Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: John Burks on May 15, 2023, 05:18:53 PM

Title: Unisonoric to Bisonoric
Post by: John Burks on May 15, 2023, 05:18:53 PM
There should be a couple of video links below that some might find of interest if you have thought about repurposing PA reeds.

The videos show a unisonoric PA reed being converted to a bisonoric reed (C4/C4 to B3/C#4)

The first video shows reprofiling by longitudinal hand linishing on the front reed to lower the pitch (B3) and the second video shows tip filing on the reverse reed to raise pitch (C#4).  Total time to create “new” bisonoric reed from the PA reed is approx 20 mins.  I used this process to achieve +-2.5 cents on each reed prior to valving and fine tuning.

Note: These are experimental reeds for my own use. I just want a set of highly responsive reeds that I have profiled myself.

The technique is not recommended for normal tuning.

I also measure reed thickness to check on stability. Photos attached re the micrometer arrangement.  Took 2 thou off 14 thickness to go from C to B in the first video.

I also weight the tips on some to lower pitch when reed thickness becomes a concern. It’s a balancing act re long term stability and response. Final photo of typical loaded tip.

Anyway just thought I would share.  I hope it’s of interest to some and it might just create a discussion on the pros and cons (:)

John

(https://live.staticflickr.com/31337/52898365213_e094769f46_z.jpg) (https://flic.kr/p/2oArX2x)Unisonoric PA Reed Reprofiling to Bisonoric - Front Reed (C to B) (https://flic.kr/p/2oArX2x) by John Burks (https://www.flickr.com/photos/192967515@N03/), on Flickr

(https://live.staticflickr.com/31337/52897913866_6e361f5195_z.jpg) (https://flic.kr/p/2oApCRG)Unisonoric PA Reed Reprofiling to Bisonoric - Reverse (C to C#) (https://flic.kr/p/2oApCRG) by John Burks (https://www.flickr.com/photos/192967515@N03/), on Flickr

Title: Re: Unisonoric to Bisonoric
Post by: Winston Smith on May 15, 2023, 11:24:08 PM
Being a touch ham-fisted, I don't place reedplates in a vice any more. It doesn't take very much of too much pressure to distort the reed slot and cause yourself a fair bit of extra work to correct it.
Also, the use of Dremel type instruments can be a bit dodgy, again a touch too much pressure and you've gone too far. Although I've used one many times to take big thick and nasty bass reeds down by a lot, I'm very wary of attacking normal treble type reeds with one.
In saying that, if you're confident that you can achieve what you want with your own methods, I'm all for it! Finding success is all part of what makes messing about worthwhile.
Title: Re: Unisonoric to Bisonoric
Post by: John Burks on May 16, 2023, 09:02:55 AM
Hi Winston,  thanks for the response  (:) I actually had concerns re clamping.  I found though that by introducing a lip on the vice faces (strips of wood 2-3mm below the vice top), the reed plate sits on them and you can clamp with the lightest of pressures.  There is also a slight high spot on my vice and I clamp mainly on the end of the plate where it is solid. (That’s why I clamp at the end of the vice in the video) This reduces the chance of gap distortion. I will distort one eventually though!

 On the subject of dremels (which I know is very very contentious  ;)) I actually agree.  They can be horrible and do a lot of damage.  I would never put a burr or a stone in a Dremel with a reed in front of me! To be quite honest it was with great trepidation that I got it out and fired it up …. But …. I do believe careful linishing works especially on lower reeds as long as you are very careful.  All reeds are made by belt linishing. They are transverse linished.  Some are even longitudinal linished.  So why not.

The main reason for trying this though it to get away from relying on heavy filing and heavy loading with solder.  My first attempts relied heavily on these techniques and I found that, while it was quick, the reeds tended to distort in the lower third as I filed over my reed support. Overloading also slowed response.  This made me think about the base manufacturing technique… hence the experiment  (:)

The good news is the PA I took the reeds from left me with quite a lot to play with!

John

Title: Re: Unisonoric to Bisonoric
Post by: John Burks on May 16, 2023, 07:07:18 PM
Hi,  I have just realised that the Flikr links in my initial post above both cut off at 3 mins.  I know that there will not be many ... but .... if you really do fancy watching the whole re profiling process to +-2.5 cents then here is the full job.  It actually took 17 mins with a lot of checking of gaps. 

I used the Bill Farmer tuner on this occasion so you can see the incremental steps as the frequency shifts.  A bit blurred but viewable on the phone app.

Youtube links (which work better):

Tuning front reed C4 (261.63Hz) to B3 (246.9Hz):  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8tm9KI3DAmE

Tuning rear reed C4 (261.63Hz) to C4# (277.18Hz):   https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZI-TeQ8hZLc

Hope this is of interest to some  (:)

Title: Re: Unisonoric to Bisonoric
Post by: Michael Denieffe on November 08, 2023, 10:49:11 AM
Hello John. I would like to see your videos on re-tuning if they are still available.
Title: Re: Unisonoric to Bisonoric
Post by: mselic on November 08, 2023, 05:44:16 PM
I'm surprised that you said you found it took you as long as it did to re-purpose those reeds.  I've done this quite a bit and find that with a simple file and shim under the reed I can get it pretty close to target pitch in less than a minute!  I do this with just a reference reed and 'pinging' the two to compare when rough tuning, then doing the 'zeroing-in' to pitch on the tuning table with a tuner.  Your videos are no longer up so I can't see what you were doing, but I promise there is a faster way!
Title: Re: Unisonoric to Bisonoric
Post by: rees on November 08, 2023, 06:07:09 PM
I'm surprised that you said you found it took you as long as it did to re-purpose those reeds.  I've done this quite a bit and find that with a simple file and shim under the reed I can get it pretty close to target pitch in less than a minute!  I do this with just a reference reed and 'pinging' the two to compare when rough tuning, then doing the 'zeroing-in' to pitch on the tuning table with a tuner.  Your videos are no longer up so I can't see what you were doing, but I promise there is a faster way!

Agreed. 20 minutes is a very long time.
Title: Re: Unisonoric to Bisonoric
Post by: Theo on November 08, 2023, 06:08:49 PM
I'm surprised that you said you found it took you as long as it did to re-purpose those reeds.  I've done this quite a bit and find that with a simple file and shim under the reed I can get it pretty close to target pitch in less than a minute!  I do this with just a reference reed and 'pinging' the two to compare when rough tuning, then doing the 'zeroing-in' to pitch on the tuning table with a tuner.  Your videos are no longer up so I can't see what you were doing, but I promise there is a faster way!

Agreed. 20 minutes is a very long time.

Speed will improve with practice. 
Title: Re: Unisonoric to Bisonoric
Post by: John Burks on November 10, 2023, 10:15:22 AM
Hello John. I would like to see your videos on re-tuning if they are still available.

Hi Michael,  here are the videos. I had a clear out recently and must have deleted them.   I hope they are of use.

Unisonoric PA Reed Reprofiling to Bisonoric - Front Reed (C to B).        https://youtu.be/C-qrMwkjLFk

Unisonoric PA Reed Reprofiling to Bisonoric - Reverse (C to C#).          https://youtu.be/8tdV3BnCmSA

Hi mselic/Rees/Theo,    I agree re timing.  It can be done much quicker that this.  These reeds though were some of the tightest tolerance reeds I had come across so I was very mindful that I wanted them right. Hence the linishing.  It took a lot of time but I felt it gave a more consistent profile.

In total I converted 120 reed plates so I must have sped up  (:).

John
Title: Re: Unisonoric to Bisonoric
Post by: Michael Denieffe on November 12, 2023, 03:10:23 PM
Thank you very much John. Very informative and a great demo of the care and attention needed to get the best from reeds.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal