some of my thoughts are -
Not too many piano players carry their instrument about with them!
I'm used to using my pinky with playing the fiddle. Of course, that's on the other hand!
The three tunes I mentioned above all have B music which is concentrated
on that dusty end. It's definitely helping by practising (what's that) these three tunes
no matter how well or badly I'm playing them.
There never seems enough room for my pork sausage fingers round the G,A, & B buttons.
To strengthen the pinky why not carry the melodeon in its box using just the little finger?
Why do we call it the keyboard when it should be the button board?
I used my melodeon for the first time when my band was playing for a dance on Saturday evening.
With no foldback speakers I couldn't tell what I was doing. Nothing unusual in that!
Nigel
-
I chimed in on this thread, not to bore the pants off everyone by flogging a dead horse, but because Nigel was asking about Irish tunes of the kind I have done a lot of work and experimentation on, played on a semitone box (As you all know I play C#/D, but I do experiment with B/C fingerings a fair bit of the time). My suggestion was for him, and not for the rest of you fellas playing different styles of music on different styles of boxes. OK chaps?
And it was a suggestion, to be tried, chewed over, and swallowed or spat out depending on the results. (Seemingly logical assumptions and theory carried over from other instruments be damned - just try it.)
Nigel, no matter that you have pork sausage fingers - they can get out of each others' way very handily. I make a lot of use of different fingers hitting the same button (for a couple of different ornaments, but also for playing the melody straight) and this involves the fingers dancing about so as not to step on each others' feet, as it were. I can suggest some exercises for this - send me a PM if you are interested. Are you playing with your fingertips, btw, or more with the flats of the fingers?
I remember the first time I played a set of reels on the box in my dance band - for a contradance, at the usual insane speeds the callers like. I felt as if I had just spent 8 minutes in a wrestling ring with a gorilla. It does get easier!
-
I Are you playing with your fingertips, btw, or more with the flats of the fingers?
Steve, what are you suggesting? Fingertips or flats? Is it a matter of personal preference or do you think one style is better than the other?
What about these exercises?
How do they work?
Us learners are always keen for good advice.
Thanks
-
Steve, what are you suggesting? Fingertips or flats? Is it a matter of personal preference or do you think one style is better than the other?
What about these exercises? How do they work?
Well you see both styles used by excellent players. I prefer to use fingertips, as I think playing on the mainly on the inside row, as you do on a B/C or C#/D, would be a bit trickier with the flats of the fingers. And I thought that pork sausages lying flat in the pan as it were might be harder to get out of each others' way.
The first exercise for finger shuffling I would recommend is one that was shown to me and which set me off on all kinds of interesting discoveries.
Take a figure such as dDDD, or aAAA, such as occur in many Irish and other tunes in various forms (mostly ornamented, but here played straight, four quavers/eighth notes, this is not an attempt at a triplet or a treble) and play it with fingers 3121. Ad nauseam.
Cheers
Steve
-
Thanks Steve,
I'll give it a go.
I've also experimented with using fingertips. Thanks for the advice.
-
Actually I just realized those examples are more natural for a D box. on a B/C they'd involve a longish though by no means impossible stretch (on the pull). Try the notes of cCCC and gGGG for greater comfort. Sorry!
-
By chance I have been putting in more practice in the last week using Mallys Cds of tunes, he plays on D G like me(although he now has fancier ones than my pokerwork! ) The Irish tunes have led me to explore the dusty end and I am enjoying the challenge. The pinky always gets a chance to join in. Great to be finally making more use of all those buttons !
Interesting to read all your thoughts so far.