Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Recordings and Videos => Topic started by: Hugh Taylor on February 02, 2023, 09:53:26 AM

Title: Delicate playing
Post by: Hugh Taylor on February 02, 2023, 09:53:26 AM
Whilst learning a triple time hornpipe called Quakers Hornpipe, I came across this video of Mikey Kenny playing Iron Legs.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UAwSc1nXJhQ
I was immediately struck by the similarity of his playing to Martin Hayes, delicate and nicely decorated.

I sometimes think that we in the 'English' tradition play almost exclusively in a robust style of playing that focuses on dancing. Perhaps in part it is the inability of a melodeon to play those decorations that a fiddler can, but I'm minded to think that it's more than that.

Thoughts?
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 02, 2023, 12:52:44 PM

  Lovely! I don’t play it, but would be very pleased if I could express it like that. And in some countries you could dance it to that eg a scottishe?

   Any Irish dancers around - I hear the video as … sprung 6/8 ryhthm. Slip jig?
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Julian S on February 02, 2023, 01:24:15 PM
Really good. Inspirational and thought provoking playing.

Julian
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Anahata on February 02, 2023, 03:26:22 PM
Tony Hall is the first melodeon player that springs to mind with something like that style.
Also on Hard Core English CD1 track 10, Tom Tolley's Hornpipe credited as "Magnetic North" but actually a melodeon solo by Robin Shepherd who I think of as a fiddle player but whose melodeon playing style has obviously been inspired by Tony Hall.
In a slightly different way, Andy Cutting when he's not belting out dance music on a 1-row.
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Pearse Rossa on February 02, 2023, 08:13:56 PM
Perhaps in part it is the inability of a melodeon to play those decorations that a fiddler can

I think that statement should be qualified; it's not true of a semitone system.

Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on February 02, 2023, 10:58:56 PM
Tony Hall is the first melodeon player that springs to mind with something like that style.
Also on Hard Core English CD1 track 10, Tom Tolley's Hornpipe credited as "Magnetic North" but actually a melodeon solo by Robin Shepherd who I think of as a fiddle player but whose melodeon playing style has obviously been inspired by Tony Hall.

Magnetic North’  are Geoff Bowen, Robin Shepherd & Gordon Tyrrall. The track is taken from the CD put out to support the first Joshua Jackson manuscript tunebook, The Miller's Jig. There is some wonderful playing on it and it is highly recommended. The tune books are fascinating, as well. You used to be able to buy both directly from Rob. I don't know if you still can. The web site is still there and it's easy to find, but the information on it seems to be dated 2012.
http://www.robin-shepherd.co.uk/index.php
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Anahata on February 02, 2023, 11:18:27 PM
Magnetic North’  are Geoff Bowen, Robin Shepherd & Gordon Tyrrall.
Yes, I knew that; sorry if I gave the impression that there was some mysterious inconsistency on the CD. I know all three of them, Geoff and Gordon particularly well. I may even have a copy of that CD lying around somewhere, and I have both Jackson books.
But we digress...
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on February 02, 2023, 11:46:45 PM
Magnetic North’  are Geoff Bowen, Robin Shepherd & Gordon Tyrrall.
Yes, I knew that; sorry if I gave the impression that there was some mysterious inconsistency on the CD. I know all three of them, Geoff and Gordon particularly well. I may even have a copy of that CD lying around somewhere, and I have both Jackson books.
But we digress...

It is a worthwhile digression. I just wanted to give an unqualified plug for the Miller's Jig CD. My wife bought me both when I took up the mandolin. I fell in love with it. It is still the music I would most like to play. played in the way I wish I could play it. Tom Tolley's is a great bit of delicate English melodeon playing to my ear.

Not really off topic.
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Becci Pamely-Bast on February 03, 2023, 06:41:36 AM
Yes, it’s more than that. I was fortunate enough to do some workshops with French diatonic accordion player Martin Coudroy last year (and Benjamin Macke, who is also excellent). But Martin did a lot of work with us on using a combination of bellows control and fingering to shape the notes and add texture. It was really enlightening. Here’s an example of his playing: https://youtu.be/wiIchz1CFWU
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: pbsalt on February 03, 2023, 10:04:44 AM
English players of  semi-tone systems might not be able to put in the decorations of fiddle players but as Becci says there are  techniques for delicate playing   with bellows control.
I'm always in awe when I listen to Ollie King's "Gambit" CD and his  playing of "Shooting" -  brings tears to my eyes ( in a good way ) 

And must go listen to the Millers Jig CD  again ( just discovered I've 2 copies of this if they are no longer available) and anyone wants one .

And must go an look up the Quakers Hornpipe to see if it is a 3/2 that I know ( I'm still working on Sheffield Fair and The Miller of Perth set Hugh which I heard you play at Whitby ).   

What a great forum for preventing" staleness
Paul
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Andy Next Tune on February 03, 2023, 10:14:20 AM
I think there are a lot of English melodeon players who play with delicacy and add ornamentation. 
A few have already been mentioned, but for example there's also Julian Sutton, Paul Young, David Gray.
It definitely is not an intrinsic melodeon problem, but skill and a desire to play in that style.

What struck me about Hugh's original post was the tune which was being played delicately.
I'd never heard Iron Legs played in the style, it is normally thrashed out robustly at sessions!

Perhaps there's a Theme of the Month lurking here? English session tunes played delicately!!  ;D
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Anahata on February 03, 2023, 11:04:09 AM
I may even have a copy of that CD lying around somewhere, and I have both Jackson books.

... I just wanted to give an unqualified plug for the Miller's Jig CD. My wife bought me both when I took up the mandolin. I fell in love with it. It is still the music I would most like to play. played in the way I wish I could play it. Tom Tolley's is a great bit of delicate English melodeon playing to my ear.

I found mine! Geoff gave me an old CDR copy (which suggests that it may not be available to buy now), with a promise to send MP3s if the CD didn't play. I found the emails about it, and the intact copied tracks on my hard disk. It is indeed lovely stuff - I was first impressed at the precision with which the two fiddles played together, but there's other gems like Gordon tackling the Morpeth Rant at speed on guitar, and of course Robin's melodeon track mentioned above. That may be the only melodeon track, but I need to listen through the whole album again anyway. Thanks for the reminder of its existence!
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: MikeK on February 03, 2023, 12:53:57 PM
I sometimes think that we in the 'English' tradition play almost exclusively in a robust style of playing that focuses on dancing.

I got talked into playing a few tunes for a Burn's night last week. It was agreed that at the end of the night, I  would play 'Will you no Come Back Again'.
Sometime during the evening it was arranged that a very good local lady singer would sing along and everyone would join in with choruses. Well, I started with playing the chorus at the usual volume and then played the verses very softly so the focus was on the singer and then raising the volume for the choruses.
She glared at me and I thought 'oh hell I'm in trouble'.
Later, she  apologised saying that no one with an accordion had ever lowered their volume while accompanying her.
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Pearse Rossa on February 03, 2023, 02:22:10 PM
English players of  semi-tone systems might not be able to put in the decorations of fiddle players

Why not?
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: arty on February 03, 2023, 08:17:54 PM
Martin posted this beautiful piece on the Theme of the Month thread but, I believe, it deserves to be on this thread too.
In my opinion, Martin's playing is never less than 'delicate' and expressive and musical and packed with emotion.
We are so lucky to have him and I for one, have learnt more by listening to Martin than any other player.
(By the way, that Mikey Kenny video in the original post is superb, isn't it!!!)

https://youtu.be/wTgOT2D2-9k
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on February 03, 2023, 08:43:16 PM
English players of  semi-tone systems might not be able to put in the decorations of fiddle players

Why not?

Because they can't play semi-tone instruments. Boom! Boom!
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: MikeK on February 03, 2023, 10:08:24 PM
English players of  semi-tone systems might not be able to put in the decorations of fiddle players

Why not?

Because they can't play semi-tone instruments. Boom! Boom!


I play a B/C box and I'm not very familiar with other tunings. Why can it not  be done on them?
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Pearse Rossa on February 04, 2023, 12:55:59 AM
English players of  semi-tone systems might not be able to put in the decorations of fiddle players

Why not?

Because they can't play semi-tone instruments. Boom! Boom!

