Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: PeterBRC on October 28, 2022, 08:39:23 PM

Title: Tony Hall. Flowers of Edinburgh
Post by: PeterBRC on October 28, 2022, 08:39:23 PM
A few days ago there was a wonderful posting of Tony Hall , it was just inspiring  to listen to . I was thinking as a newbie what sort of tuning the fantastic old Hohner has , I don't really know how to describe it  (ie as MM++) etc. I have no idea what to call it but I would like to try and get a box that sounds like it
Title: Re: Tony Hall. Flowers of Edinburgh
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on October 28, 2022, 08:59:47 PM
A few days ago there was a wonderful posting of Tony Hall , it was just inspiring  to listen to . I was thinking as a newbie what sort of tuning the fantastic old Hohner has , I don't really know how to describe it  (ie as MM++) etc. I have no idea what to call it but I would like to try and get a box that sounds like it

It's probably best described as Hohner  ;D.
I suggest you talk to Mike Rowbotham (Microbot). He's not the only one who understands it, but he  understands it better than some. He has the knack.
Title: Re: Tony Hall. Flowers of Edinburgh
Post by: IanD on October 28, 2022, 09:52:18 PM
A few days ago there was a wonderful posting of Tony Hall , it was just inspiring  to listen to . I was thinking as a newbie what sort of tuning the fantastic old Hohner has , I don't really know how to describe it  (ie as MM++) etc. I have no idea what to call it but I would like to try and get a box that sounds like it

Tony has shortened and simplified his version of FoE compared to the one he used to play many years ago, as I noticed last time I asked him to play it at a gig and on the (wonderful) posted video.

The even more glorious original version can be heard here...

https://soundcloud.com/ian-dedic/the-flowers-of-edinburgh
Title: Re: Tony Hall. Flowers of Edinburgh
Post by: rees on October 28, 2022, 10:00:35 PM
A few days ago there was a wonderful posting of Tony Hall , it was just inspiring  to listen to . I was thinking as a newbie what sort of tuning the fantastic old Hohner has , I don't really know how to describe it  (ie as MM++) etc. I have no idea what to call it but I would like to try and get a box that sounds like it

Tony has shortened and simplified his version of FoE compared to the one he used to play many years ago, as I noticed last time I asked him to play it at a gig and on the (wonderful) posted video.

The even more glorious original version can be heard here...

https://soundcloud.com/ian-dedic/the-flowers-of-edinburgh

That's the one! Still quite unbelievable after all these years.
Title: Re: Tony Hall. Flowers of Edinburgh
Post by: Julian S on October 29, 2022, 08:10:35 AM
When I first listened to 'Fieldvole Music', I remember thinking ' does the man have extra fingers ?!'
Incredible playing - still can't get my head around it.
Has anyone attempted to notate accurately what he is doing when he plays Flowers ?

Julian
Title: Re: Tony Hall. Flowers of Edinburgh
Post by: Anahata on October 29, 2022, 08:47:04 AM
Has anyone attempted to notate accurately what he is doing when he plays Flowers ?

Julian

If anyone has, it's likely to be Owen Woods. He's made a "Tony Hall Tribute" YT video of the tune, and I think he spent some time researching it.
Title: Re: Tony Hall. Flowers of Edinburgh
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on October 29, 2022, 09:38:40 AM
Has anyone attempted to notate accurately what he is doing when he plays Flowers ?

Julian

If anyone has, it's likely to be Owen Woods. He's made a "Tony Hall Tribute" YT video of the tune, and I think he spent some time researching it.

This one https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BXVKqayckH0

It's nicely filmed, with a clear view of what his fingers are doing. I still can't make it happen like that, though. It's not so much extra fingers needed, as the ability to have your concentration split three ways while following a rhythm that sounds simple when you listen to it, but just isn't that simple to do (for me, at any rate).
Title: Re: Tony Hall. Flowers of Edinburgh
Post by: Anahata on October 29, 2022, 10:15:06 AM
That's the one.
Funny, it may be more technically perfect than Tony Hall's, but Tony gets an extraordinary smoothness in his playing that's really hard to imitate.
Title: Re: Tony Hall. Flowers of Edinburgh
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on October 29, 2022, 11:05:08 AM
That's the one.
Funny, it may be more technically perfect than Tony Hall's, but Tony gets an extraordinary smoothness in his playing that's really hard to imitate.

All you have to do is poke around until the noise sounds right.
 ::) ::) ::)
Title: Re: Tony Hall. Flowers of Edinburgh
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on October 29, 2022, 11:20:37 AM
I was thinking of Owen during this discussion.
I always remember being amazed at his dexterity, holding down one finger whilst the rest does something else!
Another stunning player 'of this parish'...
Title: Re: Tony Hall. Flowers of Edinburgh
Post by: Chris Ryall on October 29, 2022, 11:21:32 AM

  Trumpington Street engineering graduates don’t “poke around”! 😳

  Back to topic, it has been very useful to compare Owen’s technically note perfect version with the early Tony Hall’s one
  posted by Ian Dedic.  While its note runs seem virtually identical, the timing is very different. In particular Tony’s bass notes
  all arrive late, to my ear, maybe … â…“-note behind the melody beat. It’s “swung”. I think that much of the magic lies there? 🤔
Title: Re: Tony Hall. Flowers of Edinburgh
Post by: Winston Smith on October 29, 2022, 12:57:52 PM
I really enjoyed both of these. Mr Hall's recording was lovely, but Owen's touched me in a different way. His canny little face showing the contortions of his concentration, especially towards the end. An excellent chap whom I wish we came across a bit more!
Title: Re: Tony Hall. Flowers of Edinburgh
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on October 29, 2022, 01:35:49 PM

  Trumpington Street engineering graduates don’t “poke around”! 😳
  Back to topic...

I think Tony does exactly that, though. He chooses the notes to play from trying them and using what works.  It's a great skill and fundamental to his sound (which is the topic).

I agree about the timing though. There is an independence between his melody, his harmony and his bass playing that is a bit like listening to three musicians each doing their part that makes me wonder how can one person do that.  It's not complicated. Just very clever and very natural.
Title: Re: Tony Hall. Flowers of Edinburgh
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on October 29, 2022, 01:39:29 PM
I agree Winston.
When I first became involved in the forum Owen and Olly King were the new young things and posted continually as their college courses gave them time to do so. Years on, I think grown up things like work have now come into play.
In  my opinion both are stunning players and much missed.
Title: Re: Tony Hall. Flowers of Edinburgh
Post by: Chris Ryall on October 29, 2022, 02:02:42 PM

  it is most unlikely that Tony Hall has studied engineering, anywhere! He is a graphic artist.
  Here’s a biography he wrote for Wildgoose Records (a few years back)

“ Im 65, a fully paid up member of the Old farts Club and have played Hohner boxes since I was about eleven years old. About 1952 or so, when our family lived in a council pre-fab. in Beccles, Suffolk, our Uncle Sam visited us from the USA and left a C/F Hohner box with us. Of us three brothers, I was the only one interested in the thing, and when Sam returned to the US, I taught myself how to play it (having started on mouth-organ a similar instrument).

I taught myself in complete isolation, as I never even saw another melodeon until many years later so there was no musical tradition at all surrounding me. I learnt tunes (of all types I wasnt aware of the word folk) from the radio and often practiced playing in our bedroom in the dark (and it didnt make me go blind). I was first introduced to folk music during a (failed) teacher training course at Matlock in Derbyshire. The college had a terrific folk club BUT I only performed using a guitar, as I never thought a melodeon would be acceptable in a folk club! Later in life, I would say that the most important musical influence was regularly attending Rod and Danny Stradlings wonderful Kings Head folk Club in Islington. There, week after week, one could experience all the terrific traditional music of these islands: one week Seamus Ennis, the uillean pipe player and storyist, another the whole Bampton Morris side etc. etc.

My other influence was a weekly visit to the White Hart, Fulham to listen to Irelands Raymond Rowland, Lliam Farrel and Mick the singer (and get rat-arsed on Guinness and bitter). I have performed as a backing musician to several worthies in the folk world including: -Maddy Prior and June Tabors Silly Sisters album and subsequent tour -Nick Jones Penguin Eggs album -Backing people such as Shirley Collins, Peter Bellamy, Royston Wood and the Kipper family on albums These days I do the odd booking in what I call pocket of masochism (e.g. clubs that can tolerate my odd outlook on life). For years Ive had the privilege of performing at Whitby Folk Festival and sometimes at Sidmouth.

Also, as my main anchor in music, I play every week with my Von Krapp Family Band in a Norwich pub. We play anti-flash, straight-down-the-line music and crack silly jokes. Career-wise Im a (not very well known) cartoonist; also an all year motorcyclist and avid pipe smoker, not averse to the odd pint or single malt ”
Title: Re: Tony Hall. Flowers of Edinburgh
Post by: Jesse Smith on October 29, 2022, 09:38:42 PM
I was thinking of Owen during this discussion.
I always remember being amazed at his dexterity, holding down one finger whilst the rest does something else!
Another stunning player 'of this parish'...

I think both Owen Woods and Tony Hall benefit from having extraordinarily long, spindly fingers, especially their little fingers.
Title: Re: Tony Hall. Flowers of Edinburgh
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on October 29, 2022, 09:49:41 PM
I'm sure Owen has Arachnid ancestry  ;D
He told me once his span on a piano I can't remember exactly what it was but remember thinking it was extraordinary.
Title: Re: Tony Hall. Flowers of Edinburgh
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on October 29, 2022, 10:18:33 PM


  Here’s a biography he wrote for Wildgoose Records (a few years back)...


Thank for that Chris. Fascinating and illuminating .
Title: Re: Tony Hall. Flowers of Edinburgh
Post by: tirpous on October 30, 2022, 12:12:57 AM
Quote
I think both Owen Woods and Tony Hall benefit from having extraordinarily long, spindly fingers, especially their little fingers.

It can be good sometimes, but not always.  I remember a long-fingered guitar-playing friend telling me how yes, he could do these incredible stretches, but he had trouble with the close chords where all the fingers must be bunched up together.  We (me, anyway) tend to forget what we have and envy what we don't.
Title: Re: Tony Hall. Flowers of Edinburgh
Post by: Dave Praties on October 30, 2022, 06:47:29 AM
I don’t think that finger size makes any difference, both Segovia and Bach had thick stubby fingers.
Dave.
Title: Re: Tony Hall. Flowers of Edinburgh
Post by: CAB on October 30, 2022, 02:42:57 PM
I don’t think that finger size makes any difference, both Segovia and Bach had thick stubby fingers.
Dave.

And look what crap melodeon players they were.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal