Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Other Free Reed Instruments => Topic started by: Peter Cane on February 22, 2023, 06:24:17 AM
-
I have stripped all the reeds out of an almost new accordion. It was an air hog.
It had " Cagnoni reeds " label on the front of it.
How can I recognize a Cagnoni reed now I have a hundred of them ?
-
Short answer: You can't really.
Most italian reed makes will only stamp their brand into one or two reeds per row, and I've only recall seeing it on the higher grade reeds. Besides that, you have to look at the scale lenght, tool marks, reed profile, rivet type and marks from the riveting (hammer or press tool, depending on type) to get an idea of what reeds comes from where, and what reeds goes along with what reeds. Another good reason to keep organised, and having 'rows' neatly lined up in wrapping paper with clear ID in writing when not used in a box.
I've only seen the Cagnoni label on the outside of beginners grade boxes, where even the more basic Cagnoni qualities would be considered an upgrade from cheap machine grade reeds.
-
Short answer: You can't really.
Most italian reed makes will only stamp their brand into one or two reeds per row, and I've only recall seeing it on the higher grade reeds. Besides that, you have to look at the scale lenght, tool marks, reed profile, rivet type and marks from the riveting (hammer or press tool, depending on type) to get an idea of what reeds comes from where, and what reeds goes along with what reeds. Another good reason to keep organised, and having 'rows' neatly lined up in wrapping paper with clear ID in writing when not used in a box.
I've only seen the Cagnoni label on the outside of beginners grade boxes, where even the more basic Cagnoni qualities would be considered an upgrade from cheap machine grade reeds.
So they ( might) not be Cagnoni reeds which would part explain the Air Hogginess of it!
But you were bang on.
It was a beginner grade box.
I was so hoping that them being of good quality and close tolerances they would not need so much air to get them moving.
Ah well thats a mystery then.
Thanks for your reply.
-
They, quite possibly, just need a proper set up. I am more than capable of setting up top quality Voci Armoniche reeds to be air hogs (:)
-
They, quite possibly, just need a proper set up. I am more than capable of setting up top quality Voci Armoniche reeds to be air hogs (:)
Are we talking " voicing" the reeds Lester?
All I know is that they do like very nice, are very shiny but I have not looked to see if the reed tongues are hammered or pressed in.
I think I am more capable than you of total fluff ups.
Can you beat three accordions in the bin?
Still learning!!!!
I only do it to make room for the next blunder.
-
Are we talking " voicing" the reeds Lester?
Yep, by far the hardest part of melodeon fettling, getting reeds to speak at low pressure (quietly) but not to choke when played with high pressure (loudly)
-
Cagnoni make all grades of reed, from very nice tipo a mano, to the cheapest machine made reeds that are often fitted to cases and mechanism made in China and often sold under European sounding names. So the manufacturer I doesn’t tell you much unless you know what grade of reed.
-
Yes Lester I can appreciate the skill involved in voicing reeds.
Theo.
So in all probability the reeds I extracted are just bog standard and nothing to get excited about.
It was the worst made box I have had.
I kept the bellows and the rest of it went in the bin yesterday in total disgust.
We live and learn.
-
Anyone have any leads on how to order some reeds from Cagnoni? I don’t need an entire set, just trying to convert the low set in a Nuage to a middle set, going from LMM to MMM. Saltarelle hasn’t answered my query, Cagnoni has informed me I’d need to contact one of their dealers, and Charlie Marshall has no plans to order anymore anytime soon. I tried ordering a couple sets from Carini last year and after 10 months and no news decided to abandon the order.
-
Most reed makers will not sell you a single set of reeds. Carini should be better for that.
-
Has anyone had trouble ordering from or communicating with Carini lately?
-
I’ve recently placed an order which generated an automatic email acknowledgment. It’s quite normal for them to be unresponsive when busy.
-
My set of TAM Cagnoni reeds have a slash up in one corner (not that helpful) but a C stamped on the big bass reeds. On the other set of Cag dural reeds I don’t see the same marking.
-
Has anyone had trouble ordering from or communicating with Carini lately?
Yes, actually. A friend has 3 outstanding orders and hasn't heard anything from them.
-
Just had notice from FedEx that my stuff has been collected from Carini today
-
Theo, that's good news. The friend I mentioned just received his order a few days ago, too (3 months after placing it).