Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: mselic on April 25, 2023, 05:28:01 AM
-
I recently acquired this 1950s Baldoni Bartoli 19 key D/C#, 4v (LMMH) in a trade, and I have to say it's a very fun box to play indeed! Easy, light action (helped, no doubt, by the very long levers of the outer row) and wonderful tone with lots of character. I've tried a few of the Irish/American boxes from the 1930s-1950s (anywhere from 4-8 reeds per note) and they can sometimes take a fair bit of muscle to play, but this one was surprisingly relatively effortless and with good compression. I was surprised to discover the original reeds to be handmade (TAM or A-Mano), save for a few substitutions that someone had presumably used to replace broken reeds.
The box is quite tall but narrow, and the D row buttons are not only large, but also span a much great stretch than I'm used to!
I've only ever seen another example of this model once before, belonging to Hugh O'Rourke. His is identical except for a different pattern on the bellows. The only other mention of this model that I could find was in a catalogue from Ted McGraw's website, which shows the same instrument except with 7 couplers instead of just 2. I'm wondering if any of the proponents on this site of the old Irish-American boxes have seen this model before?
-
Photo of the keyboard mechanism.
-
Photo of the reedblocks and Baldoni catalogue showing a nearly identical model on the left.
-
Here's a clip of the box from the previous owner:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b2PJrWln2WQ
-
What a fab sounding box!
"Easy, light action (helped, no doubt, by the very long levers of the outer row)"
After your comment in the thread about button height, I'm just wondering how much top to bottom travel there is on those buttons?
-
The longer the lever, the less force required to shift the load (open the pallet). The trade-off of course is the button at the end of the lever having to travel a greater distance. I cleaned up the keyboard mechanism, evened out the spring pressure across both rows, re-padded under the keys and even lowered button height a little (with no perceptible change in tone, volume or pitch). The button travel on the outside row is about 5/32†or 4mm.
-
Great box indeed. I used to own it. I recognize the crooked R in Bartoldi.
-
I mean Bartoli.
-
"on the outside row is about 5/32†or 4mm."
I'm astonished! Looking at the 'levers' picture, I imagined that the button end of the lever was longer than the pallet end, which would result in the pallet lift being less than 5/32" (not very much!). But perhaps I'm not looking properly, and the pallet lift is actually a bit more?
-
"on the outside row is about 5/32†or 4mm."
I'm astonished! Looking at the 'levers' picture, I imagined that the button end of the lever was longer than the pallet end, which would result in the pallet lift being less than 5/32" (not very much!). But perhaps I'm not looking properly, and the pallet lift is actually a bit more?
I believe the pallet end is longer. All I know is that there is plenty of pallet lift. Even in the inside row of pallets, operating on its own independent axle rod, has decent clearance.
-
The million dollar question now is, any idea who would have made this model? I know that it's branded "Baldoni Bartoli", but I gather these boxes were either Italian made (and then branded in the US) or perhaps made by the IORO accordion company outside of New York?
-
Wow, nice box !!
Looking at the catalog on the Ted McGraw pages ( http://www.tedmcgraw.com/Baldoni_Ads.html (http://www.tedmcgraw.com/Baldoni_Ads.html) ), it seems to be a model 732 if one goes by the technical features, even though it has many visual attributes in common with the box used to illustrate model 731.
There is variation in many details of the boxes pictured: grille pattern, number of bellows pins, shape of keyboard plate, grille, and bass buttons cutout, etc... Maybe they came from different factories, or specs varied over time, or both !! Plus custom features were possible - for instance we're told model 731 has 19 buttons, I count 21 in the picture...
The fanned keys are interesting. In theory I guess they -could- be bent to change the key spacing to whatever you like, not sure you'd want to go there in practice.
-
I’m not sure I understand the wide button spacing. The levers could certainly have been bent and arranged in such a fashion to facilitate a more ‘standard’ button spacing, but oh well…certainly not going to try and make any such changes to this box. It is what it is! (And it’s still heaps of fun to play!)
-
My Walters D/C# 19 key has a similar wide button layout with larger D row buttons to C# buttons. I have large hands and find it much easier to play than a "standard" width box.
-
I thought about starting a new thread for this, but maybe we can just piggyback off this one; how many of our members here have old Irish-American boxes from the 1920s-50s - either D or D/C# - and can you share photos and any backstory? Would love to see more of what’s out there (and yes, I have been browsing through past posts on this topic).
-
The million dollar question now is, any idea who would have made this model? I know that it's branded "Baldoni Bartoli", but I gather these boxes were either Italian made (and then branded in the US) or perhaps made by the IORO accordion company outside of New York?
Definitely made in Italy, based on Aldo Mencacini's memories of these. Not sure which factory though. I have a 6 voice 15 key Baldoni-Bartoli here with a similar grille, maybe a bit earlier, and with a different coupler system that I should post at some point.
PG
-
I have that nearly identical box! Mine has a slightly different color in one celluloid, but otherwise the same. I can't play for beans, but I took it to the Catskills Irish Arts Week some few years ago, and a well-known "pro" played the heck out of it....they do sound like nothing else. One oddity with mine is the slide switches to LH, so sort of odd "bandoneion" sound. How 'bout yours?
-
I have that nearly identical box! Mine has a slightly different color in one celluloid, but otherwise the same. I can't play for beans, but I took it to the Catskills Irish Arts Week some few years ago, and a well-known "pro" played the heck out of it....they do sound like nothing else. One oddity with mine is the slide switches to LH, so sort of odd "bandoneion" sound. How 'bout yours?
I'd love to see a photo! I actually wish my couplers would allow for LH - I quite like the sound of that reed combo. Mine switches between LMMH and MMH, the latter not being to my taste, so I don't really use it. The LMMH sound has a great 'ring' to it. It's the 'melodeon' sound but with two rows!
If you have a photo, please share!
-
Here's a try.....I am never certain pictures get there, but fingers crossed.....This one was bought new by a friend's late father in '52 or '53; they went "to Chinatown" to pick it up, according to the story. Another member here dubbed her "Marilyn" because the elegance and vintage reminded him of her.
-
Here is a 1.3 row 8 voice LLMMMMMM. It roars.
Outer row buttons slightly larger than inner buttons. DC#
Scott
-
Here's a try.....I am never certain pictures get there, but fingers crossed.....This one was bought new by a friend's late father in '52 or '53; they went "to Chinatown" to pick it up, according to the story. Another member here dubbed her "Marilyn" because the elegance and vintage reminded him of her.
Mulberry St. runs through "Chinatown" and "Little Italy." Baldoni, Bartoli & Co was at 60 Mulberry St., which does seem to be in "Chinatown" now, but (although I'm not a New York City native) I'm guessing that "Little Italy" extended further down Mulberry St. in the early 20th century. Now the border with "Little Italy" seems to be Canal St. I'll ask Hugh O'Rourke, as a historian he'll know.
Nice box and great to have a sales date for this model when new. I have what I think is a slightly later model here, but with a very similar grille.
PG
-
Here is a 1.3 row 8 voice LLMMMMMM. It roars.
Outer row buttons slightly larger than inner buttons. DC#
Scott
Very interesting, Scott! Your photo is labeled "Baldoni-Bartoli;" Is that the logo on this one? Looks like the same basic model as Terry Winch's 8 voice 13 key Butti box.
-
Baldoni Bartoli. It has 4 double sided reedblocks with 13 cavities each so they combined the 10 and 3 rows into one of 13. The super long pallets open 8 holes.
Scott
-
"Here is a 1.3 row 8 voice LLMMMMMM. It roars."
I know that lust isn't a nice thing, but I wouldn't mind being accused of it in this case. It's everything I'd want in a melodeon, except for the key(s).
-
I also have a one row Butti in D that is 6 voice LLMMMM with the switch controlling the LL reeds. Chiclet buttons.
Nice original decorated keyboard top is in 100 pieces. I'm hoping to replicate the original with my new-to-me laser cutter someday.
Scott
-
It has walnut levers and blocks. Can't quite tell but that may be true of OP's 19 button-at least for the levers.
Scott
-
"Here is a 1.3 row 8 voice LLMMMMMM. It roars."
I know that lust isn't a nice thing, but I wouldn't mind being accused of it in this case. It's everything I'd want in a melodeon, except for the key(s).
Hi Winston, Last I heard, Terry Winch's Butti (nearly identical to Scott's Baldoni in the photo) was in Europe, and for sale. I think a box with all those features, history, and decoration might command a pretty high price, but message me if you'd like to get in touch with the current owner and I'll try to find his contact info. Here's that box:
http://tedmcgraw.com/Butti.html
PG
-
"Hi Winston, ..... message me if you'd like to get in touch with the current owner and I'll try to find his contact info.
Would that life were so simple? I'm just a dreamer Paul, and $2500 is probably at least 10x my usual budget. But thanks for the thought.
-
Here's a try.....I am never certain pictures get there, but fingers crossed.....This one was bought new by a friend's late father in '52 or '53; they went "to Chinatown" to pick it up, according to the story. Another member here dubbed her "Marilyn" because the elegance and vintage reminded him of her.
Very cool! Yep - that's the same model, just with a different colour scheme. Mine is tuned quite wet - around +19 cents - which I think suits it quite well and actually doesn't sound *that* wet to my ears (mind you, the offset steadily decreases to about +13 on the high end of the scale). Interesting to hear the story of the box as well. Thank you for sharing!
-
Baldoni Bartoli. It has 4 double sided reedblocks with 13 cavities each so they combined the 10 and 3 rows into one of 13. The super long pallets open 8 holes.
Scott
Lovely box, Scott! Do you have a video or sound clip to share?
-
Not yet.
-
I have this undecorated O'Byrne De Witt Baldoni - no flags or owner's name here. It's a four-voice, (LL)MM, made in Italy. I bought it from a Mr. Baker living in Newfoundland ( ;)), and I think it had been on Cape Breton Island before that.
Similar boxes were also marketed as Walters - see the first one here for example: http://www.tedmcgraw.com/Walters_Post_50s.html (http://www.tedmcgraw.com/Walters_Post_50s.html)
-
Here are photos of the treble and bass mechanisms. The keyboard and lever arrangement is different from others seen so far in this thread. Bass side is a rather crude, but effective, 'coat-hanger wire' system.
-
I have this undecorated O'Byrne De Witt Baldoni - no flags or owner's name here. It's a four-voice, (LL)MM, made in Italy. I bought it from a Mr. Baker living in Newfoundland ( ;)), and I think it had been on Cape Breton Island before that.
Similar boxes were also marketed as Walters - see the first one here for example: http://www.tedmcgraw.com/Walters_Post_50s.html (http://www.tedmcgraw.com/Walters_Post_50s.html)
I've seen quite a few examples of that model (although not yet in person). How is it as a player? I've found that some of these old 4v boxes can take a lot of muscle to work, while others play quite easily.
Mine has 6 reeds per chord note on the bass side. Looks like yours is a similar setup?
Any sound or video clips? :D
-
I have this undecorated O'Byrne De Witt Baldoni - no flags or owner's name here. It's a four-voice, (LL)MM, made in Italy. I bought it from a Mr. Baker living in Newfoundland ( ;)), and I think it had been on Cape Breton Island before that.
Similar boxes were also marketed as Walters - see the first one here for example: http://www.tedmcgraw.com/Walters_Post_50s.html (http://www.tedmcgraw.com/Walters_Post_50s.html)
I’ve got the same model in red celluloid,it is pictured on Ted’s site.
Same setup LLMM. If remember correctly the base end was similar but mine has a different treble mechanism.
-
I've seen quite a few examples of that model (although not yet in person). How is it as a player? I've found that some of these old 4v boxes can take a lot of muscle to work, while others play quite easily.
Mine has 6 reeds per chord note on the bass side. Looks like yours is a similar setup?
Any sound or video clips? :D
Yes, they can be work to play ! Leakage, 2 L reed banks and sub-optimal air hole size are no help. Having said that, with MM only the box is sweet and no problem to play (but the bass is overpowering). Switching in the LLs gives a more manly voice, a 'smoky' character and more available power. Hard to explain 'smoky', maybe it has to do with the LLs -and- the MMs both being tremolo tuned. Incredible dynamic range, but quite a workout at the louder end of things !
Each bass button activates 5 reeds, the chords have 6 notes (4 of which are the root).
Sorry no clips.
-
A few of mine currently:
-
Were the first two of those also produced by Busilacchio, do you think? The lettering looks the same metal stuff, and the keyboard (the whole treble end casing, in fact) design is the same as well.
-
Were the first two of those also produced by Busilacchio, do you think? The lettering looks the same metal stuff, and the keyboard (the whole treble end casing, in fact) design is the same as well.
I’m really not sure. Someone else might know a little more in regards to that.
-
There is a big long thread about these 19-button Paolo Sopranis. Reply 111 on this page seems to indicate they were indeed made by Paolo Soprani. http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,768.100.html (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,768.100.html)
(funny that one of Komat's boxes is labeled Paolo Soprani-O'Byrne Dewitt and the other O'Byrne Dewitt-Paolo Soprani (:))
-
Two more that went through my shop:
Left-
20 chiclet button Walters in DD#, 6 voice, LLMMMM.
demo:https://youtu.be/1YGBjsLPTdo (https://youtu.be/1YGBjsLPTdo)
Right-
19 button Baldoni Bartoli in DC#, 4 voice, LMMM
demo:https://youtu.be/vXUqTNYCfk8 (https://youtu.be/vXUqTNYCfk8)
Scott
-
Scott - I didn’t realize there had been any full two-row DC#s made with 6 voices! I always thought the 6+ voices were for 10 - 15 buttons boxes, and that the full two row models were no more than 4v. Thanks for the info!
-
Here's a Baldoni I recently sold. 3 voice LMM. Lovely light little box. No engravings though.
-
Scott - I didn’t realize there had been any full two-row DC#s made with 6 voices! I always thought the 6+ voices were for 10 - 15 buttons boxes, and that the full two row models were no more than 4v. Thanks for the info!
Baldoni-Bartolis too were made with 19 keys, and 6 voices per row (as well as the Walters in Scott's photo above).
In fact, I think I remember seeing a box with 19 keys and 8 voices per row. Might have been one of the taller ones in which case only 4 long double-sided melody reedblocks (19 reeds long) would be needed, total, and with 19 pallets lined up in a row.
But the Baldoni-Bartoli model 730 is spec'd to have 19 keys and 6 voice per row, see screenshot below from this catalog posted to Ted McGraw's website. This would have 6 melody reedblocks; 3 that are 10 reeds long and 3 that are 9 reeds long.
http://www.tedmcgraw.com/Baldoni_Ads.html
-
I think I remember seeing a box with 19 keys and 8 voices per row. Might have been one of the taller ones in which case only 4 reedblocks (19 reeds long) would be needed, total.
Ah yes, the big Tom Treacy Walters is 19 keys and 8 voices; see photos below and discussion here:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,13003
I suspect Mickey Carton's huge Walters 2 row box also had 8 voices per row, with 4 long reedblocks of 21 reeds on each side. See photo below (courtesy of Hugh O'Rourke) and recording / discussion here (possibly the latter is only visible to members of the Traditional Irish Button Accordion page on facebook):
https://www.facebook.com/groups/329320026040/posts/10158855919496041
-
Baldoni-Bartolis too were made with 19 keys, and 6 voices per row (as well as the Walters in Scott's photo above).
http://www.tedmcgraw.com/Baldoni_Ads.html
Here's an earlier type of Baldoni (than the model 730). This one also has 19 keys and 6 voices, but this is a tall one with 19 long pallets lined up in a single row on the soundboard, and 3 long double-sided melody reedblocks each 19 reeds long.
-
A couple more pictures of the Walters & Baldoni Bartoli.
Second one shows the single row of 20 long pallets on the Walters.
Scott
-
Interior of 3x20 Walters reedblocks.
Mahogany and walnut abound. Beautiful casework.
Scott
-
Paul and Scott - thank you both! Some of those boxes with 19+ pallets arranged all in a row must have been quite tall!
-
Scott - I didn’t realize there had been any full two-row DC#s made with 6 voices! I always thought the 6+ voices were for 10 - 15 buttons boxes, and that the full two row models were no more than 4v. Thanks for the info!
I also had a 6v 2 row square button Walters not long ago. Like an oil tanker.
-
And this arrived today:
-
komat, that's a lovely little thing! Please would you tell us the key, and what the helpers are?
-
It’s D/C#, same as all the boxes in this thread. In the case of half-rows (10+3, 10+5, etc), the extra buttons are a partial C# row. So the three buttons would be G#/A#, C#/C, F/D#.
-
Thanks.
-
And this arrived today:
Whoa, boy, neat find.
-
Paul,
China town has expanded into what was Little Italy The last time i was there 60 Mulberry St still stand empty.
-
Thanks Hugh, that was my impression.
So the Baldoni shop would have been in "Chinatown" even in 1952?
PG
Here's a try.....I am never certain pictures get there, but fingers crossed.....This one was bought new by a friend's late father in '52 or '53; they went "to Chinatown" to pick it up, according to the story. Another member here dubbed her "Marilyn" because the elegance and vintage reminded him of her.
Mulberry St. runs through "Chinatown" and "Little Italy." Baldoni, Bartoli & Co was at 60 Mulberry St., which does seem to be in "Chinatown" now, but (although I'm not a New York City native) I'm guessing that "Little Italy" extended further down Mulberry St. in the early 20th century. Now the border with "Little Italy" seems to be Canal St. I'll ask Hugh O'Rourke, as a historian he'll know.
Nice box and great to have a sales date for this model when new. I have what I think is a slightly later model here, but with a very similar grille.
PG
-
60 Mulberry St. would have been in Chinatown in 1952, Little Italy starts a few blocks north. Chinatown has expanded into Little Italy in recent years. Hugh O;R
-
I think this is a similar box
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b2PJrWln2WQ&list=PLAj-HXGXVt2utpwztByVzhbpUk4N0BXjg&index=21 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b2PJrWln2WQ&list=PLAj-HXGXVt2utpwztByVzhbpUk4N0BXjg&index=21)
Although a full two-row 19+ button box would be too costly, this 4-v LMMH I would be interested in, perhaps a 13-button version? Otherwise I'm looking for a 13 button 6 or 8 voice of whatever configuration I can find that sounds interesting and lively. (I find 4-voice LMMM too boring)
I want to narrow my study to dance music, polkas, slides, barndances, waltzes that everyday people can dance to. And I want an instrument that is tonally engaging and loud. A real Gravel Mixer, as Jim Coogan used to call them.
I know a fellow on Facebook selling a 13-button 8-v for $3100 before shipping from Europe and that's just too much for this Social Security gal. I'm going to need to sell off a few of my boxes and other instruments to engineer this new direction anyway. So, I am in my exploratory phase if anyone has ideas or potential offers. ---e.
-
I think this is a similar box
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b2PJrWln2WQ&list=PLAj-HXGXVt2utpwztByVzhbpUk4N0BXjg&index=21 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b2PJrWln2WQ&list=PLAj-HXGXVt2utpwztByVzhbpUk4N0BXjg&index=21)
That's not a similar box, it IS that box! I got it from Diarmuid.
-
And Diarmuid got it from me! ;D
-
So let me understand this: The box was made in italy, finished in NYC, made it's way to Newfoundland, then to Ireland, now back to Quebec!! She is quite the traveller (:)
Let me introduce you to her long lost twin :D
-
So let me understand this: The box was made in italy, finished in NYC, made it's way to Newfoundland, then to Ireland, now back to Quebec!! She is quite the traveller (:)
Let me introduce you to her long lost twin :D
Lovely Chris!
-
Maybe this can be the official Baldoni thread?
Minneapolis box player John McCormick plays what looks to me like a O'Bierne D'Witt Baldoni:
(https://www.centerforirishmusic.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/John-McCormick-2023.jpg)
Here's a video. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mTvhvMvUdX8)
-
John McCormick plays that box as a C#/D. I’m assuming in the cases of 19 button D/C# boxes that have been converted to C#/D, that it’s a third button start and that the last note of what would normally be a 10-button D row (to complete the scale in the upper octave) would maybe be the last button on the outside (C#) row? Any idea, anyone?
-
Looks like 3rd button start on the inside row:
https://youtu.be/SiaNgugqsuA?feature=shared
-
I think his high A is on the 2nd button from the top, highest would be d'''/b'', thus no f'''/c''' button. This being a result of needing low B, provided with that 3rd button start. When I got my first button box, a 21 button C#/D, I asked Michael Usui to retune the low F# to G; I was baffled why everyone didn't do that - it's the lowest note of the fiddle, played all the time in Irish music. Maybe John has retuned that note too - I wonder how many people feel the same way I do.
Stiamh wrote here years ago about wishing box builders would put the longer row on the inside of C#/D instruments, for this reason.
With any luck people with actual experience in these matters will chime in about D/C# stuff.
I think the blocks/reeds in my D/C# Walters are helpfully labelled. Just the one row of pallets, too. That might explain its somewhat tough action, what with a single pallet having to seal up 6 holes.
Is exchanging rows always a matter of moving reeds from block to block, or can the blocks be simply swapped sometimes? That'd sure simplify things. But probably you'd have a button not sounding its note(s).
-
I think John has, or had, two of that model of box. One I sold him but it was still in DC# at that time.
Just some personal opinions here, YMMV:
For a 21 key C#D I would generally want to leave the #1 button of the inside row as F#/B. But I would want D/G on the lowest button of the C# row. I wouldn't want to retune the F# from the D row because I would want that low G on the draw. It's not hard for me to move over slightly to grab that low G (or the very low D) from the outside row rather than the inside row.
For a 19 key (10 + 9) C#D I would do the same at the low (in pitch) end of the keyboard. The question arises what to do with the high (in pitch) notes. You could do as Stephen Chambers has described, and tune the highest button of the C# row to F#/C#, the notes that would usually be at the end of a D row but that would be missing in a row of 9 buttons. My own preference would be to leave the highest button of the C# row as F/C, which is the normal layout for button #10 of a 10-key row in C#. That way you still have the high C natural note for tunes like Trim the Velvet. You still have the high C#, but it's on the press on the C# row.
So I would want something like this, myself, for a 19-key C#D layout:
F#/B A/C# D/E F#/G A/B D/C# F#/E A/G D/B
D/ G G#/C C#/D# F/F# G#/A# C#/C F/D# G#/F# C#/A# F/C
Whereas Stephen likes this (if I understood him correctly):
F#/B A/C# D/E F#/G A/B D/C# F#/E A/G D/B
D/ G G#/C C#/D# F/F# G#/A# C#/C F/D# G#/F# C#/A# F#/C#
The latter is a bit better if you are focused on the notes of the D row in the usual bellows directions as on a box with a 10- or 11-button D row. The former avoids a redundant high C# note (if you can remember that it's present on the press on C# row) and offers you the high C natural.
PG
-
Is exchanging rows always a matter of moving reeds from block to block, or can the blocks be simply swapped sometimes? That'd sure simplify things. But probably you'd have a button not sounding its note(s).
You would always have to move reeds from block to block. Due to the staggering of the rows, and the fact that one block would have more reed chambers than the other, you would not be able to swap blocks and have them line up correctly.
-
Thanks for typing all that out, Paul. I like your take better, high C is essential. Shame that we can't do a block transplant - not that I'd ever want to do that with my Walters.