Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: David P on December 16, 2022, 09:13:16 PM
-
I have just rescued a large number of reeds from two scrapped accordions and made a tuning bench from a bellows to learn a little about tuning reeds….
To help ease my journey, could anyone offer some thoughts or an explanation on the following:
What part does the valve play in the tuning process?
Or to be more specific:
Why Is it necessary to have a valve in place when initially tuning a reed in its block on the “benchâ€, bearing in mind the valve is only there to stop the opposite reed sounding when the first reed is being adjusted or is there more to this than meets the eye?
Why are valves often not fitted to the smaller, high pitched reed blocks and how does that relate to the above?
If having or not having a valve in situe when tuning affects the process, does having different types of valve material affect the tuning i.e. soft leather, plastic with or without stiffer half sections and plastic with a fine wire “keeper†on the top, and does that affect the pitch or how quickly a reed speaks or otherwise affect the response or property of the reed?
As an addendum to the above, is it practical to substitute valve material within a block to replace one or two warped valves without any noticeable tuning issues?
Many, many thanks in anticipation……..
David Perkins
-
The valve affects the pitch of the opposing reed because it changes the air pressure, and the movement of airflow, within that reed's chamber.
The valve also affects the reed that it opens/closes, by limiting the airflow (depending on the stiffness of the valve material, presence of contropelli, and how far up the glue goes).
Putting valves on the smallest reeds gives diminishing returns. The backflow from the opposite direction is insignificant, and they need all the airflow they can get in order to speak at a volume that matches well with the other reeds.
There are many subjective opinions on valve material. Personally, I prefer leather by a mile. I find it is not only more silent in operation, it gives better tone. I have sound samples of the same reeds before/after I substituted leather for the plastic valves - the difference is striking. Many folks prefer the synthetic valves, at least on the mid-range reeds, because they open quickly, and don't deform or sag easily. But for my tastes, they buzz, click, and flutter too much, even for mid-range reeds. This goes for synthetic leather as well, though to a lesser extent.
And in my opinion, you will not notice a single valve of a different type being used. Mixing is common. In particular, it is common practice to use leather for the larger reeds, plastic for the mid-range, and none for the high end.
-
And in my opinion, you will not notice a single valve of a different type being used. Mixing is common. In particular, it is common practice to use leather for the larger reeds, plastic for the mid-range, and none for the high end.
In my experience this is true.....my favourite box is ancient but had obviously been well maintained by previous owners. Two treble end valves had been renewed in plastic before I got it. I have no idea which two and would have to open the box up to find out.