Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Sebastian Trudgian on May 06, 2023, 06:54:19 AM

Title: Way to make a Pokerwork bass buttons less stiff?
Post by: Sebastian Trudgian on May 06, 2023, 06:54:19 AM
Hi,

A kind of 2 part question!

I’m a newish melodeon player (since lockdown), but play a lot and now play for two Morris groups and love it.

I have a very old german DG pokerwork and a newish Chinese Pokerwork

I was very happy with both but struggle with either to play a particular fast Morris dance one group do which needs vamping on the G bass/chord.
I use all four fingers and find I start to get serious fatigue with my little finger/can’t keep speed near the end of the tune.

I thought it was me/would build strength (all though I have been playing quite a bit), but I tried two other peoples Melodeon’s yesterday (both varieties of Dino Bafettis) and noticed the bass buttons are MANY magnitudes easier to push down/the issue doesn’t occur with these.

If seen lots of Pokerwork improvement videos (and have done the treble action restriction one), but does anyone know if there’s a mod to make the bass/chord buttons much easier to push down for faster/less tiring playing?

Or (second part!), is that just a characteristic of the Pokerwork and I should look for a different kind of box for this sort of playing?

Thanks for your time.
Title: Re: Way to make a Pokerwork bass buttons less stiff?
Post by: Lester on May 06, 2023, 08:17:20 AM
Unfortunately the weight of the bass action is a trade off between ease of playing (light springs) versus airtightness of the pallets (heavier springs). It may be possible to adjust the springs to lighten the action but you risk air leakage when playing with volume.


Out of interest which tune are you having problems with?


ps For this particular tune if you don't need access to all the basses consider using first and second fingers rather than third and little.
Title: Re: Way to make a Pokerwork bass buttons less stiff?
Post by: Sebastian Trudgian on May 06, 2023, 08:43:53 AM
Thanks Lester. That’s helpful to know, I was hoping there was some magic trick people knew of!

I guess I could just switch to my main two fingers actually… I was worried I’d confuse myself/mess up my muscle memory but it might actually be useful to get my hands used to changing position on the base side.

It’s a tune called Cock of the North played at this speed:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ciNV4yBZYHs&pp

I’m currently vamping on 1 and 3 (I think).
It wasn’t a problem on my friends melodeon at all, but my little finger seriously starts cramping by the end of the dance on my pokerwork.
Title: Re: Way to make a Pokerwork bass buttons less stiff?
Post by: baz parkes on May 06, 2023, 10:27:58 AM
should look for a different kind of box for this sort of playing?
Thanks for your time.

No.  :|glug
Title: Re: Way to make a Pokerwork bass buttons less stiff?
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on May 06, 2023, 11:47:18 AM
You could try mixing it up with playing block chords, or even no chords, on succesive iterations.
Three fingers bass playing works well.

For what it's worth, I haven't noticed the bass action on my Hohners (one Chinese Pokerwork, one old German two row) to be any heavier than my friends Dino Black Pearl. If anything they're lighter.
Title: Re: Way to make a Pokerwork bass buttons less stiff?
Post by: Steve C. on May 06, 2023, 01:18:24 PM
Lots of folks play without the pinky.  Lots play with only two fingers. Or three.
OTOH, you can always google pinky exercises for guitar players who actually need the pinky to be strong and flexible.
Title: Re: Way to make a Pokerwork bass buttons less stiff?
Post by: Anahata on May 06, 2023, 02:13:04 PM
I use all four fingers and find I start to get serious fatigue with my little finger/can’t keep speed near the end of the tune.

As others have said, learn to play using three fingers on the basses. I only use my little finger for things like a bass run that goes between the G/D button and the C/C button, but that's for a style of playing quite unsuited for belting out Cock of the North for NW morris.
Some people use only two fingers on bass, but I think that's a bit limiting. Your 3rd (ring) finger is strong enough.
Title: Re: Way to make a Pokerwork bass buttons less stiff?
Post by: Sebastian Trudgian on May 06, 2023, 06:34:19 PM
You could try mixing it up with playing block chords, or even no chords, on succesive iterations.
Three fingers bass playing works well.

For what it's worth, I haven't noticed the bass action on my Hohners (one Chinese Pokerwork, one old German two row) to be any heavier than my friends Dino Black Pearl. If anything they're lighter.

Now that’s very interesting…

Both of mine are WAY stiffer than the Bafettis I tried (a Binci II and a Black Pearl)…

I wonder if there could be something up with mine?…

I’ll see if I can find another pokerwork at some point and compare it.
Title: Re: Way to make a Pokerwork bass buttons less stiff?
Post by: Sebastian Trudgian on May 06, 2023, 06:37:27 PM
I use all four fingers and find I start to get serious fatigue with my little finger/can’t keep speed near the end of the tune.

As others have said, learn to play using three fingers on the basses. I only use my little finger for things like a bass run that goes between the G/D button and the C/C button, but that's for a style of playing quite unsuited for belting out Cock of the North for NW morris.
Some people use only two fingers on bass, but I think that's a bit limiting. Your 3rd (ring) finger is strong enough.

Thankyou. So many people told me when I started it was good practice to get used to playing with all four fingers (and it does help my brain remember quick changes to cross chords), but thinking about it, it’s obvious I should use the fingers that make sense and clearly a little finger is going to struggle with this!

(I am a rock climber so hopefully have pretty strong/durable little fingers)

Thanks for all your help everyone :-)
Title: Re: Way to make a Pokerwork bass buttons less stiff?
Post by: rees on May 06, 2023, 11:52:45 PM
It sounds as if you need lighter springs, perhaps the wrong ones were fitted at the factory.
There's plenty of leeway for lighter springs on a Pokerwork mechanism.
Title: Re: Way to make a Pokerwork bass buttons less stiff?
Post by: Theo on May 07, 2023, 08:15:19 AM
Rees bear me too it, lighter springs are what you need.  Hohner made springs from a range of different wire gauges.
Title: Re: Way to make a Pokerwork bass buttons less stiff?
Post by: Sebastian Trudgian on May 07, 2023, 10:07:48 AM
Genuine thanks both, that would make a lot of sense…

I’ll investigate this!
Title: Re: Way to make a Pokerwork bass buttons less stiff?
Post by: Sebastian Trudgian on May 10, 2023, 07:50:38 PM
Brief update incase anyone finds this in the future.

I tested it against another persons Pokerwork and both of mine were significantly stiffer.

I didn't take the case off the other persons, but when looking at both of mine interestingly the gauge of spring wire on the bass/chords was much thicker than the gauge of the melody notes (not sure if this is normal or not) and it did seem to take significant effort to open them.

I spent a while with a screwdriver disengaging the wires for the bass/chords and flexing them towards the edge of the case (i.e. putting more tension into them than normal), and when I put them back the buttons were way less stiff, with no obvious issues closing/covering the holes in time.

I've no idea if the tension will return (or if this is a good idea to do), but for the moment has resolved my issue/both melodeons are far less tiring to play the bass/chord buttons on.
Title: Re: Way to make a Pokerwork bass buttons less stiff?
Post by: Theo on May 10, 2023, 08:10:31 PM
Technically it’s called adjusting the preload when you bend the legs of a spring like that.  It’s a standard way of making small adjustments to spring pressure.
Title: Re: Way to make a Pokerwork bass buttons less stiff?
Post by: Sebastian Trudgian on May 10, 2023, 10:19:54 PM
Ah awesome! Glad I didn’t do anything stupid to it (seems to have worked!)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal