Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Gromit on November 09, 2022, 11:26:06 AM
-
B/C player mainly Irish tunes - any tips / excercises for playing faster?
-
Yes, play for dancers.
-
In terms of the physical aspects of playing - leaving aside any mental considerations - I see only two things that might be stopping you from playing fast.
1. fingering technique
2. bellows technique
Both are equally important IMO. Where is the obstacle for you? Care to describe how you experience the problem?
-
Play phrases instead of notes?
-
Good comments already !
It is said that slow practice is the ticket, but one must push the tempo occasionally to identify the problems to be worked out slowly. For example, an assumed 'best' fingering at 80-90 beats per minute may turn out to be not so great at faster speeds. Trial and error is your friend.
If a tune is played too fast for me at a session or dance, I find I can sometimes join in by playing at first only a few notes here and there, and build from that, trying to add more notes at each repeat until I have either a rough sketch, a simplified version or (with luck) the whole thing. Trial and error on the go.
-
take a look at "strum machine"...lots of irish tunes on there and you can create your own with different instruments and rhythms.....it has function where you can set it to raise the bpm after each time through. Pretty cool app and sounds are decent if you run it from your computer into a powered speaker...if you use the beta version it can do do jigs and reels.
-
I sometimes play against a metronome - gradually speeding it up day by day. My problem has always been keeping the rhythm and not rushing difficult phrases. Working out which are the problem bits and focussing on those has been my strategy.
My wife (who has been learning the fiddle - and also working on classical pieces for a few years) were discussing the challenges of moving from beginners and 'steady speed' sessions to full speed the other day. Never easy no matter the instrument !
As an aside my wife's teacher - and friends who play in top orchestras pointed out 'you don't have to always play all the notes...'
Julian
-
I think John Kirkpatrick's advice to practice slowly with an exaggerated staccato touch may be useful here, especially if the problem when trying to play faster is the that notes come out unevenly. It helps to embed rhythmic accuracy in your muscle memory, or something like that.
I must admit that when I saw the thread title I thought it meant speeding up was the problem when you were trying to keep a steady tempo. Theo's answer "play for dancers" is equally appropriate for that too!
'you don't have to always play all the notes...'
Very true!
-
You may find Jon Antonsson's stuff useful. He has a website at https://www.tunesandtools.com/ (https://www.tunesandtools.com/) with bodhran playing reel, jig and slip jig rhythms at various speeds. It's the Irish eqivalent of a metronome. Useful for playing along to and you can challenge yourself with steadily faster tempos.
There are Youtube clips of the same thing: https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=bodhran+metronome (https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=bodhran+metronome)
Someone else has done a hornpipe one here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fpeAiL6AaH0 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fpeAiL6AaH0)
The advantage of Youtube is that you have an extra way of changing the speed if you want to.
Another vote for playing for dancers, by the way, though it can be dispiriting, depending on the type of dance. I thought my playing was plenty fast enough as I could happily play in Irish sessions. Then I encountered Irish set dancing. Blistering!
-
......1. fingering technique
2. bellows technique
Both are equally important IMO. Where is the obstacle for you? Care to describe how you experience the problem?
Thanks Steve, I think it's fingering technique - Some tunes I’m ok with others not so much
I can play at speed on the flute (which is my main instrument). On the box there are some tunes I’m ok with others not so much.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JvNn5c18wvE
Tunes in the above clip (which I tune down to D) - playing along with these I can just manage Cooley's at 85% but Wise maid about 75%. Slower if playing them on my own. Can you suggest any excercises?
Yes, play for dancers
I occasionally play for ceilidh dancers but they don’t dance fast enough! (:) I don't know any step dancers at least not good ones
Play phrases instead of notes?
If you mean miss out some notes I think at speed it’s harder do that than try play them all. (:)
You may find Jon Antonsson's stuff useful
Thanks I know his site, he's tasty on the flute. I prefer downloading and playing with tunes at reduced & then increased speeds rather than a metronome.
Thanks folks
-
Play phrases instead of notes?
If you mean miss out some notes I think at speed it’s harder do that than try play them all. (:
No, I mean focus on the (quantum) flow of groups of notes rather than a string of individual notes. Dealing in phrases helps sort out fingering and affords "check points"...
-
Very interesting , at one time I was playing Clarinet and went for lessons with a first Clarinet in one of the top London based orchestras . I showed him a passage that I was having problems with , his first response was , well of course you don't want to be bothered playing all those notes , we never do !! it was quite a revelation for me . However for me with the Melodeon I agree with Anahata. Slowly until you get it correct !
-
No, I mean focus on the (quantum) flow of groups of notes rather than a string of individual notes. Dealing in phrases helps sort out fingering and affords "check points"
If I understand you I'm doing that already - when learning a tune, (which is usually by ear) I tackle it in phrases with a jig say 2 bars at a time. Is that what you mean?
-
Are you planning to push, push, your local session to play faster and faster? In which case my advice is … unsuitable for this forum.
If it’s a matter of keeping up, you could switch to an English or Anglo-French group. Fluidity and facility will develop naturally, in time.
Otherwise, just miss notes out! Again, facility will come. We’ve all been there … 🙂
-
No, I mean focus on the (quantum) flow of groups of notes rather than a string of individual notes. Dealing in phrases helps sort out fingering and affords "check points"
If I understand you I'm doing that already - when learning a tune, (which is usually by ear) I tackle it in phrases with a jig say 2 bars at a time. Is that what you mean?
Not exactly. I'm talking about musical phrases, not bars. Bars and notes belong more to the notation than the music. Maybe think of it as focusing on the words rather than the spelling?
I liked Anahatas citing John Kirkpatrick re stacatto touch. Playing stacatto lightens the touch as well as spending less time/note, ergo affording more speed by diminishing time spent in muscular effort/digital manipulation.
-
Thanks for the extra info Gromit. I think I might have had more useful tips if you had said that bellows were the problem. (:)
As far as fingering goes, if you are using four fingers, I'd say drop the little finger immediately and use only three. And then, in tricky passages, try using just two. (If you watch the great Derek Hickey - who can play as fast as anyone - closely you will see that he is using only index and middle fingers a lot of the time.) With fewer fingers, you can get around remarkably quickly and surefootedly, and with just two, sometimes the unplayable can become easy.
I'll have a go at those two tunes B/C style later and see if anything strikes me about the fingering, but since it's not my main system, my thoughts might be of limited value (er, useless).
I would not heed any advice about dropping notes to help you play faster. Dropping notes from Irish tunes will most likely denature them completely. You often hear beginners doing this in certain passages, such as dropping the pedal note in a "rocking pedal" figure. It kills the tunes stone dead.
What about ornaments? Are you using many? I occasionally hear people say that they cannot fit their ornaments in when playing at speed. This is something I can't generally relate to. You know as a flute player that producing characteristic ornaments on that instrument involves tiny finger movements. You need to have them working so fast and so effortlessly that they won't be what slows you down. I think the same is true of the box, and I have worked on the kinds of ornaments I do so that they are pretty damn fast and pretty effortless, even if I'm not in the Damien Mullane league (unfortunately ;) ). (Mind you, I don't do shovelfuls of 5-note rolls. Nor do Damien M, Dermot B or Sharon S. If you do, consider something more ergonomic...).
Exercises? I think that taking tricky phrases separately, and looking at every different way of fingering them, might help. And once you have something that works, play them hundreds and hundreds of times at gradually increasing tempi, why not.
And ornaments, if they are part of the problem: play them thousands and thousands of times while you watch the telly or listen to a podcast or whatever.
I still think that bellows control is absolutely key to playing this music fast. Let me know if you want me to start a rant on that subject. :|glug
PS I cannot see how practising staccato playing will improve your Irish reels. It certainly hasn't been necessary to do so in my experience, and I am continually harping on at a student of mine to play less staccato.
-
Break the tune up in chunks. FInd out where the fingering is not smooth. Try out simpler fingerings. And in the end, what helped me was learning a lot more reels instead of obsessing about getting a few up to speed. Maybe, it is also a question of fully committing when playing them at high speed. There is no room for second-guessing yourself. I think thats why its easier to play along in a session at a greater speed. It's easier to relax and stop thinking.ymmv
-
Thanks Steve, I've taken your advice from previous poats and stopped using my little finger and I'm sliding more. I've seen some D. Hickey videos but not noticed his fingering - will check him out and try 2 fingers.
I agree about not dropping notes.
I use rolls, cuts and taps as I do on the flute and Ive got them up to a good speed on the box - I think it's fingering I've got to work on.
I don't notice any problems with bellows control but I'd be interested to hear your rant (:)
I agree about the staccato playing, surely Irish trad is mainly about smooth flowing notes.
-
I find where I regularly trip up on the same phrase, it is typically because I'm not being consistent with fingering. So the brain/fingers are making their own choice. And it is often the fingering of a previous bar which is the root cause of that uncertainty. Working through the fingering and then consistent slow practice will sort it out.
I should add this is playing G/C and D/G styles, not B/C ITM, so may not be as relevant.
-
Andy, I think your comment is relevant to anyone regardless of the system they are playing.
BUT - hello Gromit - having experimented with these two tunes last night, I think that the second one (The Wise Maid) in particular is a challenging prospect on B/C. In fact I reckon it would be hard to come up with a better example in the Irish tradition of what makes playing in D on a B/C so special.
It's a busy enough tune on the C#/D, but on B/C the penalty for less bellows movement in the key of D, i.e. a great deal more finger agility, is demonstrated very convincingly. I like experimenting with B/C style but for me to get that tune up to a good tempo reliably would require a LOT of sustained effort. I tried following my own advice of sticking to 2 fingers and I found it helps in certain bits, but there are others where not using 3 is a hindrance. So I can only wish you good luck. :(
Cooley's Reel raises other questions for me, particularly whether you should take the easier route and play it on the draw as much as possible, eschewing the possibility of using the E bass/chord pair, or bite the bullet and make heavy use of the push Bs and push Es so that you can play the basses.
I think there are certain tunes that are easier on one system than the other, and it's perhaps not surprising that this pair (Cooleys and The Wise Maid) are associated with press-and-draw players, including Joe Cooley, and Paul Brock on the recording you linked to, which is a tribute after all to the aforementioned Joe.
-
Thanks for the info Steve - as you say the Wise Maid is a tricky tune on the box especially the B part. I've really worked on that and as I said can get up to 75% of the speed that Paul Brock is playing but it's taken a long time and I need to play it regularly.