Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: PeterBRC on September 12, 2022, 09:56:58 PM

Title: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: PeterBRC on September 12, 2022, 09:56:58 PM
I can learn a tune and play from memory quite well but as soon as I try and put 2 or 3 tunes in a row , I find this really difficult to pull off.   Any tips would be much thankfully received

Peter
Title: Re: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: tirpous on September 12, 2022, 10:20:46 PM
Assuming you know the 2-3 tunes well, the difficulty is typically to bring to mind the beginning of the next tune while still playing the end of the first.  As often, the answer is to isolate the problem and practice just the transition.  Maybe have the first few notes of tunes 2 and 3 written down in front of you to jog the memory. And try and find tunes that segue well from one to the next. 

Many years ago with friends, we made up and practiced (and practiced) a number of sets for dance.  It worked so well that now I can hardly play one of our old tunes without having the next one come to mind.

Have fun !     
Title: Re: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: PeterBRC on September 12, 2022, 11:03:18 PM
Yes that looks good advice I think   thanks
Title: Re: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 13, 2022, 08:25:19 AM
If you let fellow sessioneers know the tunes then they can help or even take over the change for you.
I find there's always a momentary lapse in my playing as I mutter 'change' or wiggle a foot in the air.

In my regular sessions we often will stick to one tune, maybe two, and give them a good airing rather than strictly go through tunes twice through and move on. Though sometimes your tunes generate a thought in another player and they take on the tune thread.
But... every session has it's own preferences, so nothing is set in stone.
Title: Re: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on September 13, 2022, 08:27:09 AM
You are not alone in finding this tricky. It can be another of those running through treacle things. Like the rest of them, though, it gets easier with practice.

I found it helped to practice the transitions by themselves. Last line of the first followed by the first line of the second, repeatedly.
Title: Re: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on September 13, 2022, 08:35:15 AM
As Q says, people can be very helpful.

Another thing, if you fall off a tune at the changeover, it can be be better not to stagger your way back into it half way through the first line. Come in the next time through. That applies  generally. It's much more stylish to come in at the start of a part than just blunder.
Title: Re: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 13, 2022, 08:49:30 AM

we’ve all been there. you sort of get into a mood for each tune, and it is hard to break your brain out of that. Agree with the above it is the change over that matters.

A lot of medleys involve a change of key and on a DG the secret switch is in C <=> C# notes. Insert a little ½-note slide between the two, and your brain, and that of the listeners moves into the new key. C implies a gear change down (musically) into the G scale, and C# up into D. 

So practice fitting those in too. It’ll rapidly become automatic. Changing into the new key abruptly works too. Though it’s a bit like changing gear in a car without using the clutch.
Title: Re: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: Little Eggy on September 13, 2022, 10:27:19 AM
I can learn a tune and play from memory quite well but as soon as I try and put 2 or 3 tunes in a row , I find this really difficult to pull off.   Any tips would be much thankfully received

Peter

Someone said something here once that really struck with me and helped.  They said that they'd heard a professional pianist practising and they always isolated particular passages and went over them several times, rather than practising the whole thing.   The same applies to transitions.  If you can isolate the last few bars of tune 1 and the first few of tune 2, and practice them several times, you will make progress.  It also helps you end a tune properly and then start the new one with the required volume/emphasis.  Like a lot of things I guess it's pretty obvious, but there you are!      (Of course this says nothing about the whole issue of "One tune and one tune only" which is guaranteed to get people going on this forum !)
Title: Re: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: Winston Smith on September 13, 2022, 10:49:35 AM
When I was little and my mam sent me to the corner shop, I'd repeat whatever it was that I was going for ('Coronation' milk comes to mind) from leaving our front door to arriving at the shop counter.
Like location, location, location, or education, education, education; you cannot beat a bit of repetition, repetition, repetition! For some of us, it's the only way.
Title: Re: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: MatlockBather on September 13, 2022, 11:31:26 AM
Sounds silly but some tunes fit together easier than others.
Firstly make sure the time signatures are the same, obvious maybe and whilst they can be mixed there is often an element of ‘arrangement’ needed to smooth the change in rhythm.
You might find it easier if the new tune starts on the same note that the other starts or ends with. Your fingers will probably be in the right place to start the new tune. I find it harder if there is a big gap, say an octave, between the end / start notes of the two tunes. Creates a good effect so the audience/dancers can tell there is a new tune but can be harder to do as you might need to alter your hand position.
You can potentially give yourself some more time to organise yourself to do the change by clipping the last note of the out going tune to create a space for you to work in. This is especially effective if the finishing tune has a good run up the scale to a crescendo. You leave everyone hanging momentarily and then you can launch into the new tune with gusto. Maybe not so effective with those that run down the scale and seem to slow in tempo but that just highlights that it is worth plying about with the order you are trying to play them in. Tune X might not run into tune Y but played Y then X might well work.
There are also some ‘musical’ reasons why some tunes work better with others, something about ‘resolving back to the home key’ etc but that doesn’t really affect how to do the change but more if it works and sound like they belong together.
I like playing about making up sets, have fun!
Title: Re: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: Squeaky Pete on September 13, 2022, 11:51:06 AM
Whatever you do, don't pair tunes that share the same first bar or lead in. Therein lies confusion and madness.
Title: Re: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: Andy Next Tune on September 13, 2022, 12:10:48 PM
When I'm in a session leading a tune set, I will often ease off my playing slightly as the change approaches to give myself some 'thinking space' before playing through the transition.
I find that is often in the final A music when the session has a firm grip of the tune, then I can shout 'Change' (other indicators are available) and play through the transition with a strong start to the next tune.

As others have said, put together a few tunes sets that work for you and practise the changes. I always try to decide which set(s) I'd like to play before I go to a session.
Title: Re: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: James Fitton on September 13, 2022, 12:13:15 PM
Just a thought on practising the transition - although I find this applies equally to any tricky passages. Perhaps try a "gradually expanding" approach. Assuming standard 32 bar tunes, start by practising Tune 1 bar 32 leading into Tune 2 bar 1, over and over until it's straight. Then Tune 1 bars 31 and 32, followed by Tune 2 bars 1 and 2. And so on, until the whole transition is properly under your fingers.
Title: Re: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: Julian S on September 13, 2022, 12:21:43 PM
And another thing ! I find it's all too easy to lose rhythm when you change tunes - obviously more of a problem if you play for dancing.
Metronome comes in useful for practice - as is recording yourself. I find that a good way to check progress and expose the problem phrases - it can feel a bit like playing in public.

Julian
Title: Re: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 13, 2022, 12:43:28 PM

  I am grinding my usual axe here, but be very cautious if the tunes are in different rhythms. I personally believe that we should never do that. Our music is based on dance; to switch from a polka rhythm into eg a gig … is quite wrong in that respect.

But people do that in sessions and you just have to play along with them 🥴

20 years back, ‘leading the set’ I decided to put to mazurkas together. Should be okay? It wasn’t!

One was traditional style 3/4 rhythm and the other was in 9/8. It completely knocked me over. So while you are learning I would recommend keeping it simple and just do 2 polkas, or 2 hornpipes tigether. There is quite enough to think about with respect to the musical juncture!

Excellent tips above. They all worked for me. Keep ‘em coming … and yes, repeat, repeat, repeat 👍
Title: Re: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: Howard Jones on September 13, 2022, 01:11:45 PM
I find it is essential for me to learn a set as a complete set.  Some people seem to be able to call out a different tune and change into it on the fly, but I can't do that.  I have to learn the tunes and the transition, and practice until it comes naturally.

The other thing is to trust your autopilot.  It's very easy to panic as a transition approaches and think "I can't remember how the next tune goes", which almost guarantees that you won't. If you have practised thoroughly, and if you can stay relaxed and not panic, you should find that the next tune miraculously appears in your mind just when you need it to (but no sooner). However this does require practice, and it takes experience to learn to relax and not worry about it.

There's also a skill involved in putting sets together.  To make a good set the tunes should have some features, either musical similarities or sometimes contrasts, which make them partner well, and they should flow easily into one another. There's more to than just playing consecutive tunes off a page.

