Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: BamaBino on December 02, 2022, 07:40:32 PM

Title: Is a Castagnari Giordy good choice for trying DG?
Post by: BamaBino on December 02, 2022, 07:40:32 PM
Hello,

Is a Castagnari Giordy a good choice for leanring/trying DG?

Or would it be better pay $1k more for bigger box?

Thanks
Title: Re: Is a Castagnari Giordy good choice for trying DG?
Post by: Lester on December 02, 2022, 07:44:44 PM
I would recommend a decently refurbed Hohner Erica/Pokerwork, available in the UK for <£600. It will be worth what you paid for it if you decide to sell it later whereas posher boxes (in my experience) do lose value due to their initial high price.
Title: Re: Is a Castagnari Giordy good choice for trying DG?
Post by: malcolmbebb on December 02, 2022, 08:26:42 PM
My Giordy is my favourite box but I wouldn't recommend it for your purpose. I would go for a more "standard" box, and not new if you are trying it out.
Title: Re: Is a Castagnari Giordy good choice for trying DG?
Post by: heartshaped1 on December 02, 2022, 08:56:19 PM
I agree with Lester and Malcolm. I teach absolute beginners and I wouldn’t recommend a Giordy as a starting box. You’d be better off with a few more buttons, for one, but the main thing for me is that the bellows are small and can take some controlling - ‘standard’ bellows will be way more forgiving for someone trying to learn what to do with them!

Vicky

Title: Re: Is a Castagnari Giordy good choice for trying DG?
Post by: BamaBino on December 02, 2022, 10:45:10 PM
I agree with Lester and Malcolm. I teach absolute beginners and I wouldn’t recommend a Giordy as a starting box. You’d be better off with a few more buttons, for one, but the main thing for me is that the bellows are small and can take some controlling - ‘standard’ bellows will be way more forgiving for someone trying to learn what to do with them!

Vicky

Thank you. That answers my question.
Title: Re: Is a Castagnari Giordy good choice for trying DG?
Post by: pete /acorn on December 02, 2022, 11:52:34 PM
I get enquiries from customer re buying a Gordy as a starter box and actually refuse to sell them one.

At the moment I have several instruments in stock which would be ideal for starters,Hohner Poker works and Erica's,Castagnari Studio,s, Saltarrelle Le Bouebe,to name but a few,all serviced with 12 months warranty.
Ful details on web site shortly.
Title: Re: Is a Castagnari Giordy good choice for trying DG?
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 03, 2022, 08:22:03 AM

   I started on a Hohner and switched to a Casta 6 months later when I realised that I’d “found my instrument”

   The Pokerwork was new, a birthday present so we lost about £100 on it at 1986 prices. I’d guess half that sort of discount if you get a refurbished pre-loved one and can sell on at that rate of progression. Keep the receipt.  Regard it as hedging your bet.

   Another scheme would be to borrow one. I’ve lent out twice … for about ± a year in my own journey, both to young musicians. And that was the Casta I’d bought 36 years ago!  Good melodeons last well.
Title: Re: Is a Castagnari Giordy good choice for trying DG?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on December 03, 2022, 08:53:43 AM
Unless money is really no object to you, I wouldn't recommend rushing out and buying the best posh box you can afford. Learn to play on something more humble first. That way, when you do commit to something classy, you will have a better understnding of what you are buying and why you are buying it. People often say that a well set up Hohner two row makes the best starter box and they're right. The odd thing about them, though, is that they can stay being your favourite boxes for life.

SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal