Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: John MacKenzie (Cugiok) on September 24, 2022, 07:01:03 PM
-
I realised today that my melodeons were still in their cases from Whitby. I am so demotivated recently that I haven't felt like playing.
Anybody else ever get like that?
Sir John
-
Yes all the time, but then a tune comes along, or a box winks at me and it starts up again. It’s good to leave them out of their boxes tho. (:)
-
When I don't feel like playing, I listen. Sometimes I listen to the silence...
-
Yes I have conceived a liking for silence, I used to have the radio on 24 hours a day. now I listen to it in bed at night and in the morning when I wake, and that's it for the rest of the day. I sometimes listen to folks on You Tube mostly trad jazz and that's it.
Sir John
-
Well I was fed up with being unable to play my melodeons for a month or so recently.
The skin cancer Dr decided to cut a chunk of flesh off the back of my right hand, and the wound then got infected.
I find just going out to sessions and mixing with other friendly musos is a good antidote to periods of low motivation.
-
I have played very little for 5 years since I had a life-changing pelvic abscess. That was put right by (London) surgeons in February, but minor complications from that have kept me lying on tjus couch You need to sit, to play my sort of Melodeon tunes …
Never mind, the District Nurses discharged me to my own GP last week, after I passed a fitness to drive test. Two pupils came to my flat last week and are already making fine progress. Hoping to get back into the flow of those … beautiful notes very soon 🙂
-
Physical difficulties are quite often present especially as we age, somehow though the lack of enthusiasm seems so much more difficult to deal with. I have spoken on this forum before on a personal level regarding this problem. For myself I acknowledge that my playing in public or gigs has finished or is certainly very much reduced, and now that I have accepted that I am at peace with the music and with myself.
Lizzy
-
I've had "performance issues" for years now, not quite the same as a lack of enthusiasm but it is related. There was a time when music was an all-consuming passion, and I would be willing to perform anywhere at any time and my nerves were controllable. First of all my nerve went, live performance and recording sessions became an issue, then a burden, then virtually impossible. I managed to convince myself that this was a passing thing and I still played for enjoyment and the challenge of a great tune. Gradually my enthusiasm for music has declined, without the challenge of playing with others and the need to rise to the occasion in order to avoid letting the side down it becomes diminished in more than the chordal sense.
So yes, I understand where you are, I'm there mostly too and I sympathise. As for a solution, I'm working on it. Perhaps it's time to abandon folk stuff and take up the blues.
Well, I woke up this mornin' . . .
-
I'm fed up too, not with playing the melodeon, which I do almost every day and enjoy a lot, but with lack of progress. I feel like I've hit a plateau (more or less; I think I'm a bit better than a year ago but not to a massive degree) and can't break through to the next level. What to do, what to do...
-
I'm feeling the same way about not breaking through to the next level, and struggling over decades with the same faults of rhythm and tempo.
I'm thinking that a way forward might be to book some skype lessons with one of the players who are half my age with double my musicianship, or more. A teacher might be able to see/hear what I have been blind/deaf to.
Another way forward might be to greatly increase daily practice time. I heard somewhere that Bruno LeTron practises scales in all keys for two hours every day. ( You'd have thought that he wouldn't need to!). That would mean practising daily even when I don't feel like practising, which I haven't done since schooldays. But progress has its price.
-
...Another way forward might be to greatly increase daily practice time. I heard somewhere that Bruno LeTron practises scales in all keys for two hours every day. ( You'd have thought that he wouldn't need to!). That would mean practising daily even when I don't feel like practising, which I haven't done since schooldays. But progress has its price.
Beware of injury. I overdid things during lock down and I am still getting a lot of discomfort.
-
Yes, lockdown did for me too, but mine was digging out Leylandii. I now have tendon damage above the elbow which is getting better sloooowly. Combined with a new heavier box it means 'little and often' rather than a 2 hour solid practice.
I am trying some scales though, for the first time in my life... but not for that long a stretch ::)
-
I'm fed up too, not with playing the melodeon, which I do almost every day and enjoy a lot, but with lack of progress. I feel like I've hit a plateau (more or less; I think I'm a bit better than a year ago but not to a massive degree) and can't break through to the next level. What to do, what to do...
-
No stranger to de-motivation
During the week in the evening, the kids are in bed. No one is telling me but I must get up from the couch to rehearse. There aren't many opportunities to do so.
during weekend performances I am glad for the times that I got up. But sometimes, I'm just slacking
-
I'm fed up too, not with playing the melodeon, which I do almost every day and enjoy a lot, but with lack of progress. I feel like I've hit a plateau (more or less; I think I'm a bit better than a year ago but not to a massive degree) and can't break through to the next level. What to do, what to do...
In my experience hitting plateaux is completely normal. Fortunately they are often the long and frustrating prelude to some leap ahead. (Until you reach the final plateau you may never escape from, but I'm sure that's not your case!)
What to do? I dunno. I agree that playing scales and arpeggios in every way you can ought to be a good idea. (On a semitone box you have a greater choice of scales but on a quint you must have many more button choices.) Maybe practise some aspect of playing your instrument that you have never tackled? Maybe try to work out and reproduce some of what better players far better than you are doing? Try some "impossible" tunes?
But don't give up. And don't stop enjoying the music you are able to make now. That quantum leap will come, and you might only realise some time afterwards that it has.
-
Hi John, what's got you demotivated?
It helps me keep going to have groups (English Country Dance, Québécois, and Irish) that meet weekly. If I didn't get to play with others I'd lose steam. I find that even playing tunes with one other person (on any instrument) is a shot in the arm.
-
In my experience hitting plateaux is completely normal. Fortunately they are often the long and frustrating prelude to some leap ahead. (Until you reach the final plateau you may never escape from, but I'm sure that's not your case!)
What to do? I dunno. I agree that playing scales and arpeggios in every way you can ought to be a good idea. (On a semitone box you have a greater choice of scales but on a quint you must have many more button choices.) Maybe practise some aspect of playing your instrument that you have never tackled? Maybe try to work out and reproduce some of what better players far better than you are doing? Try some "impossible" tunes?
But don't give up. And don't stop enjoying the music you are able to make now. That quantum leap will come, and you might only realise some time afterwards that it has.
Thanks Stiamh! I suppose really tackling things head-on and making myself dissect what others are doing and challenging myself to replicate is the way forward, rather than continuing to play hoping it will just happen.
-
Well this thread is way old now, but never too late to reply. I started learning by myself at the youngish age of 65, never having played an instrument before. It took at least 6 months to be able to split my left and right sides and play chords. Learning is dreadfully slow - in other words - good candidate for frustration and throwing in the towel. But no!
I would say - learn tunes you really like, even though they not be for beginners. Then you're less likely to get sick of them and chuck yer instrument back in the box. My very first was Mrs. Saggs - took ages. Then the next one was The Abbess. Then after that heard Origin of the World and loved it - so sat down with Paul Young on You Tube and noted every single chord and note he played. Painful, because the sound and video was out of sync. Next - Rose of Raby and other tunes I love and play now are Princess Royal, King of the Fairies, Just as the day was a'flowing, Old Tom of Oxford and others. Many of these tunes you will find on Daddy LongLes page and you can buy the music, chords, and playing guide (video) for a very reasonable price. That helped me heaps - just do what he says and all is well. Plus, same tunes on YouTube and you can slow them down and play along - perhaps, eventually. So that is my sixpence worth. Of course, if you've been playing for 40 years, everything I've said above don't apply.
Dave
-
Wow David, definitely in at the deep end with your starter tunes. Good for you!
I'm revisiting those Dave Shepherd penned tunes very ably demonstrated by Paul Young. I'm trying to play them 'as writ' in their home keys on a new larger box that enables me to play in Gm and Am amongst other new to me keys.
It certainly has taken me back to starter level and reminded me how painfully slow it can be at times.
As you've demonstrated, you've just got to keep going!