Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Marien Lina on October 06, 2022, 02:43:21 PM
-
Dear all,
Currently, I am working on a Hohner liliput to make it DG (it is a CF). A typical thing of a Hohner Liliput is that it does not have deep basses like a pokerwork, if I play it now, feels like I miss a bit of volume in the basses. I have measured that there is space enough to put a bigger bass block inside, hence, I am considereing to make new blocks for larger bass reeds (one octave lower). It is a bit of work, and I am wondering if anyone on this forum has experience with doing this, and whether it works fine. Is there a reason why I should not do this for having deeper basses on a liliput?
Thanks in advance, Marien
-
Is there a reason why I should not do this for having deeper basses on a liliput?
increased air consumption?
-
Possibly, the bellows of a liliput are relatively small. I was more thinking about the volume of the bass and the balance with the melody notes...
-
As Jozz says, increased air consumption could well be a problem.
Also, bass reeds an octave lower might sound good for the player, but from even quite a short distance away those low reeds won't be very loud.
If the lowest reeds are weighted, you might be able to replace then with unweighted reeds of larger size at the same pitch, which would give more sound at frequencies that carry well.
I would imagine that Hohner experimented with the Liliput and came up with the best compromise they could, so don't hold out great hopes for a dramatic improvement.
-
Certainly there would be more air consumed by larger reeds. The small pallets on the Liliput may not allow sufficient air to pass to enable standard bass reeds to sound.
The Liliput already has a good balance between bass and melody. There might be too much bass sound for good balance. Lots of questions. The only way to answer them is to try.
-
There's another problem with low bass reeds in a small box, which my Oakwood exhibits. When the lowest bass notes are playing, the notes on the treble side are modulated by the bass sound pressure in the bellows, giving them a somewhat rasping quality. It's only noticeable on certain combinations of notes, fortunately, and the basses on that box are a lucky compromise of depth, volume and managing not to choke when played hard, so I wouldn't want to change them.
-
I’d be surprised if there really is enough space in there. I once put new bellows on a Liliput and the internal dimension was decreased by about 2mm, and it was super tight even with that. But I’m thinking the clearance you need is where the bass and treble blocks nearly touch with the bellows closed. Anyway, good luck.
-
Flat mounting the low reeds might be something to consider...
-
Out of curiosity, are Pokerwork bass reeds -all- one octave lower than on a Lilliput, or is it rather that the overall range of bass notes extends a bit further down, say a fourth or a fifth, which means about half the notes would be lower but the others would be the same. Just wondering...
-
I’d be surprised if there really is enough space in there. I once put new bellows on a Liliput and the internal dimension was decreased by about 2mm, and it was super tight even with that. But I’m thinking the clearance you need is where the bass and treble blocks nearly touch with the bellows closed. Anyway, good luck.
A bass reed block of 70 mm high will fit, and when closing the bellows it will not touch the treble blocks.
-
Certainly there would be more air consumed by larger reeds. The small pallets on the Liliput may not allow sufficient air to pass to enable standard bass reeds to sound.
The Liliput already has a good balance between bass and melody. There might be too much bass sound for good balance. Lots of questions. The only way to answer them is to try.
The balance between bass and treble is one of the main worries, the other is about the size of the bass block, effectively making teh inside of the bellows smaller, making it less responsive to low frequencies, and causing side effects mentioned by Jazz and Anahata.
Thanks to all for the hints, Marien
-
I’ve done a lot of ultrasound in my career, and in tissue the lower frequencies carry much better. eg 10-20MHz is only really useful for the eye
It turns out to be the same for audio sound, in air! Low notes carry much better!
-
Not unlike the low roar of a lion being audible for up to 5 miles?
-
Or more relevant here much like the often voiced complaint from new platters that “the bass is too loud compared to the trebleâ€. Partly down to playing technique, but also to bass sounds being less directional so the player hears a different balance to the the audience
-
I’d be surprised if there really is enough space in there. I once put new bellows on a Liliput and the internal dimension was decreased by about 2mm, and it was super tight even with that. But I’m thinking the clearance you need is where the bass and treble blocks nearly touch with the bellows closed. Anyway, good luck.
A bass reed block of 70 mm high will fit, and when closing the bellows it will not touch the treble blocks.
The other thing to be mindful of is the clearance between blocks + the valves and moving reed tongues (the tongue vibrates outwards obvs) and esp between the bellows folds and the outer reeds. If I was thinking of trying out your idea I’d probably mod one set of chambers to take the bigger reeds and see if it works. If it doesn’t it’s not too difficult to revert the block back. That is quite a bit less effort than making a whole new block. Also consider the clearance at the back of the reed chamber for bigger reeds. But trying out the idea would be the best way to go. You‘ll discover all sorts of interesting things.
-
As Roger implies, trial and error can be great fun, if also a little frustrating.
-
Yes most standard bass reeds catch the lilliput bellows and become detatched. I have a modified lilly with extra basses and the actual end is extended to house the blocks this has a modified shall i call it fondo which makes the pallets slightly louder . this seems quite a lot of skillfull adaptation.
-
On some PAs there is a wire valve guard across the tops of the outside big bass reeds to stop the valves catching on the bellows. I’d make/fit one of those. …or…I’ve also seen loops attached to the bottom of the valve and the to the top of the block…the valves works inside the loop and can’t get caught on the bellows. But this is essentially the point I was making about having enough space for it to work.
-
Personally I don't think there is enough space with or length in a standard lilliput. Flat mounting may be possible. The mods on mine are well done and ingenious and the extra basses novel. As a liily fan i like the extra but I don't think its really worth it unless its your thing. I could not do it myself.If you want another type of instrument others are available but you wont have a Lilliput if you mod it. Unless you have several. Good luck anyway.
-
Have you thought of weighting the reeds you have, to drop them down by an octave? I expect that there's a good reason not to try this, but I think I've done this on some of mine with reasonable success.
-
Have you thought of weighting the reeds you have, to drop them down by an octave? I expect that there's a good reason not to try this, but I think I've done this on some of mine with reasonable success.
Haha! I recall you bringing me some reeds to tune. Some had been weighted so much that I found them nigh on impossible to tune. Reeds that are weighted to extreme can become slow to respond, produce less volume, and have pitch that varies excessively with changes in playing pressure.
Liliput is a great design, it has good balance between bass and treble. Enjoy it for what it is. If you want deeper basses get a full sized instrument.
-
"Haha! I recall you bringing me some reeds to tune. Some had been weighted so much that I found them nigh on impossible to tune."
Well, there is that aspect I suppose! You can't win them all.
-
Liliput is a great design, it has good balance between bass and treble. Enjoy it for what it is. If you want deeper basses get a full sized instrument.
I think I am going to stick to this balance, also because today I opened the box and concluded that I will have to replace the valves on the bass blocks. the old bass valves (the biggest 8) are open when not pushing or pulling - causing air leakage on push and pull, explaining the quite "silent" bass notes on this particular instrument. After replacing reeds with new valves I think the balance will be back again...
-
Out of curiosity, are Pokerwork bass reeds -all- one octave lower than on a Lilliput, or is it rather that the overall range of bass notes extends a bit further down, say a fourth or a fifth, which means about half the notes would be lower but the others would be the same. Just wondering...
Good question, I have checked this on CF pokerwork and the CF liliput.
I noticed that 3 of the 16 lowest bass reeds produce a higher note on the Liliput. Most of them (12) have exactly the same notes, not deeper on a pokerworktuning. One chord is different (on push: Bb chord on a 2 row is a Eb chord on a Liliput). Maybe worth another discussion, what is the advantage of having a Eb than a Bb on push on a CF