Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: juker on November 08, 2009, 12:05:51 AM

Title: Accordion Repairs Made Easy by John Reuther
Post by: juker on November 08, 2009, 12:05:51 AM
'Accordion Repairs Made Easy'
by John Reuther

Does anyone know if this book is useful for button accordion repairs and maintenance?
Title: Re: Accordion Repairs Made Easy by John Reuther
Post by: RGF on November 08, 2009, 03:44:01 AM
I found it so.  I bought a copy after I'd once again picked up the PA and became brave enough to venture inside. But much of the guts of it is the same: reedblocks and reeds, waxing, valving, tuning, pallets, etc. Gave me the courage, then, to delve into my first button box repairs. Don't think you can go too far wrong with this one....good basic information, IMO.

Bob
Title: Re: Accordion Repairs Made Easy by John Reuther
Post by: juker on November 08, 2009, 03:46:45 AM
Thanks for that Bob. It might make a good christmas pressie for my husband (so he can maintain my instruments  ;D)
Title: Re: Accordion Repairs Made Easy by John Reuther
Post by: tjsmithdog5 on November 08, 2009, 04:19:01 AM
I have had this book for several years. Although it was clearly written with the repair of piano accordions in mind, the book is useful for anyone who plays an instrument with bellows, reeds and keyboards.

Here are the main chapter headings, along with the pages they cover so you can get some idea of emphasis:

Air Leaks--Bellows repairs,  pages 3-5
Air Leaks Other than From the Bellows, 5-10
Treble Keyboard Repairs, 10-16
Grill Fitting and Adjustment, 17-18
Special Methods for Removing Tight Axles, 18-21
Special Types of Keyboards, 22-28
Bass Keyboard Mechanisms, 29-41
Switches, 42-48
Reeds, 49-61
Accordion Amplifiers, 62-63
Accordion Alteration and Modification, 63-73
Concertina Repairs, 79-80

I used this book as a guide for replacing the leathers (valves) in an 80-bass Ebay PA, and I found it to have all the information I needed to do that job.
Title: Re: Accordion Repairs Made Easy by John Reuther
Post by: graememackay on November 08, 2009, 10:51:26 AM
where can I get one?
Title: Re: Accordion Repairs Made Easy by John Reuther
Post by: Theo on November 08, 2009, 11:09:59 AM
Reprints appear on ebay from time to time.  Here (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Accordion-Repairs-Book-How-to-repair-any-part_W0QQitemZ270481814305) is an example

If you want a reference book, that is also more up to date, and includes button and piano models the The Ins and Outs of the Accordion (http://www.musicforaccordion.com/Boutique/inform/benetoux/index.htm) by Thierry Benetoux is very comprehensive
Title: Re: Accordion Repairs Made Easy by John Reuther
Post by: juker on November 08, 2009, 11:20:47 AM
Thanks Theo - definitely buying a repair book, it is just a matter of getting the right one.
Title: Re: Accordion Repairs Made Easy by John Reuther
Post by: TomB-R on November 08, 2009, 01:17:15 PM
IMHO......
Having got both, I wouldn't want to spend money on either!
They both seem to belong to the "old-school" form of "how to" books that somehow manage to avoid telling you anything particularly useful!

I'd save the money and spend the time online. The information is here, and out there, if you hunt for it.

(Send me a PM if you'd like my copy at a good price, though I won't be able to reply before Thursday.)
Title: Re: Accordion Repairs Made Easy by John Reuther
Post by: graememackay on November 08, 2009, 05:23:36 PM
I nearly bought one online this afternoon but the website was slow and my patience ran out.

I wouldn't mind having something like these books but as TomB-R says the info is all online somewhere so why should I shell out any money.  On the other hand, a proffesional published book should be a more reliable source of info than some bloke writing in a blog.

I'm torn two ways now.  Maybe I should seek an apprenticeship with a proffesional repairer for a week rather than rely on a book.  I'd rather pay for lessons.

Any workshops going on that?
Title: Re: Accordion Repairs Made Easy by John Reuther
Post by: Martin J on November 08, 2009, 05:52:03 PM
a proffesional published book should be a more reliable source of info than some bloke writing in a blog.
Why ?
When I was in engineering we said there were those who could and those who couldn't and those who couldn't wrote about it.

Cynical perhaps but the object of writing a book is to make a profit whereas the bloke on the blog is probably an enthusiast sharing the results of his own mistakes and how to get round them.

Just a point of view
Title: Re: Accordion Repairs Made Easy by John Reuther
Post by: Pete Dunk on November 08, 2009, 10:42:58 PM
Cynical perhaps but the object of writing a book is to make a profit whereas the bloke on the blog is probably an enthusiast sharing the results of his own mistakes and how to get round them.

Just a point of view

Well I agree to a certain extent, I'm an enthusiast sharing the results of my own mistakes, often posting about my work-arounds but they are at times work-arounds of my own making in that I made a complete a*se of it in the first place and I swear that just now and then I can here a very sharp intake of breath from the general direction of Gateshead.

Don't believe for one moment that repeating the mistakes that I or any other 'enthusiast' makes will make you into better person, it just means you're as stupid as I am for making the same mistakes all over again.  ::)

The Thierry Benetoux book is very good, not easy to follow at times I'll grant you. At times I think it's a book written by a professional for the benefit of other, lesser professionals. Rather like a good cookery book, it expects you to have a (good) basic understanding of the subject before venturing inside ...
Title: Re: Accordion Repairs Made Easy by John Reuther
Post by: triskel on November 09, 2009, 04:18:10 AM
Reprints appear on ebay from time to time.  Here (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/Accordion-Repairs-Book-How-to-repair-any-part_W0QQitemZ270481814305) is an example

Except that those are illegal pirated photocopies of John Reuther's book (with the title changed to protect the guilty  ::)), which is actually still in print and available from the legitimate publisher...
Title: Re: Accordion Repairs Made Easy by John Reuther
Post by: RGF on November 09, 2009, 05:32:16 AM
Interesting point. Got mine a few years ago from Ernest Deffner/BMI, who I believe to be the publisher at this time, although I could be wrong. http://www.bussomusic.com/catalog/featured_products.php?products_id=149

Bob
Title: Re: Accordion Repairs Made Easy by John Reuther
Post by: Accordion Dave on December 19, 2009, 04:01:43 AM
I bought the book from Busso last year. It has a lot of useful information that I had to learn through experimentation over the years.

I was not aware of the book until the advent of the internet. I wish I had discovered the book decades ago.
Title: Re: Accordion Repairs Made Easy by John Reuther
Post by: Kautilya on January 01, 2010, 06:30:36 PM
I bought the book from Busso last year. It has a lot of useful information that I had to learn through experimentation over the years.

I was not aware of the book until the advent of the internet. I wish I had discovered the book decades ago.

I needed to know how to sort out sticking keys and access to the keyboard and I found Reuther did not help me really.  It always seemed to run out of the crucial nitty gritty info (like how to open up the outside!) when I needed a dummy's step by step. Fortunately I was able to read a library copy and did not spend out.That said, there were sections which could be usable for other particular problems.

I shall definitely check out Theo's recommendation of Thierry Benetoux.

If any knows a url with a good visual explanation of how to get at keyboards and axles to fix sticky keys that would be most helpful.  I spent quite a few hours searching and failed....

BTW I understand that even the Italians, with all their history of production have no good repair books for the amateur. :-[
Title: Re: Accordion Repairs Made Easy by John Reuther
Post by: Accordion Dave on January 02, 2010, 03:26:54 AM
As I said, I had to learn accordion repair myself over the past several decades.

I had to rebuild the treble switch mechanism on my used East German piano accordion back in the 1970s. I improved it by adding more metal parts in place of the original poor quality plastic. It still works just fine nearly 40 years later. 

Reuther's book really doesn't cover anything that specific, but it would have given me some ideas.

I had virtually no information at the time, no books, and obviously no internet.

I learned about
Title: Re: Accordion Repairs Made Easy by John Reuther
Post by: Kautilya on January 02, 2010, 03:59:38 AM
As I said, I had to learn accordion repair myself over the past several decades.

I had to rebuild the treble switch mechanism on my used East German piano accordion back in the 1970s. I improved it by adding more metal parts in place of the original poor quality plastic. It still works just fine nearly 40 years later. 

Reuther's book really doesn't cover anything that specific, but it would have given me some ideas.

I had virtually no information at the time, no books, and obviously no internet.

I learned about
Tks Dave - I think I will just have to get an abandoned box and literally do a breaker's job on it! The melodeon one row I have is much easier to open .... (:when u have been shown where the nails are in the handle....
Title: Re: Accordion Repairs Made Easy by John Reuther
Post by: juker on January 02, 2010, 04:35:14 AM
I started with a Hohner G/C (which I still have and love!) and wanted a D/G as well but these things are not thick on the ground in Australia and I didn't want to outlay a lot of money at this stage so we bought a cheap Weltmeister G/C on ebay, a complete set of D/G Cagnoni reeds (from Charlie Marshall) and my husband changed the reeds. We considered buying a book first, but he just worked carefully, used some info and pictures from melnet and did it himself. The change has worked well, didn't cost a lot and my husband has learned heaps about looking after the boxes. He also enlarged the holes in the reed blocks to match the new reeds. A book might have been good, but there is just so much info on the net these days so not really necessary if you have confidence on your own ability to be careful and learn.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal