Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Steve C. on November 11, 2009, 05:03:51 AM
-
Maybe first dumb question of the day: why? More specifically, I have seen many Handry players with the 12 or 18 bass, OK I understand. Why 16? What did he add/leave off and why?
-
I'm assuming this could have been an earlier prototype... prior to them being able to fit 18 in there...
At any rate, I know for a while Frans Van der Aa only used to offer 16 - then redesigned the mechanics/blocks to fit 18 in there.
That said.. I have seen a pic somewhere of an earlier Handry shaped lump with (I think?) 24 bass... though exactly what these buttons were linked up to (thirdless chords or melodic bass) I couldn't say...
Ed J
-
Maybe first dumb question of the day: why? More specifically, I have seen many Handry players with the 12 or 18 bass, OK I understand. Why 16? What did he add/leave off and why?
I believe his 16 bass is a *very* old Handry - at least 20 years - and was a custom job; in those days there were 12 bass Handry's and that was it. I think Castagnari weren't happy with the sound/weight compromises in making an 18 bass mechanism. However, at about the same time Marc Perrone did manage to persuade them to make him a 18 bass Handry, but they were absolutely one off's. These days, of course, the 18 bass is now part of their main product line; I assume improvements in components and manufacturing techniques mean what used to be impossible has become more doable.
I had the privilege of attending one of the first Folkworks summer schools many years ago with Marc Perrone (and Andy Cutting too!) - he loved showing off his 18 bass and explaining how Ricardo had to make do with 16...
Cheers,
Clive
-
What Clive says, certainly matches up with Riccardo's story as he relates it in the notes to his extraordinary solo album simply called Riccardo Tesi. He seems to have gradually evolved from a 8 bass to a more chromatic instrument as he pushed the boundaries of what is possible on a diatonic accordion. The 16 bass was a first attempt. He seems to hang on to his instruments: the 8 bass tracks on the album are played using his very first box.
How many of us still have our first box? (I think Tony Hall still plays his original C/F Erica?)
-
How many of us still have our first box? (I think Tony Hall still plays his original C/F Erica?)
Me! A D/G Castagnari Lilly in walnut. OK I had a pokerwork from March to August 1994 - but that 'proper' box was love at first sight. "I want one". The wife sighs. Babe in arms, Mathilda squirms as I try out her namesake tune (mysteriously not a waltz). Its now been round the world twice. Real women come and go in one's life, but I still love my 'Lilly'.
-
How many of us still have our first box? (I think Tony Hall still plays his original C/F Erica?)
... and me. My D/G Pokerwork can still be seen on my TOTM videos - the start of the month takes where I deliberately limit myself to a standard 2 row/8 bass box that is. I had it dry tuned a few years ago though. I still take it to sessions occasionally (despite having 3 12 bass boxes that play in D/G and are *much* more flexible) and when I do I'm always blown away by it's sheer power and punch. A cracking box.
Cheers,
Clive
-
How many of us still have our first box? (I think Tony Hall still plays his original C/F Erica?)
I still have my Pokerwork, it sits under my computer stand and I play it every day while my computer turns on but I get a lot less practice since updating the computer.
-
How many of us still have our first box? (I think Tony Hall still plays his original C/F Erica?)
Still have, and play, my first box a Hohner 1 row 4 stop in G which gives me the rights to advise all and sundry not to try and learn with a Hohner 1 row 4 stop in G as your first box.
-
I still have my first box, which is ......(you'll never guess).........a D/G Pokerwork!
It hasn't been played much for over 15 years, but I've never really wanted to sell it. It has been tuned, but needs more work as it's so clacky its impossible to play, and I've not got round to that. However, since I got my Club and seen how good a well done up Hohner can be, I'm quite excited about the idea of turning my "old faithful" into something special, and I'm going to get it sorted out.....but I'm getting my Dony tuned first!