Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Little Eggy on June 21, 2023, 11:59:32 AM

Title: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Little Eggy on June 21, 2023, 11:59:32 AM
I've just spent a while playing along with a metronome on YT. 
Interesting.  Tried it with a number of morris tunes.  Thought I had a good ear for timing but ....... oh dear!
I think I speed up because I don't hold on long enough notes at the end of bars where you often get a whole note.
From other posts on this forum I may not be alone in having a somewhat elevated judgement of my timing ability.
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: arty on June 21, 2023, 12:15:52 PM
I speed up on some tunes as well....I call it enthusiasm  ;)

It’s not until you play with other musicians that you realise what a common problem it is. Tapping my foot doesn’t help, I just tap faster as well. I guess it’s wavering concentration.
I’d be interested to know if someone has a cure  (:)
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Mcgrooger on June 21, 2023, 12:42:56 PM
I couldn't agree more.  When I watch some of my YT videos I'm shocked at how much faster some pieces are by the end. I tend to use a metronome when recording more often these days but it always feels very odd.  I tried using one for Peacock Follows the Hen but gave up in the end. I do sometimes worry that it takes the 'swing' out of my playing.
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: JohnAndy on June 21, 2023, 01:14:12 PM
I find that practicing with a metronome can really help, because it makes me more aware of any tendency to deviate from a steady rhythm.

But I wouldn't want to use one when making a recording or in any kind of performance, for exactly the reasons given by Mcgrooger above.

On the subject of speeding up, I was listening in detail to a recording of Jimmy Shand playing John MacDonald's March, and whilst it had fantastic rhythm and drive throughout, it was undeniably speeding up, and the tempo by the end was considerable faster than when it started. Make of that what you will!
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: CAB on June 21, 2023, 01:22:04 PM
A bit more interesting than a straight metronome is a bodhran track.  It may be a bit too Irish for some but they're nice to play to and available on Youtube in various rhythms and tempos - not forgetting that you can adjust the speed anyway in Youtube.

A slow jig: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z7CrOq23FVc (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z7CrOq23FVc) (with faster examples beneath).

A hornpipe: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fpeAiL6AaH0

A polka: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O8-Qxjt5Q9M (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O8-Qxjt5Q9M)
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Dick Rees on June 21, 2023, 03:35:51 PM
Tempo can have dynamics just as volume has dynamics, and the beat is not simply metronomic clicks but encompasses a certain amount of time.  You can "push" the beat by playing at the very front of it, by anticipating the beat by tying across from the previous beat/bar or using a grace note tied or not.  The trick is to not speed up while emphasizing the attack.  So how to maintain intensity without running away with the tune?

I find that paying attention to phrasing can help.  Dividing the tune into phrases and "checking" yourself at phrase junctions can help "catch your breath", regulating your tempo not on a per beat basis but rather by checking "mileposts".

Additionally, progressively lengthening your metronome settings from beats to measures and beyond may be of use.  Ultimately, a visual metronome may be best.  I believe you can still find light sweeping devices which allow you to regulate tempo without the double task of listening to your playing AND an audible cueing device.

At a minimum, just "laying back" at the repeat of an A or B part of the tune helps. 

Good luck, have fun.

Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: george garside on June 21, 2023, 03:45:15 PM
this may sound a bit arse upards but the trick to keep perfect time ( not the same as mechanical metronome time) for dancers is to play to the feet of the best dancer in the morris side ,other dance team  ceilidh or whatever...in oter words you folow them not they follow you!  This allows for very slight adjustments to be made automatically for tricky bits of dance formation and makes the musician or musicians at one with thedancers'   

This is not something I have thought up but a technique I have used for many years of playing for dance,  It was the secret of Sir Jimmy Shands   superb timing!  and world wide acclaim as a dance band  leader.

It is also remarkably easy to carry out . the band leader (or solo musician) playing to the feet of the best dancer and the rest of the band keeping stricktly in time with the leader rather than 'this is how we play   it aand  you will dance to it at that tempo.  It also automatically adjusts for eg young lively dancers , experienced  and inexperienced dancers and doddery old ones like me
george

Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: tirpous on June 21, 2023, 04:01:15 PM
Quote
Additionally, progressively lengthening your metronome settings from beats to measures and beyond may be of use.

I know what you mean here.  However this assumes the player's internal clock will keep things (reasonably) steady in between.  Some players may be at a stage where what they need is to set the metronome the other way, ie to a beat subdivision, to develop/regularize their internal clock.  This is what comes to mind when I read:

Quote
I think I speed up because I don't hold on long enough notes at the end of bars where you often get a whole note.
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Little Eggy on June 21, 2023, 05:12:33 PM
I'm very new to playing for Morris and I value all of these comments. Thanks.
The first time I was asked to lead I was pretty nervous and played it at a pace which caused worried looks and some friendly comments at the end. "We don't normally do it quite that fast!!" (gasps for breath)
Next time I started one of the dances at what I thought was a nice steady pace and realised after the first chorus that they were pushing the tempo up quite significantly so I had to adapt quite quickly.
The music director found it highly amusing and said afterwards "Don't worry - they're always saying 'too slow' or 'too fast'."

Thanks for the suggestion about using YT to get drum shuffles and bodrhan rhythms. You can turn up the volume which is handy (my Korg metronome has a very quiet click/tap).

I can see what McGrooger means about the "positive" side of speeding up.  If you play to the metronome/YT drum, after eight AB's you're nearly nodding off!!!


Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Arnold on June 21, 2023, 09:40:54 PM
I recently had a rude awakening on listening back to an attempt at a Jackie Daly Polka. I managed to turn it into a complete garbled mess with the left and right hand horribly out of sync. At first I blamed the spoon basses, but then I just decided to face reality and accept that after making good progress at first, I plateaued quite early in my playing (fairly typical for someone who is coming from other musical instruments).

So rather than racing ahead with Hornpipes at the the tempo of the old Norfolk maestros (around 190-210 bpm), I am now playing them all to a metronome set at 110 bpm. This has really opened my ears to certain things I wouldn’t have noticed, and has helped me to identify specific traits in my playing. For example, I noticed a tendency to race into the note following an ornament, eg a triplet. I also found that to get the sound I am looking for, I need to lift my fingers off the button more between notes, contrary to what I would expect for smoother playing. Rhythm is king.

On the other hand, applying a more classical ‘elastic’ approach to rhythm can also be helpful if you are tending to race from one phrase to the next, eg you can kind of lean into the first note of a phrase, and add a tiny pause or slowing towards the end. This can help to frame the melody and bring it to the fore…
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Gena Crisman on June 21, 2023, 09:50:11 PM
For live performances, I typically still use an app on my phone to tell me what tempo we're playing at. I use liveBPM (https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.DanielBach.liveBPM&hl=en&gl=US) because I don't mind paying for it and it has a history graph, but other apps are no doubt available.

It tells me if we're speeding up/slowing down, and lets me aim to fix that, but without it trying to control where the beats fall. And, that distinction is important.

If I played to the best dancer in my morris side, then, on some days, we'd be playing faster than normal, potentially leaving the weaker dancers behind. We're a team, so primarily, I play to what we've practiced and agreed before hand. But if going faster or slower seems like a democratic decision amongst the dancers that day, then, I match them - we're here to make them happy, not the metronome.

I've also found that being able to respond to 'was that faster than normal?' with a demonstrably accurate 'yes' or 'no' really quite rewarding.
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on June 21, 2023, 11:42:13 PM
A great assett playing out is a good drummer who knows your repertoire and your dancers.
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Stotty on June 22, 2023, 12:06:53 AM

Like Gena,  I also use the liveBPM app for playing for dance teams 
I bought a cheap small mobile (without a SIM card) and downloaded the app on WiFi at home.
I stuck some velcro tape on the back of the mobile and another bit on the top bellows strap in a "sandwich" and position the bellows strap over the right hand end of the box behind the L voice stop. I might add some photos if anyone is interested? I just look down and can see how fast I'm going, and can react accordingly.
Like others I was embarrassed to see and hear in videos dancers being led along too fast (by me) when playing solo, and I also found a race developing when playing with some other musicians in a North West morris band/group..
The app doesn't alway pick up the beat, but it usually does and it gives a read out of your tempo rather than constraining you like a metronome (which are in any case less practical when out at dance outs). It has given me a lot more confidence in playing for dance teams..
I have noticed, but can correct, a tendency to speed up in the B part of a few tunes.  I have also found that even 5 beats per minutes is noticed by dancers at around the target speed in a normal range of 95 to 115 bpm for different north west tunes.
I have a couple of tactics for trying to keep "band mates" at a steady pace. I try to make sure i can hear my own box well above the other instrument(s)/players which I think can start a race. I then stick to a tempo and try to make sure others follow, and I try to make sure the "band" is in a short line or group to minimise the risks of the two ends of a line playing out of sync.
Ironically I discovered that a fellow musician who is most likely to suggest I am playing too fast seems to play slightly ahead of the beat, and that can start a race.  I also think that higher pitched instruments like single reed boxes, concertinas and whistles played by others are more likely to influence my own speed (IE lead to a speed race).
Over time use of the app has given me a much better feel for consistent natural speeds and I now barely need to use it as long as I watch the dancers.

Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Jack Humphreys on June 22, 2023, 07:51:11 AM
Gina, Thank you VERY MUCH for telling us about the BPM app. I have a longstanding tendency to speed-up when performing, without awareness.  So I'm hopeful that the app could help.  I'm also grateful for the suggestion of playing to the tempo of the good dancers.
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: george garside on June 22, 2023, 10:01:32 AM
how did pre digital everything bands keep spot on time with dancers...did they have better eyes and ears than ?many of todays musicians ;D
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Theo on June 22, 2023, 10:15:12 AM
George, they probably learned the dances first,  then they will have the benefit of the knowing the physical movement of dancing which can act as a built in metronome.  The people  I know who are excellent dance musicians are all (or have been) dancers too.
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Little Eggy on June 22, 2023, 11:03:15 AM
And yet more good advice.
Thanks

Stotty I would like to see a photo please.
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 22, 2023, 12:04:59 PM
A great assett playing out is a good drummer who knows your repertoire and your dancers.

   I tried that, in drummer mode playing for my local Women’s side.

        But the bloke with the loud concertina would still speed up by 30-40% through a tune 🥴

   Thanks for tge BPM tip, Gina 🙂
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 22, 2023, 01:38:39 PM
Following on from Theo's comment - Little Eggy, have you tried dancing?
Just bouncing around quietly in the corner of the practice room can be enormously enlightening. It gives you an insight into what dancers need.
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: hickory-wind on June 22, 2023, 01:43:59 PM
One option is the cleaver Pulse wristwatch metronome. It uses vibrations instead of sound so particularly nice for recording as it is virtually silent. I suppose you could even put it around your ankle if you don't want it visible in a video. For practicing I use a vintage old Franz electro-mechanical (it has a motor inside) strapped to the music stand post for easy access. Turn it on and rotate the dial to desired beat frequency. It also has a silent mode where a small neon light on top flashes instead of the 'clap'.

https://www.soundbrenner.com/pulse/ (https://www.soundbrenner.com/pulse/)

Scott
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on June 22, 2023, 02:12:06 PM
A great assett playing out is a good drummer who knows your repertoire and your dancers.

   I tried that, in drummer mode playing for my local Women’s side.

        But the bloke with the loud concertina would still speed up by 30-40% through a tune 🥴

I did say "a good drummer"  >:E

Seriously though, the bloke with the loud concertina wants putting straight on the bad effect he's having. One thing I have done, in practice, is stop everybody and tell them we're all going too fast. Blame myself if necessary, especially if it's my fault.
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 22, 2023, 02:18:20 PM
Another thought:
What type of morris are you playing for?
As a gross generalisation, Border and North West tend to require a steady speed whereas Cotswold will vary for each dance and within the dance, so a metronome isn't necessarily the best way forward.
Though I suppose it will get you used to playing at a given speed whether metronome or lead musician...
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Little Eggy on June 22, 2023, 05:20:37 PM
Hi Thrupenny - thanks for your suggestions.
No I haven't tried dancing but I fully recognise the point.
I may give it a go after one or two beers.
I've tried moving around like Lisa Jo of the Domesday side - but her style and skill are well beyond me!!!
I play with a Border Morris side.
At this early stage in my career I want to achieve a consistent tempo which the dancers like.
I've got the tunes in my fingers (for the most part) so I'm concentrating on learning the dances as a player, and getting the As and Bs right.
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Gena Crisman on June 22, 2023, 05:36:57 PM
how did pre digital everything bands keep spot on time with dancers...did they have better eyes and ears than ?many of todays musicians ;D

I think that the sentiment behind this kind of comment is uncool. It is important to avoid mistaking 'those who you consider to have been successful' as being 'the entire group who had aimed to try' - aka: survivorship bias.

Regardless, dear reader, these tools do exist today, so why not use them if you think they'd help you? If someone calls it a crutch, think about what a world with no crutches looks like, and tell them to sod off. You can decide for yourself if, when and how you want to use it. In the case of a bpm detector, you can even use the tool itself to prove you don't need it. How about that for building self assurance?
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Andrew Kennedy on June 22, 2023, 06:04:56 PM
'Crutch' is actually a good analogy for a metronome, in that a crutch allows a degree of mobility that might otherwise have been impossible but is no substitute for a healthy gait.  To mix metaphors, a metronome can be a good servant but is a poor master.

Surely the best judges of one's tempo in playing for dance are the dancers themselves.  Apart from anything else, the required tempo of a given dance can vary according to a range of factors (dancing surface, space, dancers' energy levels, etc).  The performance is, after all, a partnership between musician(s) and dancer(s), not between musician and electronic device.  This is where it becomes crucial to be sensitive to signals given - consciously or unconsciously - by the dancers, and especially by the squire, leader, or equivalent.  Being or having been a dancer is undoubtedly an asset (albeit not in itself sufficient) in a musician.
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 22, 2023, 06:29:00 PM
Hi Eggy,
If it's Border then yes a steady tempo is what you need.
Give stepping a go. You don't need to involve yourself in the intricacies of the dance. Just step-hop or whatever the stepping is, and keep it going. Get a sweat on.
Nothing like bashing it into the brain with your feet!
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Andy Next Tune on June 22, 2023, 07:13:14 PM
Some comments and thoughts -

- Beware 'sticking', dancers (border and cotswold) have a strong tendency to push the music in sticking choruses and it is too easy to follow them and speed up. 
- It is really helpful to know what is happening in the dance as well as the tunes, even if you don't dance. Visualising the dance helps me to set an appropriate tempo.
- Be aware of the 'non-standard' parts of a dance, perhaps a double length figure or 'slows'.

- For Android users wanting a great free metronome app, try MetronomerousSE. It has lots of great features to help/guide you, not just going beep, beep, beep, beep......
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Lester on June 22, 2023, 08:24:37 PM
Beware 'sticking', dancers (border and cotswold) have a strong tendency to push the music in sticking choruses and it is too easy to follow them and speed up.
They get one warning to stick in time, after that I go with them and carry on at the new 'dancer preferred' speed after the sticking ends   8)
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Tone Dumb Greg on June 22, 2023, 08:54:22 PM
Beware 'sticking', dancers (border and cotswold) have a strong tendency to push the music in sticking choruses and it is too easy to follow them and speed up.
They get one warning to stick in time, after that I go with them and carry on at the new 'dancer preferred' speed after the sticking ends   8)

Upton Upon Severn Stick Dance is very prone to this. Dancers and musicians both seem to like to speed up slightly each time through. Playimg on tempo for the figures feels to many like they're slowing down when they are not.
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: george garside on June 22, 2023, 11:34:24 PM
Hi Eggy,
If it's Border then yes a steady tempo is what you need.
Give stepping a go. You don't need to involve yourself in the intricacies of the dance. Just step-hop or whatever the stepping is, and keep it going. Get a sweat on.
Nothing like bashing it into the brain with your feet!

I like the notion of bashing it into the brain with your feet!   
this applies to many forms of dance where a steady rhythm is required  throughtout  the proceedings exept cotswold which I never mastered as I never played for that genre.   
for most dance music the musicians foot tapping should mimic that of a good dancer with small variations in tempo. Anexample of this was at a major week long festival i was sudenly asked to play every day for the border workshop having never played for that genre.   The workshop leader suggested a few tunes somr of which  i was quite familer with  and then he solo danced so i could pick up the required  tempo and phrasing.  We did this for 5 or 10 minutes before he commenced the weeks woth of workshops  and ,fingers fully crossed , I was able to provide the passable  music for the weeks workshops.  this was possible simply because i had grasped the tempo and phrasing required even though the tunes we settled on were not the ones he would normally have used .
I supose this just highlights the importance of  foot tapping as a very reliable way of keeping the right tempo because it allows for small changes in rhytm and timing that metronomic reliance can not provide










1
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 23, 2023, 07:28:01 AM
Andy - good point about sticking.
Yes it is a good opportunity for speeding up.
The discipline of the dancers needs to be highlighted in practice sessions to help reduce this.
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Chris Brimley on June 23, 2023, 08:23:55 AM
My take on this is that the crucial thing is always to tap your foot gently, to realise that your foot knows rhythm better than your fingers, and then to take the mental discipline of making sure your fingers follow your foot.  This may sound like gobbledygook, but I believe it works.  It's a question of 'groove'.  There seems to be something in the way the brain works that allows feet to understand rhythm well - they can keep plodding along whatever happens, and that's exactly what you need to get groove going.

The best musicians to listen to always have strong and disciplined rhythm.  Admittedly they don't always tap their feet though most use some sort of inner metronome technique, but my point is that steady rhythm allows music of all kinds to grow on the audience, whereas varying rhythm can quickly grate on the ears.

IMO a melodeon is not the easiest of instruments to control rhythm on, because of its inherent low 'attack', in comparison with say a guitar, drums or piano, but if played with a steady rhythm so as to bring out the internal rhythm in a tune, it can be very flexible and effective, which is why it is so good at dance music.  The trick is to learn the interrelationship between the attack of the foot beat, and the required emphasis on the played note, which of course occurs a fraction of a second later unless you correct by playing the note a fraction of a second earlier, as you learn to do automatically.

I use two different boxes for playing dance music, and the one I prefer the sound of has slightly less attack on the reeds.  When I swap to the faster action box, it actually takes me a few bars to adjust my fingers to play notes very slightly later, and I've found it is crucial here to listen to that foot!

But there's an added benefit in gentle foot-tapping - it relaxes your playing, and that in itself is the best way to allow you to play the right notes when you're nervous.  This seems to be a psychological thing - if I find I'm falling over in a tune, I've learnt to relax, impose calm on my foot, and that almost always works and brings your fingers back on track.

It's a strange world, playing a box!
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: george garside on June 23, 2023, 10:36:37 AM
totally agree with what Chris has written.  I would add that always playing with the smallest bellows opening where possible  rather than waving the bellows in the wind  enables changes of direction (and crispness) of notes that simply cant be achieved with wide open bellows  .
where a particular part of a particular tune necesitates a wide opening eg a bar or so with all push or pull notes a swift return to minimum opening where possible makes life much easier

george
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: CAB on June 23, 2023, 02:58:54 PM
Plenty of references to the Shand rhythm & tempo and playing to the dancers' feet in this tribute programme:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YAqHNNuPxvE (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YAqHNNuPxvE)
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Gena Crisman on June 23, 2023, 06:30:09 PM
Per https://youtu.be/YAqHNNuPxvE?t=677 :

"He was always a strict tempo man, and I asked him once, 'Jimmy, can you speed that up a wee bit?' and he said to me 'Son, you'll just dance it to the tempo it's supposed to be played at' *laughs*" - Dixie Ingram.

Food for thought, I suppose.
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: george garside on June 23, 2023, 07:13:29 PM
indeed (:) (:) ;D
G
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding upr
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 23, 2023, 10:31:20 PM

   My test is that any dance music should “inform the dancers’s feet’. In Scotland, that is pretty strict tempo as the Jimmy Shand video illustrates. Strathspay arguably an exception? 

    I’ve always played a lot of French stuff and there is a vast difference between the pulse of a bourrée, the firm swing of a waltz, the push and pull of a modern 9/8 mazurka, and the infinite complexities of Breton or Basque dance where are you have to … know the village concerned? But very few of these actually speed up. Une Circle Cecasse sometimes does.

   A lot of this is about Morris dance, where “know your village” also applies?  Slowing down and speeding up, is often intrinsic  to the dance concerned. But the art of Morris accompaniment is that the musician has to know his “6 fools”, and as they inexorably move to an increasing average age, their musician has to compensate for that.

   The bottom line is to know and respect the tradition within which you are playing. otherwise, you might destroy it. The metronome has a place, and is fairly critical, if you ever want to do an improvised line.
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: IanD on June 23, 2023, 10:54:37 PM
Watch the dancers.

Applies to cotswold, NW, border, ceilidh. If they're looking like the music is uncomfortably fast, slow down. If they're looking like the music is uncomfortably slow, speed up. If some bits of the dance work better with the music a little bit faster or slower, do that. If the dance wants to speed up as the energy builds then follow the dancers.

Don't just watch the "best" dancer *unless* all the others can keep up (or down) with their speed, watch the entire set -- you don't want to end up with one dancer fitting the music perfectly and the rest being way off the pace.

If there are multiple musicians, learn to play *together* -- one way is to have a lead musician who does all the above, and the rest follow them. But it's even better if everyone does all the above because it's the right thing to do when playing for dancing... ;-)
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: george garside on June 24, 2023, 11:07:33 AM
This can take place  for an hour or so on the way to a pub!!.  I t works well   and helps the togetherness that changes a motley connection of players into a band ....which provides the dancers with something that they can enjoy dancing to and unifies musicians and dancers.

I used this when I had a ceilidh band -- weekly band practice for maybe an hour followed by a group of friends having an evening in the pub.

george
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Dick Rees on June 24, 2023, 11:54:03 AM
Watch the dancers.

If their shoulders are ahead of their feet, the beat is too slow.


If their shoulders are behind their feet, beat is too fast.

Edited per message from TD Greg.
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: streb on June 24, 2023, 12:29:35 PM
I have found this great for Scottish and English tune fiddle practice, much better than a soulless metronome. Maybe a bit Irish for English melodeon

https://jonantonsson.bandcamp.com/album/bodhr-n-metronomes-for-practicing-irish-traditional-music

I don't know the fellow at all but the digital download was worth the £12.
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: IanD on June 24, 2023, 01:24:23 PM
This can take place  for an hour or so on the way to a pub!!.  I t works well   and helps the togetherness that changes a motley connection of players into a band ....which provides the dancers with something that they can enjoy dancing to and unifies musicians and dancers.

I used this when I had a ceilidh band -- weekly band practice for maybe an hour followed by a group of friends having an evening in the pub.

george

Except that practising without dancers can lead to a band who play together well but not to the dancers -- I've seen bands who do that and don't even look at the dancers when playing... :-(
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: george garside on June 24, 2023, 04:23:17 PM
Watch the dancers.

Applies to cotswold, NW, border, ceilidh. If they're looking like the music is uncomfortably fast, slow down. If they're looking like the music is uncomfortably slow, speed up. If some bits of the dance work better with the music a little bit faster or slower, do that. If the dance wants to speed up as the energy builds then follow the dancers.

Don't just watch the "best" dancer *unless* all the others can keep up (or down) with their speed, watch the entire set -- you don't want to end up with one dancer fitting the music perfectly and the rest being way off the pace.

If there are multiple musicians, learn to play *together* -- one way is to have a lead musician who does all the above, and the rest follow them. But it's even better if everyone does all the above because it's the right thing to do when playing for dancing... ;-)
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Stotty on June 24, 2023, 09:58:48 PM
And yet more good advice.
Thanks

Stotty I would like to see a photo please.

Two approaches.  The quick and simple version here is just some broad, self adhesive velcro tape backed with some thin black "leather" fabric (facing the box).  I did this as a temporary measure and I didn't even put the tape on centrally it my haste, but it has lasted well. I just hold the velcro when I "peel" off the mobile. 
I have a more elaborate set up on another box, and I'll post images of that too, but quite honestly this just does the trick and is less hassle as it stays on the box all the time, whereas the rigid attachment has to be removed.
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Stotty on June 24, 2023, 10:01:14 PM
(Other Christmas chocolate box lid designs are available)  The neater, but less convenient velcro base
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Little Eggy on June 25, 2023, 11:52:56 AM
Thanks Stotty and Gina.  I've bought that app. I like the way it follows what you're playing, unlike a metronome. And the history track line.
Of course, a metronome is quite good for practising how to quickly get back on beat when you slip,
who for me is a pretty frequent thing.

Just a thought but it would be neat if it incorporated a metronome, ie to enable you to set the tempo at the start, and get your foot tapping. Then turn it off and watch your progress.
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Gena Crisman on June 25, 2023, 03:34:22 PM
Sometimes before we start, I'll run the app and just tap on my phone at the tempo I think we'll be playing at, to see if I'm right. Not quite the same as a metronome to get a feel for the beat you want, but, good enough for me.

Effectively it hears loud things and tells you the lowest bpm that they occur, within a range, so it's listening for like a a drum beat? So the loud clack the mic picks up when you tap the phone is a good substitute, as are our basses. For a melody with no accompaniment, it's probably not going to work well, so you can't hum or sing to it really.

It needs the range slider set appropriately it turns out, because like musical frequencies, tempos have 'harmonics' too.

I use a 360 degree rotating elasticated bicycle phone holder, with a stretching band that goes around your handle bars, but with that threaded through my strap bracket, between my straps. It's very close to me, too close to read eg sheet music, which is what most people assume I'm using it for, but does the job for this. The exact one I bought is no longer available, but I can see very similar ones on amazon. This is the exact one I bought (https://amzn.eu/d/90gOf5b) to give you and idea, but can't vouch for any others as yet. Most fixed holders hold the phone vertical, for GPS navigation, which is no good for me, hence the 360 aspect. Also despite having the rubberised strap between the hard plastic parts and my melodeon, it has put a couple of small dents in the wood, mostly from the bad habit of not taking the phone holder off after I'm done, though, I think. I use my actual current phone, so confidence it wasn't going anywhere was important - while my phone isn't as expensive as my melodeon, I do own melodeons that cost less than it... So I wanted a relatively rigid feeling solution, and this satisfied me.
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 25, 2023, 04:47:18 PM
I agree a metronome or such like instrument or app is useful to learn how to maintain a constant speed, but be aware that given speed is not set in stone. As IanD says, the dancing speed will change throughout the day or situation.

In performance at a festival, on a sprung stage, with adrenaline squirting out our ears then our musicians will slow a touch to allow for the ( hopeful  ) extra height were dancing at.
Conversely at the end of a long hot day they will speed up as our energy flags and we are knackered.

Yes, use tools to get you playing at a given speed, but watch the dancers. A mantra for Morris musicians!
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Little Eggy on June 25, 2023, 08:52:06 PM
Sometimes before we start, I'll run the app and just tap on my phone at the tempo I think we'll be playing at, to see if I'm right. Not quite the same as a metronome to get a feel for the beat you want, but, good enough for me.

Thanks. I’ve tried that and it works well.  Also very useful for practising the tempos.
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Little Eggy on June 27, 2023, 01:33:11 PM
On last night’s dance out I field tested the app with our drummer and guitarist.  I tapped in the beat which we sort of agreed between us we stood waiting.  For the first two tunes it came out pretty close to what I had written down from recordings of our side’s recent dances. Anyway, feedback was good from the dancers.  So for the rest of the evening we trusted our collective judgement.  I will definitely continue with the app for practice, though, and on evenings when I’m the lone musician.
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: Andrew Kennedy on June 27, 2023, 02:15:35 PM
"...trusted our collective judgement".  Yes indeed.

And this discussion has barely touched upon dances with changes of tempo (Cotswold 'slows' for example).  The other night I was playing for a sword dance in five sections, using three different tunes, each at a different pace, danced on a slightly gravelly surface. That very much involved using our collective judgement.

Then again, there are different philosophies at play here. Some, such as Ian, have been emphasising the give and take relating to multiple factors.  Others see the music as a backing track to which the dancers can then add their contribution.  Fluffy Morris is now largely performed to recorded music which gets abruptly turned off when the routine is complete (the tempo is, of course, always absolutely consistent), and it has become favoured at DERT (the annual rapper contest) for teams to enter duos or small ensembles who play some lovely music to which the dancers then perform, but adaptability to circumstance is not a hallmark of the style. (Some will dispute this, but nevertheless...).

Each to their own, I suppose.  The most satisfying playing I have done is for a single step dancer, where you each get a feel for what's happening and are constantly responding to each other. But that's just me.
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: baz parkes on June 27, 2023, 05:03:49 PM
"...trusted our collective judgement".  Yes indeed.
.  Fluffy Morris is now largely performed to recorded music which gets abruptly turned off when the routine is complete

Coughs gently....Carnival Morris.... :|glug :|glug
Title: Re: Metronome and speeding up
Post by: george garside on June 27, 2023, 11:30:43 PM
This can take place  for an hour or so on the way to a pub!!.  I t works well   and helps the togetherness that changes a motley connection of players into a band ....which provides the dancers with something that they can enjoy dancing to and unifies musicians and dancers.

I used this when I had a ceilidh band -- weekly band practice for maybe an hour followed by a group of friends having an evening in the pub.

george

Except that practising without dancers can lead to a band who play together well but not to the dancers -- I've seen bands who do that and don't even look at the dancers when playing... :-(

It worked very well for me and my band as  we were all familiar with the tunes  ( from the weekly ish practices)  and myself followed closely by the drummer adjusted  the pace to suite  the dancers ( by watching their feet) the rest of the band also watched the daancers feet together with the tempo mainly of the drumer and myself. It worked very well.  I too have seen bands even at major festival events sitting more or less in a circle on the stage and doing their own (?individual?) thing  and bugger the dancers !
george
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal