Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Tune of the Month => Topic started by: Clive Williams on February 23, 2023, 09:17:14 AM

Title: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: Clive Williams on February 23, 2023, 09:17:14 AM
Hello again, here we go! Time to vote, vote, vote!

- First up, from last month, The First of May - Traditional, and from the playing of William Kimber, https://youtu.be/HLygbHHg6E4?t=58

- Jenny Lind - thanks for the suggestion; surprised we haven't done this one too. Ideally needs a 2 row instrument, first part outside row, 2nd part inside row; here's Lester's version https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ijk0V3QWyDY

- Glorishears - like many morris tunes, there's lots of (sometimes very different) versions of this; here's Lester playing one of my favourite, Field Town, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fc5YC3dHdiY - and playing the completely different Bledington one. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nkaR4GT2pzk . As usual, any version is fine for playing for TOTM - pick your favourite.

- Ceci N'Est Pas Une Valse - this is written by Pascale Rubens of Naragonia, here played nicely by Mel, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kEO6Bm_GslM . I dare say it's named that for a reason, so if it's not a waltz, what is it? Answers below please!

Happy voting one and all!

Clive

-
Title: Re: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: CAB on February 23, 2023, 10:32:33 AM
- Ceci N'Est Pas Une Valse - this is written by Pascale Rubens of Naragonia, here played nicely by Mel, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kEO6Bm_GslM . I dare say it's named that for a reason, so if it's not a waltz, what is it? Answers below please!

The Magritte reference suggests it might be a meta-waltz.  :-\  Lovely tune, anyway.
Title: Re: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: Lester on February 23, 2023, 10:41:41 AM
Jenny Lind - thanks for the suggestion; surprised we haven't done this one too. Ideally needs a 2 row instrument, first part outside row, 2nd part inside row; here's Lester's version https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ijk0V3QWyDY (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ijk0V3QWyDY)
It should be noted that I am possibly the only one that considers the part in G to be the A music and the part in D to be the B music  8)
Title: Re: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 23, 2023, 12:20:34 PM

   Hesitation waltz? 🤔 Pascale plays her composition like this https://youtu.be/n_seu8I-6No

   There’s an underlying 9/8 there? Some dancers start doing a mazurka to it. but more likely, a pun or cultural reference of some kind.

   [edit] just listened on. She speeds up 😳 the second half of the video would do for a French bal folk waltz. They do it that fast!
         
    It might … just work as an Auvergne bourrée (note heartbeat rhythm) but it’s really quite fast to do anything but spin, and how would you get the dancers into the right positions? I’ll ask. 
Title: Re: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: heartshaped1 on February 23, 2023, 12:57:51 PM
Ceci N’est Pas Un Waltz - Pascale wrote this for teaching multiple different styles, hence the enigmatic title. When she taught it to us, we learned it as a Waltz, a Bourree, and a Mazurka. Hence it also appears in duplicate in different sections of the Naragonia tunebook! I’ve since learned another tune with Pascale nine different ways, which is even more fun!  (:)
Title: Re: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: Paul Jewell on February 24, 2023, 06:48:11 AM
Ceci N’est Pas Un Waltz - Pascale wrote this for teaching multiple different styles, hence the enigmatic title. When she taught it to us, we learned it as a Waltz, a Bourree, and a Mazurka. Hence it also appears in duplicate in different sections of the Naragonia tunebook! I’ve since learned another tune with Pascale nine different ways, which is even more fun!  (:)
Which of the tunebooks is it in?
Title: Re: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: heartshaped1 on February 24, 2023, 07:45:12 AM
Hi Paul,

It’s in the G/C tunebook as discussed recently here:

http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,21636.0.html

It’s a great book.

All the best,
Vicky
Title: Re: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: rees on February 24, 2023, 10:52:10 AM
On the Topic album The Milltown Lass by Rose Murphy she plays a couple of Irish polkas The First of May and The Last of June.
The First of May is no relation to the William Kimber tune but The Last of June is a version of Jenny Lind.
Title: Re: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: Paul Jewell on February 24, 2023, 12:38:14 PM
Hi Paul,

It’s in the G/C tunebook as discussed recently here:

Vicky
Many thanks Vicky!
Title: Re: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: tirpous on February 24, 2023, 02:42:19 PM
Quote
- First up, from last month, The First of May - Traditional, and from the playing of William Kimber, https://youtu.be/HLygbHHg6E4?t=58

This one must be a close relative of Fisher's Hornpipe (to my ear anyway).
Title: Re: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: Graham Spencer on February 24, 2023, 05:43:53 PM
[It should be noted that I am possibly the only one that considers the part in G to be the A music and the part in D to be the B music  8)

Yes, I think that's very likely!  ;D
Title: Re: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: Arnold on February 24, 2023, 06:32:53 PM
Several old recordings of Jenny Lind I’ve heard just keep it in a single key - Scan Tester, Harry Cox, Stan Seaman. I think it sounds pretty good like that on the one-row…
Title: Re: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: Anahata on February 24, 2023, 06:47:28 PM
The original composed Jenny Lind Polka has both those sections in the same key.  I think it also has more parts which aren't usually played by folk musicians.
The D/G change was invented by someone and has become popular, possibly because of recordings of that version. One is Alastair Anderson's Concertina Workshop around 1970, but I don't think he ws the first to play it that way.
Title: Re: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: rees on February 24, 2023, 06:49:25 PM
I usually play it in a single key which causes some confusion at sessions.
Title: Re: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: smiley on February 24, 2023, 08:41:37 PM
The original composed Jenny Lind Polka has both those sections in the same key.  I think it also has more parts which aren't usually played by folk musicians.
The D/G change was invented by someone and has become popular, possibly because of recordings of that version. One is Alastair Anderson's Concertina Workshop around 1970, but I don't think he ws the first to play it that way.

Jenny Lind was being played with with a key change going into the 2nd section in the 1850's - see https://tunearch.org/wiki/Jenny_Lind_(1) (https://tunearch.org/wiki/Jenny_Lind_(1))

In Australia the bush bands play a different second part, which surfaced when someone forgot how the turn went!
Title: Re: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: CAB on February 25, 2023, 12:07:51 AM
The D/G change was invented by someone and has become popular, possibly because of recordings of that version. One is Alastair Anderson's Concertina Workshop around 1970, but I don't think he ws the first to play it that way.

Jenny Lind was being played with with a key change going into the 2nd section in the 1850's - see https://tunearch.org/wiki/Jenny_Lind_(1) (https://tunearch.org/wiki/Jenny_Lind_(1))

That's brilliant.  I learned it first from Concertina Workshop but an old friend in the 1970s had a wonderful 78 recording (dating from around the 1920s) of the Henry Ford Dance Band (including cimbalom!) playing Jenny Lind much as we know it today except for some cheeky accidentals.  There are some examples of the Henry Ford Band on Youtube but sadly I can't find that particular one.
Title: Re: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: Anahata on February 25, 2023, 09:50:41 AM
Jenny Lind was being played with with a key change going into the 2nd section in the 1850's - see https://tunearch.org/wiki/Jenny_Lind_(1) (https://tunearch.org/wiki/Jenny_Lind_(1))

Er...
The Tunearch ref shows two versions of the tune. The one dated 1859 is in G for both first and second part of the tune.
I don't think you meant the third part, which is not played much these days, and which does seem go into D, despite lack of key signature for the change.

The second version of the tune on that page has the usual D→G key change that we all know, but that's dated 1978

(correction: second and third versions on the page both go D to G, and it's the third one that has a 1978 date. No date on 2nd one.)

I rest my case, yer honour.
Title: Re: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: baz parkes on February 25, 2023, 10:46:16 AM
The D/G change was invented by someone and has become popular, possibly because of recordings of that version. One is Alastair Anderson's Concertina Workshop around 1970, but I don't think he ws the first to play it that way.

Didn't The Albion Band do  much to popularise it when they paired it with Uncle Bernard's on Rise Up Like the Sun ?
Title: Re: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: baz parkes on February 25, 2023, 10:47:12 AM
I usually play it in a single key which causes some confusion at sessions.

Not if I'm there... :|glug
Title: Re: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on February 25, 2023, 12:15:40 PM
The oldest version I know of is credited to  by Anton Wallerstein with an A part in Eb and a B part in B flat. I haven't a date of publication, but I have seeb it ascribed to dates of1846 and 1850.

Page 1 here. I had to reduce the size which has affected quality but I have clearer copies.

This makes it clear that the earliest version of the tune has [the]  a key change.  ;D ;D ;D
Title: Re: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on February 25, 2023, 12:17:05 PM
Tunearch describes it as "A dance tune composed in 1846 as "Jenny Lind's Lieblings-Polka," attributed to the composer Anton Wallerstein (1813-1892), commemorating the "Swedish Nightingale," Johanna Maria "Jenny" Lind [1] (1820–1887), an operatic soprano."

Wallerstein setting Page 2. I had to reduce the size which has affected quality but I have clearer copies.
Title: Re: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: GBbox on February 25, 2023, 05:41:01 PM
Talking about recent publications that might have had an impact on the keys Jenny Lind is played in today, I can tell that I picked it up as a beginner from the Roger Watson's Handbook for Melodeon (1981), where is notated in D and G.

Yet it was also the very first tune in Dave Townsend's A First Collection of English Country Dance Tunes, that was published the following year. The transcription is in G, and I think it's the scan Tester's version.
Title: Re: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: Anahata on February 25, 2023, 10:07:16 PM
This makes it clear that the earliest version of the tune has the key change.

I have a copy of the same file, printed out here from the PDF. It has a key change in the middle, but look closely at the notes.If you call the two part version that most people play the A and B music, Wallerstein "as played at the Baltimore Museum" has:
AABBAA all in Eâ™­
(Trio)
CCDDCC all in Bâ™­

C and D parts are not in the tune that most people play.

I have a G/D transcription of the same as an ABC which I'll be attempting to play if it wins the poll, and might learn even if it doesn't.
I don't know where that came from, but I have an Eâ™­/Bâ™­ version as ABC which seems to have come via the John Chambers ABC tune finder and looks identical to yours, and I must have transposed the G/D version with ABC2ABC, though I don't remember doing it. It would have ben a few years ago...
Title: Re: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: smiley on February 25, 2023, 10:34:21 PM
Sorry Anahata - I shouldn't post anything until I've had my morning coffee.
When I played through the first tune at https://tunearch.org/wiki/Jenny_Lind_(1) (https://tunearch.org/wiki/Jenny_Lind_(1)) yesterday, my 'usual' chord change going into the B section (i.e. from a Gmaj to Cmaj) fitted the notes. So my sleepy brain interpreted that "chord change" as a "key change". I like that C part too.
I'd better go and vote for Jenny Lind now.
Title: Re: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: Mcgrooger on February 27, 2023, 12:27:17 PM
It seems interesting that the tune that has generated the most discussion and, I would guess, would result in the most postings isn't winning the vote.
Title: Re: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: CAB on February 27, 2023, 01:34:55 PM
an old friend in the 1970s had a wonderful 78 recording (dating from around the 1920s) of the Henry Ford Dance Band (including cimbalom!) playing Jenny Lind much as we know it today except for some cheeky accidentals.  There are some examples of the Henry Ford Band on Youtube but sadly I can't find that particular one.

Found it!  I'm not convinced this is the recording I remember hearing 40+ years ago but here is the Henry Ford Old Time Dance Orchestra playing Jenny Lind, all in D, in 1926.  It's recognisably our Jenny Lind from 50 seconds in.  Label suggests it's blended with another tune?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3PY6mmRG-r8 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3PY6mmRG-r8)
Title: Re: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: Graham Spencer on February 27, 2023, 03:52:20 PM
It seems interesting that the tune that has generated the most discussion and, I would guess, would result in the most postings isn't winning the vote.

I'm not quite sure why you'd say that - some of the best tunes ever are basically very simple and great fun to play and experiment with. "Challenging/complex" doens't necessarily mean "better".

Guess which tune I'm going to vote for..... :D
Title: Re: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: Hugh Taylor on February 27, 2023, 07:14:41 PM
I'm not quite sure why you'd say that - some of the best tunes ever are basically very simple and great fun to play and experiment with. "Challenging/complex" doesn't necessarily mean "better".

I never seem to be amazed at how one persons comments are mis-construed by another. Mcgrooger didn't say anything about complexity. He simply said Jenny Lind is generating a lot of postings, but was unlikely to win the vote.
Title: Re: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 27, 2023, 09:28:46 PM

   Neck and neck just now 🤔
Title: Re: Poll: Tune of the Month for March 2023
Post by: Mcgrooger on February 27, 2023, 09:33:35 PM
I voted for Glorishears.  :-\
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal