Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Martyn Hunter-Wyatt on October 17, 2022, 08:58:21 PM
-
What’s the opinion on re-taping over old Hohner cloth tape? The bellows I’ve re-taped before have gone exactly the way Lester’s video shows. The ones I’m working on now have a few tapes that came off easily but most are soundly glued except for some of the ends. It seems to be quite damaging to get these old tapes off. It’s going to look odd if I put new tape on the 20% or so that need it and leave the rest.
-
You might need longer bellows straps.
-
There is nothing wrong with just repairing the damaged tape. It’s a common practice. As opposed to 'restoring' bellows with new tape. It also takes a lot less time and effort. Having re taped a few bellows it’s a job I generally avoid as much as possible now (though on some older bellows the tape pulls straight off…so it’s happy days…..but even then it’s a biggish job to cut and fit 18 x 4 bits of tape). If the box is just for your own use, personally I’d just do a repair. Others may advise differently.
-
If it was me, I'd renew them all. If the tape is very hard to strip off, I usually scratch the surface with a small file/nail board and then apply
a damp cloth so as to slightly moisten them. It needs patience but worth it in the end.
-
If old tape is lifting in places then parts that appear to be firm may work loose in the near future, and if the moisture from the glue used to apply the new tape me affect the old glue. Re-taping is a laborious job however you do it, so better to do it right first time and strap off all the old tape. Use some moisture as suggested by Mike K and it will come off. It's also perfectly fine to just patch a worn area. I do this on instruments I'm preparing for sale if the value of the instrument does not justify the time to do a complete re-tape. Here is the back of a Hohner Double Ray I sold recently:
(https://theboxplace.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/IMG_4349.jpeg)
-
Thanks for the replies, all very helpful. Consensus is not to tape over existing so I won’t try it. This one is similar to Theo’s Double Ray. I’ve cleaned off 22 strips completely. They were all loosened by wear or impact damage. I’ll retape those and leave the rest for now. I have another that’s similar but with worse bellows, I’ll have a go at dampening the tape on those, see how I get on, before I do anything riskier on the present project. It played well as it was but had a couple of leaky spots where it may have been dropped. The rest looked like wear from playing.
-
Just to mention another approach between the localized patching and total retape, I sometimes see boxes where only the badly worn sides (typically back and/or bottom) have been retaped.
-
Just to mention another approach between the localized patching and total retape, I sometimes see boxes where only the badly worn sides (typically back and/or bottom) have been retaped.
I have done this a few times, especially when I want a good functioning instrument, but want to preserve the ravages of time (patina).
-
Thanks for all the tips. I have it playing again and it's passable for appearance given the age. It was a combination of wear and damage so I've ended up doing all the bottom tapes plus three each side and over the top. The modern tape is much thicker so the bellows straps are at the limit but overall it seems good for the time taken. I have another set of bellows to do but they are in poor condition so they will be a complete re-tape. Given what I've learnt here they should still be worth repairing rather than replacing.