Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: mselic on July 04, 2023, 06:06:26 PM
-
I'm in the process of modifying a set of Hohner Erica reedblocks to accept LM reeds, instead of the usual MM configuration. Typically, I would have a 'matching' arrangement of blocks in the instrument, meaning that if you looked down at them from above they would be 'LM', 'LM', but I'm concerned about the (probably unlikely) scenario of having the weighted tips of the inside L reeds making contact with the M reeds of the opposite block. I suppose a safe way to go about it would be to just keep both sets of L reeds on the outside of each block? I'm thinking the difference in tone (with the one set of L reeds getting the least amount of pallet lift while the other row's L reeds get the largest amount of lift) would be negligible? I'm sure more than a few folks have made this mod on an Erica and would appreciate input. Cheers.
-
If it’s a problem you can sand a small angle on the underside of the blocks so they lean away from each oither.
-
If it’s a problem you can sand a small angle on the underside of the blocks so they lean away from each oither.
But do you see any issue with the L reeds being mounted on the outside of each block instead? (LM, ML configuration when looking down at the blocks in situ).
-
I have an LM box built on a course with Emmanuel Pariselle it is very similar in size to to a pokerwork and there is no problem with reed tips making contact.
I don’t think there would be a problem putting the L reeds facing away from each other, but take care they don’t make contact with the bellows or bellows frame.
-
I've made one of these ( https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rONFTyBGCJQ (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rONFTyBGCJQ) ), will have a look tomorrow and get back to you.
-
It's easy enough to measure the amplitude of the reed tip on your tuning table. Even I manage it with my Heath Robinson equipment when I'm playing at making Frankenstein boxes.
-
Had a look at mine and what I did was mount the L reeds on the outside of the blocks. Pics HERE (https://photos.app.goo.gl/B18ryAVuVx9bh6117)
-
Here is a Pariselle LM with sone measurements. The L reeds are all on the furthest side of their blocks from the keyboard so they get maximum pallet lift. That is important to get a good response from the low reeds, and especially so with LM tuning so that the L and M reeds remain in tune over the largest range of playing pressure.
Space between facing reed tips is 11.5mm for the largest reeds. Space between the top edge of reed plates is 15mm