Title: Re: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: Julian S on September 13, 2022, 01:19:29 PM
I'm with Chris on the subject of changing rhythms. At our local session someone quite often plays a set of three tunes - the first two go well together, the last is in a quite different time signature ! Aaargh ! To me it just doesn't work.
(But I do think there are exceptions - rhythm change when playing for Gay Gordons or Strip The Willow can work well)

Julian
 
Title: Re: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: CAB on September 13, 2022, 04:00:50 PM
So many great pointers here.  I still sometimes struggle to follow Howard's excellent advice - don't panic and trust your autopilot.

I find changes are easier to remember if there is a clear identifiable linking phrase between the two tunes.  It's not just about finishing one tune and starting another.  If you have a definite change-over phrase it tends to stick in your mind.  Chris's C-C# thing is an example.  The d-e-f run-up from Harper's Frolic into Bonny Kate is another.  I have a set of jigs going from one in G to one in Am which begins on a C.  Again, the transition is a run-up from the final G through A and B to the C and that has become part of the tune in my head.

Having said that, once you have a set firmly in in your head,  it can be nice sometimes to leave a nice clean moment of silence between the tunes.

As someone else has said, I use a set list with incipits when playing for a dance: the first two bars of every tune in abc format (although you could use conventional notation).  I glance at this as I reach the end of the first tune and it takes me nicely onto the next one.
Title: Re: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 13, 2022, 04:45:11 PM
I'm with Chris on the subject of changing rhythms. At our local session someone quite often plays a set of three tunes - the first two go well together, the last is in a quite different time signature ! Aaargh ! To me it just doesn't work. (But I do think there are exceptions - rhythm change when playing for Gay Gordons or Strip The Willow can work well)  Julian

In Gay Gordons the rhythm change is intrinsic to the dance, which is a set piece.  The Danish dance “Swedish masquerade” is another example.

I recall dancing Strip the Willow at Whitby, sometime in around 1980. The band was the High-Level Ranters. They switched rhythm halfway through,  Very clever I’m sure, but my dance set fell apart. It did not ‘inform our feet’ anymore 🥴

We are either ‘part of a tradition’, or we abandon the dancing roots of a music and set off on a more lonely journey. It is a choice. The French group Dèdale used  to do some fantastic improvised melodic lines in some of their dance music. The best  example I can remember was Chris Saccatini, in a medium pace waltz. You sort of had to … dance to the rhythm of your feet. But at the end of it, it all resolved back and you found you were still on the correct foot. They respected  their dance roots. To be fair, most of the dancers knew what they were doing
Title: Re: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: CAB on September 13, 2022, 05:02:15 PM
In Gay Gordons the rhythm change is intrinsic to the dance, which is a set piece.  The Danish dance “Swedish masquerade” is another example.

I recall dancing Strip the Willow at Whitby, sometime in around 1980. The band was the High-Level Ranters. They switched rhythm halfway through,  Very clever I’m sure, but my dance set fell apart. It did not ‘inform our feet’ anymore 🥴

We are either ‘part of a tradition’, or we abandon the dancing roots of a music and set off on a more lonely journey.

I make an exception with Cumberland Square Eight.  A change (from, say, My Love She's But A Lassie Yet) into a jig the second time through picks it up nicely and the dancers get it straight away, galloping off into the distance with great gusto (and even, heavens forfend, the odd whoop).
Title: Re: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 13, 2022, 05:15:20 PM
I saw that Towersey had a Flowers and Folics reunion celigh. Their absolute classic dance was Queensland Backstep which had two very different tunes and rhythms bolted together to allow two sections of the dance come together... one of our classic English ceilidh dances in my opinion, especially when Taffy Thomas called it, back in the day.
Ah, happy days....  8)
Title: Re: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: PeterBRC on September 13, 2022, 09:29:12 PM
Thanks all for the time taken to help , a lot of very good advice
Title: Re: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on September 13, 2022, 09:40:23 PM
One thing not mentioned is, practice doing it right, not doing it wrong. That is, start with short enough sections, at a slow enough tempo, to guarantee you get it right.  You can bring it up towards tempo as you learn it better, but don't panic and don't rush it. It will happen.
Title: Re: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: PeterBRC on September 13, 2022, 10:04:58 PM
Yes you are right I am very guilty of getting it wrong by going too fast , so in the future slow and correct !!  Sometimes even the first tune that I should know  well goes out of my head !    but I do enjoying practice
Title: Re: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 13, 2022, 10:50:55 PM
I make an exception with Cumberland Square Eight.  A change (from, say, My Love She's But A Lassie Yet) into a jig the second time through picks it up nicely and the dancers get it straight away, galloping off into the distance with great gusto (and even, heavens forfend, the odd whoop).

Again, it’s ‘part of a special dance’. I think that was another “Square 8”,  from the west country with a similar theme?  I last danced it about 40 years ago.

I used to try to get medleys perfected at a slow pace,  and then speed up too. It worked for me, and still does - wrt variations. I’m really not into medleys. I perceive them as the curse of British session music. Just as the music gets interesting, complex, interactional, somebody changes to a completely different tune 🙄
Title: Re: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on September 13, 2022, 11:11:30 PM
...I’m really not into medleys. I perceive them as the curse of British session music. Just as the music gets interesting, complex, interactional, somebody changes to a completely different tune 🙄

Thread drift alert. It's an important point, though.

Yes.It is a delight to play with people who get this and are prepared to give the music room to breath.

The medley does have it's place, especially in come all ye sessions, but it is so much more satisfying to play in an environment where music is a conversation between people with a common understanding.

As a general recommendation, I would encourage anyone who can to go to a Leveret workshop if they get the chance. This is exactly what they explore I have a selfish motive here. The more people go, the more people will get it and the more people there will be who I can play like this with. I don't know if there are other musical tutors out there pushing the same approach. I hope so. I think there must be, because this is how my favourite music works and I hear a lot of it.
Title: Re: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 14, 2022, 07:45:10 AM
Sticking with the same tune and not moving to another has been the way forward advocated by John Kirkpatrick for years.
He often advises 'Play the same tune for an hour and see where it takes you... ' in his notes and conversations.

It was always ever thus.
Notes from Thomas Hardy's days when he and father, both accomplished fiddlers, played 'at the big house' for the Squire's dances. Playing until the head couple ( the hosts ) danced all the way to the bottom of the longway set and back again playing the same tune ( for ~ 15 mins??).

It is satisfying at a session to give a tune a good long thrashing!!!
Title: Re: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 14, 2022, 09:17:05 AM

 I’m with de Sade on the subject of ‘good thrashings’.  Why do it? … Because it’s so nice when it stops! 😉

  But yes, there are certain ‘standard session medleys’ mainly off some ancient LP or other. And they are very commonplace
  in the British scene, and in Aus/NW when I got there. Much less so in Europe. It is certainly “music’, in its own way. But in
  that sense so is the punched Jacquard paper roll on a Victorian pianola.

  My point is that the same  techniques that you’d use to string a medley together - eg that slip C=>C# when it changes key
  - may be used creatively in varying that same piece of music. One of my favourite theme melodies is a Waltz, taken from a
  superb Morris tune. I tend to announce it as “the Sherborne waltz” … “medleyed with itself”.

  Here’s … hmmm it’s a medley! Join type ‘abrupt’ in my terminology, they just ‘do it’.  But there’s a real conversation going on?

       https://youtu.be/kwxpAxA5_EY
 
Title: Re: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 14, 2022, 09:48:30 AM
Perhaps ' a very good airing' might be a better choice of words Chris?
One wouldn't wish to convey too much speed or volume would be appropriate or even used   ;)
Title: Re: Learning for a set of tunes
Post by: Jesse Smith on September 14, 2022, 02:11:17 PM
It is interesting that American contra dance music, pieces are often paired in a set with the explicit idea to switch rhythms, say from 4/4 to 6/8, because it gives the dancers a surge of excitement at something new happening. (Although contra dance is generally done as just "fast rhythmic walking", similar to the sedate "Playford" style of ECD but unlike English ceilidh dance which incorporates actual stepping, maybe it needs a bit more injected excitement from the change in music? >:E)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal