You could be right, The Box came with Hohner reeds tuned fairly wet. I think he said the farthest he could tune it up was to 21 cents (I know nothing of terminology here but I think he called it Demi swing, I could be wrong) I'm aslo pretty sure that he said the original reeds could not be tuned any drier for some reason,
As I understand it there would be no need for new reed blocks, the cost will just be for the labour and the installation and tuning of the New Italian reeds. As for the Corso in the other post that I am having converted yes it does need different reed blocks as It's a C/F- MMM being converted to B/C LMM. So I guess my question boils down to what reeds should I have it upgraded to. As a novice player am I going to notice much difference between Super Dural and TAM either Cagnoni or Binci?
Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
So are you telling me that the dry tuned Hohner reeds will sound as good as Dry tuned Cagnoni or Binci super Dural.No but they will sound vastly different from wet tuned Hohner reeds, so different that you will wonder if its the same reeds.
Or are you intimating that the most economical solution with the best sound is to retune the Hohner reeds to be much dryer?
Thus his statement about not being able to make a huge change.
...but I'm looking for something that will satisfy my needs for the next 5-6 years while I learn to play. ...
I've got Hohners from the 30's or 40's. If its lasted some people a life time I'm sure it can last you 6 years!
Of course my recent bout with MAD left me in possession of an old Corso which as said in a prior post I'm Converting to B/C simply because I wanted a 3 voice box that didn't break the bank. Then I went and purchased a Hohner Primatona from Ted on this forum and am expecting that any day, yeah I wanted a 4 voice too. So for all that money I probably could have picked up a Soprani Red. Oh well I was in the grip of some sickness >:E
Well I have to gently disagree Theo, on my budget Economics is always a factor. So are you telling me that the dry tuned Hohner reeds will sound as good as Dry tuned Cagnoni or Binci super Dural. Or are you intimating that the most economical solution with the best sound is to retune the Hohner reeds to be much dryer? Believe me if money weren't an issue I'd not even be discussing it. I'd have a nice grey Paolo and be done.
hence there are only a few "pros" who play them (Sharon Shannon did YEARS back, Josephine Marsh, Martin Quinn..almost all the big boys are on Gaillards, Paolos etc.)
hence there are only a few "pros" who play them (Sharon Shannon did YEARS back, Josephine Marsh, Martin Quinn..almost all the big boys are on Gaillards, Paolos etc.)
John Kirkpatrick, Pete Coe, Dan Quinn, Tony Hall, Mark Bazeley. ???
hence there are only a few "pros" who play them (Sharon Shannon did YEARS back, Josephine Marsh, Martin Quinn..almost all the big boys are on Gaillards, Paolos etc.)
John Kirkpatrick, Pete Coe, Dan Quinn, Tony Hall, Mark Bazeley. ???
Don't forget Josephine Marsh and Donncha Lynch.
I didn't forget Josephine Marsh. Seriously tho, I'm not familiar with some of the guys mentioned but from what I can gather no one with any sort of serious technical ability is playing a hohner. There's nothing wrong with owning a number of boxes but why own several substandard boxes instead of one respectable one? When one is getting into talking about replacing reeds in a cheap box with reeds that belong in a higher quality box while keeping whole bunch of boxes then it makes sense to reconsider the options...how is the action on that hohner etc. gonna serve you when you're playing advances?hence there are only a few "pros" who play them (Sharon Shannon did YEARS back, Josephine Marsh, Martin Quinn..almost all the big boys are on Gaillards, Paolos etc.)
John Kirkpatrick, Pete Coe, Dan Quinn, Tony Hall, Mark Bazeley. ???
Don't forget Josephine Marsh and Donncha Lynch.
I didn't forget Josephine Marsh. Seriously tho, I'm not familiar with some of the guys mentioned but from what I can gather no one with any sort of serious technical ability is playing a hohner. There's nothing wrong with owning a number of boxes but why own several substandard boxes instead of one respectable one? When one is getting into talking about replacing reeds in a cheap box with reeds that belong in a higher quality box while keeping whole bunch of boxes then it makes sense to reconsider the options...how is the action on that hohner etc. gonna serve you when you're playing advances?
Hmm pretty good for an old Double Ray
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dv2XjpuqtyA&feature=related
What kind of Box is John playing on this bit. Is that a Hohner Gaelic?
... I wouldn't consider Brendan Begley to be particularly good or technical but that's just me.
I guess it's often happening that people who are new to an instrument get obsessed with technology and try to find shortcuts or easy ways of either "playing better" or "sounding better" by altering their instrument instead of concentrating on their technique! A Hohner should sound like a Hohner, no matter who plays it, and changing the reeds won't make anyone a better player, no offense intended.
Tony Hall is the champion of the Pokerwork (though some of his albums have a little bit of overdubbing?)
Tony Hall is the champion of the Pokerwork (though some of his albums have a little bit of overdubbing?)
Maybe, but in some cases even though you'd swear that what he was playing was overdubbed (try Flowers of Edinburgh) it isn't, I've seen him play like this live on many occasions. He just seems to have more fingers than normal human beings...
Ian
Tony Hall is the champion of the Pokerwork (though some of his albums have a little bit of overdubbing?)
Maybe, but in some cases even though you'd swear that what he was playing was overdubbed (try Flowers of Edinburgh) it isn't, I've seen him play like this live on many occasions. He just seems to have more fingers than normal human beings...
Ian
It's more than that though, he hardly seems to make any effort to produce these sounds. If you're going to be better than everyone else then you should really put on a grimace to let people know that it isn't as easy as you're making it out to be :P
LDbosca, I don't know you so I may be well out of order but it seems you are confusing speed with technique.
.. I completely understand that being a fast player isn't much in itself (and I don't have much time for people who think speed is what it's all about), when I speak of technique I mean exploiting the full range of subtleties available on the instrument. I believe to do that an instrument with the best possible response and minimal mechanical noise is required. ..Thanks for your reply. Although I agree with you about having the best possible response and minimal mechanical noise where I have been most impressed is by players who can make a Hohner sound brilliant. My view of your comments was coloured when I think you sold yourself short regarding JK and TH particularly as they are noted for subtleties, see Ian's post re Tony. I do agree there are tunes I cannot do justice to on my Hohners but maybe I haven't been lucky enough to have tried a top end Hohner box or maybe I'm just not good enough to make the Hohner perform as I would like it to. Nor may I add, continuing thread drift, have I ever played a box fettled by Theo which apparently are more responsive and mechanically quieter. On thread again it seems that you are also advocating tune the box you have, don't throw heavy money at it, save that for a top end instrument.
Do you have a URL for that? I don't think that I have it and would be interested in hearing it.
I'm sure there are myriad examples to the contrary...,and I'm glad there's plenty of people enjoying their Hohners// :|||:
Oh, sure there are... Kepa likes 'em (http://www.flickr.com/photos/berritzen/307729806/sizes/l/)... 8)12 bass Polka work - wow, where do they come from ?
Yes... he owns Italians too (http://www.flickr.com/photos/berritzen/307729782/sizes/l/)... but all the same, as far as technique goes, triki players arguably ask more out of an instrument than most... so choosing (and sticking with) a Hohner has to say something...
Ed J
12 bass Polka work - wow, where do they come from ?
I believe to do that an instrument with the best possible response and minimal mechanical noise is required. My experience of playing Hohners (which is restricted to Ericas and Double Rays in B/C and Csharp/D) is that they haven't provided these attributes to the extent some other boxes have.
12 bass Polka work - wow, where do they come from ?
No URL, but here's the last time through squashed down to a 32kb/s mono mp3 to get in under the 256kb file size limit...
Ian
P.S. Guaranteed no overdubbing !
I believe to do that an instrument with the best possible response and minimal mechanical noise is required. My experience of playing Hohners (which is restricted to Ericas and Double Rays in B/C and Csharp/D) is that they haven't provided these attributes to the extent some other boxes have.
My Hohner Club has had the button travel limited, and it has a very, very fast keyboard. It is very light and responsive, and repeated notes seem easier to play on it than on my other boxes. Also, the buttons are just slightly closer together (both vertically and horizontally).
I just found a 12 Bass Erica on Ebay c/f tuning black in color. Is this a Polka box? So I posted the link over in Buy and sell
12 bass Polka work - wow, where do they come from ?
Mike from St Ives, who did my Club, has a 12 bass Club which he did for himself. All Hohner bits, I would think.