Why not?
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Arnold on February 04, 2023, 09:12:25 AM
Well, I suppose you can’t slide to a note like you can on a fiddle, and even on a semitone box you don’t always have adjacent scale notes in the same direction eg G and A on a BC box, meaning certain ornaments need approximating. Anyway, I have found that listening to different instruments especially the fiddle, and trying to approximate that sound and level of expression on a box, can be a worthwhile exercise. I’m currently learning some tunes following Sam Sweeneys fiddle playing as closely as possible. It’s kind of impossible but still I think it opens up different avenues for expression…
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on February 04, 2023, 09:27:22 AM
English players of  semi-tone systems might not be able to put in the decorations of fiddle players

Why not?

Because they can't play semi-tone instruments. Boom! Boom!

Why not?

Because we don't  have time to learn how, we're too busy playing DG?
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Anahata on February 04, 2023, 09:40:57 AM
I think the whole discussion about ornamentation is a red herring.
On the the instruments usually used in Irish music, ornamentation can't be done in exactly the same way and is adapted to suit each instrument. Of course you can decorate tunes on a D/G melodeon, in a different way from a B/C, which is also different from a flute, or pipes or a fiddle.
On top of that, there are perfectly respectable Irish 1 row players!

Martin Hayes' playing is chacterised by a slow and relaxed style than can be emulated on any instrument in the right hands, and pedantically if you want to play legato there are more opportunities on a D/G than a B/C.
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Pearse Rossa on February 04, 2023, 10:49:18 AM
English players of  semi-tone systems might not be able to put in the decorations of fiddle players

Why not?

Because they can't play semi-tone instruments. Boom! Boom!

Why not?

Because we don't  have time to learn how, we're too busy playing DG?

I see. That's a good reason, I guess.
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 04, 2023, 11:33:14 AM

   Here’s another aficionado of extreme subtlety! https://youtu.be/mmuNydEkyK0
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Theo on February 04, 2023, 12:04:35 PM
Three masters of subtle box playing

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=NYQ3RafQYNM

I was on the dance floor on the occasion of that recording in a marquee at Halsway Manor.  It was pure magic. 
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Theo on February 04, 2023, 12:08:36 PM
And another

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ZrnNAOc82iU
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: pbsalt on February 04, 2023, 01:18:24 PM
English players of  semi-tone systems might not be able to put in the decorations of fiddle players

Why not?

OK apologies for taking the focus away from the original posting about Iron Legs. And my comment above should perhaps have said Some English players  (  or perhaps just myself ) of  semi-tone systems might not be able to put in the decorations of fiddle players .

And the Why not - would be because we ( I )  don't practice the ornamentation enough - given the a finite amount of practice time I'd rather focus on bellows control. 

I've written off Iron legs as a tune to learn  - having reached the age where I've realised that there are far too many tunes to learn to play well in a lifetime .

I think the problem for me with Iron Legs  on a D/G box is trying to get a sensitive chord   accompaniment to the B music - in which case an option would be not to play the chords and leave that to a sensitive guitar player. .
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Julian S on February 04, 2023, 03:27:46 PM
So personal short term project - Iron Legs (focussing on delicacy, chords AND ornamentation).
Personal long term project - find out more about ornamentation in Irish (and Scots) music - and what might or might not be possible on D/G.

For me, listening to and learning from other musical traditions is great.

Julian (currently in Glasgow for a couple of Celtic Connections concerts and rooting for Sam Mabbett in the Young Traditional Musician competition tomorrow !)
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on February 04, 2023, 04:40:07 PM

And the Why not - would be because we ( I )  don't practice the ornamentation enough - given the a finite amount of practice time I'd rather focus on bellows control. 


\If I attempt to onrnament a tune I tend to use the bull in a chinashop approach of blundering in ad lib and trying not to knock the note over. I mostly end up with cuts, as a result.

I wonder if I should go for Micheal Coleman's approach of learning ornaments with the tune and always playing them the same in the same positions for each time through.

And, bellows control is part of ornamentation.
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 05, 2023, 01:59:44 PM


   The Pignol & Milleret DVD “Aire et Geste” is essentially all about bellows control and that “so important” air button 🤔

         https://mustradem.com/boutique/en/dvd/9-l-air-et-le-geste-3760238260375.html

  As such the music they’ve chosen for their teaser video isn’t the best paradigm, though … it finishes well 😎 (DVD has English subtitles)
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Arnold on February 08, 2023, 09:26:15 PM
My top pick for delicate playing on the one-row (an instrument possibly not often associated with subtlety) is Oscar Woods. This performance I think comes as close to musical perfection as is possible on the instrument (and is why I must have one! ;)): https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=7VoU8OyBXj8
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Lizzy on February 11, 2023, 07:01:19 PM
I am an experienced and  delicate player and have often been  drowned out and not appreciated in numerous sessions. The talk here  is ( and I have only read some of it) seems to be technical.  Question, isn't the wonder of playing and feeling the melodeon in your rib cage, heart, and soul far more important than anything else. As I have already said I havn't read all the posts so please excuse that. 

For me that is delicate playing .  Ha struggling now to make sense ..well thats ok

Oscar Woods playing has been always there in my learning . Wonderful playing

Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Ellison on February 11, 2023, 07:26:41 PM
I am an experienced and  delicate player and have often been  drowned out and not appreciated in numerous sessions. The talk here  is ( and I have only read some of it) seems to be technical.  Question, isn't the wonder of playing and feeling the melodeon in your rib cage, heart, and soul far more important than anything else.

Dear Tiny
Had I written a response, those would have been my words exactly. We should duet  ;)
Martin
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Lizzy on February 11, 2023, 09:14:47 PM
Thank you Martin,

I am a player from the heart and not so much the brain although I do have one  (:)

Lizzy
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 12, 2023, 09:24:00 AM

   I can still remember a sweet mini session with Tiny and her friend in the bar at a middle England festival ? Shrewsbury.

   All three (I hope) listened and responded to what the other two were playing. Nobody sped up, or played loudly. It was delightful.
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: arty on February 12, 2023, 12:01:23 PM
Question, isn't the wonder of playing and feeling the melodeon in your rib cage, heart, and soul far more important than anything else.

First of all, I will say that I am definitely NOT an experienced player but I absolutely connect with what is said here about 'playing with heart'. YES!!! That is where the music is found.
 
I have never played in a session and don't really have the desire to, even if there was one in my neighbourhood. However, I do occasionally play with a group of friends, 2 fiddles, a penny whistle and a concertina, which I find both enjoyable and frustrating in the same measure. Frustrating, because, in your words, Tiny, 'rib cage, heart and soul are far more important than anything else' but it seems everyone else, (all very competent musicians), play the notes according to mathematics. By this I mean a very strict rhythm with little room for expression and feeling.

When I am playing alone, e.g. I like to stretch a note and shorten another, I like to vary the tempo a little, play loud and soft etc, etc, in order to create feeling but I can't do that when I am playing with these friends because I feel I am being overridden by the sound of the majority. .We have talked about it and they look at me as if they don't know what the hell I am talking about!

Consequently, I enjoy playing by myself most of all. I have to say, in their defence, it must be very difficult to play with someone like me who is, maybe, more liberal with timing in order to add more expression to the music. It would mean that they would have to listen and follow.

If you read through this thread, you will see very little take-up about this side of the debate. As Tiny has said, the discussion is mostly technical.

Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Andy Next Tune on February 12, 2023, 12:22:27 PM
"It would mean that they would have to listen and follow."

Isn't that the problem? Someone should be leading the musical performance, and everyone else should be listening and taking timing etc from them not just their internal metronomes!

It is always a challenge when everyone is sitting, playing carefully off sheet music in front of them. Perhaps choose one tune you all know very well, and ditch the music. Then someone leads it and the rest follow, perhaps take it in turns to lead.

The music will hopefully begin to breathe and develop as they listen and follow.



Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 12, 2023, 01:13:46 PM

   The most important technical skill by far, once one is comfortable with the instrument is listening. OK, playing solo … do what you like, and if you get off on mimicking a wind up Victorian music box - go ahead.

   But in a small group of fellow delicates - one must be sensitive, and it only takes one to spoil that … intimacy. As with all forms of human intercourse, the journey is more important than the destination.
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: IanD on February 12, 2023, 02:03:16 PM
For real subtlety and feeling -- and superb piano playing as half of a tight duo, not just accompanying the box -- try this... ;-)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YgsEO2f02vE

If you haven't already, buy the album -- it's sublime, and this track is two minutes longer and even better... :-) :-) :-)

Then there's this -- just listen to the intro and outro... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IUofcKZm6uc

And this... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hjAhTNbXljc

Two fabulous musicians obviously having an absolute hoot... :-)
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Lizzy on February 12, 2023, 02:29:35 PM
Arty.

Experienced, well I used that word yesterday but may not have chosen it today  (:)

I understand what you share and have experienced the situations you describe so well in your post. I also love lengthening notes and bending phrases but as you say it works really when you play on your own.



Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Lizzy on February 12, 2023, 02:31:37 PM
Ian.

Thank you for sharing those music clips beautiful playing and enjoyment from the musicians.
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: IanD on February 12, 2023, 02:54:28 PM
Ian.

Thank you for sharing those music clips beautiful playing and enjoyment from the musicians.

You can support them by buying the album... ;-)
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 12, 2023, 03:12:17 PM

   I’d say that’s an arrangement, with the pianist amazingly fluent. And delicate 🙂 and she … certainly understands chords!
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: IanD on February 12, 2023, 03:25:49 PM

   I’d say that’s an arrangement, with the pianist amazingly fluent. And delicate 🙂 and she … certainly understands chords!

I suspect it's at least partly improvised, maybe by drawing from a whole stack of arrangements in her head -- the even longer track on the album (more than 7 glorious minutes of it...) has several other different bits including a lovely drop down to almost nothing except "twinkling" towards the end, I don't think she plays it the same twice out of maybe 10 times through...
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Julian S on February 12, 2023, 05:15:41 PM
Thanks for sharing those recordings, Ian - lovely playing. And the communication between the musicians is fundamental.
I'm not generally a fan of piano playing in traditional music, but that - and the stunning playing of Amy Laurenson in the Scottish Young Traditional Musician competition last Sunday has certainly made me reconsider.
I think sessions are often a set of individuals rather than an ensemble - and I suspect I've often also been guilty. But hopefully less so since I've been going to the Leveret events at Halsway (probably the highspot of my musical year) where listening, musical communication and expression, improvisation - and definitely delicacy are very much key. And valuing each other when playing together, irrespective of skill level.

Julian
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Dick Rees on February 12, 2023, 06:01:03 PM
There's a long tradition of piano in  Scots, Cape Breton and Grench Canadian dance music.  And here's Irishman Ryan Molloy backing Fergal Scahill:

https://youtu.be/uO6RueWkNfo

Check also Finnish pianist/arranger Timo Alakotila.
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 13, 2023, 08:42:46 AM

  We used to have a good ‘communion’ type session here in NW England at Style, a village tucked behind Manchester airport. Adrian Schofield, the punk bagpiper, would usually get there from Mid Lancs, and I travelled 40 miles or so from Wirral, but the core were from the Manchester and Stockport area.

  Often my neighbour here would come over with me. He plays no instrument, vaguely folky, in his teens used to be a member of Nic Jones’s folk club in Chelmsford. A fellow bridge player and 40 year friend. 

  After a couple of months he gave up. “There’s a conversation going on in that front bar, but I’m not part of it”! The room was indeed full of ‘listeners’.   I wouldn’t describe it as ‘delicate’ … Adrian would do his Northumbrian reels … really fast! But he didn’t ever speed up 😉 and it was quite beautiful music.
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Guy on February 13, 2023, 11:15:10 AM
Ian.

Thank you for sharing those music clips beautiful playing and enjoyment from the musicians.

Ian, thanks for this-they were great, new to me and I've bought a couple of the CD's now...

Cheers,
Guy
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: IanD on February 18, 2023, 02:00:34 PM
Ian.

Thank you for sharing those music clips beautiful playing and enjoyment from the musicians.

Ian, thanks for this-they were great, new to me and I've bought a couple of the CD's now...

Cheers,
Guy

When I go their duo album I sat and listened to it entranced. Twice through. And then my favourite tracks again. At least twice more each... ;-)
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Hugh Taylor on February 20, 2023, 12:37:26 PM
Thank you all for your contributions.
Whilst some have posted examples of playing with sensitivity and nuance, most/all of the videos are not of English dance music, which was the focus of my topic.
I remember being in the Radway in Sidmouth years ago, and a young person whom I'd never seen before, played a tune - probably a hornpipe - quite briskly but well. When he'd finished, an older - no names - said "you'd never dance a hornpipe at that speed". Apart from the fact that he should have been encouraging him, the fact that he wasn't playing for dancing meant the speed was irrelevant. I never saw the young player again.

It's the need to always playing robustly, as if someone was dancing, that I'm querying. Why not play the tune as if someone was just listening to it. Perhaps someone who disagrees with my line of thinking can post a video of a melodeon/diatonic accordion player playing an English dance tune with subtlety, nuance, and decoration.
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on February 20, 2023, 01:24:01 PM
TIt's the need to always playing robustly, as if someone was dancing, that I'm querying. Why not play the tune as if someone was just listening to it. Perhaps someone who disagrees with my line of thinking can post a video of a melodeon/diatonic accordion player playing an English dance tune with subtlety, nuance, and decoration.

This describes nearly all of Leveret's output.
[or am I missing something?]
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: arty on February 20, 2023, 02:01:42 PM
I too, have come across someone who tells me that I am playing it wrong if it is not dance speed or doesn’t have a strict danceable rhythm. My answer is always the same...where are the dancers? I don’t and have never played for dancers and, to be quite frank, that is not something that would interest me at this time. Playing music, is something I do for myself and more often than not, on my own.

I know this is a bit simplistic but....I always thought that people danced TO the music, not the other way round.  ;)
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Lester on February 20, 2023, 02:11:15 PM
I always thought that people danced TO the music, not the other way round.  ;)
Almost entirely the other way round for me. As a morris musician I very much play to the dancers. For instance for a set of 6 dancers when each pair in a corner dance are dancing the speed/emphasis/etc may differ markedly between the three repetitions.
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: IanD on February 20, 2023, 02:56:21 PM
I too, have come across someone who tells me that I am playing it wrong if it is not dance speed or doesn’t have a strict danceable rhythm. My answer is always the same...where are the dancers? I don’t and have never played for dancers and, to be quite frank, that is not something that would interest me at this time. Playing music, is something I do for myself and more often than not, on my own.

I know this is a bit simplistic but....I always thought that people danced TO the music, not the other way round.  ;)

Often the problem is not whether it's "dance speed" or not, but that it's played so fast that all the life and lift is knocked out of the tune and it just becomes a succession of notes smooshed together.

Irish music as often played in England is a good (or bad...) example of this where speed is seen as everything and all the lift and subtlety of the best traditional (and modern) Irish players is absent -- not the only culprit genre, but a common one... :-(

Which is not to say that super-slow and ploddy and pedestrian is a good thing either, as sometimes heard in English sessions... ;-)

P.S. I agree 100% with what Lester said, both when playing for Morris and for ceilidh dancing -- always watch the dancers, and find the "right" speed for them, which is not always the same...
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 20, 2023, 05:56:39 PM


  To be clear - if a melody is played as a dance tune - it should ‘inform the feet’. Basically that makes it danceable.

    As such your music remains in touch with its tradition.  OK, all things are legal in music, but if you play it in some other way, change the rhythm, medley to a completely different rhythm, play it at unsuitable speed - you are deluding yourself and others if you still call it “traditional music”.  An example:  the Beatle’s “twist and shout” was no longer of the Mexican “la bamba” tradition.

  Speeding up the pace “racing” … is a related, but quite different matter.  It is discriminatory against weaker players. It has absolutely nothing to do with dance, or tradition either. But my main criticism is that it’s ugly.   I have frankly only seen it here in Britain, and in New Zealand 😕
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: MikeK on February 20, 2023, 07:14:20 PM
Quote from: arty
I too, have come across someone who tells me that I am playing it wrong if it is not dance speed or doesn’t have a strict danceable rhythm.

 I've often been told  that I don't play some tunes in strict 3/4 timing. I play them as how they were  sung when I was young lad. There wouldn't
 be a musical instrument to be seen. There are some great young players in Scotland  led to believe that the faster they play the better.
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Becci Pamely-Bast on February 20, 2023, 07:27:33 PM
I too, have come across someone who tells me that I am playing it wrong if it is not dance speed or doesn’t have a strict danceable rhythm. My answer is always the same...where are the dancers? I don’t and have never played for dancers and, to be quite frank, that is not something that would interest me at this time. Playing music, is something I do for myself and more often than not, on my own.

I know this is a bit simplistic but....I always thought that people danced TO the music, not the other way round.  ;)

I think it’s six of one and half a dozen of the other. A sensitive musician will be watching the dancers and playing for them. Good dancers will listen to the music and dance accordingly. I do think musicians playing for dance need to have a steady rhythm and the right feel for the dance in question.

If you’re not playing for dancing then none of that matters and you can interpret the tune however you like! And you do, beautifully of course. (:)
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Becci Pamely-Bast on February 20, 2023, 07:33:17 PM
TIt's the need to always playing robustly, as if someone was dancing, that I'm querying. Why not play the tune as if someone was just listening to it. Perhaps someone who disagrees with my line of thinking can post a video of a melodeon/diatonic accordion player playing an English dance tune with subtlety, nuance, and decoration.

This describes nearly all of Leveret's output.
[or am I missing something?]

Agreed. I’d also suggest Spiers & Boden as musicians who sometimes play for “just listening.”
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on February 21, 2023, 10:07:52 AM
TIt's the need to always playing robustly, as if someone was dancing, that I'm querying. Why not play the tune as if someone was just listening to it. Perhaps someone who disagrees with my line of thinking can post a video of a melodeon/diatonic accordion player playing an English dance tune with subtlety, nuance, and decoration.

This describes nearly all of Leveret's output.
[or am I missing something?]

Agreed. I’d also suggest Spiers & Boden as musicians who sometimes play for “just listening.”

Definitely!
how about Boldwood?
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Julian S on February 21, 2023, 10:47:19 AM
Re. Leveret, I'm looking forward to them playing for a ceilidh at Shrewsbury Folk Festival. I'm sure they will be great - both to dance and listen to.
After all - not all English dance music has to be lumpy or stompy.

Julian
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Hugh Taylor on February 21, 2023, 12:12:37 PM
After all - not all English dance music has to be lumpy or stompy.

Should any of it?
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Lester on February 21, 2023, 12:26:19 PM

After all - not all English dance music has to be lumpy or stompy.

Should any of it?
Yes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P1quQR5u9OI
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Julian S on February 21, 2023, 12:39:16 PM
After all - not all English dance music has to be lumpy or stompy.

Should any of it?

Certainly questionable, Hugh. I do love a stompy Nottingham Swing dance, and I quite like lumpy hornpipes, but I'm more drawn to subtlety these days.

Julian
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 21, 2023, 02:04:21 PM


   â€¦ absolutely yes. As Lester’s Molly dance video demonstrates 🙂
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: nigelr on February 21, 2023, 04:46:50 PM
...post a video of a melodeon/diatonic accordion player playing an English dance tune with subtlety, nuance, and decoration.
Whilst this is highly subjective and others may disagree, I think Saul Rose is a master of exactly that:

https://youtu.be/mGTaocyW0m4
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on February 21, 2023, 05:00:38 PM
After all - not all English dance music has to be lumpy or stompy.

Should any of it?

It has it's own charm and can be great fun.
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Tufty on February 21, 2023, 05:16:04 PM
There should be room for many ways of playing English dance tunes, the focus of the original question. My own taste leans toward a fairly simple style, the bands that attracted me as a late teen were Oak, Old Swan and Flowers and Frolics. If the only playing I heard had been delicate I doubt I would have taken up melodeon... which some would say might not have been any great loss. Many of the current bands are clearly very talented but I cannot really get very enthused by them. Doubtless a symptom of "old geezer syndrome" it being a well known fact that nothing is as good as it was in the 1970s ;D
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Julian S on February 22, 2023, 07:40:59 AM
For me, learning from and being influenced by other styles feels a bit like learning another language - I still retain my original accent and have limited vocabulary and knowledge. And I'm sure that my original playing accent ((particularly for ceilidhs) is based on the music I heard and loved back in the late seventies - Old Swan , Flowers and Frolics, New Victory - amongst others - notably Hemlock Cock and Bull. I'm sure I'm still absorbing other influences but perhaps the capacity is less forty years on !
The difference from learning a new language is that we can mix and match the vocabulary - though whether others approve is another matter.
As for Leveret (and also Naragonia and Topette amongst others)  - it's their repertoire as well as their skill, style and interpretation that resonates with me - and it's so different from the music I first learned to play.


Julian
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Mcgrooger on February 23, 2023, 02:02:33 PM
This ain't 'delicate' and some people might call it 'stompy'.  It's still fab though! It's Jimbo playing his 3 late night tunes watched by 69thousand peops and loved by many.
 ;) @my good friend and bandmate, Hugh!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PIpZYznP1CY
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on February 23, 2023, 05:15:47 PM
This ain't 'delicate' and some people might call it 'stompy'.  It's still fab though! It's Jimbo playing his 3 late night tunes watched by 69thousand peops and loved by many.
 ;) @my good friend and bandmate, Hugh!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PIpZYznP1CY

I don't know what it is either, but I wish I could do it like that.
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 24, 2023, 09:27:40 AM

   At it’s heart, Hugh’s medley is solid, yomping late English style country dance reels, played bravely, and LOUDLY. Bravo!

   But this thread is about delicate playing. Well, I thought that it was very delicate too! There’s a … tidally strong rhythm, led from his left arm, but also … so many other things going on. He puts in swing, syncopation, and fantastic triplets, exquisitely timed to emphasise his other artistry. There seem to be very few comments on the video that don’t find it “wonderful” 🙂

  He’s very much expressing his own style skills here, and it would be difficult to “play along with” the other than perhaps simple, flat chords, or a drummer, with a very good ear. That is maybe because he is departing from “the right notes in the right order”.  I’m reminded of Eric Morecambe’s classic. As here, he played what Previn said to be “the wrong notes”, but they were “in the right order”?

  i’m beginning to think that a large part of “delicacy” in music is about exquisite timing. I (try to) vary timing a lot when I sing, to bring outbthe lyric. This guy’s doing the same on a melodeon. More of a journey than a “tune”?
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: IanD on April 15, 2023, 01:01:30 PM
This ain't 'delicate' and some people might call it 'stompy'.  It's still fab though! It's Jimbo playing his 3 late night tunes watched by 69thousand peops and loved by many.
 ;) @my good friend and bandmate, Hugh!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PIpZYznP1CY

I love playing with Jimbo (though he's changed a bit since then), we really click together, there's a kind of telepathy goes on -- either playing for Smiffs or in a session or ceilidh... :-)
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Chris Ryall on April 15, 2023, 01:16:40 PM

   very nice demonstration that delicate playing can still be … quite robust!
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: george garside on April 26, 2023, 10:31:41 AM
a half decent melodeon player should be able to play "lumpy bumpy"  or "extremely smooth" tunes or parts therof  or anything in between the key being bellows control.  The bellows are much more than just a bloody big air pump  and are the very give melodeons a vast range of dynamic qualities  that few other instruments can match(!??)   
"The buttons merely control which note or notes are to be played   ie. they are more or less "on/osmothff" switches . the way the bellow are used  controls everything else  so those who  think only in terms of rumpy pumpy playing are missing out on the potential to play  some lovely smooth tunes  with or indeed without any bass.

haunting slow airs and many other types of music respond very well to delicate variations of bellows pressure .etc etc

george

Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: Julian S on April 26, 2023, 01:06:16 PM
Toon and Pascale of Naragonia - wonderful exponents of delicate playing through bellows control - as demonstrated last weekend at Hawes.
Though whether I'll ever master stopping a note using the bellows (not taking the finger off the button )remains to be seen !

Julian
Title: Re: Delicate playing
Post by: george garside on April 26, 2023, 02:03:36 PM
oneof my favourite techniques is to use the bellows to add minute 'grace notes'  by chucking in minute bellows reversals so that a quick flick of the note on the other side of a button or buttons is thrown in free of charge.  Much easier to do than to explain  (playing with smallest possible bellows opening makes it easier)

george
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal