Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Andrew Culwell on November 08, 2009, 07:52:48 PM

Title: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on November 08, 2009, 07:52:48 PM
So as I progress in my learning to play and wish to hear a sweeter sound from my box I am debating upgrading the reeds.  I already have invested a fair amount of hard earned cash into my Hohner double Ray, I think it sounds fairly good but while it's loud it lacks a certain sweet tone that I hear from other higher end boxes.  I've been debating having Michael at Dancemaster upgrade the reeds to Binci Avional or TAM but is this a good use of my money?  It certainly will be less expensive than a Soprani (if I could even find a decent red one).  Martin Quinn's Hohner sounds great does anyone have an idea of what his reeds are?   I don't have any experience with how this box will sound with a higher quality reed.  Anyone out there have a Double Ray that is upgraded to Binci and is it worth the investment?
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: LJC on November 08, 2009, 08:04:08 PM
Could it be that the 'sweetness' your hearing in more expensive boxes is less tremolo? The Italian ones tend to be tuned drier. It could be a much cheaper way of sweetening your box just to have the tuning adjusted. Putting different reeds in your box would mean making new reed blocks as the Hohner reeds are a different size, which is going to add cost on top of the reeds them selves and tuning etc.
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Theo on November 08, 2009, 10:20:21 PM
I've put Italian reeds into many Hohners and I've not had to replace any reedblocks yet,  usually it's been suficient to trim away some wood to lengthen the reed chambers.  Maybe I've been lucky, but it's not certain that new reed blocks are always needed. 

Whether it's worthwhile I don't know.  Tuning with less tremolo will make a big difference to the sound,  you may also find that the instrument is not quite as loud with Italian reeds.  It will still retain some of the distinctive Hohner sound, even with new reeds.  My regular player fir the past 6 years has been a Hohner club 2 with Cagnoni tam reeds, so I am talking from experience. 
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on November 08, 2009, 10:31:57 PM
You could be right,  The Box came with Hohner reeds tuned fairly wet.  I think he said the farthest he could tune it up was to 21 cents (I know nothing of terminology here but I think he called it Demi swing, I could be wrong)  I'm aslo pretty sure that he said the original reeds could not be tuned any drier for some reason, the conversation at the time went way above my level of melodeon knowledge.   Anyway it has much less tremolo now It sounds pretty good and is pretty loud but  I'm not so concerned about loudness as i am tone.  I do like some slight Tremolo too, so are you telling me that you can't have tremolo and have the same kind of sweet tone that I hear from some of the italian boxes.  I always heard that the reeds and the tuning had a huge part to play in the sound of the box.  I listen to Martin Quinn and he seems to have a very dry tuning and nice sound out of his Hohner.      I guess my question would be if I have new italian reeds put in would it be a huge difference in sound between say Binci TAM and Super Dural?  Enough Difference to justify the expense of the more expensive reeds?    
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: an bosca ceoil on November 08, 2009, 10:34:22 PM
 ??? Why would new reedblocks be needed.
I have always found that Binci reedplates will fit  Erica/Double Ray if you shave enough off the walls  and chamber ends to accomodate the larger heels and longer tongues/valves.  (Basses also fit but you have to reduce the chambers.)
What I do not understand is the talk off converting his other instrument from MMM to MML because I cannot see how this could be done without a new block?
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on November 08, 2009, 11:07:47 PM
As I understand it there would be no need for new reed blocks, the cost will just be for the labour and the installation and tuning of the New Italian reeds.  As for the Corso in the other post that I am having converted yes it does need different reed blocks as It's a C/F- MMM being converted to B/C LMM.    So I guess my question about the Double Ray is what reeds should I have it upgraded to.  As a novice player am I going to notice much difference between Super Dural and TAM either Cagnoni or Binci? 
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Theo on November 08, 2009, 11:08:57 PM
You could be right,  The Box came with Hohner reeds tuned fairly wet.  I think he said the farthest he could tune it up was to 21 cents (I know nothing of terminology here but I think he called it Demi swing, I could be wrong)  I'm aslo pretty sure that he said the original reeds could not be tuned any drier for some reason,

That is quite untrue.  There is absolutely no reason why Hohner reeds can't be tuned from their normal wet to completely dry, or anything in between.   I've done it with Hohner reeds and it works fine.
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Theo on November 08, 2009, 11:12:56 PM
As I understand it there would be no need for new reed blocks, the cost will just be for the labour and the installation and tuning of the New Italian reeds.  As for the Corso in the other post that I am having converted yes it does need different reed blocks as It's a C/F- MMM being converted to B/C LMM.    So I guess my question boils down to what reeds should I have it upgraded to.  As a novice player am I going to notice much difference between Super Dural and TAM either Cagnoni or Binci?
Quote
Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?

Economics is the wrong way to judge this.  Its a matter of what sound you want. 
If you want a drier tuning just get the existing reeds adjusted.   If your tuner says he can't do it then find one that will.  The cost will be a fraction of the cost of installing new reeds.
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on November 08, 2009, 11:17:41 PM
I'm sure I'm mangling what he said to me as far as the tuning.  All I know is that he did a "reed tongue adjustment"  is that the terminology and is that different than a complete tuning?   I have since become somewhat less confused about the whole tuning thing but the more I learn the more I realize how little I know, is a Reed tongue adjustment different than a complete retuning?
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on November 08, 2009, 11:28:51 PM
Well I have to gently disagree Theo, on my budget Economics is always a factor.   So are you telling me that the dry tuned Hohner reeds will sound as good as Dry tuned Cagnoni or Binci super Dural.  Or are you intimating that the most economical solution with the best sound is to retune the Hohner reeds to be much dryer?  Believe me if money weren't an issue I'd not even be discussing it.  I'd have a nice grey Paolo and be done.
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Theo on November 08, 2009, 11:35:28 PM
I've not heard the exact term 'reed tongue adjustment'  but it sounds similar to what I would call reed voicing where the reeds are bent up or down by minute amounts to get the optimum reed response.  This will have a small effect on the tuning (not noticeable on typical Hohner wet tuning) but will in itself not make any difference to the overall sound of the instrument.

Its all very confusing because even the word tuning can mean several different things.  All of the following are often referred to simply as 'tuning':

1 spot tuning where just a few reeds are tuned because they are audibly out of tune with the rest of the instrument.
2 Tuning - where the tuning of every reed is checked and if required it's pitch is adjusted back to where it should originally have been
3 changing from wet to dry or dry to wet
4 re-pitching to a completely different key eg changing C/F box to D/G etc
5 re-pitching to modern concert pitch eg changing from a reference pitch of A=435 to A=440

There is lots to learn!
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Theo on November 08, 2009, 11:39:25 PM
So are you telling me that the dry tuned Hohner reeds will sound as good as Dry tuned Cagnoni or Binci super Dural.
No but they will sound vastly different from wet tuned Hohner reeds, so different that you will wonder if its the same reeds.

Quote
  Or are you intimating that the most economical solution with the best sound is to retune the Hohner reeds to be much dryer? 

Yes

Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: rees on November 08, 2009, 11:47:02 PM
I have an old Double Ray fitted with Hohner reeds in Bb / Eb. It is tuned totally dry and sounds wickid (!)
I wouldn't dream of changing the reeds to Italian or whatever.
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on November 08, 2009, 11:53:47 PM
Thanks Theo!  I appreciate your taking the time to explain.  I take it that the procedure you describe would limit the amount of change from wet to dry.  Thus his statement about not being able to make a huge change.  I might just have the Hohner Reeds tuned Drier rather than expend the cash for italian.
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: melodeon on November 09, 2009, 12:25:05 AM
I would refer you back to a post where Andy experienced a 37 button modified Hohner Corona that had stock reeds  revamped
I believe he said he was in near disbelief that these were still Hohner reeds.

Some box techs/tuners simply have it in for Hohner and Hohner reeds... and will attempt to convince others to fit Italian reeds but not offering the other less expensive option  of a retuning.

Also some techs/tuners believe that Hohner reeds only sound good with a fair amount of tremolo. See comment about the 37 button Hohner mod box

As to the economy of switching reeds to Italian in a Hohner....   the "value" would be in a newer/"better" sound and
a financial loss would only be experienced in an attempt to sell the box.

This would be like tricking out an International pickup truck
While infinitley better than a Ford , Dodge or  Chevy here's a reality check

Assuming a modest purchase price of $1000  and then dumping $2500 into it...
It is still worth $1000... maybe $1500 to a Cornbinder freak such as me...
But in keeping it.. I have the joy of owning something better than its rivals


Another option is to get a new Hohner Morgane.....

Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on November 09, 2009, 02:17:18 AM
Good insights, all.  I'm sure that there is more money to be made in selling a full set of italian reeds and installing them rather than a full tuning with the original hohner reeds.  That said the cost of tricking out the Double Ray with A full set of italian reeds along with the keyboard upgrades and adjustments (the former owner thought it was practical to adjust the key rod assembly, specifically the horizontal key rod levers which were crooked and bent downward forcibly - most likely in an attempt to lower the buttons quickly.)  That work plus the cost of the  "Demo" Hohner itself (inflated price from the high end retail establishment in New Hampshire who shall remain nameless)  All of that still comes to a price less than a Castagnari or a Bouebe.  That said a Hohner sounds like a Hohner which isn't a bad thing.  All of this to say that even if I trick the box out with italian reeds I'll have less out of pocket than the cost of a high end box.  Like you said I'd probably not recoup the cost if I sold it but I'm looking for something that will satisfy my needs for the next 5-6 years while I learn to play.   Of course my recent bout with MAD left me in possession of an old Corso which as said in a prior post I'm Converting to B/C simply because I wanted a 3 voice box that didn't break the bank.  Then I went and purchased a Hohner Primatona from Ted on this forum and am expecting that any day, yeah I wanted a 4 voice too.  So for all that money I probably could have picked up a Soprani Red.  Oh well I was in the grip of some sickness >:E 
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: LJC on November 09, 2009, 07:49:34 AM
Thus his statement about not being able to make a huge change.

Just to be clear (not sure from reading the posts that it is) you can have Hohner reeds tuned completely dry to very wet, or anywhere in between. Same goes for Italian reeds. If your tuner claims he's unable to do that then get a new one as Theo suggested.

Regarding Hohners - I really like the sound of Hohner reeds, but I don't like the mad tremolo they so often have. Its nothing to do with the reeds, just the tuning. Drying them out somewhat gives you a very sweet sound to my ears.

Regarding reed blocks - I've never actually put Italian reeds in a Hohner and just assumed that it wouldn't be as simple as putting them on the existing block, nothing in Melodeon repair is ever as simple as it should be!.
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Theo on November 09, 2009, 08:33:28 AM
...but I'm looking for something that will satisfy my needs for the next 5-6 years while I learn to play.   ...

Hohner reeds tuned the way you want them will do that. 
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: LJC on November 09, 2009, 10:36:43 AM
I've got Hohners from the 30's or 40's. If its lasted some people a life time I'm sure it can last you 6 years!
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: ganderbox on November 09, 2009, 10:39:56 AM
I have just got myself a C/F Club from somebody in Cornwall who specialises in restoring Hohners. I asked for it to be tuned quite dry...possibly a fraction wetter then swing tuning, but much drier than he would normally tune them. It sounds wonderful.
There is no mistaking that they are still Hohner reeds, but without the warble they sound richer and (as someone described it) it plays with "authority". A Castagnari or Loffet it isn't, but it holds its own with them and of course cost a fraction of the price. Also, as I think somebody pointed out, there is something very satisfying about making a Hohner into a really nice box, but keeping it as a Hohner.

Something to bear in mind as well is that there is more to making a good box than just the reeds, as the design of the case and the materials used for it (and, I think, the reed blocks) also affect it. Putting italian reeds into a Hohner won't necessarily give you an italian sounding box.

Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: triskel on November 09, 2009, 01:44:45 PM
I've got Hohners from the 30's or 40's. If its lasted some people a life time I'm sure it can last you 6 years!

The one I play was made at the beginning of the 1930s, and I wouldn't swap it (or its original Hohner reeds!) for anything...

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/1930-modelHohnerC-Dpost.jpg)
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: LDbosca on November 09, 2009, 07:19:46 PM
Of course my recent bout with MAD left me in possession of an old Corso which as said in a prior post I'm Converting to B/C simply because I wanted a 3 voice box that didn't break the bank.  Then I went and purchased a Hohner Primatona from Ted on this forum and am expecting that any day, yeah I wanted a 4 voice too.  So for all that money I probably could have picked up a Soprani Red.  Oh well I was in the grip of some sickness >:E 

Just wondering, could you sell all the boxes you have and buy a new good accordion such as an entry level Italian box? A new set of Italian reeds is pricey and several low quality accordions are rarely better than one quality accordion. I don't mean to be rude but I've seen people on this forum with several hohners in their collections and it seems pretty pointless...I understand that some people like the sound and they are an adequate beginner's box but they really are not quality instruments. Sure many have lasted years but they don't really stack up in terms of playability or responsiveness or sound, hence there are only a few "pros" who play them (Sharon Shannon did YEARS back, Josephine Marsh, Martin Quinn..almost all the big boys are on Gaillards, Paolos etc.) Unless one is a rather busy gigging musician then ONE accordion (the best you can afford) will probably serve better than several cheap ones. Just my two cents...
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: RickC. on November 09, 2009, 07:29:27 PM
Well I have to gently disagree Theo, on my budget Economics is always a factor.   So are you telling me that the dry tuned Hohner reeds will sound as good as Dry tuned Cagnoni or Binci super Dural.  Or are you intimating that the most economical solution with the best sound is to retune the Hohner reeds to be much dryer?  Believe me if money weren't an issue I'd not even be discussing it.  I'd have a nice grey Paolo and be done.

Ajay,

 PM me your email, I will send you an MP3 of a C#/D Double Ray with reeds tuned drier that used to belong to me. 


      Rick
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: rees on November 09, 2009, 09:24:41 PM
hence there are only a few "pros" who play them (Sharon Shannon did YEARS back, Josephine Marsh, Martin Quinn..almost all the big boys are on Gaillards, Paolos etc.)

John Kirkpatrick, Pete Coe, Dan Quinn, Tony Hall, Mark Bazeley.  ???
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on November 09, 2009, 10:15:43 PM
hence there are only a few "pros" who play them (Sharon Shannon did YEARS back, Josephine Marsh, Martin Quinn..almost all the big boys are on Gaillards, Paolos etc.)

John Kirkpatrick, Pete Coe, Dan Quinn, Tony Hall, Mark Bazeley.  ???



Don't forget Josephine Marsh and Donncha Lynch.
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on November 09, 2009, 10:20:07 PM
So I'm pretty darn convinced that I'm just going to have the Double Ray's original Reeds Retuned rather than put in italian reeds.  I just layed out a nice bundle to have Cagnoni export done up for the Corso Conversion.  Dry tuning so I'm anxious to hear it's sound!  But the Double Ray will keep it's Hohner reeds I'm thinkin.  As for buying an entry level italian I'd much rather have my three different Hohners I really don't think a single two voice Castagnari would satisfy my taste for the multi-voice sound I can get with the Corso and the Primatona.  Just a preference mind you.  But I'm looking forward to that "glorious racket."
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Christopher K. on November 09, 2009, 11:04:53 PM
hence there are only a few "pros" who play them (Sharon Shannon did YEARS back, Josephine Marsh, Martin Quinn..almost all the big boys are on Gaillards, Paolos etc.)

John Kirkpatrick, Pete Coe, Dan Quinn, Tony Hall, Mark Bazeley.  ???



Don't forget Josephine Marsh and Donncha Lynch.

Jimmy Shand, Johnny Connolly, Bobby Gardiner, Steve Jordan, Flaco Jimenez, Marc Savoy, Winse Saunders... Hohner made and makes very fine accordions!   :||:  Can't beat the pre-Chinese models for consistency, and customer service from most Hohner dealers is very fine.  I don't see what's wrong worth owning a number of accordions, either, if that's what you like to do.  Since there are practically unlimited permutations of reed type, tuning, key, and other features like stops, etc., this is even practical.

I am myself planning a retrofit on a nice old 1930s three voice Club model.  I'm buying a new set of reeds from Hohner.  I prefer their tone to the soft and quiet Italian tone.  Then again, it will be tuned pretty wet. 
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: LDbosca on November 10, 2009, 01:33:01 AM
hence there are only a few "pros" who play them (Sharon Shannon did YEARS back, Josephine Marsh, Martin Quinn..almost all the big boys are on Gaillards, Paolos etc.)

John Kirkpatrick, Pete Coe, Dan Quinn, Tony Hall, Mark Bazeley.  ???



Don't forget Josephine Marsh and Donncha Lynch.
I didn't forget Josephine Marsh. Seriously tho, I'm not familiar with some of the guys mentioned but from what I can gather no one with any sort of serious technical ability is playing a hohner. There's nothing wrong with owning a number of boxes but why own several substandard boxes instead of one respectable one? When one is getting into talking about replacing reeds in a cheap box with reeds that belong in a higher quality box while keeping whole bunch of boxes then it makes sense to reconsider the options...how is the action on that hohner etc. gonna serve you when you're playing advances?
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Owen Woods on November 10, 2009, 01:53:51 AM
I didn't forget Josephine Marsh. Seriously tho, I'm not familiar with some of the guys mentioned but from what I can gather no one with any sort of serious technical ability is playing a hohner. There's nothing wrong with owning a number of boxes but why own several substandard boxes instead of one respectable one? When one is getting into talking about replacing reeds in a cheap box with reeds that belong in a higher quality box while keeping whole bunch of boxes then it makes sense to reconsider the options...how is the action on that hohner etc. gonna serve you when you're playing advances?


John Kirkpatrick and Tony Hall don't have any sort of serious technical ability?
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on November 10, 2009, 02:08:17 AM
What kind of Box is John playing on this bit.  Is that a Hohner Gaelic?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p3EhKyns7xo&feature=related

Love it's sound!
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Steve C. on November 10, 2009, 02:08:48 AM
Tony Hall is the champion of the Pokerwork (though some of his albums have a little bit of overdubbing?)
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Christopher K. on November 10, 2009, 03:16:02 AM
And Brendan Begley too.  He plays Hohners.  So does the player from Ceili.
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Andy Simpson on November 10, 2009, 04:14:48 AM
This sounds an awful lot like Hohnerphobia to me.  ;D

I'm currently waiting for my new Baffetti and having sold my Jorgina I'm back on Hohners for the time being and loving it, although I totally understand why some people don't like them. Taste differs but the list of top drawer musicians playing Hohners from around the world, featuring the likes of John Kirkpatrick and Flaco Jimenez, is enough to show that the idea they're beginner boxes, not good enough for proper players or somehow "substandard" is complete rubbish.
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on November 10, 2009, 04:18:56 AM
Hmm pretty good for an old Double Ray

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dv2XjpuqtyA&feature=related
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Christopher K. on November 10, 2009, 04:47:22 AM
Hmm pretty good for an old Double Ray

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dv2XjpuqtyA&feature=related

His playing reminds me a little of what Tommy Peoples might sound like if he could play an accordion.  By the time he finishes, I think, is that even the same tune?  Quite an interpreter!   :||:
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: LDbosca on November 10, 2009, 01:16:19 PM
Ok, many of those guys mentioned can definitely play, I wouldn't consider Brendan Begley to be particularly good or technical but that's just me. Anyway, just a suggestion about spending all that money on a cheaper box, if the hohner's for you then don't mind me...
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Stiamh on November 10, 2009, 01:33:16 PM
In that case you probably wouldn't consider Charlie Piggott or Mary Staunton or Andrew Mac Namara technical either. I wouldn't know about that - but they make really lovely music on old Hohners.

(Yes I know Andrew Mac plays an old Paolo most of the time but he used a Hohner B/C on Open Hearth.)
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: triskel on November 10, 2009, 02:03:44 PM
What kind of Box is John playing on this bit.  Is that a Hohner Gaelic?

No, that's an Orfeo.
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: triskel on November 10, 2009, 02:35:14 PM
... I wouldn't consider Brendan Begley to be particularly good or technical but that's just me.

In that case I'm beginning to think I might not be too keen on what you'd describe as "serious technical ability" - 'cos I'd consider Brendan one of the best, and I spent a lot of nights listening to him play at Hughes' in Dublin, in the '90s.
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: LDbosca on November 10, 2009, 03:06:23 PM
I saw him in UCC a few years back with Caoimhin O Raghailligh, he kept doing really loud cuts that were out of the key he was playing in and he was playing very loud and hard with such a sensitive player, I found it a bit of a mismatch and I didn't think a whole lot of his playing. Guys like Colm Gannon, Benny McCarthy, Danny O'Mahony, Joe Derrane and Mairtin O'Connor would be some of the players I would rate, I don't know if they are to your taste or not.
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: LJC on November 10, 2009, 03:49:39 PM
Technical ability has nothing to do with the box your playing. The lists of people who play Hohners well is huge. What about all of the Scottish players who use them? No technique there?
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: LDbosca on November 10, 2009, 05:51:24 PM
What I mean is that when technique gets to a certain level then a box that does not respond quickly enough will let you down. I'm suggesting that people with a very high level of technique generally chose to play an instrument that serves that technique and I don't know many players that I regard highly that do play hohners. I don't play Scottish music so I'm afraid I can't really comment on Scottish players or the models of Hohners that are used in Scottish music. As I said before, if you really think Hohners respond and play as well as the noted Italian boxes then don't mind me and work away, I was just saying that from my point view it seemed like one high-end instrument would be better than messing around with several Hohners. Again, just the way it looked to me.

Also, I was under the impression that Mary Staunton played a Castagnari these days...although I don't feel the "who plays what" arguments will get us very far...
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Theo on November 10, 2009, 06:06:18 PM
I think we are in danger of getting off topic here (what! thread drift on mel.net oh dear).  The original question was about the choice of type of reeds from someone who is a fairly new player who is looking for a box that might keep him happily playing for a few years, and does not want to spend a shedload of money.  I think his question has been well answered by earlier posts.  If we all agreed on what was the 'best' box/reeds etc then this would be a very dull place, so can I please ask anyone wants to continue the discussion from recent posts to please start a new topic.
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: rees on November 10, 2009, 06:38:33 PM
Theo said please twice in one sentence. He is serious!  ;D
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Theo on November 10, 2009, 08:36:34 PM
Nice to know someone pays attention to my babbling.   :o
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Quebecois on November 10, 2009, 09:17:29 PM
I guess it's often happening that people who are new to an instrument get obsessed with technology and try to find shortcuts or easy ways of either "playing better" or "sounding better" by altering their instrument instead of concentrating on their technique! A Hohner should sound like a Hohner, no matter who plays it, and changing the reeds won't make anyone a better player, no offense intended.
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on November 10, 2009, 10:13:34 PM
I guess it's often happening that people who are new to an instrument get obsessed with technology and try to find shortcuts or easy ways of either "playing better" or "sounding better" by altering their instrument instead of concentrating on their technique! A Hohner should sound like a Hohner, no matter who plays it, and changing the reeds won't make anyone a better player, no offense intended.

Actually that is kind of offensive....the implication is that I'm taking a short cut in order to sound better without working harder.  I'd be the first to tell you that having a stradivarius won't make you Yehudi Menuhin, but that said there is nothing wrong with wanting your box to sound it's best.  If that can be achieved with tuning or new reeds or tinkering with one's instrument then I think that's hardly cheating.  I have no illusions about where I am as a player, I simply want the best sound I can get out of my box. 
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Steve C. on November 10, 2009, 11:02:08 PM
No, no I think that Mr. Quebec is quite right.  From my own experience, I have often thought that "if only I had an X"  I would be able to play like "Y".  But also based on my limited experience, what I do agree with is the question of sound or tone.  I think a lot of us Hohner players really wish we had that less tremolo, drier sound, and that the posters recommended a general "drying" of the current instrument are on track to providing reasonable happiness at (very) reasonable cost.  If I understand it, it is not hard or expensive to dry out a tuning, using the current reeds.
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: RickC. on November 10, 2009, 11:08:25 PM
The way I read the original question, it was asking whether it was worth it to put the better part of a thousand bucks in a Hohner to give it a different sound (and it's been mentioned that retuning it will do the same thing at a fraction of the cost).

 I didn't see anywhere Ajay expressing the notion that new reeds would make him the new Jackie Daly.


                  Rick
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: EeeJay on November 10, 2009, 11:19:00 PM
As far as improving sound goes, reeds are only part of the recipe...

Other ideas - shaping/profiling the holes in the soundboard... help to provide better airflow if you want to reduce key travel... and/also reaming the holes to a slight taper.

Varnishing the insides... less internal sound absorbtion/more projection...

And an odd little tip picked up from this book  (http://www.amazon.de/Akkordeon-Jazz-Akkorde-Norbert-Seidel/dp/3925572090/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1257894080&sr=8-2)(possibly might make some impact in a big box like the Corso)... use thick card (or varnished card) to create internal baffles/chambers to 'shape' the sound... could be an interesing experiment in itself...

And to blazes with Hohnerphobia. The notion of a universally good high end box is, unfortunately, inadequate. I've encountered several junky posh lemons that a decent tricked out Erica would beat hands down...

Ed J
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Falseknight on November 12, 2009, 08:47:52 PM
Didn't Hohners used to be high end boxes once?
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Theo on November 12, 2009, 08:59:08 PM
They certainly included high end boxes in their range, notably the Morino models and later the Gola models.  The Gola models are still available, but only as piano accordion, and possibly chromatic button accordion.  No diatonics that I know of.

Many of the Club models were high end instruments in their day too.
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: IanD on November 13, 2009, 02:33:44 PM
Tony Hall is the champion of the Pokerwork (though some of his albums have a little bit of overdubbing?)

Maybe, but in some cases even though you'd swear that what he was playing was overdubbed (try Flowers of Edinburgh) it isn't, I've seen him play like this live on many occasions. He just seems to have more fingers than normal human beings...

Ian
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Owen Woods on November 13, 2009, 02:57:16 PM
Tony Hall is the champion of the Pokerwork (though some of his albums have a little bit of overdubbing?)

Maybe, but in some cases even though you'd swear that what he was playing was overdubbed (try Flowers of Edinburgh) it isn't, I've seen him play like this live on many occasions. He just seems to have more fingers than normal human beings...

Ian

It's more than that though, he hardly seems to make any effort to produce these sounds. If you're going to be better than everyone else then you should really put on a grimace to let people know that it isn't as easy as you're making it out to be :P
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: IanD on November 13, 2009, 06:24:15 PM
Tony Hall is the champion of the Pokerwork (though some of his albums have a little bit of overdubbing?)

Maybe, but in some cases even though you'd swear that what he was playing was overdubbed (try Flowers of Edinburgh) it isn't, I've seen him play like this live on many occasions. He just seems to have more fingers than normal human beings...

Ian

It's more than that though, he hardly seems to make any effort to produce these sounds. If you're going to be better than everyone else then you should really put on a grimace to let people know that it isn't as easy as you're making it out to be :P

Trouble is, I suspect that to TH -- after all these years -- it *is* as easy as he's making it out to be...

Ian

P.S. In Flowers of Edinburgh, I *still* can't work out how he can play a tune and two counter-melodies -- one across the rhythm of the other two -- simultaneously on the right hand :-(
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Owen Woods on November 13, 2009, 06:53:28 PM
Do you have a URL for that? I don't think that I have it and would be interested in hearing it.
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Martin J on November 13, 2009, 07:23:51 PM
I'm late to this thread but having a Castagnari that I absolutely love and being a great extoler of it's virtues I think I am well placed to say that my Hohners, yes I have several, are absolutely irreplaceable for the tunes I play on them.

LDbosca, I don't know you so I may be well out of order but it seems you are confusing speed with technique.

There are many fabulous players out there but Tony Hall does stand tall amongst them and yes he is modest.  I have noted his emotions when the going gets tricky, his pipe emits more sparks and flames than is normal during his playing.  It is believed by some that he has six fingers and that they are all over 8" long, all we know is, he's called Tony Hall.

Back to Ajax and the thread, I didn't read it that anyone was criticising either directly or by inference, they were just sharing their experiences most of which support you in re tuning the box you've got.

All the best with your project.
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: LDbosca on November 13, 2009, 08:23:16 PM
LDbosca, I don't know you so I may be well out of order but it seems you are confusing speed with technique.

I assure you I'm not. I completely understand that being a fast player isn't much in itself (and I don't have much time for people who think speed is what it's all about), when I speak of technique I mean exploiting the full range of subtleties available on the instrument. I believe to do that an instrument with the best possible response and minimal mechanical noise is required. My experience of playing Hohners (which is restricted to Ericas and Double Rays in B/C and Csharp/D) is that they haven't provided these attributes to the extent some other boxes have.

It was initially asked if it was economically sound to place a very expensive set of reeds into a Hohner instrument and it seemed to me that for the same money a more expensive accordion could be bought, this being what I would do. That's not exactly "hohnerphobia" now is it? It wasn't my intention to offend any Hohner fans, it's just been my experience that most Irish box players use them as a starter instrument and move up the ladder as it were. I'm sure there are myriad examples to the contrary...and I'm glad there's plenty of people enjoying their Hohners// :|||:
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Martin J on November 13, 2009, 10:56:18 PM
.. I completely understand that being a fast player isn't much in itself (and I don't have much time for people who think speed is what it's all about), when I speak of technique I mean exploiting the full range of subtleties available on the instrument. I believe to do that an instrument with the best possible response and minimal mechanical noise is required. ..
Thanks for your reply.  Although I agree with you about having the best possible response and minimal mechanical noise where I have been most impressed is by players who can make a Hohner sound brilliant.  My view of your comments was coloured when I think you sold yourself short regarding JK and TH particularly as they are noted for subtleties, see Ian's post re Tony.  I do agree there are tunes I cannot do justice to on my Hohners but maybe I haven't been lucky enough to have tried a top end Hohner box or maybe I'm just not good enough to make the Hohner perform as I would like it to.  Nor may I add, continuing thread drift, have I ever played a box fettled by Theo which apparently are more responsive and mechanically quieter.  On thread again it seems that you are also advocating tune the box you have, don't throw heavy money at it, save that for a top end instrument.
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: IanD on November 13, 2009, 11:00:29 PM
Do you have a URL for that? I don't think that I have it and would be interested in hearing it.

No URL, but here's the last time through squashed down to a 32kb/s mono mp3 to get in under the 256kb file size limit...

Ian

P.S. Guaranteed no overdubbing !
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: EeeJay on November 14, 2009, 02:11:06 AM
I'm sure there are myriad examples to the contrary...,and I'm glad there's plenty of people enjoying their Hohners// :|||:

Oh, sure there are... Kepa likes 'em (http://www.flickr.com/photos/berritzen/307729806/sizes/l/)... 8)

Yes... he owns Italians too (http://www.flickr.com/photos/berritzen/307729782/sizes/l/)... but all the same, as far as technique goes, triki players arguably ask more out of an instrument than most... so choosing (and sticking with) a Hohner has to say something...

Ed J
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Martin J on November 14, 2009, 10:57:38 AM
Oh, sure there are... Kepa likes 'em (http://www.flickr.com/photos/berritzen/307729806/sizes/l/)... 8)

Yes... he owns Italians too (http://www.flickr.com/photos/berritzen/307729782/sizes/l/)... but all the same, as far as technique goes, triki players arguably ask more out of an instrument than most... so choosing (and sticking with) a Hohner has to say something...

Ed J
12 bass  Polka work - wow, where do they come from ?
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: EeeJay on November 14, 2009, 11:10:47 AM
12 bass  Polka work - wow, where do they come from ?

Custom shop jobbie I'd guess... using Corona bits... though the buttons look more like an Italian cross kit... could be Zero Sette bits...

That, and it's possibly also been tricked out with a full length air bar - these were fitted to a lot of pre-Corona, 20s/30s Hohner 3 rows... it's a 'relict' of earlier diatonic accordions that the Basques seem to have found useful/vital to what they do, and keep as part of the spec on new boxes...

Ed J
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: ganderbox on November 14, 2009, 11:38:49 AM
I believe to do that an instrument with the best possible response and minimal mechanical noise is required. My experience of playing Hohners (which is restricted to Ericas and Double Rays in B/C and Csharp/D) is that they haven't provided these attributes to the extent some other boxes have.


My Hohner Club has had the button travel limited, and it has a very, very fast keyboard. It is very light and responsive, and repeated notes seem easier to play on it than on my other boxes. Also, the buttons are just slightly closer together (both vertically and horizontally).


12 bass  Polka work - wow, where do they come from ?

Mike from St Ives, who did my Club, has a 12 bass Club which he did for himself. All Hohner bits, I would think.
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Owen Woods on November 14, 2009, 01:49:08 PM
No URL, but here's the last time through squashed down to a 32kb/s mono mp3 to get in under the 256kb file size limit...

Ian

P.S. Guaranteed no overdubbing !

Are you sure?! That doesn't seem possible :D

Thanks very much for that. I've been trying to do similar things on my box with Hesleyside but had decided that it was far too difficult  :|bl
Title: Re: Italian Reeds in a Double Ray...is this good economics?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on November 14, 2009, 04:29:29 PM
I believe to do that an instrument with the best possible response and minimal mechanical noise is required. My experience of playing Hohners (which is restricted to Ericas and Double Rays in B/C and Csharp/D) is that they haven't provided these attributes to the extent some other boxes have.


My Hohner Club has had the button travel limited, and it has a very, very fast keyboard. It is very light and responsive, and repeated notes seem easier to play on it than on my other boxes. Also, the buttons are just slightly closer together (both vertically and horizontally).


I just found a 12 Bass Erica on Ebay c/f tuning black in color.  Is this a Polka box?  So I posted the link over in Buy and sell
 
12 bass  Polka work - wow, where do they come from ?

Mike from St Ives, who did my Club, has a 12 bass Club which he did for himself. All Hohner bits, I would think.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal