Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: mselic on December 01, 2022, 05:25:24 AM
-
A recent discussion about thirds on the bass end got me wondering - has anyone ever replaced the thirds with another root note in a different (I'm thinking lower) octave?
-
Yep, I've replaced 3rds with lower or higher root notes numerous times - sometimes because someone asked me to, most often to get 'open' chords on E/A (B/C) or A/E (C#/D) boxes.
Choice of octave depends on if it's a 'shared' reed, what the other notes in the chord are (above vs. below), and to best match other chords.
I've also often replaced reeds on Paolo Sopranis chords with same note an octave higher, as some of them (F# in a D-chord) sounded too low for my taste. I generally like the idea that Hohner uses, where all chord reeds are within the same range - meaning that they have 'similar' sounds despite some being root lowest, others having 5th or 3rd lowest. When talking to other box players about this, I've found that we all have different tastes and opinions - as expected:-)
-
Alternative: I once had an old Hohner Club C/F in which the thirds had been replaced by a reed doubling the fifth.
-
I have a club VII that shares reeds. There's two root reeds shared in both the bass and chord and the 3rd and 5th added to make the chord. I replaced all the 3rds with a second 5th either an octave below or above the existing 5th.
So my chords are 2 roots and octave apart and 2 5ths an octave apart.
For a tiny box (Liliput sized reeds) it packs a lot of volume.
-
A recent discussion about thirds on the bass end got me wondering - has anyone ever replaced the thirds with another root note in a different (I'm thinking lower) octave?
Is that not the effect you get on a high end box with multiple 'stops' when you take the Bass 'low' reed out and the chord block 1/3rds, to get the Bass upper octave reed sounding with the 1/3'rd less chord ?