Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Mike Hirst on October 02, 2022, 01:29:02 PM

Title: B/C bass alteration
Post by: Mike Hirst on October 02, 2022, 01:29:02 PM
Following more than three years of almost exclusive working with the McComiskey layout on two different B/C instruments I have noted a recurring weakness.

This concerns the two inside bottom bass buttons which on on older instruments must be changed from C/F to D/F.

I've noticed for some time that the D bass in that pair is often slow to speak. At first I thought it might be a consequence of technique. I often use this while stretching down with my little finger, frequently on a change of bellows direction. I recently have been working on exercises to improve this. I've also considered that it may be a consequence of change in temperature and/or humidity. Here on the North Sea coast in Tyneside the weather has changed dramatically over the past few weeks.

It occurred to me today that this may be a consequence of re tuning the bass reed. As I say, I have noted this on two different instruments. I would be interested to hear the views on this from those who know more than me with regards to instrument alterations and repair. 
Title: Re: B/C bass alteration
Post by: Theo on October 02, 2022, 01:44:31 PM
Hi Mike,  I’m guessing that I was the person who altered the basses?  All I can suggest is that the difference may be just a consequence of the variability in the quality of Hohner bass reeds.
Title: Re: B/C bass alteration
Post by: Mike Hirst on October 02, 2022, 02:00:56 PM
Hi Mike,  I’m guessing that I was the person who altered the basses?  All I can suggest is that the difference may be just a consequence of the variability in the quality of Hohner bass reeds.

Hello Theo.

You are indeed the person who altered the basses. This is not in any way a slight on your admiral abilities. I am more concerned with separating the issue between technique and weakness caused through re tuning. I'd be interesting to see if other players have noticed this.
Title: Re: B/C bass alteration
Post by: Stig Bubblecard on October 02, 2022, 03:20:51 PM
Wow! I had no idea Theo was a seafaring person!
Title: Re: B/C bass alteration
Post by: Mike Hirst on October 02, 2022, 03:41:00 PM
Wow! I had no idea Theo was a seafaring person!
Ha Ha!!! Ooops.
Title: Re: B/C bass alteration
Post by: Squeaky Pete on October 02, 2022, 03:42:35 PM
Well, Theo
variability in the quality of Hohner bass reeds.

That says it all.

I have very little experience compared to many fettlers on here, but while messing about with old Hohner boxes one of the first things I discovered was "variability in the quality of Hohner bass reeds."
Some reeds never play quite like I think they should , some take retuning well even sounding better than the original pitch, and some are just - well - Hohner. Most are basically ok.
Title: Re: B/C bass alteration
Post by: Michael Driscoll on October 02, 2022, 03:58:06 PM
Excuse my curiousity but I presume it was a C Reed being changed to a D one rather than the C Reed being altered in pitch to the D?
Title: Re: B/C bass alteration
Post by: Rog on October 02, 2022, 04:32:39 PM
If a reed is slow (and assuming the valves are ok and there are no unwanted air leaks) it can be because the gap isn’t optimised…or the reed is one of those horrible cheap ones you get in East German and (sometimes) Chinese made instruments.. So I would be getting the block off and checking it on a tuning table. At least then you could witness it doing its slow thing. Theo would have done all this so maybe the gap has altered?
Title: Re: B/C bass alteration
Post by: Theo on October 02, 2022, 05:13:13 PM
Of course adjusted the gaps, and replaced the valves, but so times there are subtleties of response that only become apparent to the player after a while.  But even with optimised gaps some Hohner bass reeds respond better than others.  It seems to be cause of either (1) how well the reed tongue is fitted to the plate whether there are excessive gaps, or the tongue is not central or not parallel with the vent, or (2) whether the reed profile is less good than it should be. These are machine made reeds, so out of tolerance examples could get into production instruments if there were lapses in quality control.
Title: Re: B/C bass alteration
Post by: Mike Hirst on October 02, 2022, 05:31:55 PM
There are many different factors at play here. The seasonal change in temperature and humidity; the fact that I often play in different rooms during the cold months; shifts in repertoire and musical expectation; and many more.

It's best here to look for commonalities and then to focus on the most likely causes.

The main factor that has prompted me to ask this question is the fact that I have experienced the same thing on two different instruments. The commonalities here are that both instruments are older Hohners; both have had the inside bass reed tuned up a whole tone from C to D; with both instruments the work was done by the same person (Theo); and also both instruments are played by the same person (me). The possibilities raised by Roger re air valves, reed gap and leaks are all good suggestions, but it seems less likely that they would cause issues in exactly the same place on two different instruments.

I have no reason to doubt Theo's craftsmanship. He is a well respected technician who has done work on all the instruments I have owned over the past 20 years. I have never before had occasion to question his abilities, so I'm ruling that out. There is the possibility of error or oversight, but that seems unlikely given that both instruments have the same issue.

Working through things logically one eventually comes to the realisation that there are only two outstanding possibilities. On the one hand the issue may be related to playing technique and on the other hand it may be due to the fact that the reed has been re tuned. Playing technique I can improve. Matters related to reeds are outside my experience. I can tune reeds, but I will be the first to admit that I have butchered more reeds than those with which I have had success.

For me than the question remains with re tuning. Is it possible, or likely that re tuning bass reeds can alter response?
Title: Re: B/C bass alteration
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on October 02, 2022, 08:28:33 PM
Have you tried getting another competent player to see if they have a similar experience?
Title: Re: B/C bass alteration
Post by: Winston Smith on October 02, 2022, 10:08:07 PM
"Have you tried getting another competent player"

I would have thought that changing the reed in one of the instruments would be a better test. Perhaps, if the 'right' combination isn't available try one nearer enough where the D reed was either 'as manufactured', or could be tuned down instead of up? Not much to be lost, and possibly everything to be gained.
Title: Re: B/C bass alteration
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on October 02, 2022, 11:04:30 PM
"Have you tried getting another competent player"

I would have thought that changing the reed in one of the instruments would be a better test.

Nothing wrong with systematically addressing all the possibilities. It's a normal part of diagnostics. This is a very straightforward thing to do and gives relevant information. As would reed swapping,
Title: Re: B/C bass alteration
Post by: Winston Smith on October 03, 2022, 05:11:49 AM
"It's a normal part of diagnostics."

I certainly don't mean to be argumentative here, maybe I just spend too much melodeon time by myself? But I'm struggling to imagine how another player playing it can alter the response time of a slow starting reed. (Or how Mike's own "playing technique" could either?)
Title: Re: B/C bass alteration
Post by: Mike Hirst on October 03, 2022, 09:56:41 AM
Thank you for the many replies. Plenty of useful input. To prevent the discussion from disappearing up it's own cloacal conclusion I have to say that I am erring on the side of playing technique rather than instrumental defect.

There does not seem to much evidence for my theory of weakening the reed through re tuning. I have recently been been playing a slightly different repertoire using different keys. I have noticed that I sometimes have to change the position in which I hold my left hand. I guess I just have to practice more.
Title: Re: B/C bass alteration
Post by: Theo on October 03, 2022, 10:29:25 AM
When I retune bass reeds I pretty much always do it by adding or removing weight from the tip which would not weaken the part of the reed that flexes.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal