Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: mikesamwild on November 14, 2009, 06:38:01 PM

Title: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: mikesamwild on November 14, 2009, 06:38:01 PM
I know it makes sense if you have to use a letter to start on, although everyone seems to start teaching from C and that is the one with no sharps or flats. !
I've also asked this (to me) perplexing question on concertina.net.
http://www.concertina.net/forums/index.php?showtopic=10298


Any illumination from the illuminati would be welcome

My little Grandaughter asked me why the scale didn't go CDEFGHIc when I showed it her on the piano!
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: NeilA on November 14, 2009, 10:58:10 PM
I thought it didn't matter as long as you were playing in the home scales on a diatonic instrument? Playing D or G on a D/G would be the same as C  on a C - if you know what I mean?
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: Ollie on November 14, 2009, 11:28:45 PM
Because that is the home key for many instruments. However, when I started playing the trombone, the first scale I learnt was Bb major, as the home key for the 'bone is Bb. I think it is more of a case that you start by learning the easiest scale possible on your particular instrument, it just happens that for many instruments, the easiest scale is C (mainly because it has no sharps or flats!)
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on November 14, 2009, 11:32:48 PM
Mike - as ever you have the answer! "C" is used simply because  it has no sharps or flats, which makes it easier for a beginner to read from the page. It's also almost exactly halfway up the piano, and for that instrument, you only need to worry about hitting the white keys. Why do you think the PA has a piano keyboard!  :||: :|glug

Love and Fishes,

Chris.
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: GbH on November 14, 2009, 11:40:07 PM
As ever, I think that Wikipedia hints at the answer that you're looking for.  See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Note (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Note), in the History Of Note Names section.

Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: TomB-R on November 14, 2009, 11:47:45 PM
Interesting GbH but still doesn't seem to answer the question, "why start on C"

Or have we been wrong all this time, and A Minor is actually the fundamental scale?
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: Simon on November 15, 2009, 10:42:56 AM
I don't remember the details, but I think they just used A for the lowest note used at the time (until they added the gamma for the note below). A piano keyboard also starts on A.
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: ganderbox on November 15, 2009, 10:53:22 AM
From reading the Wikipedia article, it looks as if, at the time letters were first allocated to the notes of the scale, there were just 2 octaves in use. A was given to the lowest note, and the next 14 letters of the alphabet were used to denote the remainder of the 2 octaves. Later this was changed so that only the 7 letters from A to G were used, repeating them for the higher octaves.
Because many tunes have notes in them which are lower than the first note of the scale in which they are written, the fundamental scale (in which presumably most tunes were sung or played) would be higher than A.
In countries that use Do Re Mi etc to name the notes of the scale, Do is equivalent to C. The article says that these names came from the first syllables of the musical phrases of a Gregorian chant. If you follow the link to the chant, it is actually written in D minor, and C is just the leading note. Maybe if D minor was popular, it explains why B abd Bb were the first "accidentals" to be added.

This is just my understanding of the article...don't know if it's correct!  

As Tom BR suggests, maybe the use of C as the fundamental scale is something to do with the fact that early music was generally in minor keys, whilst modern music is generally in major keys.


ps  Simon posted (much more concisely) while I was writing this.
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: nemethmik on November 15, 2009, 11:46:07 AM
In countries that use Do Re Mi etc to name the notes of the scale, Do is equivalent to C.
This is true for France. In Hungary. DO (being a relative note) could mean any absolute note.
For example, in an A major scale DO = A. In a G major scale DO = G. In an A mixolydian scale DO = D.
Miki
 
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: Simon on November 15, 2009, 05:44:52 PM
In countries that use Do Re Mi etc to name the notes of the scale, Do is equivalent to C.
This is true for France. In Russia and Hungary. 
Called 'fixed do'; see also wikipedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solf%C3%A8ge).
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: mikesamwild on November 15, 2009, 05:51:29 PM
I like the keyboard starting on A at the LHS thing (I've never noticed and don't now have one ), but my son has just confirmed it on the phone.  As a kid I messed about on an old piano in our parlour.  I kept to the white notes  and 'hunted and pecked' till I got a nice Do-Re-Mi scale all on the white notes that would from C near the keyhole as I remember.
I found it interesting in the Wikipedia article about the fact that the black notes on the piano scale came gradually and later.
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: Simon on November 15, 2009, 07:11:38 PM
I like the keyboard starting on A at the LHS thing
It's not the reason for the 'starting with A' though; piano's are from much later than the note names. Perhaps it does show that the lowest note in use isn't always the root of the scale, even though you can play in any key on a piano. On a full score (treble and bass clef as for piano) the note on the bottom line is a G (the already mentioned gamma or gamut). The next one is the first A. I think this standard music notation was related to the note naming, but I forgot where I read all this stuff.  :-[
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: ganderbox on November 15, 2009, 09:30:40 PM
Or have we been wrong all this time, and A Minor is actually the fundamental scale?

Probably correct. The answer almost certainly involves modes.

I seem to remember from Howard Goodall's excellent television programmes some time ago that back in the 7th century or so, formal music was primarily for use in church, and only minor scales were used. Major scales  were seen as being inappropriate as they were too "jolly", and encouraged merriment rather than devout contemplation .
The scale which started on A (the first note) would therefore be A minor, and the notes in that scale became the "white notes".
When music became more secular, it started to be written in major keys. The major scale which used all the "white notes" would be C (the relative major of A minor).

Does that make sense?   
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: nemethmik on November 15, 2009, 09:55:37 PM
Does that make sense?   
Yes. Thank You! Miki
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: Chris Ryall on November 16, 2009, 08:21:25 AM
Early music was a big mix it seems, with different countries and different instuments going off in their own directions. I think it's a diversion  >:E to bring in the transposing instruments such as clarinet and sax. Their 'C' might be our Bb or Eb.  So I'll not mention them except to say this underlines the power of 'C' as the anchor note of musical notation.

We know the stave came from plain chant and I was thinking along the 'this as usually Am' lines too. So that perhaps that explains ABCDEFG

To my mind the power of 'C' comes from the harpsichord, and more especially its successor the immensely popular piano.  Once that had been invented, was fully chromatic, and happened to have the diatonic C major scale in a special colour I guess music theorists breathed a sigh of relief and found they at last had common ground. But it remains rather arbitrary - and begs the question as to why those harpsichord makers picked C a couple of centuries earlier. Or were they building with the A (aolian) minor scale in mind - the two are completely equivalent on an even tempered instrument.

So it begs another question  -as to why that wwhwwwh (half/whole tone increments) Ionian mode was chosen as basis. I'd guess that it's bacause 'to the ear' it is the 'least coloured' - no minor, blue or over bright notes. anyone know?  Again there may be a clue in that aolian (white notes) Am is regarded as the 'least coloured' of the various minor scales.

[edit] whoops - see ganderbox has already alluded to this sort of thing. Acknowledge all said there (also simon).
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: Simon on November 16, 2009, 08:21:59 AM
Does that make sense?   
It's based on a system where the 15 notes in use were numbered a through o. Not sure why they used those 15 notes. It could be because of the minor scale, but that assumes that the lowest note in use was the root of the scale. If I only had two octaves and wanted to play C major I'd probably want a G for the lowest note. (Actually they did add the G below the lowest A.)
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: Simon on November 16, 2009, 09:02:21 AM
Found some links again: dolmetsch (http://www.dolmetsch.com/musictheory1.htm), history (http://boris.reitman.name/math_music_hist.pdf), and Guido d'Arezzo (http://www.totallyratted.com/theory/0004_guido.pdf). Seems like it's more based on hexachords than on major or minor scales, which were 'invented' long after note naming and staff notation.
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on November 16, 2009, 10:40:43 AM
To my mind the power of 'C' comes from the harpsichord, and more especially its successor the immensely popular piano.  Once that had been invented, was fully chromatic, and happened to have the diatonic C major scale in a special colour I guess music theorists breathed a sigh of relief and found they at last had common ground. But it remains rather arbitrary - and begs the question as to why those harpsichord makers picked C a couple of centuries earlier.

Chris: Wouldn't the organ be a more likely basis if our origin is in Church music? The harpsichord is moore of a chamber instrument and the organ is also older in origin. Just a thought.

Chris B.
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: mikesamwild on November 16, 2009, 12:06:50 PM
Thanks ganderbox that sounds good to me. Guido lettered his scale from A which was Do (or Ut as it was also known)
 I've just mentioned on conc.net a little singing experiment I did from low A.


Actually one and a half octaves from a low G# suited me better and I do a lot of singing.  The 'A' would be lower in olden time in frequency

I also found the A aeolian scale nicer than A with the 3 sharps.


By the way in Beverley Minster there is one carving with an angel playing a portative organ

http://www.annandave.org/organ%202.JPG

 Maybe they were tuned to fit in with the chants   Nice one here 9 pipes doubled up

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-oS-1Jto4x0&feature=related  Seems to be a Dminor tune on a  DA drone

These must have been the squeezeboxes of the day before the free reed hit Europe in the 1700s
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: mikesamwild on November 24, 2009, 01:27:21 PM
Does that make sense?   
It's based on a system where the 15 notes in use were numbered a through o. Not sure why they used those 15 notes. It could be because of the minor scale, but that assumes that the lowest note in use was the root of the scale. If I only had two octaves and wanted to play C major I'd probably want a G for the lowest note. (Actually they did add the G below the lowest A.)



I understand that they called it the Gamut from that initial GA etc
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: Pete Dunk on November 24, 2009, 04:47:39 PM
I found this lesson on staffs and cleffs (http://www.8notes.com/school/theory/staff_clefs_ledger_lines.asp) elightening. Scroll through the lesson until you reach the bit about the theoretical 'Grand Staff' which gives an explanation for the naming of middle C. Placing middle C at the centre of a keyboard is simply a logical progression ...
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: old geezer on November 25, 2009, 09:13:39 AM
on another tangent...

the Italians use these - do re mi fa so la si - to name the key of melodeon reed sets

we are able to transpose these to our English alphabet and key of a row on a keyboard

so, why do the Italians start their run with 'do' and not 'la' ?

or can we attribute the scale to start with the lady whom sung that song in the movie.. wot was it now....?

Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: mikesamwild on November 25, 2009, 08:37:12 PM
Originally in church muisic chants  'Do' was the first letters of Dominus (Lord) one of the chants to which the scale was applied
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: Rob2Hook on November 26, 2009, 01:16:15 PM
And how do you define the pitch, e.g. A-440?  An orchestra tunes to the oboe playing an A.  There must be something to all these stories form the mists of time!

Rob.
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: Simon on November 26, 2009, 01:34:39 PM
And how do you define the pitch, e.g. A-440? 
See wikipedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pitch_(music)) for a brief overview. Also tells you how that oboe tunes (or not).
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on November 26, 2009, 04:45:19 PM
And how do you define the pitch, e.g. A-440?  An orchestra tunes to the oboe playing an A.  There must be something to all these stories form the mists of time!
In most orchestras, including my own, the oboist gives the A for tuning at the start of a rehearsal or concert. Usually, the oboist has a tuning fork or electronic tuner to hand and will carefully check their A against it and will try to adjust their reed and embouchure (the way yer stick it in yer gob) to get as close to A=440 as possible.  Once he/she is happy with the A they will sound it as a good, strong, held note for the rest of the orchestra to tune to.

There seem to be two oft-quoted reasons why it is the oboist who does this job - (a) the oboe is the instrument whose A is least able to be adjusted, so everyone else tunes to the oboe; and (b) the sound quality of the oboe ensures that it is audible above the sound of the orchestra.

As the rehearsal/concert progresses, the temperature of the instruments and room usually warm up, which affects the wind and brass instruments the most (makes them go sharp) whilst the strings tend to go flat. So retuning is necessary every so often, usually between pieces. The oboist is unlikely to be able to give exactly the same pitch A as earlier, so the whole orchestra's pitch will gradually change, often going sharp as a performance progresses.  So - all tuning is a compromise anyway. The best orchestras and players will listen to each other and make minute changes of embouchure and finger position to ensure they are playing in relative tune to everyone else. It's something you learn to do as you become a trained orchestral player. The top professional orchestras do it the best, which is why they sound so good. 
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: mikesamwild on December 02, 2009, 03:55:11 PM
Going back to the original post.  I've been ploughing through Scholes' Oxford Companion to Music which has been fascinating if taxing on my old eyes ( what small print!)


Apparently Boethius in the 5th C started listing the notes of the musical scale then used beginning with A

They had fewer notes in  a scale from A to A'  ( what we'd call the octave wasn't seven notes) and no accidentals.


I can't believe that people singing or messing around on flutes, one string fiddles or pipes wouldn't use a lot more notes  but I haven't seen any material on that yet.



It would be interesting to know what that early A was pitched at as the human voice won't have changed too much in its compass.  This was called Ut as it was the first word of a Latin chant to St John. The other names for notes were the first letters of the other phrases hence Ut (later Doh, it was easier to say) Re Mi Fa Soh La Si (Ti ) Doh withits variants in various countries
As time went on they added a lower G or a gamma.  So that gave us gamut  the range from G -A' and repeats


Somewhere in the 10th C The notes of the bass Clef were put on, and between 5 lines,  and we got the 'All Cows Eat Grass' stave .  That ran up through Middle C and on to the Tenor or G clef.  I can't find why they chose to locate the bass clef by the symbol for an F or the tenor by a G sign, even those weren't uniform anyway)


So it looks as though the compass from A to A'' in  a minor mode , relative minor to C major ( all on the white notes) was the range of a decent Tenor ( which comes from Latin 'to hold', same as for tenant) the one who held the tune or melody.  Middle C would be within that and probably became the effective range for a singer.  A lot of people still like to sing in C and it's a populat key for accompanying singers (guitar, C/G Anglo. early melodeons).. A system of learning and memorising  6 note scales or Hexachords was developed and memorised using the joints and tips of the fingers.  The 'Natural Hexachord' was Ut =C through to A.  Other hexachords were selected from the full range for help in singing within that mode and compass of the notes .  The one from G - E was the 'Durum Hexachord' ='hard' so they may have had one row melodeons in G

Gradually accidentals crept into musical notation so A would become a major scale as we know it .

Apparently they had a little bell for the pitching of the chants and later pitch pipes and tuning forks.


A good singer would sing the first word of the chant in the appropriate pitch and they'd work round that.. We do that at our local South Yorkshire carols when there's no organ or piano.  there we seem to get a pitch centred round one of the chords in a three chord trick for that key (I, IV, V, eg. C, F, G in key C)


It's been an interesting voyage of discovery starting from my Grandughter's puzzlement when she took up the recorder at school aged 6 a few months ago  'Why does the scale go CDEFGABc, not CDEFGABc' ?


She was satisfied by her Mum pointing out the first white note on their piano was A and that middle C was near the keyhole so that's why we use it!.  But not her old Grandad, oh no... ???   Now where's that book on the Enigma codes or why DNA is based on nucleotides labelled CGAT and where's the lost chord and what is the score for the music of the spheres, aaagghhh!

Kids eh!?
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: Theo on December 02, 2009, 06:32:06 PM
If you go to Scotland then the most common scale for trad music does start on A!

Must be the home of music   >:E  ;D
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: mikesamwild on December 02, 2009, 08:54:08 PM
As a D/G box player I did notice that for many years Theo!

Do you think that came about when the fiddle  came in .  I don't know what the crowd , the predecessor to the fiddle, was tuned to but the Italian violin seems to allow A quite nicely.

Would Bb pipes be around the A mark before A was 440 Hz?
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: Theo on December 02, 2009, 11:23:54 PM
Highland pipe tunes are written in A, the pipes are a bit sharp of A and may even get to Bb.  I guess the fiddlers just followed the pipe tradition and A is such a great key on fiddle.
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: Pushpull on December 03, 2009, 10:09:20 AM
Going back to the original post.  I've been ploughing through Scholes' Oxford Companion to Music which has been fascinating if taxing on my old eyes ( what small print!)
Apparently Boethius in the 5th C started listing the notes of the musical scale then used beginning with A
They had fewer notes in  a scale from A to A'  ( what we'd call the octave wasn't seven notes) and no accidentals.
I can't believe that people singing or messing around on flutes, one string fiddles or pipes wouldn't use a lot more notes  but I haven't seen any material on that yet.
Well most earlyish music was fairly diatonic (as is much folk music now). Chromaticism took some time to catch on.
Quote
Somewhere in the 10th C The notes of the bass Clef were put on, and between 5 lines,  and we got the 'All Cows Eat Grass' stave .  That ran up through Middle C and on to the Tenor or G clef.  I can't find why they chose to locate the bass clef by the symbol for an F or the tenor by a G sign, even those weren't uniform anyway)
I can hazard a guess. Our present notation system of treble and bass clefs is based on the "Great Stave" which consisted of 11 lines having C on the middle line. Separating it out into two staves of 5 lines each with C on a ledger line between makes it easier to read. G is a 5th above C and F is a 5th below, so these are "obvious" positions to highlight.

Bear in mind there have historically been many different clef signs to suit various vocal ranges and instruments. A few remain. Viola uses alto and treble clefs, cello and bassoon use bass, tenor and treble clefs.
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: Pushpull on December 03, 2009, 10:17:54 AM
In most orchestras, including my own, the oboist gives the A for tuning at the start of a rehearsal or concert.

There seem to be two oft-quoted reasons why it is the oboist who does this job - (a) the oboe is the instrument whose A is least able to be adjusted,
I think the conductor in our orchestra was genuinely surprised to discover how much pitch variation I could get on my oboe without pulling the reed out (which in my view is a real last ditch effort to get in tune). Hence the need for the electronic tuner on the music stand.
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on December 03, 2009, 10:42:20 AM
I can hazard a guess. Our present notation system of treble and bass clefs is based on the "Great Stave"
Hooray! Fame at last!!
.
.
.
.
.
Oh - sorry, I thought you said the "Great Steve"

 :D
Title: Re: Why is the commonest major scale started on C not A?
Post by: mikesamwild on December 03, 2009, 11:18:11 AM
No that was Stove Grate! ;)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal