Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: kenakordeon on November 05, 2022, 01:12:59 PM

Title: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: kenakordeon on November 05, 2022, 01:12:59 PM
I had posted on FB Traditional Irish Accordion about reed tremolo but want to follow up here. My accordion is LMMM with an "Irish" tremolo tuning. I want to have the tremolo tightened/lessened. Somewhere I think I read that wet tuning is louder than dry tuning. Is that true? Or, is it that the spread of the sound of the three reeds in tremolo-tuned or "detuned" accordion is not really louder but seems to be louder because of the aural width(for lack of a better term) of the reeds as they respond to the air pressure? Will a MMM dry-tuned accordion be any less loud? Or, as I think, is the loudness more a result of the size of the box? I find my single-row LMMH to sound louder than the the bigger box LMMM.

I hope these questions make sense. I appreciate any thoughts you might have.

Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: Graham Spencer on November 05, 2022, 01:30:13 PM
I'm no acoustic physicist, but I wouldn't expect there to be any real difference in sound pressure. What I might expect is  difference in the perceived loudness of the wetter-tuned box's more complex waveform. Of course I coud be entirely wrong......
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: mselic on November 05, 2022, 01:33:26 PM
Yes, there will be a perceived drop in volume with a dry-tuned MMM. Whether it’s an actual drop or not doesn’t really matter because most people would agree that a drier tuning tends to sounds quieter than one that has a moderate amount of tremolo.
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: kenakordeon on November 05, 2022, 10:13:35 PM
Thanks. I also think its a perceived drop in loudness based on the more complex waveform of the wetter tuning. Thanks for defining it as a “more complex waveform.”
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: IanD on November 06, 2022, 05:28:22 PM
Thanks. I also think its a perceived drop in loudness based on the more complex waveform of the wetter tuning. Thanks for defining it as a “more complex waveform.”

Research showed that perceived volume to the ear increases with wider detuning/tremolo, rapidly up to about 4Hz difference and then more slowly up to about 7Hz difference, which sounds loud but extremely "wet" -- above this the sound gets even nastier but no louder. It's no coincidence that this tremolo rate is also typically what is used by opera singers and violin players striving for maximum audibility when unamplified...
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: Winston Smith on November 06, 2022, 11:16:58 PM
"It's no coincidence that this tremolo rate is also typically what is used by opera singers...."
Wow, that would be a good trick! In over 55 years of singing, I've never come across anyone with that capability.
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on November 07, 2022, 12:16:13 AM
...Research showed that perceived volume to the ear increases with wider detuning/tremolo, rapidly up to about 4Hz difference and then more slowly up to about 7Hz difference...

Is that relationship constant as pitch gets higher?
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: Jesse Smith on November 07, 2022, 01:48:54 AM
"It's no coincidence that this tremolo rate is also typically what is used by opera singers...."
Wow, that would be a good trick! In over 55 years of singing, I've never come across anyone with that capability.

Obviously with a singer it is vibrato rather than two simultaneous tones (except perhaps for polyphone overtone singing), but the perceived tremolo rate is roughly the same (around 5 Hz) and done for the same reason, to increase the perceived volume or "thickness" of the sound.
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: Winston Smith on November 07, 2022, 02:41:18 PM
"Obviously with a singer it is vibrato rather than two simultaneous tones"
 
Hardly obvious to someone who imagined that a vibrato singing voice was some kind of speech impediment! To my untrained ears, vibrato singing just about ranks alongside a descant as being the worst ruination of any musical/choral piece!

But I'm going off topic!
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: tirpous on November 07, 2022, 02:49:06 PM
For the visuals among us...
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: mselic on November 07, 2022, 02:59:36 PM
For the visuals among us...

Brilliant!
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: Lester on November 07, 2022, 03:03:09 PM
For the visuals among us...
So, AM and FM then
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: Anahata on November 07, 2022, 03:16:09 PM
So, AM and FM then
Precisely!
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: IanD on November 07, 2022, 11:01:02 PM
"It's no coincidence that this tremolo rate is also typically what is used by opera singers...."
Wow, that would be a good trick! In over 55 years of singing, I've never come across anyone with that capability.

Listen to some of the early recordings of old-style coloratura opera singers, the warbling is something else... ;-)
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: IanD on November 07, 2022, 11:06:04 PM
For the visuals among us...

Indeed -- but what singers do is tremolo which is volume variations, and that's also what you get with two reeds as they move in and out of phase (violins do vibrato).

The key is that the ear is sensitive to how quickly the sound changes in both amplitude and pitch, and the apparent volume behaves as I described -- louder up to about 7Hz, then just nastier above that. If you don't believe me (or the research I described) do what I did and borrow an audio signal generator which can add amplitude (tremolo) or frequency (modulation) and listen to how "loud" it sounds as you up the beat rate.
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: IanD on November 07, 2022, 11:07:36 PM
...Research showed that perceived volume to the ear increases with wider detuning/tremolo, rapidly up to about 4Hz difference and then more slowly up to about 7Hz difference...

Is that relationship constant as pitch gets higher?

As far as I know, yes. It certainly seemed that way to me when I tried it out (see previous mail).

Knowing the way the ear works that's not at all surprising, the hardware in your ear does the frequency-related bits to tell your brain what the sound is, but your brain then looks at the modulation to decide whether it sounds nice/quiet or loud/nasty.
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: Chris Ryall on November 08, 2022, 12:39:10 PM

 The standard formula for adding 2 fairly η-adjacent  sine waves together is sin(a) + sin(b) = 2 x cos((a+b)/2) x sin((a-b)/2)

 Which (I was told in year-1 uni physics) is amplitude modulation. ie beats,  around the mean frequency 🤔

 I’m not sure where the concept of frequency modulation has come from in this, but I’m very happy to be educated.
 â€¦ we have a couple of PhD physicists and at least one very competent electrical engineer in the group.

  http://spiff.rit.edu/classes/phys207/lectures/beats/add_beats.html

  I totally agree that I once it gets into the brain everything is parametric. The brain also looks at the phase of sound coming into both ears,
  as part of judging direction of the source. I’m not sure how relevant that is to Melodeons, unless you are … a blindfolded Morris man! 🤔😉
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: Willem Feltkamp on November 10, 2022, 07:21:42 PM
I've always wondered about the way reed tremolo works. It is represented by neither of the two graphs, I would think.
But if it's the 'in phase'-phase that is louder, then a faster tremolo would be louder not only perceived but in reality, since there are more times per second in which the reeds are in phase in a faster tremolo compared to a slower one.
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: Anahata on November 10, 2022, 10:06:42 PM
I've always wondered about the way reed tremolo works. It is represented by neither of the two graphs, I would think.
The amplitude modulation ("tremolo") graph is approximately what you get with two reeds tuned slightly apart. If they were pure sine waves it would be exactly the same. Because of reed harmonics, it's more complex, as each harmonic will have an amplitude modulation at a higher frequency, i.e. the Nth harmonic will beat at N times the fundamental tremolo frequency.

Quote
But if it's the 'in phase'-phase that is louder, then a faster tremolo would be louder not only perceived but in reality, since there are more times per second in which the reeds are in phase in a faster tremolo compared to a slower one.
More times per second, but shorter times, and in between the peaks are troughs where they are out of phase and there's more of those too. The average amplitude as measured will be essentially the same.
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: PeterBRC on November 11, 2022, 09:23:33 AM
So does this explain why my playing of the bass sounds better when I am in a corner ! facing outwards of course .?
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: Chris Ryall on November 11, 2022, 10:05:15 AM
So does this explain why my playing of the bass sounds better when I am in a corner ! facing outwards of course .?

Melodeons are very directional, Peter. “Never sit to the left of a melodeonist”, as they say. You may have invented your own reflex speaker system in that corner!

Another interesting experiment is to get somebody else to play your Melodeon. It is surprising how different it sounds. Even if styles of play are similar.
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: PeterBRC on November 11, 2022, 10:35:27 AM
That is interesting Chris I have never thought of listening to someone playing my Box ,  now where did I see my wife a few minutes ago  so I can put here in the same corner  ! 
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: Graham Spencer on November 11, 2022, 11:56:08 AM
Another interesting experiment is to get somebody else to play your Melodeon. It is surprising how different it sounds. Even if styles of play are similar.

I agree entirely - my Saltarelle sounds to me quite different from hearing it played by someone else, or on a recording - though in the latter case there are other factors at play besides pure acoustics (or psycho-acoustics?)
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: Winston Smith on November 11, 2022, 01:03:03 PM
"now where did I see my wife a few minutes ago  so I can put here in the same corner  !"

You're a better man than I am!
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: baz parkes on November 12, 2022, 11:50:51 AM
Another interesting experiment is to get somebody else to play your Melodeon. It is surprising how different it sounds. Even if styles of play are similar.

In my case it invariably sounds better...
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: Graham Spencer on November 12, 2022, 04:53:43 PM
 ;D
Another interesting experiment is to get somebody else to play your Melodeon. It is surprising how different it sounds. Even if styles of play are similar.

In my case it invariably sounds better...

 ;D
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: Peter Cane on November 15, 2022, 07:47:49 AM
Would I be correct in saying that the reason violin players add vibrato which can also vary in length on a single note is not purely to add volume which can have that effect to the human ear, but to add warmth, sweetness and feeling to the piece.
Also , played by a master, it can be so powerful as to force tears.
This is not to do with volume but the way the vibrato is played.
Volume on a violin I believe is achieved by placing the bow  nearer to the bridge whilst also applying downward pressure with the forefinger of the bowing arm.
A violin vibrato is essentially two different notes which can be varied in speed.
I think the idea with reeds in an accordion is to emulate that but of course by varying reed pitches.
Is it fair to say the more reeds together that play a single note tremolo / vibrato or not will be louder in volume?
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: Chris Ryall on November 15, 2022, 10:50:51 AM

   I think that vibrato is most poignant when done with a single voice. I generally simply waggle a middle finger. It works on both ends
   with a right-finger waggle … rather more subtle. Most commonly, it might be at the end of a song, although with practice you can do
   vibrato dynamically during play. As with violin it trends to get applied to the longer notes.

   With mutliple voices is in play, particularly MM you have to be a little more vicious. For example holding down a single button on the
   right and waggling your whole left hand. Arm works too of course, but is difficult to control.

   That is for volume vibrato. Frequency vibrato is rather more difficult. You have ¾ close-off a right end reed and then stress it using
   increased bellows pressure. The note will bend exactly as it would on a mouth harmonica. It is easier on the pull and on lower notes.
   Again, much easier with a single reed. With two voices going, they tend to stabilise each other.

         I suspect that this treatment might not be very healthy for the reeds? Perhaps one of our fettlers might advise on that …

  Another thing worth practising is “burying a note” at the end of a lyrical melody. that is simply a matter of bellows pressure, but with a
  bit of practice, you can fade a single note, or even a right-hand cord down from full volume … … to nothing.

  Final technique is the right end shove on a push note. generally anacrusis is done with your left arm on our instrument. But a quick
  bang with heel of right wrist into rt-end will briefly double the volume of the note in play. I don’t use it much myself, but it can be
  useful in eg Morris accompaniment (?)  :|glug
   
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: CAB on November 15, 2022, 11:08:01 AM

   I think that vibrato is most poignant when done with a single voice. I generally simply waggle a middle finger. It works on both ends
   with a right-finger waggle … rather more subtle. Most commonly, it might be at the end of a song, although with practice you can do
   vibrato dynamically during play. As with violin it trends to get applied to the longer notes.

   With mutliple voices is in play, particularly MM you have to be a little more vicious. For example holding down a single button on the
   right and waggling your whole left hand. Arm works too of course, but is difficult to control.

  Final technique is the right end shove on a push note. generally anacrusis is done with your left arm on our instrument. But a quick
  bang with heel of right wrist into rt-end will briefly double the volume of the note in play. I don’t use it much myself, but it can be
  useful in eg Morris accompaniment (?)  :|glug
   

A technique I saw Karen Tweed use to great effect in her Poozies days involved holding a right-hand chord while rapidly tapping the left hand end of the instrument, perhaps alternating finger and thumb or using several fingers in quick succession.  A kind of vibrato but gently percussive.
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: Chris Ryall on November 15, 2022, 11:28:05 AM


  I think that Karens left end weighs …  rather more than mine does 🤔
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: IanD on November 20, 2022, 02:44:51 PM
Would I be correct in saying that the reason violin players add vibrato which can also vary in length on a single note is not purely to add volume which can have that effect to the human ear, but to add warmth, sweetness and feeling to the piece.
Also , played by a master, it can be so powerful as to force tears.
This is not to do with volume but the way the vibrato is played.
Volume on a violin I believe is achieved by placing the bow  nearer to the bridge whilst also applying downward pressure with the forefinger of the bowing arm.
A violin vibrato is essentially two different notes which can be varied in speed.
I think the idea with reeds in an accordion is to emulate that but of course by varying reed pitches.
Is it fair to say the more reeds together that play a single note tremolo / vibrato or not will be louder in volume?

Of course it's true that vibrato/tremolo is not only used to make the sound "louder", it's also used to add tonal quaility and "feeling".

I found the research into both opera singers and violinists using around 7Hz when trying to project absolute maximum volume against orchestras more than 20 years ago, when I did a lot of investigation into the acoustics of musical instruments (I was designing a synthesizer using a new method of storing/generating waveforms) -- I can't remember where it was, quite possibly the JASA (Journal of the Acoustical Society of America) which is where most acoustical research was published, but this is not accessible for free, you need to go to the Britich Library (where I spent *many* hours) to read it.

Research also shows that the relative size of the peaks and dips in the amplitude (e.g. as two detuned noted beat together) has a strong effect on the apparent loudness, especailly when there is background noise (e.g. other instruments!). With two reeds (e.g. MM) the dips are quite deep as the two cancel each other out; with three reeds the gaps tend to get filled in as well as the pattern of sound being more complex, and again the ear tends to "lock on" to repetitive sounds better.

So with "wet" tuning (e.g. several Hz detuning) three reeds (e.g. MMM) can actually sound less "loud" to the ear than two reeds (even if they measure louder on an SPL meter), because the gaps tend to get filled in by the third reed. This is even more true if the third reed is a different pitch (e.g. LMM). Also L reeds tend to be quiter/less penetrating than M reeds.

With "dry" tuning (slow or no beats, which sounds quieter to the ear) this difference disappears or is reversed, 3-reed boxes sound *and measure* louder than 2-reed ones.

I've confirmed that all this is actually the case in real life, both by listening to melodeons with different reed setup and tuning, and also playing around with synthesized waveforms. If you want a "volume pecking order", I'd put it as follows (with all other things being equal such as size of box and type of reeds):

wet 2-reed MM -- "loudest" to the ear, wetter=louder up to about 7Hz beat rate
wet 3-reed MMM
wet 3-reed LMM
dry 3-reed MMM
dry 3-reed LMM
dry 2-reed MM
1-reed M
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: Chris Ryall on November 21, 2022, 09:08:53 AM

   Thanks Ian. That was masterful
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: rileycat on November 21, 2022, 10:05:00 AM
This is no more than a passing observation, but I've noticed in sessions, on a good few occasions, how 'penetrating' the sound of a Castagnari Lilly can be, despite its single reed treble.  Also, back in my morrissing days, in a crowded street with a band of melodeons, I walked away to get refreshment and, as the music faded with distance, I was surprised that the only instrument I could clearly hear (apart from a drum!) was the solitary anglo concertina - single reeds again.  Just musing!.
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: Anahata on November 21, 2022, 11:00:52 AM
This is no more than a passing observation, but I've noticed in sessions, on a good few occasions, how 'penetrating' the sound off a Castagnari Lilly can be, despite its single reed treble.  Also, back in my morrissing days, in a crowded street with a band of melodeons, I walked away to get refreshment and, as the music faded with distance, I was surprised that the only instrument I could clearly hear (apart from a drum!) was the solitary anglo concertina - single reeds again.  Just musing!.

Note IanD said "(with all other things being equal such as size of box and type of reeds)"
Both the instruments you mention have low cross sectional bellows area which translates into high air pressure, and are built with reeds mounted flat instead of on blocks, which makes a far brighter sound.
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: rileycat on November 21, 2022, 01:02:29 PM
Thanks, Anahata  -  as I said, 'just musing' not trying to sidestep any of IanD's wisdom. I appreciate the explanation, as I've often wondered why the Lilly seems so loud.
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: Chris Ryall on November 21, 2022, 01:40:49 PM

  My old Lilly could certainly “cut a crowd” as I used to say.

   Most of our conversation has been about continuous notes. there is also “attack”, or anacrusis. Both the little Lily and a concertina get their air pukse directly from the bellows, ie straight on. In a larger instrument in the reed chambers act I think 🤔 as a sort of clutch, or sump (in automotive terms) on any bellows dynamics. There are also real pallet effects unless they are cantilevered (let’s not go there)!

  Or is there more to instrument “brightness” than that, too?  We use K-space amplitude/frequency manipulations in Medical MRI too (every course starts with a Physics lecture)!  In imaging rapid spacial change => an increase in high frequency harmonics. Essentially to “define the edge” of the formant. I believe it’s “the same” with sound?
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: IanD on November 21, 2022, 10:31:17 PM
Thanks, Anahata  -  as I said, 'just musing' not trying to sidestep any of IanD's wisdom. I appreciate the explanation, as I've often wondered why the Lilly seems so loud.

For the reasons Anahata said, you can really cane those Lilly reeds -- which is also why they can be prone to breaking when played hard, the small bellows make it easy to generate far more air pressure than a bigger box.

I've heard them being played loudly for Morris outdoors, and winced because I can hear the reeds dropping in pitch when the bellows are really being squeezed... :-(
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: Matt T on November 22, 2022, 09:27:20 AM
I've heard them being played loudly for Morris outdoors, and winced because I can hear the reeds dropping in pitch when the bellows are really being squeezed... :-(

Can you take it as far as bending down a full semitone intentionally?

Matt
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: Chris Ryall on November 22, 2022, 01:30:24 PM

   Just tested (using the tuner Rees recommended to me 🙂) which says …

   Single voice the pull A3 and G2 low reeds on my vdA rt end bend down to G#3 and A#2 respectively, both fairly easily 😎

   There’s a big octave effect in upper half keyboard.  Pull A3 is … OK bending by -45 cents, can reach -50, but isn’t stable there.
Title: Re: volume/loudness of reeds
Post by: Matt T on November 23, 2022, 09:52:04 AM

   Just tested (using the tuner Rees recommended to me 🙂) which says …

   Single voice the pull A3 and G2 low reeds on my vdA rt end bend down to G#3 and A#2 respectively, both fairly easily 😎

   There’s a big octave effect in upper half keyboard.  Pull A3 is … OK bending by -45 cents, can reach -50, but isn’t stable there.

Thanks, interesting!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal