Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Chris Ryall on December 25, 2022, 10:11:46 AM
-
Common vocabulary helps avoid misunderstanding? Brian JM has just found a youtube, describing box voicing in terms of organ pipes! Here’s how I think that we describe our melodeons here. All open to debate, and the weekend’s UK telly looks dire 😉
In terms of right-handed play …
Right end: is occasionally referred to as treble end
2-row, 3-row, 2+5-row (eg Mory)
Name the diatonic rows, from outside => inside eg D/G, G/C, B/C
helper rows generally referred to as ‘accs’
except that a 2-row ‘+accs’ refers to head end buttons
‘Club’ system means that middle 5th/6th (eg D,E on a G row) is changed to 5th both ways (D,D)
‘Dutch’ inversion or reversal has notes of that button opposite ways = E,D
Default set-up is tonics of diatonic rows at 3rd button towards the floor from head end the melodeon’s chinward side
… ‘4th start’ is an increasingly popular layout in UK (suiting)m D/G systems, with tonic is 4th from head the chinward side
‘Voicing’ is number of reeds per button, we use L=low M=mid H=high
Might be LM, MM, MM* tremolo, ‘Dedic’=M-/M+, LMH or LMMH on 1-row kit
Default for M on the innermost main is C4 in piano notation, middle C 🤔
Left end often called bass end, is described wrt its button count 2-bass, 4-bass, 8-bass, 12-bass, 18-bass etc
The buttons are chord/bass pairs by default. Free bass notes are not uncommon, describe as necessary
3rds ‘in’, ‘out’, ‘no’ … means a middle chord note is absent, taped or switched out. eg triad G+B+D => G+D
Left end voicings vary quite a lot and usually need explicit description 🤔 Any ideas?
What have I missed out? Or got wrong?
-
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,terminology.html (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,terminology.html)
-
The only thing that bothers me slightly is "3rd button down from head end"; I would have said simply "3rd button from head (or chin!) end", as a) there is only one direction you can move from the end of the keyboard and b) "down" would mean to me "lower in pitch" rather than physically lower. I have the same kind of problem with online guitar tutorials that talk about the "top" string, which to me is the high "E", when they mean "furthest from the floor", which is the low "E" and therefore the bottom string, not the top one. You can tell I'm at a bit of a loose end at present, can't you.......??
-
Thought we had decided on 'chinmost' and 'kneemost' (:)
-
Thanks chaps. Please keep the corrections coming. Dear me … the telly is awful and we did the big meal here on the 21st 🙂
Off to look at Lester’s terminology page. Didn’t know it existed!
-
Thought we had decided on 'chinmost' and 'kneemost' (:)
Had we? OK, if that's the general feeling. As a retired teacher of English (note NOT "Emglish teacher", which would mean something entirely different) I applaud the sentiment, though I'm not convinced by its linguistic integrity! If it works for you, fine. It's good job I don't apply the same degree of pedantry (or is it the local wine on this festive evening?) to my melodeon playing; if I did I'd probably still be on "Three Blind Mice"..... ;D
Merry Christmas, all!
PS In case you were wondering, I'd have gone for "chinward" and "kneeward", as the root words are nouns, not adjectives.....
-
Common on PAs to name voicing after organ pipe length: L=16', M=8', H=4', so I can see why some might use the same terminology for melodeons, too.
-
Common on PAs to name voicing after organ pipe length: L=16', M=8', H=4', so I can see why some might use the same terminology for melodeons, too.
thanks, Chris. I can see a few pitfalls with that. One is that Helmholtz, ie tick notation C C’ C’’ C’’’ etc is used in France and elsewhere for octaves. (Confusingly French then voice their bagpipes in “inchesâ€)! 😳
But the main issue is appropriateness. Pianos are ubiquitous and I think everybody in the world understands the concept of middle C (C4). Only a few avant-garde jazz theorists in the 1950s, have ever really queried it.
I see no logic, and little merit in using a system designed for static instruments, based on a vibrating column of air to describe something whose principle is free reeds. Reed length might make more sense, but that doesn’t get us very far either? I’ll keep out of the relative weights of a PA, compared to a lead alloy organ pipe 😉 And while 8 foot free reed harmonicas … do exist, they are a bit of a mouthful!
But fundamentally commonality of terms seems better than building another Tower of Babel?
-
I'd never heard of the organ pipe length naming system until I saw it on Chris M's previous post...
-
Common on PAs to name voicing after organ pipe length: L=16', M=8', H=4', so I can see why some might use the same terminology for melodeons, too.
I can see it....but organ stops are based on the lowest note being "C", whereas 2 voice melodeons are (usually) MM and their (3rd button) start notes range from G below middle C to F above middle C.
So the melodeon mid voice is the one in which the first octave includes middle C.
-
The lowest note on a PA isn't (usually) a C, either, though. The lowest C on a PA is conventionally read as a middle C (regardless of which reed banks are used to play it), but the lowest note will be the F below that on a full-size PA, or a G, B or the C itself on smaller instruments. I can see no logic whatsoever to equating a low reed bank to a 16ft organ pipe or a medium reed bank to an 8ft organ pipe, but logical or not, it's very commonly done!
-
Thought we had decided on 'chinmost' and 'kneemost' (:)
This is some what ambiguous as it depends on which side the player has the keyboard.
-
The only thing that bothers me slightly is "3rd button down from head end"; I would have said simply "3rd button from head (or chin!) end", as a) there is only one direction you can move from the end of the keyboard and b) "down" would mean to me "lower in pitch" rather than physically lower. I have the same kind of problem with online guitar tutorials that talk about the "top" string, which to me is the high "E", when they mean "furthest from the floor", which is the low "E" and therefore the bottom string, not the top one. You can tell I'm at a bit of a loose end at present, can't you.......??
I quite " get" what you mean and your frustrations with regards "Top E " guitar string.
" Top E" was always Top E and everyone who knew and played guitar was aware if this.
What is so irritating is that those who have not understood this musical term, ( top end has always described the higher pitch notes) have somehow changed the world to believe differenttly.
Mutch the same as Grammar and spelling.
If you were to be an Australian guitarist then Top E would be a challenge.
However in order to get out of all this I notice that with electric guitar strings they merely give you the string thicknesses in thousandths of an inch.
Here we go again.......thought we had gone metric?
They keep changing things to be clever.
It was always easier to have a set of strings with the note name on the packet. Clearly the thickest string in the set will be Low E and the thinnest High E.
-
I have edited the initial post to reflect chin and feet directions. I see no problem with the few left-handers who plays melodeon upside down. They can work it out for themselves. I am a left-hander incidentally, but play the instrument right-handed.
The comment about right end notes being an octave or so higher than the left is not entirely true. I have 4th-button start on both of my instruments, and the right-hand L reeds are in the same octave as the basses on the other side.
It is however true of M-voiced reeds which is another good reason to specify the ends in terms of M voicing? My ‘rodec’ machine readable melodeon descriptor system does that “I want this button to be a bass note, not a chord†is indicated by using octave zero on the left. No Melodeon has reeds that low?
-
Thought we had decided on 'chinmost' and 'kneemost' (:)
As a retired teacher of English (note NOT "Emglish teacher", which would mean something entirely differe
Merry Christmas, all!
I.m glad I'm not the only one that steers towards the pedant on this.... :|glug
-
Thought we had decided on 'chinmost' and 'kneemost' (:)
As a retired teacher of English (note NOT "Emglish teacher", which would mean something entirely differe
Merry Christmas, all!
I.m glad I'm not the only one that steers towards the pedant on this.... :|glug
We pedants have to stick together, Baz!
-
Slightly off topic (or is it) but I was hoping someone would turn up with a version of the poem, but not about a rifle. ;D
-
A friend of mine did a punk rock cover of that poem.
-
It’s a suite of 6 poems. But we digress …
-
Slightly off topic (or is it) but I was hoping someone would turn up with a version of the poem, but not about a rifle. ;D
Ask and it shall be given: (:)
Today we have naming of parts. Yesterday
We had tonality .And tomorrow morning
We shall have how to re- tape bellows. But today.
Today we have naming of parts. The rain
Falls softly on the morris team in the pub garden.
And today we have naming of parts.
This is the lower strap bracket. And this
Is the upper strap bracket, whose use you will see
When you are given your strap. And this is your second strap
Which in your case you have not got. The morris team
Hold in the garden their half empty pewter tankards
Which in our case we have not got.
This is the air button, always operated
With an easy flick of the thumb. And please do not let me
See anyone using the heel of their hand. You can do it quite easy
If you have any strength in your thumb. The musicians
Stand waiting motionless, idly noodling whilst
Using the heel of their hands.
And these are the bellows. The purpose of these
Is to sound the reeds, as you can hear. We can move them
Rapidly in and out: we call this
Sounding the reeds. And rapidly inwards and outwards
The musicians are noodling whilst tapping their fingers
They call it sounding the reeds.
They call it sounding the reeds: it is perfectly easy
If you have any strength in your thumb: like the bellows,
And the strap , and the strap bracket, and the thumb strap,
Which in our case we have not got; and the musicians
Silent in the pub garden and the dancers going backwards and forwards,
For today we have naming of parts.
:|glug
-
It’s a suite of 6 poems. But we digress …
A pedant (see above) writes actually it's one poem in a suite of six...The suite is called Lessons of War... (:) :|glug
-
Baz..that’s brilliant. Particularly like 'The morris team
Hold in the garden their half empty pewter tankards
Which in our case we have not got.'
-
Different cultural approaches, that usually are common among people who speak different native languages, lead to different vocabularies.
Just a couple of simple examples.
In Italy, according to the ethnomusicologists practice, the melodeons are roughly classified according to the number of buttons of the left hand keyboard. 2/4 basses are one row instruments (or to say better 1 ½ row instruments, since melodeons with just one row of buttons aren't played traditionally). 8 basses melodeons are two row instruments, and 12 basses melodeons are three row instruments in three keys. And the right hand keyboard is called tastiera del canto – the singer/singing keyboard.
In our vocabulary there aren't terms to make a distinction between a two row melodeon, like a G/C or a D/G instrument, and a two row button accordion, like a B/C or a C#/D instrument. An Irish button accordion is simply an organetto, and eventually you can hear it called organetto cromatico. That's often confusing for the Italian classically trained musicians, as the organetto for them, as a matter of definition, is a fisarmonica diatonica – i.e. a diatonic accordion. Then, an Irish button box becomes a chromatic diatonic accordion. Puzzling, isnt'it?
And by the way we don't have an acccepted word/term to describe a thee row instrument based on the right end keyboard layout of a two row melodeon with a third one with accidentals and reversals, and virtually chormatic – the instrument in France are occasionally called accordeon chromatic bisonore. I fear we don't even have an accepted word to translate the term reversal, in fact. But this isn't a problem among the melodon players, since we use to describe the instruments according to the home keys, eventually giving for granted that an additional half row, or a third full row, are used to allocate both accidentals and reversals.
Literal translations between different native languages speakers, both ways, could lead to a lot of misunderstanding, but open minded players are usually able to communicate behind the language barriers. In other words I think that to avoid misunderstanding among the players, and not just those with different native languages, what we need, more than a common vocabulary, is simply some common sense. Well... probably a lot of it! ;)
-
Slightly off topic (or is it) but I was hoping someone would turn up with a version of the poem, but not about a rifle. ;D
Ask and it shall be given: (:)
Today we have naming of parts. Yesterday
We had tonality .And tomorrow morning
We shall have how to re- tape bellows. But today.
Today we have naming of parts. The rain
Falls softly on the morris team in the pub garden.
And today we have naming of parts...
Wow! Respec'. I love that.
Having spent most of my life teaching A level English Language, though, I can't agree with the pedantry. "English" can function as either an adjective or a noun. Indeed, it's a noun in "teacher of English". We regularly use nouns to pre-modify other nouns: "dinner plate", "shoulder strap", "history lesson", "English lesson", "English teacher". The last one is ambiguous but perfectly allowable.
Sorry - major thread drift but couldn't let that pass! ;)
-
There seem to be several “parts†🙄 contributing this thread, but I won’t name them 🙂
-
There seem to be several “parts†🙄 contributing this thread, but I won’t name them 🙂
Did that say something different before your spillchucker got at it? ;-)
-
Clearly 'The naming of parts is a difficult matter...'
Julian
-
In other words I think that to avoid misunderstanding among the players, and not just those with different native languages, what we need, more than a common vocabulary, is simply some common sense. Well... probably a lot of it! ;)
Couldn't agree more! English dictionaries (I assume other languages too) are often take to prescribe how to use words. A dictionary is useful in this way, but it's also helpful to remember that dictionaries are compiled by observing how words are actually used, and as such the usage and meaning of the words do change over time. This thread started out with a noble aim to try to regularise the usage of words that describe our instruments. Sadly I believe this attempt is doomed, because it can only be followed by the people who have read it and agree with the proposals. In real life we just have to live with the diverse (even chaotic) nature of the terminology we use for a diverse family of instruments.
-
we had some useful imputs, until it started to go a bit giddy. I will look through the forums present page and make appropriate suggestions.
admin might consider pinning a reference to the vocabulary sub-page in this section?
-
we had some useful imputs, until it started to go a bit giddy.
Apologies. Sometimes I can't resist a challenge... :|glug
-
Apologies from me too. Must try harder to take this seriously. GBbox and Theo sum it up perfectly.
-
Comment deleted