Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: PeterBRC on September 25, 2022, 11:06:40 PM
-
Does anybody know of a YouTube site that I can hear D/G Melodeon with thirds played as normal then as taped up
-
This is something that's often included as part of a box video demo, such as https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o-7IT9CD9Gw (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o-7IT9CD9Gw). This particular one is for a B/C, but it gives a good idea of the difference,
-
You can have an idea of the effect of removing the third note of the chord by using a right hand chord.
Go to your G row start button, either button 3 or 4 depending on 3rd or 4th button start .
Press this and the following 2 buttons so you're holding down G-B-D the chord of G.
Keep pushing and lift off button 2, B, and press it again.
This is adding or removing the third of a chord.
In terms of the left hand chords, it is often down to personal choice.
I'm generally a 'thirds in' person on my 2 row 8 bass box as I like the fuller sound.
I've been starting to learn some tunes in other keys on a 2.5 row 12 bass that can switch 3rds in or out.
I'm faced with some minor chords, ie Gm and Dm in the music. I don't have these as part of my 12 basses but do have G major and D major. By switching out the thirds it means I have a G and D 'open' chords, neither major or minor, so can use these open chords.
Despite being a 'thirds in' person for most tunes I am now realising how useful it is to take out the thirds.
... but friends I play with prefer the thirds out on their 2 row 8 bass DG's.
-
That is very useful thanks. I will go and listen to my playing now.
Much appreciated. Peter
-
Thirdless chords can be very useful in some contexts. e.g., (on a DG) playing outside the home keys, especially in minor keys, such as Am and Bm. These are commonly faked by playing the relative majors (C and D respectively) with the bass, to give something commonly called the minor 7th, but this doesn't really satisfy if the chord is the tonic. If you want a Dm things get even trickier.
This is a reason for taping off or otherwise muting thirds in the A and B chords or getting a box with a thirds stop.
-
A lot of boxes can have a stop fitted to enable you to add/remove the thirds in chords when you want.
The smaller sized boxes such as the Tommy can't, either through sheer space available in the left hand, or the configuration of shared reeds where the bass and chord share a reed.
Full sized boxes like Pokerworks, Erica's, Hascys etc. can be adapted by a tuner to have a stop fitted then you have the option when you want or need it.
-
And of course many boxes come with a thirds stop fitted as standard.
-
I'm a 'thirds in' person too, and I don't mute the thirds if I don't need to. I think the contrast between the major and the minor chords add depth to an articulated harmonic progression. If you mute the thirds, everything results flattened - it's like printing a colour photo in black and white, you might end with a beautiful image but a lot of details are lost. Of course I am aware that we all can spot the difference between a colour photo and a black and white one. To appreciate the different moods of a major chord and a minor chord the listener needs to have a trained musical ear...
Both my G/C 2 1/2 row and my A/D/G boxes have a stop to mute the thirds, but while I use it a number of times on the former to play tunes not in the home keys, I almost never use it on the latter, on which I mainly play English music. Yet, please note that I'm not playing a standard instrument, but a customized one.
On my A/D/G both the B push chord and the F# chord are tuned to be minor chords. Since the B minor is a diatonic triad in G, D and A, and the F# minor chord is a diatonic triad in D and A, that for me was a logical choice. The problem was the A chord, that I use both as a minor chord playing in G and as a major chord playing in D and A. Here I had to accept a compromise, and my A pull chord was built on purpose without the third - the C# reed has been replaced by a second E reed. The A push chord remains a major chord.
When I need a B major chord or an F# major chord to play tunes in E minor of in B minor using the harmonic or melodic minor scales, then I use the stop to mute the thirds. This in fact means that, except for an odd chromatic tune, and three or four tonal minor tunes, I don't need to use it. Considering that I play sets of tunes in different keys, and in most of them at least in one I use a minor chord, on a standard instrument I would probably play a good 60% if not 70% of the time using the stop.
If I had to switch back to a two row D/G with a stop for the thirds, I would simply retune the B chord to be minor, and replace the C# reed with an E reed in the A chord. BTW, I remember that in the nineties D/G boxes with a B minor chord were regularly advertised/sold in England. On a two row instrument without the stop to mute the thirds I wouldn't tape all the thirds, but only those of the A, the B and E chords, assuming of course that the chin accidentals have been inverted to give the G# as a pull note.
Unfortunately, if you tape just some of the thirds, the sound of the chords using just two reeds will result different from the sound the full triads, but as we use to say in Italy: you can't pretend to have both a full barrel and a drunken wife! :(
-
Peter, as you may realise, playing the melodeon involves a great deal of compromise. The best players hide these so well you don't realise they're happening. There are a number of people posting on here that carry this off. Anahata comes to mind. it's worth looking at his playing.
-
Thanks Greg a good point you make , I am an great admirer of Anahatas playing
-
Also some of Paul Young's playing on YouTube.
In particular some of his tunes in other keys using his Mory.
I'm thinking of his version of Rose of Raby in Gm, and Origin of the World with a fiddler, 'in Gm' but have recently discovered it's in Am.
In both he has thirds out in his chords, and has switched in a low Reed on the treble end, playing either LM or LMM to give a rich sound on the melody.
It's lovely playing, and a different sound.
-
I learned cross-fingered chording using Rose of Raby! The lesson was in Am, but actual key doesn’t matter. The melody is so smooth in its flow of notes that everything works! It was a revelation. Yes, I then tried it with different voice voicings. Trusted my ear … and wondered why Emaj on Cbass wasn’t so nice? 🤔
Because the 3rd in an E chord is G#, so the cross chord is CEG#B = Cmaj7,#5. That isn’t very folky! The solution was easy. Take the 3rds out of my left end chords. It’s not rocket science and it works every time 👍
-
Peter, as you may realise, playing the melodeon involves a great deal of compromise. The best players hide these so well you don't realise they're happening. There are a number of people posting on here that carry this off. Anahata comes to mind. it's worth looking at his playing.
Ooh - my ears are burning!
I wanted to post here, but I don't literally have an example of a single recording with thirds in and out.
What I can say, though, is that my Dino Baffetti/Oakwood box has just one stop, which is for thirds out, and I've found it far more useful than I thought I would at first, having come from a 3 Voice Saltarelle that has stops for everything.
I definitely play some tunes with thirds in and others with thirds out.
I've never wanted to change the stop mid-tune. If I want a change in texture, I'll take the thirds out and accompany a tune with the bare fifth chords only, then bring in the basses later, making a satisfying deepening of the texture. This works best on slowish tunes that can be played over sustained chords, where full chords would overpower the melody.
In cases like that I'll often start with the tune once though alone, no accompaniment. Less is more, when you can add harmony and texture later.
As mentioned, stopping out the thirds makes minor tunes much easier in several keys, and in conjuction with accidentals reversed from the usual Hohner layout, A minor especially, complete with implied E major with pull G♯s in the tune.
Examples:
Gypsy's Lullaby (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ATnZbEc5-9M) Only major key example I could find with thirds out. There may be others.
Origin of the World (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XWvc5d1cLwE) in B minor
Two Playford tunes in A minor:
Epping Forest (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cphD40Qn0as)
Dove's Figary (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9uNqqMpPCEM) (with some other stuff going on in the basses too!)
Contrast with another minor key Playford tune, but with the thirds IN. This one played in E minor.
Drive the Cold Winter Away (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sLXG8WbSRPg)
-
Ooh - my ears are burning!
Credit where credit's due ;D ;D ;D
-
I'm a 'thirds in' person too, and I don't mute the thirds if I don't need to. I think the contrast between the major and the minor chords add depth to an articulated harmonic progression. If you mute the thirds, everything results flattened - it's like printing a colour photo in black and white, you might end with a beautiful image but a lot of details are lost. Of course I am aware that we all can spot the difference between a colour photo and a black and white one. To appreciate the different moods of a major chord and a minor chord the listener needs to have a trained musical ear...
Both my G/C 2 1/2 row and my A/D/G boxes have a stop to mute the thirds, but while I use it a number of times on the former to play tunes not in the home keys, I almost never use it on the latter, on which I mainly play English music. Yet, please note that I'm not playing a standard instrument, but a customized one.
On my A/D/G both the B push chord and the F# chord are tuned to be minor chords. Since the B minor is a diatonic triad in G, D and A, and the F# minor chord is a diatonic triad in D and A, that for me was a logical choice. The problem was the A chord, that I use both as a minor chord playing in G and as a major chord playing in D and A. Here I had to accept a compromise, and my A pull chord was built on purpose without the third - the C# reed has been replaced by a second E reed. The A push chord remains a major chord.
When I need a B major chord or an F# major chord to play tunes in E minor of in B minor using the harmonic or melodic minor scales, then I use the stop to mute the thirds. This in fact means that, except for an odd chromatic tune, and three or four tonal minor tunes, I don't need to use it. Considering that I play sets of tunes in different keys, and in most of them at least in one I use a minor chord, on a standard instrument I would probably play a good 60% if not 70% of the time using the stop.
If I had to switch back to a two row D/G with a stop for the thirds, I would simply retune the B chord to be minor, and replace the C# reed with an E reed in the A chord. BTW, I remember that in the nineties D/G boxes with a B minor chord were regularly advertised/sold in England. On a two row instrument without the stop to mute the thirds I wouldn't tape all the thirds, but only those of the A, the B and E chords, assuming of course that the chin accidentals have been inverted to give the G# as a pull note.
Unfortunately, if you tape just some of the thirds, the sound of the chords using just two reeds will result different from the sound the full triads, but as we use to say in Italy: you can't pretend to have both a full barrel and a drunken wife! :(
It has to be said that I could not agree more with everything that you have said.
There was a time when I thought that open fifths could be the solution to all my problems. 10 years on I have come full circle and I can't abide the sound of open fifths, whether I am playing it, or someone else. I'd much rather use a bass note on it's own, a bass run, or a left hand arpeggio.
While I'm at it, I must say I love your Italian idiom. "Avere la botte piena e la moglie ubriaca" will now be added to my repertoire of popular European sayings, along with "Heute Die Welt, Morgen Das Sonnensystem!","Ewige blumencraft" and "j'habite dans un cul de sac".
-
While I'm at it, I must say I love your Italian idiom. "Avere la botte piena e la moglie ubriaca" will now be added to my repertoire of popular European sayings, along with "Heute Die Welt, Morgen Das Sonnensystem!","Ewige blumencraft" and "j'habite dans un cul de sac".
Amazing. Love j'habite dans un cul de sac. A concise alternative to I can't see the light at the end of the tunnel. And it avoids the standard reply: what about furnishing it?
-
Thirdless chords can be very useful in some contexts. e.g., (on a DG) playing outside the home keys, especially in minor keys, such as Am and Bm. These are commonly faked by playing the relative majors (C and D respectively) with the bass, to give something commonly called the minor 7th, but this doesn't really satisfy if the chord is the tonic. If you want a Dm things get even trickier.
This is a reason for taping off or otherwise muting thirds in the A and B chords or getting a box with a thirds stop.
An interesting point I forgot to comment.
If on a D/G box you play an A bass and a C chord or a B bass and a D chord like block chords, they you really obtain a real Am7 or Bm7 chord. The problem is that if you play the fundamentals of a minor chord and then, after a rest, a major chord, a well trained musical ear will immediately spot that you are playing a major after a bass note that's not part of it, and not a minor chord, even of on the paper is true that the major chord can be seen like the minor 7 chord played without the fundamental.. There are time you can can hold the bass note for a while and release it after you start playing the chord, but it doesn't happen that often.
I agree that the use of a minor 7 chord isn't totally satisfactory when the minor triad is the tonic, but the real problem here is that you are using what is and remains a major chord. Whether this is acceptable depends, I suppose, on the musical ear of the listeners, and in the contest you do it. If we are talking about a solo performance the listener with an harmonically trained musical ear will immediately spot the major chord, while in a band performance, with other instrument playing the fundamental, like a bass, and/or playing the full minor triad, like a guitar, the use of the major chord will remain unnoticed.
And I dare add that the melodeon players who insist to mainly play press and draw on one row won't be able to appreciate the difference anyway!
In general, considering that the use of a major chord in place of a minor 7 one is intended to trick the ear of the listener, I use i when I am able to keep the illusion consistent – i. e after playing the root or the fifth of the minor chord, and after in the bar I have played at least once the real minor chord, or the 5 chord. Well, since I switched to the A/D/G, I haven't had the need to, but I still do it for backward compatibility on the Michael Turner's waltz, that I still play like I learned it on the D/G box.
-
That may be true, but the melodeon wasn't designed for people with harmonically trained musical ears. It's a simple and rather limited instrument, and that means compromises have to be made, especially with the basses. Sometimes the "proper" chord which musical theory would suggest simply isn't possible, so something else has to be substituted. Those who play the instrument, and many of those who listen to it, accept that these substitutions may be only partially successful, but that's part of the charm of this instruments The challenge for the player is to make these necessary fudges as convincing as possible, but they remain fudges. If someone with harmonically trained musical ears finds this difficult or intrusive then perhaps the melodeon isn't for them.
Whether to have thirds in or out is one of these fudges. My mains instrument has a stop for this, so it is a choice I make for every tune. I'm afraid I don't base this choice on musical theory but on my gut feel for how I prefer the tune to sound.
-
The major chord is sometimes appropriate,. The main concept to wrap your mind round is that there is no such thing as “minor key.â€.
Last night I listened to Yehudi Menuhin playing a Bach Concerto in E Minor. It was Aeolian minor. (My new cat really enjoyed it). Aolian is the more common one in classical music, and all you have to do is raise the D to D# and you get harmonic minor. It’s called harmonic for a reason. It is the basis of tonal music.
Meanwhile, out in folk country, we are far more likely to play the E minor scale evolved from the D notes. They has a C sharp. And so should any chord used to harmonise. It is Em dorian. Chords … 🤔
Well let’s just do a simple 2 4 5 2 progression. That is Em Amaj Bm Em. Surprised? It has to be A major because of that C sharp note. And I just spent an hour showing pupil exactly that.
Try it. You have a pull a major on your base when you’re playing E Dorian … play that instead. It gives the thing a real lift 👏
-
... there is no such thing as “minor key.â€.
I think you're out on a bit of a limb there, Chris. It might be better to argue that there are three major modes, three minor keys and a monstrosity.
-
That may be true, but the melodeon wasn't designed for people with harmonically trained musical ears. It's a simple and rather limited instrument...
...I'm afraid I don't base this choice on musical theory but on my gut feel for how I prefer the tune to sound.
The one row four stop melodeon wasn't designed for people with harmonically trained musical ears, and proved to be a successfully dance music instrument in contests where the musical traditions really had not an harmonic dimension – and it's still a key instrument in spite of its limitations where it takes a lead voice, and the harmonic dimension of the music is left to other musicians, like in Louisiana or Quebec.
The evolution of the instruments of the melodeon/button accordion family, up to 5 row RH keyboards, and eventually chromatic Stradella LH keyboards, shows a trend toward an harmonic wise approach to the music, in order to satisfy the now harmonically trained musical ears of both the players and the listeners. ignoring of course the exceptions of the South of Italy, with the 1 ½ row instruments, and the Basque Country, with the Trikitixas that guarantee to the players the real possibility to correctly harmonize using the tonic, the subdominant and the dominant chords.
If we choose to play music that remains mainly in a diatonic/modal dimension, in the hands of a competent player the melodeons are perfectly able to cope with it in the frame of the diatonic harmony. The three rows instruments in three keys, that have been adopted in Texas ans South America, are probably the best choice. Adding a row of reversals and accidental might offer some chromatic flexibility on three, four or five row instruments, but they will never match the agility of the piano accordion or of its button counterpart. It's the music you choose to play that dictates which instrument you'll play.
And no, I'm sorry, but your choices are not based on your guts, nor on your musical taste. Whether you are aware of it or not, they are based on your musical ear, or eventually of the lack of it. There are some lucky musicians that have been blessed by mother nature with an excellent musical era – some even an absolute musical ear. They are good if not excellent players not because they ignore or do not respect the musical theory, but because they instinctively follow and respect it without actually have consciously learned it.
But here, to use another Italian idom that Mike could appreciate, the cat eats his tail. To be able to effectively play a melodeon finding a way round its limitation you must develop a well trained ear, that on a limited instrument like the melodeon is virtually impossible to acquire without some solid music theory knowledge.
-
... there is no such thing as “minor key.â€.
I think you're out on a bit of a limb there, Chris. It might be better to argue that there are three major modes, three minor keys and a monstrosity.
Er, isn’t that what I’ve been saying for years 🤔 My objection to term “in ‘whatever’ minor†is that it implies some form of harmony structure that doesn’t exist. Whatever ‘works’ can be trivialised as ‘functional’, but that’s to ignore ‘beauty’ as a concept.
-
And no, I'm sorry, but your choices are not based on your guts, nor on your musical taste. Whether you are aware of it or not, they are based on your musical ear, or eventually of the lack of it.
I said my choices weren't based on musical theory. Of course anyone who has grown up listening to western music, and especially anyone who plays an instrument, will have absorbed if only unconsciously its rules and conventions. In that sense I acknowledge that my musical ear is governed by those rules and conventions, even though I may not be able to express them in terms a trained musician would use.
What I was trying to convey is that the melodeon is an instrument which is often unable to comply with those rules and conventions, and that there is no point fretting about it, you just have to get on and play the best compromise you can achieve. If that offends someone's idea of what is musically correct, that's unavoidable.
I tend to think of chords as fingering patterns rather than as groups of notes. When I play guitar in open tunings I don't actually know what chords I am playing, and sometimes not even which key I am in. Similarly when I play anglo concertina chords to me are just patterns of buttons, but in most cases I don't know the name of the chord or even which individual notes I am playing. This doesn't apply so much to melodeon, which has only 6 principal chords to worry about, but once I go off-piste playing cross-row chords (or on boxes in keys other than D/G) I don't know what they are called. I just poke about until I think it sounds right, but of course my sense of "right" is governed by the musical tradition I have grown up in.
The same applies to my choice whether or not to include thirds. I acknowledge my taste has been governed by the western musical tradition, but I am not consciously applying these rules.
-
I’m with you Howard. Long time guitarist, chords are shapes and progressions they are old and trusted patterns, instinctive and natural. I read music but never did so when playing guitar. I too consider the melodeon to be a play by touch instrument although my instincts are far less reliable because diatonic instruments are confusing for me. Such is life.
-
We diatonic outlaws don't need no stinkin' roolz...
-
I like the freedom of not having thirds in.
Assuming DG 2 row.
In a tune that needs a Bmaj and Bmin, is it more of a fudge to go Bmaj and Bmin7 ( without the B) or on a box set up with Bmins just ignore it, or take the thirds out and let the melody tell the listener which is which?
I often want an Emaj too. How do I find it?
If I was a better player, I might be able to fake things better, but I'm not so 3rds out for me.
-
I often want an Emaj too. How do I find it?
Many chords are implied by playing just one or two notes of the chord. Hit a E bass in a context where E major is likely and you are near enough.
Listen to Bach's pieces for solo unaccompanied instruments - the violin partitas and the cello suites. There's rich multi part harmony going on, just not all of the notes of every chord are played at once.
To answer your question more specifically for a melodeon: my Dino has a pull G# so I can make a RH E chord. My Oakwood has those accidentals the other way round, so I either make a fifth with E and B, or play a push B with a G#, making the chord without the root. If people expect an E major chord in context, they'll hear it.
-
I often want an Emaj too. How do I find it?
Many chords are implied by playing just one or two notes of the chord. Hit a E bass in a context where E major is likely and you are near enough.
Listen to Bach's pieces for solo unaccompanied instruments - the violin partitas and the cello suites. There's rich multi part harmony going on, just not all of the notes of every chord are played at once.
To answer your question more specifically for a melodeon: my Dino has a pull G# so I can make . If people expect an E major chord in context, they'll hear it.
Exactly!
-
Many chords are implied by playing just one or two notes of the chord. Hit a E bass in a context where E major is likely and you are near enough.
Listen to Bach's pieces for solo unaccompanied instruments - the violin partitas and the cello suites. There's rich multi part harmony going on, just not all of the notes of every chord are played at once.
To answer your question more specifically for a melodeon: my Dino has a pull G# so I can make a RH E chord. My Oakwood has those accidentals the other way round, so I either make a fifth with E and B, or play a push B with a G#, making the chord without the root. If people expect an E major chord in context, they'll hear it.
I agree, except for your last statement. True, in general, but not all the times.
Playing a bass in place of a missing chord, or eventually a bass run, is an approach I'm familiar with. It's something I occasionally do today on the A/D/G, not because I have to fudge some missing chord, but as a variation that make the tune interesting for the listeners, and for me as a player.
But honestly, is everybody sure that what the people expect is always what he assumes the people expect? I have played, and I still occasionally do, with a friend who is a professional musician, a guitar player with a formal tuition in his background. I've learned that his perception of the chords is based on his perception of the intervals. If I have muted the thirds, he can tell I am playing undefined chords. If I play a chord without the root – like it happens for instance with a C in place of an A minor - he will rely on the interval between the the the root and the third, and will immediately spot I'm playing a major chord. I can't fool him telling that's a minor 7 played without the root. OK, such an harmonically well trained ear is not common, but he isn't the only player that owes it.
Yet, seriously, I wonder in how many tunes you really need to fudge a missing chord. I would say they are few and far apart. For most of the tunes you probably can just find an alternative chord progressions using the chords that are available on your instrument. And whether you have a stop to mute the thirds, or you have taped some or all of them, or hacked the LH keyboard as I did, on a D/G instrument you actually have the six diatonic chords to play in G and 5 of them to play in D, with the possibility to use the C chord, that I found pretty useful on the D/G. If you are able to use the substitutions it can occasionally result technically tricky playing a correct harmonic progression, but the only real problem on a D/G is most of the time missing A pull chord.
I remember that John Kirpatrick stated that most English tunes are based on chord progressions using just the major triads – he even blamed the use of the dominant 7 chords on the guitar players, although are probably the accordion players the ones that exceed with it – and criticised the use of more articulated harmonic progressions that denied the true nature of the traditional English tunes. I wouldn't don't go that far, and I suspect John was in fact deliberately exaggerating to get the message home. but when I hear some player discussing the use of some twisted extended chords, or of the suspended chords, I can't help thinking that this is too much. And, above all, that's definitely non needed to build correct and convincing harmonic progrssions... if you are able to, of course.
-
Please GBbox, do cut Anahata a bit of slack! 🙂He’s one of Britain’s more respected Melodeon players, and also has studied cello up to National
youth orchestra standard. He’s sound. And yes, axiomatically, “not all the timeâ€, but it’s amazing how often that works! Especially if they musical
motif is transient. By the time you have moved on, your listener’s ear is carried forward … by the flow of music.
It’s not just amongst the corps melodeonistae that this sort of trick works incifentally. The excellent Jens Larsen guitar channel has examples
in jazz comping, where it’s eg close to impossible to get a finger to the G## when the chord is Eaug7 or the scale lydian augmented. His advice
is very similar, to just miss it out. He uses the same logic. Because context is everything in music.
-
Don't worry Chris., offence has not been taken ;)
-
I'm Glad Anahata didn't take what I wrote as offensive, but anyway I can't honestly see how my statement that I only partially agree with him when he says that if people expect something, then they'll hear - given but not granted that what they expect is really what we think they expect -, could actually sound offensive.
No doubt Anahata is one of the most respected English melodeon players, and it's clear reading his posts that he can rely on a solid formal musical tuition. I take him in the highest esteem. Yet when I talked about that friend of mine who is a respected Italian professional guitarist, with an equally sound formal tuition in his background , and a well know writer, I was talking of what I have learned from my first hand experience. He can't probably be added to the people Anahata talks of, and he might even be the exception to the rule, but be sure he exists!
It's just like talking about the lucky people with an absolute ear -.we common human beings perceive a melody like a sequence of intervals, they as as sequence of notes with a given pitch... the fact that we can't do it doesn't imply that they can't!