Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Yooval Mann on October 30, 2022, 12:48:16 PM

Title: Analysing the sound of Máirtín ó Connor,'s box
Post by: Yooval Mann on October 30, 2022, 12:48:16 PM
Hi folks, I'm about to get my MM B/C box tuned and I would like to ask the technician to achieve a certain sound after an example from a video from Máirtín ó Connor,

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=EgMPpSOPMxI

Can someone with a tuning equipment (strobe?) tell me from the video what's the type of tuning on mairtin box with regard to whether it's M and M+ or rather M- & M+?

Also how many cents between the two reeds and whether its the same distance in cents throughout the range of notes?

I'm willing to pay for this information just let me know how much 😁

Thanks a million!

Title: Re: Analysing the sound of Máirtín ó Connor,'s box
Post by: PeterBRC on October 30, 2022, 01:57:46 PM
I have the exact same question but from a different box
Title: Re: Analysing the sound of Máirtín ó Connor,'s box
Post by: Chris Marriott on October 30, 2022, 02:04:22 PM
The adjacent thread in this forum on "Dirk's Tuner" may be of interest. It'll probably give you the information you're looking for.
Title: Re: Analysing the sound of Máirtín ó Connor,'s box
Post by: Theo on October 30, 2022, 03:37:24 PM
I suggest you send the video to your tuner and ask for yours to be the same. There is very little tremolo, if any. With very small spread between the two reeds it becomes unimportant whether it is MM+ or M+M-,
Title: Re: Analysing the sound of Máirtín ó Connor,'s box
Post by: Yooval Mann on October 30, 2022, 03:53:16 PM
thanks appreciate your help!

Theo. could that be the original "Swing" Saltarelle tuning of 7 cents apart? does it sound like it could be within 6-7 cents range?
Title: Re: Analysing the sound of Máirtín ó Connor,'s box
Post by: Theo on October 30, 2022, 04:15:40 PM
It's hard to tell.  I find it easiest to judge when a not is help for a longer time, but in this recoding on all the longer notes Mairtin plays two notes at the same time.  I think it's much less than the typical Saltarelle swing and could be dry.   Here is another recoding of the same box where its clearer that there is either no tremolo or very little.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3ov0RWJDV30

My best guess is its dry or perhaps a 0,5Hz swing, which is 2.5 cents at A440
Title: Re: Analysing the sound of Máirtín ó Connor,'s box
Post by: Rog on October 30, 2022, 04:16:55 PM
Can I point out that you don’t hear cents. You hear the 'beat’ or rate of tremolo between two reeds (let’s leave three reeds out of it). If you want 1bps (beats  per second, which is quite slow), the difference in cents varies depending on the reed pitch. So (in my opinion) it’s more useful to describe what you can actually hear. When tuning, you decide which reed to move and listen to the result…so it’s not even necessary to know the cent offset..and indeed once you have the concert/ref pitch where it needs to be (say, it’s an A) you don’t actually need a tuner to set the tremolo. Well…that’s how I think of it. And some tuners use a tone generator to set the ref pitch, rather than a meter.
A meter is useful if, for instance, you measure a single set of reeds in the box, and then adjust them on a tuning table, which is faster than to-ing and fro-ing with the blocks in situ. And you know you are moving each reed by x cents, so that (mostly) they are where they should be back in the box.
Title: Re: Analysing the sound of Máirtín ó Connor,'s box
Post by: Theo on October 30, 2022, 04:22:17 PM
I agree with you Roger that it's much more useful to talk about Hz than cents for the reason you give,  but:

 which is faster than to-ing and fro-ing with the blocks in situ.


If you learn the skills and have the right tools then the quickest way to get top quality, precise tuning is to do it all with the blocks in the box.  That's true whether you tune by ear or use a meter, or best of all a combination of both.

But lets stick to the topic of trying to analyse the sound of Mairtin O'Connors box.
Title: Re: Analysing the sound of Máirtín ó Connor,'s box
Post by: Rog on October 31, 2022, 07:27:41 AM
Yes it was a bit off topic. Apols …one can get carried away on here. I’ll try better next time.
Title: Re: Analysing the sound of Máirtín ó Connor,'s box
Post by: Yooval Mann on October 31, 2022, 10:43:57 AM
I don't know it sounds to me like there is  a little bit of 'sizzle' to the tone there where I would expect the  2-3 cents you mentioned to be very very dry... but I'm no professional tuner and you are so I'd say I'm probably wrong 
it would be nice if someone with the Dirk tuner or any other technology could analyse it, again WILLING TO PAY FOR THE JOB
Title: Re: Analysing the sound of Máirtín ó Connor,'s box
Post by: Yooval Mann on October 31, 2022, 10:47:32 AM
Ive found another video of Mairtin with a different box with a sound I prefer and is wetter, also slower tempo
is that closer to 7 cents?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pe1EjTMPl0Q
Title: Re: Analysing the sound of Máirtín ó Connor,'s box
Post by: Theo on October 31, 2022, 11:16:19 AM
Yes there does seem to be more tremolo on that one.

I suggest you focus on the sound, not on numbers.  Find a recording you like and ask your tuner to make it like that.   Bear in mind though that the same spread between reeds will sound different in different makes of instrument, and with different makes and qualities of reed.
Title: Re: Analysing the sound of Máirtín ó Connor,'s box
Post by: Yooval Mann on October 31, 2022, 11:39:50 AM
yes important to bear that in mind. thanks Theo

Title: Re: Analysing the sound of Máirtín ó Connor,'s box
Post by: Graham Spencer on October 31, 2022, 12:32:16 PM
Ive found another video of Mairtin with a different box with a sound I prefer and is wetter, also slower tempo
is that closer to 7 cents?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pe1EjTMPl0Q

In the first video you posted he's playing (I think) a Saltarelle Pastourelle of the same vintage as mine, but it sounds nothing like mine - much more "edgy" to my ears. The second one is again a Saltarelle, but a different model, and its tuning sounds very much the same as mine. When I bought my Saltarelle new (they were new on the market back then) it came tuned very dry, and I had Nils Nilsson work his magic by increasing the tremolo just a little and it came back sounding much sweeter; I've stuck to that offset ever since, and it's still my favourite box of the 8 or so playable ones I have - even more so than the lovely little vintage Bb/Eb Hlavacek I picked up in Prague a few years back.  I guess you'd call it a little wetter than swing......
Title: Re: Analysing the sound of Máirtín ó Connor,'s box
Post by: Gromit on October 31, 2022, 03:18:14 PM
You could try asking him, let us know the answer.

http://mairtinoconnor.ie/contact/
Title: Re: Analysing the sound of Máirtín ó Connor,'s box
Post by: Willem Feltkamp on November 01, 2022, 08:12:05 PM
There is a note that might suggest that it's tuned actually quite wet. It's the (A) single note at the end of a phrase at counter 1:04 which sounds quite wobbly.

Finding the right tuning might take more than one tuning session, at least that's my experience.
I used to tune every box to nearly unison, but my preference seems to shift.
I've been dabbling with tuning two accordions to swing tuning lately using the tuning tables in the book 'sounding out the accordion' by Thierry Benetoux.
He defines swing tuning as follows: b3 40 beats/min, f4 50 beats/min, a4 60 b/m, C#5 70b/m, going up to f6 110 b/m
I found that to sound nice for Irish music on a homemade box (not by me) with reeds fairly rich in overtones.
But then when I applied it to my CBA which had more mellow sounding reeds, I found the result a bit tame.
So even though normally I don't like to much wetness, it is possible to have to little.

If you're not sure what kind of tuning you're into, you might want to take into consideration the tuning at this moment. If it's fairly wet, the tuner would have to make seriously deep scratches at the bottom of the reeds to get it swing tuned. Should you then decide you want a wetter sound, he would then have to remove material from the tips, reversing the first tuning action.
maybe having it done in increments is the way to go. At least that way the tuning person wouldn't have to reverse his previous work, and less damage would be done to the reeds.
Title: Re: Analysing the sound of Máirtín ó Connor,'s box
Post by: Steve C. on November 02, 2022, 09:21:22 AM
Agree with Theo that the OP is asking for analysis of Martins' box. That's the topic.
But:
"Dear Abby:
Reading the OP "between the lines" i keep ending up with Yooval, old friend, you cannot have the the sound of this box in this video because you are not the player in this video. This guy is a melodeon god.
There are some things you can do, sure, to get in the ballpark of the right box, right reeds, right tremolo, etc.
But...
I wondered for a few years, "why can't I play like Clive" when I had a box like his.  Same Lester. Folkblues, Howard Mitchell, etc. x N.
Answer:  10% box.  90% player. 
Some of the recordings also have a light bit of reverb and chorus that fills out the sound."
     from Concerned fellow melodeon player

Also from a previous relevant  thread, your box does not sound  the same to you the player as it sounds if someone plays it to you the listener, especially "sizzle", overtones, etc.
Title: Re: Analysing the sound of Máirtín ó Connor,'s box
Post by: Graham Spencer on November 02, 2022, 10:00:13 AM
Agree with Theo that the OP is asking for analysis of Martins' box. That's the topic.
But:
"Dear Abby:
Reading the OP "between the lines" i keep ending up with Yooval, old friend, you cannot have the the sound of this box in this video because you are not the player in this video. This guy is a melodeon god.
There are some things you can do, sure, to get in the ballpark of the right box, right reeds, right tremolo, etc.
But...
I wondered for a few years, "why can't I play like Clive" when I had a box like his.  Same Lester. Folkblues, Howard Mitchell, etc. x N.
Answer:  10% box.  90% player. 
Some of the recordings also have a light bit of reverb and chorus that fills out the sound."
     from Concerned fellow melodeon player

Also from a previous relevant  thread, your box does not sound  the same to you the player as it sounds if someone plays it to you the listener, especially "sizzle", overtones, etc.

This is where I need a "like" button.......
Title: Re: Analysing the sound of Máirtín ó Connor,'s box
Post by: Yooval Mann on November 03, 2022, 08:54:11 AM
I've extracted F G A C and D out of the audio file, does that sound like 7 cents apart or more do you reckon?
Title: Re: Analysing the sound of Máirtín ó Connor,'s box
Post by: gettabettabox on November 03, 2022, 12:01:24 PM
I think if you had the same box with the same reeds then 6,7 or 8 cents would suit.
Then you will have to grow a beard and play with B/C fingering on a C#/D box to give you this tune set in A  ;D
Title: Re: Analysing the sound of Máirtín ó Connor,'s box
Post by: gettabettabox on November 03, 2022, 12:12:46 PM
And...thank you for posting this lovely clip.
Title: Re: Analysing the sound of Máirtín ó Connor,'s box
Post by: Yooval Mann on November 03, 2022, 01:35:54 PM
Thank you, forgive me for inquiring you say 6-8 cents based on a similar configuration on another box you own please?

BTW it's a  d/d# box I think
Title: Re: Analysing the sound of Máirtín ó Connor,'s box
Post by: tirpous on November 03, 2022, 02:22:39 PM
Quote
I've extracted F G A C and D out of the audio file, does that sound like 7 cents apart or more do you reckon?

Playing that file in the Farmer tuner (set for multiple notes) gives roughly:

F  0  +12
G  0  +4
A  +1  +8
C  -1   +7
D  0    +4

BTW, you can see it for yourself, this software is free.
Title: Re: Analysing the sound of Máirtín ó Connor,'s box
Post by: gettabettabox on November 03, 2022, 02:35:50 PM
Thank you, forgive me for inquiring you say 6-8 cents based on a similar configuration on another box you own please?

BTW it's a  d/d# box I think

 (:) Hi again, I just meant that by listening I get an approximate measure of the tuning offset.

Tirpous is more accurate.

As regards the model of box, I meant that even with an identical box fitted with the same quality reedset ...and tuned with same identified offset, there might still be a difference in tonal quality and reed behaviour, but good luck with your efforts. Most of us pursue the sound we like.
Title: Re: Analysing the sound of Máirtín ó Connor,'s box
Post by: Yooval Mann on November 03, 2022, 04:29:44 PM
Thank you, very interesting does it make sense to have such a difference in cents between notes relatively close to one another? I mean the D nearly dry while the F close to wet
Title: Re: Analysing the sound of Máirtín ó Connor,'s box
Post by: Willem Feltkamp on November 04, 2022, 09:59:27 PM
hi Yooval,

It is not common (on well-tuned accordions) to have jumps in the amount of wetness between notes close to each other.
With most tunings, it is common to have the beats, or 'wobble' increase in speed toward the higher notes very gradually.
The difference in cents, however, will decrease in the same direction.
This can be explained if you realise that two reeds tuned one Hz apart will give a beat frequency or 'wobble' of 1 beat per second.
A cent is 1/100 of the difference in Hz (vibrations per second) between two adjacent notes. So a cent doesn't equal a fixed number of Hz, because notes increase in frequency as they get higher.

For example, on the low side of the keyboard, the difference between two notes may be, say, 10HZ, being the difference between a C of roughly 130 Hz and the adjoining C# of roughly 140 Hz. One cent here means 1/10 of a Hz. So if you want to detune the C so that it will give a beat of 1 per second, you need to detune it by 10 cents, which equals 1 Hz.
Four octaves higher, the difference between C and C# is more than 120 hz. Here one cent equals 1,2 hz, and detuning by just three cents gives a beat frequency of 3,6 per second. So even though the note is detuned far less (measured in cents) than the one in the low octave, it will give a faster beat.
Title: Re: Analysing the sound of Máirtín ó Connor,'s box
Post by: Yooval Mann on November 05, 2022, 07:01:16 AM
thank you for the detailed explanation
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal