Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: callmemario on November 03, 2009, 04:10:47 AM
-
Hi everyone,
I'm one of those guys who has been fortunate enough to own a 2 and a half row Castagnari Dony...but had to sell it due to finances! :-(
Since I can't keep away from "squeezing" I have been seriously studying 2 possibilities: The Weltmeister Wiener 86W or the Hohner Morgane. (I am looking for a 2 row in the key of G/C)
WHAT do you think of my choices?...all have good and bad sides to them, but the thing here is money. Trying to find "the best" at "low" cost.
I would love to get your feedback and or suggest something else in a 2 row.
Thanks!
Mario
-
Bought a black and gold 86W from Emillio some time back and posted a comment. Felt that it was a more modern design than the Pokerwerke, without sharp edges and better finish.
Why not consider one of Theo's Club2/Erikas? You can specify start button, degree of tuning and still have a half row left to have both low and accidentals.
Ancient Grumpy and down to one box Bill.
-
Go for weltmeister. I'd recommend them to anyone. Great affordable boxes. I'm looking for a b/c
weltmeister melodeon again.
-
Well, I started playing on Weltmeister 86W, and although it played nicely and (to my ears) had a sweeter tremolo than a Pokerwork, the big problem (unless they've changed the design) is the one piece keyboard. This means that to change a spring you can't just take off the cover like on a Hohner to get at the mechanism, but you have to pull out the rod, with the risk of all the springs going everywhere, and fiddle a new spring in place.
It's definitely not something for the inexperienced, and I think Theo, who repaired mine twice, would agree that it's a hell of a job.
-
Its not so difficult on a newish one because the rod usually comes out quite easily. The problem is with older boxes where the rod seems to become one with the wood and can be next to impossible to remove. Once the rod is out it is simple enough to replace the spring.
-
Some great and encouraging observations!.
Thanks guys.
Mario