Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Dan Gordon on October 03, 2022, 04:47:30 PM
-
In the book "The Irish Accordion Tutor" there is a nice chart showing what grace notes go with each note, based on what key you're playing in. But since the book is geared towards B/C boxes it doesn't cover the keys for my instrument (Bb/Eb). I've looked online for a grace note chart that covers all the different keys but haven't found one. Does anyone know of one out there?
-
As I understand it you grace-note up or down to an adjacent note in the scale/mode that the tune is in. Mordants are a 3rd or 5th away.
It’s all ‘diatonic’. So you could do it by ear, and perhaps might better learn it that way?. If I’m correct the graces will usually be other row,
though sometimes same row if eg near the upper end of a dorian scale
Most of the mordants I’ve ever done were on-row. There are many far more experienced “Irish music†players here, but a lot of them play
½-tone. Anyone here play Irish style on a 4th apart system?
Steph Milleret has a lesson on his videos (G/C) that goes through all the Irish ornaments. But looks like he only has the set of 10 lessons
on sale. (Otherwise a bargain, at €70 for 10 subtitled 1-hour repeatable lessons)!
-
Anyone here play Irish style on a 4th apart system?
I don't, Chris, but I know a man who does! I know an Irish D/G player for whom I have done a couple of repairs; unfortunately, he's an instinctive rather than an academic player, so might not be able to analyse what he does. Fortunately, however, his wife, an excellent fiddle-player, does have an academic musical background, and in fact plays in the first violins of the Cyprus Symphony Orchestra, so might be able to shed some light. I'll give her a call and see if she can help.
-
I play ITM on a DG so here's my take on it:
First of all, I'd think of them as "cuts" rather than grace notes. A grace note has a clearly perceived pitch but a cut serves to articulate the note it precedes so it's played very briskly and its pitch should be hardly perceptible.
BC players tend to use notes on the adjacent row, so their cuts are often just a semi-tone away from the subject note. Despite what I just said about pitch, this isn't to everyone's taste. Not something you need to worry about on your Bb/Eb. Actually, with that box, I wouldn't worry about keys. Play by ear, as Chris suggests, and choose ornamentation which sounds right. (I'm guessing you're not planning to play tunes in their usual keys.) Typically, the cut should be in the same key and one or two notes away from the subject note. In practice, this means hitting an adjacent button, either on the same row or the other row. For example, on a DG box, playing in G, I might cut a G note either with the adjacent B on the G row or F# or A on the D row. Transpose as necessary!
Irish ornamentation is very instrument-dependent - a fiddler's or flute player's ornaments will be distinct from those of a box player. Paul Young is a decent model on Youtube and offers lessons by Zoom or similar.
I don't think a chart is the way to go.
-
The OP is quite literally playing "Eb Box" .... Which is a standard Irish practice, albeit using B/C fingering (for D) on a C/C# box. Old School Wyper method.... D# = Eb.
If you want to use standard Grace notes for D, just whack them up a semi tone ....or as CAB says do whatever suits you. Always remember that grace notes are just that. Frilly things that make your playing sound cool. They are not part of the melody.
My playing doesn't sound cool. Ever.
-
I prefer "articulation" to "ornamentation" when describing such phenomena.
-
Agreed but it's a bit of both. A cut articulates a note. Extend it into a roll and you're ornamenting.
-
The OP is quite literally playing "Eb Box" .... Which is a standard Irish practice, albeit using B/C fingering (for D) on a C/C# box. Old School Wyper method.... D# = Eb.
If you want to use standard Grace notes for D, just whack them up a semi tone ....or as CAB says do whatever suits you. Always remember that grace notes are just that. Frilly things that make your playing sound cool. They are not part of the melody.
My playing doesn't sound cool. Ever.
But a Bb/Eb box is not an Irish system, even if one of the rows happens to be a key that ITM is sometimes played in (Eb). The Bb row will not help with cuts or grace notes in the same way that a semitone system would.
-
Agreed but it's a bit of both. A cut articulates a note. Extend it into a roll and you're ornamenting.
Yes, a roll in Irish music...or a croissant in French.
-
Agreed but it's a bit of both. A cut articulates a note. Extend it into a roll and you're ornamenting.
Yes, a roll in Irish music...or a croissant in French.
Done to a turn.
-
Agreed but it's a bit of both. A cut articulates a note. Extend it into a roll and you're ornamenting.
Yes, a roll in Irish music...or a croissant in French.
Done to a turn.
Oh, the mordant wit. We'll be getting on to apologgiaturas soon. Those are the notes you have to say sorry for playing. ;)