Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: PeterBRC on November 17, 2022, 10:28:49 PM

Title: good tunes for air button practice
Post by: PeterBRC on November 17, 2022, 10:28:49 PM
I am finding the use of air button difficult to get to grips with , I tend to make a grab for the air and ofter a its feels rather snatched and not smooth , also between notes it sounds far too hurried . Has anyone a good tune to get to grips with this problem , one that I could practice   Thanks
Title: Re: good tunes for air button practice
Post by: The Oul' Boy on November 17, 2022, 10:36:56 PM
Pick a simple tune you know already (I've always found Donkey Riding to be a good tune for trying out new techniques without having to worry about remembering the tune) and rather than looking for gaps to grab air (though you'll have to do that sometimes too), try just using the air button whilst playing notes so that the bellows close or open more quickly than normal (you need to push or pull harder to keep the note steady when you do this). It takes a bit of practice, but once you get it, you can get air much more easily than waiting for a gap, and indeed will find yourself using the air button not just to get or lose air but to constantly adjust the bellows position, often without thinking about it.
Title: Re: good tunes for air button practice
Post by: Rick St. John on November 17, 2022, 10:48:25 PM
The tune that forced me to get to grips with the air button was "Vandals of Hammerwich"
Title: Re: good tunes for air button practice
Post by: Phil Howard on November 18, 2022, 07:11:38 AM
The tune that forced me to get to grips with the air button was "Vandals of Hammerwich"
I was about to say something similar. Especially if played properly loud, and you play the full semibreve d in bar four instead of substituting a crotchet run down d-c-A-F#.
Title: Re: good tunes for air button practice
Post by: Lester on November 18, 2022, 08:18:28 AM
When you think you have mastered the air button try Ghost Riders in the Sky (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7ORDbw0oXjs)
Title: Re: good tunes for air button practice
Post by: Theo on November 18, 2022, 08:41:51 AM
“make a grab fir the air” — I wonder if you have to move your hand to get to the air button?  Try to find a way of holding the box that allows you to place your left hand so that the yiu need the least movement of the thumb only to operate the air valve.  What works for you depends a bit on the shape of your hands, but for most people it helps to have the instrument tilted away slightly so the top is further from your body.  This allows your left forearm to be nearer to 90 degrees to the LH strap.  This should help to get your fingers to reach the buttons at the same time as the thumb rests on the air button.
Title: Re: good tunes for air button practice
Post by: Sharon on November 18, 2022, 10:00:08 AM
I don’t know  how long you’ve been playing but I found the air button tricky to get to grips with when I started. You will probably find it gets easier purely with time (as long as you play / practice regularly ;D ) as you get more used to the instrument, at least that was my experience. I did do some specific air button practice (some exercises but I can’t remember them - if I do I’ll post them up) but mostly I just worked on different tunes I liked and gradually I found I was using it more. I have the side of my thumb on the air button pretty much all the time (mine is a wedge style, I can’t get on with the sliding ones at all) and I use it loads now without even thinking about it much. I think it’s like any new physical skill, you just need to keep doing it and trust the process but also be mindful of what’s not working / where you might be able to improve. You’ll get there!
Title: Re: good tunes for air button practice
Post by: PeterBRC on November 18, 2022, 10:48:30 AM
Thanks very much for that , all very helpful indeed ,no shortcuts just practice !
Title: Re: good tunes for air button practice
Post by: PeterBRC on November 18, 2022, 10:51:27 AM
people it helps to have the instrument tilted away slightly so the top is further from your body.  This allows your left forearm to be nearer to 90 degrees to the LH strap.  This should help to get your fingers to reach the buttons at the same time as the thumb rests on the air button.
That is well worth a try , I think the problem is often using bass buttons at the same time without a great gush of sound !
Title: Re: good tunes for air button practice
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on November 18, 2022, 10:55:20 AM
I'm like Sharon, having a wedge type air button and rest the side of my thumb on it. This means it's constantly gently feathered rather than huge gulps of air.

Yes, practice is the answer!
It is one of those 'gateway' things on a melodeon. It takes time but persistence means one day it's happening rather than thinking about it.
Title: Re: good tunes for air button practice
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on November 18, 2022, 11:06:42 AM
Donkey Riding is a good suggestion. Simple tunes offer all sorts of learning opportunities when you get to grips with them. You can try all sorts of things out...double stopped harmonies, variations and bellows control (of which air control  is a big part)without having to worry to much about getting the melody right.

I learned a lot through playing Johnny Todd (aka Z Cars), another simple tune with more push notes than pull, in the A part. When I first learned the tune I was desperately pulling harder on the notes in that direction. I  realised, quite suddenly, that if  I rode the air button on the pull notes I could keep air in the bellows. I played the tune a lot before this happened. The notes have to be automatic before your brain releases a sector to work on how you're playing rather than what you're playing.

Riding the air button soon got to be a habit to the point where it no longer took a concious effort. 

One thing I did discover was that  I used the fleshy pad at the base of my thumb, rather than the thumb itself.  I was Just, sort of, squeezing the button, rather than levering it with the first joint. That was something that happened withoiut concious thought. I just found I was doing it. 

That was on a Hohner. When I got a box with a wedge I had to go climb the learning curve again, but it went much quicker and the technique ended up pretty similar.
Title: Re: good tunes for air button practice
Post by: PeterBRC on November 18, 2022, 12:06:06 PM
Once again thanks to all for the very helpful suggestions which all make good sense . I never knew ZCars was called Johnny Todd  but I can manage that and Donkey Riding with out to much brain power , I do love the idea of the "your brain releases a sector to work on how you're playing "  yes I can see that but I am not quite there yet as memory of tunes and fingering rows seems to engage at least 85% of what I have upstairs !     Luckily I enjoy practice but my domestic goddess doesn't appreciate too much repetition in her ears !  . But I do tell her it is going to be worth the wait !!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal