Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Irian Greenleaf on November 16, 2022, 09:00:20 PM

Title: Recommended beginners' books for irish chromatic melodeon?
Post by: Irian Greenleaf on November 16, 2022, 09:00:20 PM
Hi, I'm very much starting out, and would really appreciate recommendations for good books on learning irish folk technique.

I have an "interesting" right hand but I'm confident it can do the things. I'm hoping to get hold of a Sandpiper Stint or Dunlin II (a lightweight instrument is vital). I'm very familiar with the music (and good at picking up tunes by ear, I play whistle) so I have a head start here.
Title: Re: Recommended beginners' books for irish chromatic melodeon?
Post by: Stiamh on November 16, 2022, 09:37:06 PM
Are you planning to get a B/C box? If so, there are some teaching books and DVDs out there - Damien Connolly has a well-thought-out book, and John Williams made a DVD decades ago.

If you haven't made up your mind which system to get, I'd advise you, as an adult starter and a whistle player, to go for a C#/D box instead of B/C. I think you will find it far more intuitive, because the D row equates to the natural scale of your whistle. Worked for me, anyway. The system is just as capable as B/C for your normal trad repertoire, although certain keys will be a tad easier on one rather than the other.

The problem with that choice is that there are no books or DVDs that I know of about the C#/D system. There are a few videos on YouTube - I have made a few myself, of variable quality.  ;)

However there are quite a few excellent players who can give you online lessons via Zoom or similar. Let us know what kind of box you get and I and others can make suggestions.
Title: Re: Recommended beginners' books for irish chromatic melodeon?
Post by: Irian Greenleaf on November 16, 2022, 11:36:00 PM
Thanks - I'm most likely to go for a Sandpiper Dunlin II in B/C, for reasons of the music I'll be wanting to play that's not irish tunes (as well as the tunes that are), and because of minimal weight for a 23 button instrument.
Title: Re: Recommended beginners' books for irish chromatic melodeon?
Post by: mselic on November 17, 2022, 02:16:20 AM
Steve (Stiamh) is being modest - his YouTube instructional videos for C#/D are excellent : )

Title: Re: Recommended beginners' books for irish chromatic melodeon?
Post by: Gromit on November 17, 2022, 08:29:23 AM
I've used the Damien Connolly book with DVD and the John Williams DVD and found them both useful. If I was starting out now I'd consider C#/D as most of the players I like seem to play that system.

Like you the box was a second instrument for me, main instrument being "Irish' flute & whistle. I didn't find the fingering on the flute / whistle much help with the box as the way you use your fingers is completely different.

"interesting" right hand - ?
Title: Re: Recommended beginners' books for irish chromatic melodeon?
Post by: JohnS on November 17, 2022, 09:19:19 AM
I started out with a B/C Sandpiper.  It played ok but the quality of the reeds wasn't great and when I eventually had cause to strip out the reeds I discovered that the reed blocks were very poorly constructed.  You might want to consider Martin Quinn's wooden Lisheen model instead, TAM reeds and Martin has a very good reputation.
https://www.martinquinnaccordion.com/Accordions/student-accordions

I moved on fairly swifly to a Castagnari Ciacy.  After seven years of learning B/C I then supplemented that with a C#/D box.  I was struggling with 10-15% of the repertoire but switching those tunes to C#/D made them a whole lot easier.

For learning material here is something to consider:
https://irishbuttonaccordionlessons.com/starter-course-info/
Title: Re: Recommended beginners' books for irish chromatic melodeon?
Post by: Irian Greenleaf on November 17, 2022, 10:36:00 AM
The Martin Quinn box looks great, but I'm in the UK so the VAT and carriage takes it over my budget (it'll come out at something like £1175).

As for my mutant hand, my right hand is smaller than my left and missing a few muscles but is very fast and up to the job (I've tried one out). And I've played a wide variety of different instruments, so I'm confident I can learn yet another new fingering system.

I can see how a C/C# C#/D box would effectively be the same as a B/C with 23 buttons when it came to range, since tunes I'll be playing don't need to go below low C anyway - but C/C# C#/D seem a lot rarer over here for affordable instruments. I'll have to consult my savings!
Title: Re: Recommended beginners' books for irish chromatic melodeon?
Post by: JohnS on November 17, 2022, 10:54:27 AM
Ok, in which case yes the Sandpiper boxes would get you up and running.

The distinction between B/C and C#/D (C/C# is something else entirely) isn't to do with range but with how easy they are to play in the various keys, determined by how much you have to play across the rows.  Very broadly:
2 or 3 sharps - C#/D easier
1 sharp - 50/50 between the two
no sharps or 1 flat  - B/C easier.

