Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Peadar on September 27, 2022, 12:19:48 AM
-
Has it occurred to others that the second easiest key to play on a C/C# is F? Which suggests the old 4 bass British Chromatic would have easily been played as an alternative to a quint box in C&F
-
Yeess
Has it occurred to others that the second easiest key to play on a C/C# is F?
Ignoring the keys of C# and G#, yes.
Which suggests the old 4 bass British Chromatic would easily play alongside a quint box in C&F
Are you perchance looking for a use for all those dusty C/C#s lying around? (:)
Note that by the same logic a D/D# would "easily play alongside" a D/G.
As for semitone boxes in more common use, a C#/D would go alongside an A/D (or a D/G for that matter), and a B/C alongside a G/C. Owners of these systems will no doubt be grateful for the knowledge. ;)
-
Speaking of C/C# tuning, why is it so popular with players like Sharon Shannon and Damien Mullane? Is it to stay ahead of the pack?
-
D/G would have easily played as a D/D# alternative .... Absolutely. But D/G boxes hardly existed before Peter Kennedy got a batch made in 1949, whereas 4 bass C/C# and C/F Vienna boxes were contemporary "standard" tunings in GB pre 1930.
-
Hi Peadar.
Whilst I fully recognise what you are saying, I'm afraid I cannot agree.
You are absolutely correct in suggesting F as the most logical key. On my D/D# instruments I can run complete scales in G over three full octaves. I can also play block chords for the full scale over a span of two octaves.
Indeed, there is a commonality linking C/F with C/C#, as you have clearly indicated. I would though suggest that this is more a consequence of musical theory than it is related to instrument design.
One could also indicate the common bass patterns which link the B/C and C/G layout. Again, I would suggest that this is more a phenomenon of music theory than it is an example of developmental design.
-
Thanks Mike.
It was less instrument design than musical tastes that set me on the line of thought.
Settings of songs (and even more so hymns) in "Flat" keys is very common in late 19 c printed books and a lot of melodeons played hymn tunes at the time..
-
Do you think that hymns published in flat keys might have been influenced by the popularity of brass bands, which of course play in those keys? I'm thinking of such things as Salvation Army bands which generally played such material? The Sally Army had Anglo concertinas made in Ab/Eb to cater for their requirements.
Brass bands remain a strong tradition today here in the North of England.
-
"a lot of melodeons played hymn tunes at the time.."
There's a collection of them in Windy Nook which still does!
-
Do you think that hymns published in flat keys might have been influenced by the popularity of brass bands, which of course play in those keys?
Can't speak for hymns much, but carols often end up in F for reasons of range, regardless of instrumentation. Of course individual voices are all different but for many people who aren't trained singers, a top D is comfortable, C even more so. I was advised by a regular church-goer many years ago to pitch carol tunes that way. For tunes that go up to the dominant or the 6th, F is just an easy key for a majority of the congregation to sing in. I attach a list I compiled a few years ago based on the keys in which a few well-known carols appeared in some collections I had on the shelf. F appears quite commonly.
-
Do you think that hymns published in flat keys might have been influenced by the popularity of brass bands, which of course play in those keys?
Can't speak for hymns much, but carols often end up in F for reasons of range, regardless of instrumentation. Of course individual voices are all different but for many people who aren't trained singers, a top D is comfortable, C even more so. I was advised by a regular church-goer many years ago to pitch carol tunes that way. For tunes that go up to the dominant or the 6th, F is just an easy key for a majority of the congregation to sing in. I attach a list I compiled a few years ago based on the keys in which a few well-known carols appeared in some collections I had on the shelf. F appears quite commonly.
I would concur with all those key choices.
One xmas I spent a couple of weeks prepared for a carol service, taking keys from respected printed sources. Mostly from the Oxford Book of Carols. Most were in F, with the occasional foray to Bb or Dm. When I got to the church I was dismayed to find that the two guitar players had practiced everything in A and D. there was no melodeon on that gig. >:(
-
Knowing no better; when asked to play hymn tunes for congregational singing, I've taken along a 1 row in C. My unlearned reasoning being that scales seem to emanate from 'middle' C, so it must be a middling key. They seemed to manage OK, I'm pleased to say.
-
I was dismayed to find that the two guitar players had practiced everything in A and D. there was no melodeon on that gig. >:(
Well I hope they found capos in their Christmas stockings.
-
...but carols often end up in F for reasons of range, regardless of instrumentation. Of course individual voices are all different but for many people who aren't trained singers, a top D is comfortable, C even more so. I was advised by a regular church-goer many years ago to pitch carol tunes that way. For tunes that go up to the dominant or the 6th, F is just an easy key for a majority of the congregation to sing in. I attach a list I compiled a few years ago based on the keys in which a few well-known carols appeared in some collections I had on the shelf. F appears quite commonly.
An excellent reason for investing in a CF. Suits most people's singing very nicely and they're still cheaper than DGs.
-
...but carols often end up in F for reasons of range, regardless of instrumentation. Of course individual voices are all different but for many people who aren't trained singers, a top D is comfortable, C even more so. I was advised by a regular church-goer many years ago to pitch carol tunes that way. For tunes that go up to the dominant or the 6th, F is just an easy key for a majority of the congregation to sing in. I attach a list I compiled a few years ago based on the keys in which a few well-known carols appeared in some collections I had on the shelf. F appears quite commonly.
An excellent reason for investing in a CF. Suits most people's singing very nicely and they're still cheaper than DGs.
Very true. I know of one player who bought a CF precisely to play with the local carollers. I thought about it and decided it was a bit much for the sake of 1 month a year! Of course, if you plan on accompanying other things, it would be very useful. Some great songs work well in Gm and Dm too - those with a range of about an octave, dominant to dominant or tonic to tonic.
One of my current challenges is learning to play in F on a Bob Ellis system DG Benny. Unfamiliar but very doable, especially with simple carol tunes. O Little Town of Bethlehem is coming along a treat with two months to go. ;D
-
...but carols often end up in F for reasons of range, regardless of instrumentation. Of course individual voices are all different but for many people who aren't trained singers, a top D is comfortable, C even more so. I was advised by a regular church-goer many years ago to pitch carol tunes that way. For tunes that go up to the dominant or the 6th, F is just an easy key for a majority of the congregation to sing in. I attach a list I compiled a few years ago based on the keys in which a few well-known carols appeared in some collections I had on the shelf. F appears quite commonly.
An excellent reason for investing in a CF. Suits most people's singing very nicely and they're still cheaper than DGs.
Actually I saw it as a reason to invest in a C/C#, rather than a C/F. :|bl
-
...but carols often end up in F for reasons of range, regardless of instrumentation. Of course individual voices are all different but for many people who aren't trained singers, a top D is comfortable, C even more so. I was advised by a regular church-goer many years ago to pitch carol tunes that way. For tunes that go up to the dominant or the 6th, F is just an easy key for a majority of the congregation to sing in. I attach a list I compiled a few years ago based on the keys in which a few well-known carols appeared in some collections I had on the shelf. F appears quite commonly.
An excellent reason for investing in a CF. Suits most people's singing very nicely and they're still cheaper than DGs.
Actually I saw it as a reason to invest in a C/C#, rather than a C/F. :|bl
...or a CC# ;D ;D ;D