Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: jarviw on October 02, 2022, 03:36:59 PM
-
I am sure somebody at some point has asked this question, but what's the difference between pokerwork, Erica, and Morgane?
Even the Hohner website is not too helpful. They are all 2 voice instruments with same number of buttons and layout, no registers. ::)
-
The Pokerwork and Erica are almost identical inside, to the extent of having interchangeable reed blocks. As far as I know only the casework is different, but the Erica curved grille is sometime said to project the treble sound forwards more, making it possibly a better a morris box.
The Morgane is a much newer model that seems to sacrifice quality for lower cost.
-
I would say that the Morgane just does not compare to the traditional Hohner models. Build, materials, fit and finish have been sacrificied for a low price point. The triumph of marketing over quality.
-
The big difference is in the keyboard. The Morgane has mushroom buttons screwed into the key posts, and in fact is much nicer to play than either the Erica or the PW. I have fixed a couple of Morgane keyboards.
-
I would say that the Morgane just does not compare to the traditional Hohner models. Build, materials, fit and finish have been sacrificied for a low price point. The triumph of marketing over quality.
Thought when both were available new in the UK the Morgane was the more expensive!
-
Well, the Morgane I’ve seen were quite nice and certainly played better then the PW and Erica, with a better finish and keyboard.
-
Does the Morgane suffer from the traditional Hohner clackiness?
-
I have a D/G Morgane with low notes, no accidentals, and I love it. It's beautiful, easy to work on when needed, if there's a lack of quality I sure don't see it. Mostly I like the sound, a bit drier than other Hohners. And I confess to liking the nameplate, which doesn't affect the sound at all, but has a ship and a very cool motto. Not particularly clacky, maybe a little.
I also have a G/C Galaad, same family, with accidentals and 12 bass, and love it just as much.
-
And I confess to liking the nameplate, which doesn't affect the sound at all, but has a ship and a very cool motto. Not particularly clacky, maybe a little.
Funny they have a Pokerwork on the plate ;D
-
Does the Morgane suffer from the traditional Hohner clackiness?
I didn’t notice it. The build quality is more akin to an Italian box, with better/modern thickly covered pallets.
-
...and in fact is much nicer to play than either the Erica or the PW. I have fixed a couple of Morgane keyboards.
Having played 2 or 3 I find the opposite. All rather soulless. For me, the Morgane is a faux posh box that doesn't quite succeed in being 'posh' while rather losing its way as a Hohner.
-
with better/modern thickly covered pallets.
Like the Chinese Pokerworks and Ericas then
-
I had a G/C Morgane that seemed to me a decent, solid instrument. Better built that my Pokerwork but less pleasant to play than my Erica (not so rounded off). I got it to replace a Sandpiper that kept falling to bits, so certainly a step up from that! I only moved it on when I bought a 3 voice G/C. Perhaps the style was better as a G/C rather than a D/G?
-
...and in fact is much nicer to play than either the Erica or the PW. I have fixed a couple of Morgane keyboards.
Having played 2 or 3 I find the opposite. All rather soulless. For me, the Morgane is a faux posh box that doesn't quite succeed in being 'posh' while rather losing its way as a Hohner.
Soulless, yes.
-
I think HH captures the essence of the Morgane-Meriln-Galaad line.
They were nice, but....
For some reason I thought of them as a melodeon flavored marshmallow. I mean that in a good way. (:)
Here in the States the Merlin (2 button third row) was a good deal and nothing else in that price range.
No stop for thirds was a fatal flaw for the market ("Euro box")
-
No stop for thirds was a fatal flaw for the market ("Euro box")
Absolutely this.
-
No stop for thirds was a fatal flaw for the market ("Euro box")
Absolutely this.
When I bought my first box it was a toss up between a Morgane and a Sandpiper (at the time I didn't like the standard Hohner wetness). The thirds stop was a crucial factor with going for the Sandpiper. The Morgane was also about £150 more expensive at the time (late 2013). Luckily I didn't have any quality/build/breaking issues with the Sandpiper unlike others (but it was fettled by Lester a couple of times so got some good TLC).
-
Does the Morgane suffer from the traditional Hohner clackiness?
I like the clackiness of my pokerwork - but since I suffer from MAD I do have other options if I want something more subtle .
-
You guys. Not sure why you are so down on the Morgane. Apart from the keyboard which is different from the terrible PW/Erica kbs, it is very light compared to the Italian style boxes… it has inherited that from the PW, whereas a Dino or a Casta is heavy in comparison.
-
I think they suffer from some type of asthma.
-
I found when I had an Erica that the inset bass/chord buttons would “nip†my fingertips, which doesn’t happen with a pokerwork’s mushrooms. I think (hope) it is an ergonomic issue rather than/as much as technique (I don’t have the problem with my Ouverture that has the same inset buttons).
As always, if possible it’s worth having a go in person and seeing how each of them works for you.