Title: Re: Recommended beginners' books for irish chromatic melodeon?
Post by: Irian Greenleaf on November 17, 2022, 11:05:21 AM
Aye, the C/C# thing was a brain typo on my part, I meant C#/D.
Title: Re: Recommended beginners' books for irish chromatic melodeon?
Post by: Irian Greenleaf on November 17, 2022, 11:19:39 AM
Also does anyone have experience of this McNeela (http://"https://mcneelamusic.com/accordions/new-mcneela-wooden-b-c-accordion/") instrument?
Title: Re: Recommended beginners' books for irish chromatic melodeon?
Post by: Stiamh on November 17, 2022, 01:00:32 PM
I couldn't make your link work. This seems to be the box in question (https://mcneelamusic.com/accordions/new-mcneela-wooden-b-c-accordion/).

I haven't any experience of any of the new models discussed. But if light weight, fast response, supple bellows and general playability are important, I reckon you couldn't do much better than a well-set-up second-hand Hohner Double Ray. (Edit: as long as you can deal with the characteristic mechanical noise - most can 🙂.)

In St Ives you have Mike Rowbotham, who specializes in fixing up old Hohners, and who could certainly provide you with a suitable instrument, perhaps well within your budget. He is a member here. (Edit: Mike's website (http://www.michaelrowbotham.eclipse.co.uk), or you can find him in the members section here as "Microbot".)

Supple bellows are extremely important, in my view, for Irish-style playing. Beginners tend to fixate on right-hand fingering, but using the bellows efficiently is not only essential for questions of strain and fatigue, but for being able to play fluently.   
Title: Re: Recommended beginners' books for irish chromatic melodeon?
Post by: Irian Greenleaf on November 17, 2022, 01:58:17 PM
Thanks! I've dropped him a message. Weight is definitely a key factor for me - the Sandpiper Stint is under 2kg and that's a goal - the Dunlin II is heavier (two-voiced, two extra buttons) but still only 2.6kg I think.
Title: Re: Recommended beginners' books for irish chromatic melodeon?
Post by: tirpous on November 17, 2022, 02:26:59 PM
See this recent thread about McNeela : http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=28300.msg339260#msg339260 (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=28300.msg339260#msg339260)
Title: Re: Recommended beginners' books for irish chromatic melodeon?
Post by: Irian Greenleaf on November 17, 2022, 02:35:44 PM
Thanks, I've now ruled out pretty much everything but the Sandpiper and maybe Hohner, due to weight issues and other stuff.

Unless there's a really light Hohner I'll probably go for the Sandpiper Stint in the end, which is only 1.9kg.
Title: Re: Recommended beginners' books for irish chromatic melodeon?
Post by: Arnold on November 17, 2022, 06:55:11 PM
Thanks - I'm most likely to go for a Sandpiper Dunlin II in B/C, for reasons of the music I'll be wanting to play that's not irish tunes (as well as the tunes that are), and because of minimal weight for a 23 button instrument.

Hi, just curious to know what the music you want to play that isn’t Irish tunes is?..
Title: Re: Recommended beginners' books for irish chromatic melodeon?
Post by: Irian Greenleaf on November 17, 2022, 09:18:39 PM
Heh, actually it's Bach!

Also I've changed my plans and am almost certainly going for the Sandpiper Stint for now, as it's really light and that's most important. Unless it turns out the Hohners are not much heavier. I need to just learn to play first!
Title: Re: Recommended beginners' books for irish chromatic melodeon?
Post by: Arnold on November 17, 2022, 10:07:31 PM
Brilliant! I play baroque melodica   8) I call it a poor man’s oboe  :D
Title: Re: Recommended beginners' books for irish chromatic melodeon?
Post by: Arnold on November 17, 2022, 11:17:08 PM
Sure you don’t want C#D though? Would seem to fit nicely with baroque flute repertoire for example mainly on D row, but then basing yourself on C# row for A=416hz baroque tuning… C#D seems to be more specialist tuning ergo more expensive however… BC double rays seem fairly common at a reasonable price, less likely to be hoarded by MAD sufferers perhaps (maybe since they are not really Melodeons but rather accordions lol..)
Title: Re: Recommended beginners' books for irish chromatic melodeon?
Post by: mselic on November 18, 2022, 06:16:22 AM
I once owned a Sandpiper C#/D. It was not nearly as good a box as a well set-up Hohner.
Title: Re: Recommended beginners' books for irish chromatic melodeon?
Post by: Irian Greenleaf on November 18, 2022, 02:17:39 PM
Well, I've been very lucky and found a pre-owned Saltarelle Le Bouëbe Irish B/C instrument at a good price. I'm just sorting all that out with the owner, I hope it'll be with me next week.

I will need to get it retuned, but otherwise all is good.
Title: Re: Recommended beginners' books for irish chromatic melodeon?
Post by: mselic on November 18, 2022, 04:02:07 PM
Well, I've been very lucky and found a pre-owned Saltarelle Le Bouëbe Irish B/C instrument at a good price. I'm just sorting all that out with the owner, I hope it'll be with me next week.

I will need to get it retuned, but otherwise all is good.

Excellent! Congratulations! Best case scenario ;)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal