Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Ed Rennie on February 17, 2023, 08:39:03 PM

Title: 4th button starters. Wotcha got?
Post by: Ed Rennie on February 17, 2023, 08:39:03 PM
I believe there are such things as 4th button start melodeons. Goodness.

So, all you folks that have them, tell me this. When you've shifted all but the first two buttons towards your knee (assuming, for the sake of argument, they are the standard Hohner style accidentals and staying put) and you're not mucking about with the tuning of those thus shifted, what notes do you have on those now liberated/vacant buttons?

I'm not after the reasoning, just the information in a format not dissimilar to:

G row F#/F#, D Row F#/F# (seems improbable, but music making is a broad church)

I thank you

Ed



Title: Re: 4th button starters. Wotcha got?
Post by: Dick Rees on February 17, 2023, 08:55:53 PM
Maybe this...

http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/keyboards/2%20Row%20-%20D_G%20-%20G%20Scale%20with%20accidentals.jpg
Title: Re: 4th button starters. Wotcha got?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on February 17, 2023, 09:16:13 PM
Low  scales in three different formats:

1.  DG  pokerwork with button 2 push B+pull C on inner row and push F + pull D on the outer row. Standard accidentals.

2. DG Salterelle 2.4 row. Low G scale with standard accidentals, except that the lower push F+ pull Eb is moved to the helper row and push G + A on button 2 of the inner row.

3. Low F scale ( usual "Anahata") on a 2 row CF Hohner, standard accidentals.

Title: Re: 4th button starters. Wotcha got?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 17, 2023, 09:26:08 PM
On the newly liberated 2nd button on each row, ive got:-
G row = B push C pull
D row = G push A pull

Therefore the liberated buttons give the G A B C which extend the range down to low G.
That was what was on my Erika you tried the other week!.
( Q in disguise 🥸)
Title: Re: 4th button starters. Wotcha got?
Post by: rees on February 17, 2023, 09:46:13 PM
On the newly liberated 2nd button on each row, ive got:-
G row = B push C pull
D row = G push A pull

Therefore the liberated buttons give the G A B C which extend the range down to low G.
That was what was on my Erika you tried the other week!.
( Q in disguise 🥸)

This system is the low G scale a.k.a Anahata system.
Alternatively there is the pre-Anahata system with standard low notes on button 2.
G row - B/D
D row - F#/A
Title: Re: 4th button starters. Wotcha got?
Post by: smiley on February 18, 2023, 05:30:08 AM
My 4th button D/G low notes:

G row - D#/F, B/C, ...
D row - G#/Bb, G/B, ...

I'm always using the pull B on the D row, which is a common layout for one-row boxes in D. Great for Em tunes.
Title: Re: 4th button starters. Wotcha got?
Post by: baz parkes on February 18, 2023, 10:35:14 AM
My D/G Pressed wood has a 4th button start. All the other two rows are standard third button. It doesn't sem to make a difference when I play...As to what the notes are, you'll have to ask a big boy...
Title: Re: 4th button starters. Wotcha got?
Post by: IanD on February 18, 2023, 01:54:11 PM
G row : D#/F  B/C -- because the low C is really useful
D row : G#/Bb  F#/A -- because I use the F# as a low harmony note when playing in D

All on a 23-button Oakwood Model 4 so I also have the high notes. I got Martyn Banks to reduce the button spacing slightly (by 1mm IIRC) to make the extra button jump to the accidentals a bit shorter...
Title: Re: 4th button starters. Wotcha got?
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 18, 2023, 02:16:32 PM

   When Theo converted a D/G 3rd => 4th start for me I’d done some simulations and went for Anahata’s low G.

   Also ‘clubbed’ it, turning over the mid G-row D/E plate to be E/D.  Both … opened up an amazement of rt-end chords!

   To do both, 🤔 probably need an ‘in-chords’ style of play on the right. But 4th start is a massive improvement. In 20 years I’d used the higher pitched rt-end buttons … not at all!  Here’s how melnet voted, a decade+ ago

  http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7358.msg92844.html

   Follow up vote was … very pro “Anahata” variant, but less decisive

  http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7727.msg96025.html
   
Title: Re: 4th button starters. Wotcha got?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on February 18, 2023, 02:34:20 PM
Experiment on the 2.4 row (all the accidentals were on the helper row).

G row: (Low G scale)    G3/A3; B3/C4
D row: (Low D scale)    D3/E3; F#3/D4

The D row sounded pretty good. Playing in octaves it was like a church organ, LLMM, rather than LMM made it richer, but it didn't get used enough, so the low D/E gave way to low accidentals. I sometimes wish I'd left it low D and put more effort into getting better at the octave playing.

Title: Re: 4th button starters. Wotcha got?
Post by: Chris Marriott on February 18, 2023, 07:51:08 PM
Having the low G scale makes available lots of tunes that you couldn't otherwise play due to the lack of low B and C on a standard DG layout. Middle C in particular is a really useful addition.
Title: Re: 4th button starters. Wotcha got?
Post by: Julian S on February 19, 2023, 10:05:53 AM
Does anyone have a D/G/Acc three row with fourth button start ? I'm trying to see a way to have that middle C AND the pull D.

Julian
Title: Re: 4th button starters. Wotcha got?
Post by: Gena Crisman on February 19, 2023, 11:49:11 AM
I'm not after the reasoning, just the information

In DG speak, I have or have had instruments with low notes set up as

G row B/D, D row F#/A

G row B/C, D row G/A

G row B/C, D row D#/B

And I have friends who have

G row B/E, D row F#/A    (same pull E as already on D row)

G row B/D, D row G/C

Some of these aren't strictly forth start, as they either had no accs, or have a half row, but these are low note set ups I've seen.

Best of luck with whatever it is you're trying to find out, Ed.
Title: Re: 4th button starters. Wotcha got?
Post by: tirpous on February 19, 2023, 03:20:46 PM
Quote
Does anyone have a D/G/Acc three row with fourth button start ? I'm trying to see a way to have that middle C AND the pull D.

Julian

Julian, do you mean something along the lines of Paul Young's layout ??  http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,29034.0.html (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,29034.0.html)
Title: Re: 4th button starters. Wotcha got?
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 19, 2023, 04:03:57 PM

  Here are my choices. The  template 3rd start 3-row head end layout was one … favoured by the Oakwood group, and is basically “squished”. Original kit was simple C#/D/G with 1st buttons  F3/Bb3  F#3/B3 and  G3/A3

   G is my inner row, D = middle. My outer row is a rich source of accidentals, based on the C sharp diatonic scale.
   Note that C# is a semitone away from D, and a tritone away from G.  Hence I term it accs/D/G

   laying out my VanderAa replacement as a 4th start, I added (head ends)

       E4/D4 - reversal of the fourth button start on the D row
    C5/A4*- reversal of my G-row pull C, and the only pull-Ab on the layout
   C4/G3 - reversed low C and low G notes.  Gives me a push D7 chord.

  *The base layout is chromatic apart from Ab=push only. Hence the pull Ab facilitating mid range note runs, and chords in eg C minor

  FWIW left-end is ‘no-5ths’ standard D/G block at head aspect. Flatter chords below those. That gives me 2 basses in
            both directions, 6 in single directions. The inner left end row supplies the missing notes in opposite directions
            and monotonic Ab and C# buttons (bass-chromatic both ways ‘Grenoble’ 18-bass).

Rodec notation
Code: [Select]
name: Ryall 3-row 4th-start 18-bass accs/D/G
index: 270
blacknotes: C# Eb F# Ab Bb
transpose: 0
left:
               D3/A3    D0/A0    G3/D3    G0/D0   Bb3/F3   Bb0/F0
               B3/E3    B0/E0    C3/C3    C0/C0   F#4/Eb3  F#0/Eb0
               E0/A0   Ab0/Ab0  C#0/C#0   A0/G0   Eb0/F#0   F0/Bb0
right:
  E4/D4  G3/A3    E4/F#4  G4/A4   B4/C5   D5/E5   G5/F#5  B5/A5   D6/C6  G6/E6            <= my G row
 C5/Ab4 F#3/B3   A3/C#4  D4/E4  F#4/G4   A4/B4   D5/C#5 F#5/E5   A5/G5  D6/B5 F#6/C#5            <= my D row
C4/G3   F3/Bb3 Ab3/C4  C#4/Eb4  F4/F4  Ab4/Bb4 C#5/D5   F5/Eb5 Ab5/F5 C#6/Bb5 F6/D6 Ab6/Eb5            <= ‘accs’
Title: Re: 4th button starters. Wotcha got?
Post by: Julian S on February 19, 2023, 04:34:48 PM
Quote
Does anyone have a D/G/Acc three row with fourth button start ? I'm trying to see a way to have that middle C AND the pull D.

Julian

Julian, do you mean something along the lines of Paul Young's layout ??  http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,29034.0.html (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,29034.0.html)

I've seen Paul's layout - but not full three row D/G acc layouts with fourth button start. I have to say I hadn't thought about the possibilities of making it Acc/D/G as Chris has  - maybe I'm too used to 2.5 row boxes.

Julian
Title: Re: 4th button starters. Wotcha got?
Post by: Helena Handcart on February 19, 2023, 07:06:03 PM
G scale all the way in this house - the only boxes that aren't G scaled are a couple of Liliputs/Preciosas and an old 1930s  C/F (and the Giordy of course). All of the rest have been converted.

This includes Mr Handcart's boxes, Old Salty is now G scale across the main rows. I think I messed about with the half row too but that's probably outside the scope of this conversation.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal