Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Thrupenny Bit on July 08, 2023, 06:16:28 PM
-
Following on from Julian's thread about choosing a 3 row layout, one responder mentioned the Castagnari Mas was becoming popular on the Continent.
At the recent DG Weekend at Halsway, we met a gentleman called Harwin Dhoore who plays a Mas and I think we were all blown away with the sound he gets from it.
Looking at the Castagnari catalogue, it has a 'thirds out' bass end and I think the left hand 2 switches bring in/out the low bass reed.
The right hand -I think - is LM with grill switches as seen on several of their models.
There's a mention of a baffle somewhere but where? dunno I'm baffled ( sorry, couldn't resist >:E ).
I think Hartwin's is a GC which also will have a much more lower resonant sound to my 'DG ear'.
I'm just wondering is there more to it, other than being a GC?
Listening again on Youtube last night, it's a very rich sound.
I think a 3 row would blow my mind, and have no intention of going along that road, but.... I'm curious!
yours
Curious of Devon.
-
I have one, and love it.
What's different? - less mass, mostly.
Both ends are two voice so less reeds, blocks, smaller pallets, lighter springs etc etc.
The RH keyboard is flat with very low button travel and fast, light action.
Compared with a Handry or Mory it feels overall significantly lighter, livelier and much more responsive.
It's much more akin to the kind of lighter 2 voice three row intruments which various French makers make.
The LH switch takes out the low bass, and the tonic from the chords.
The baffle is simply a very thin plywood sheet which slots in behind the keyboard. Unless you desperately need to practice without annoying people I can't imagine
when you would ever use it.
The price you pay is no thirds, a somewhat less 'full' sound, and the loss of that lovely rich Castagnari MM sound.
For what it's worth I also have a Handry - and the Mas has become the go to everytime for sheer playing pleasure.
-
I'm definitely tempted - Mas or an Evo...same weight I think, but Mas more expensive. Not certain whether Evo has thirdless chords.
When I tried the Mas before, I didn't really notice much difference using the baffle.
Julian
-
First came across the Mas a decade back and was ‘impressed’, (see 2nd paragraph). The ‘baffling’ one had its own name in 2012
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,9957.msg123250.html#msg123250
-
Ah lovely, a Mas owner, nothing like getting a 'user review'.
Thank you Graham for popping along and for explaining what the beastie is, it's good to know exactly what it is.
I'm getting to know my Mory but it's a weighty box, only a little less than the Handry, a lighter box certainly has it's attractions.
I think the main impression for me, listening to Hartwin's box recently was the lovely warm sound. I've since seen Hartwin uses a GC which must add to the mellow sound he produces.
I wonder if a DG sounds markedly different?
Graham, what tuning is your Mas?
-
... oh and thanks Chris for your baffling explanation 👍
-
I'm definitely tempted - Mas or an Evo...same weight I think, but Mas more expensive. Not certain whether Evo has thirdless chords.
When I tried the Mas before, I didn't really notice much difference using the baffle.
Julian
I think the Evo has thirds, with a stop an optional extra.
Bear in mind also that the Evo has conventional bass/chord pairs on the third row whereas the Mas has 6 basses with no chords. (Layouts are on Castas website).
The Mas bass buttons are also smaller (13mm instead of 15mm dia) and are raked on a slight angle which falls under the fingers nicely.
The Mas generally 'feels' very different to the other castagnaris with stepped keyboards.
Good luck!
-
I think the main impression for me, listening to Hartwin's box recently was the lovely warm sound. I've since seen Hartwin uses a GC which must add to the mellow sound he produces.
I wonder if a DG sounds markedly different?
Graham, what tuning is your Mas?
Mine is a GCacc.
The sound is subtly different to the Handry played with LM reeds only.
I'm not sure about DG - but the LM voicing works really nicely on the GC where you're more often playing in the upper areas of the keyboard. The lowest pitched L reeds are heavily weighted and the response (or at least, the subjective 'feel', of the lowest notes is affected). I guess that on a DG you are more often around the lower end of the keyboard so this will be a factor in how a DG Mas might sound / respond.
It's all fascinating ;)
-
Thanks Graham, yes it certainly is most fascinating.
It sounds like it is just that bit different than selecting LM on a Handry or Mory.
Your insight into the Mas is very useful to hear.
-
Hi Julian,
Why not have a drive North.
I have a Mas and Evo in stock as you know.
It really is worth spending 2 or 3 hrs playing them and making an informed decision
-
Hi Julian,
Why not have a drive North.
I have a Mas and Evo in stock as you know.
It really is worth spending 2 or 3 hrs playing them and making an informed decision
Would if I could Pete - email sent...
Julian
-
Graham did a good job summing up the Mas. I’ll add my thoughts (once again for a G/C/acc). They are very fast boxes and totally different to something like a Handry - both in tone and feel. The M/L works well but I do sometimes miss M/M - but it’s a compromise for achieving a lighter faster box. M/M would limit the potential range of the box and M and M/L give it two completely different sounds - I find just the M on the Mas to have a really sweet sound. M/L makes the box fit well with fiddle or mandolin - along with the bringing down the upper ranges of a G/C box. Anyone who has heard Hartwin Doore know the way that the Mas can sound. Overall it’s a joy to play.
Lack of thirds on the left hand does not bother me and the free bass selector on the left hand is an interesting option. Free bass once again opens up potential opportunities but it’s not for everyone.
As to the popularity of them on the continent (and I can only attest to this from seeing them crop up on YouTube videos) . It’s probably fair to say that its closest alternative is a Galliard. It’s certainly a move away from the big Handry 18 basses that were / are so popular. I’ve seen them in the hands of a lot of younger players and this could be the market that is pushing them forward.
Overall they are great boxes. They may not be everyone’s cup of tea, but if you are interested in the Bal scene on the continent then you’ll find a lot to like in them.
-
Thanks Schnorbitz for another owner review.
The Mas seems to be uncommon over here at present but exposure to such players as Hartwin and the rich mellow sound he has will I'm sure will change that.
It certainly impressed us when spending a weekend with him as a tutor in May.
-
I think the question in my mind is whether a D/G Mas sounds as good as the G/C. The lighter weight would be a big plus for me.
Julian
-
Yes, I would be interested to hear how a D/G Mas sounded. It’s probably fair to say it’s a box that is suited to more continental style playing (or maybe that is my perception). Well worth a trip to Acorn if you are thinking about one.
-
Absolutely take up Pete’s offer. Try before buy. It’s almost 13 years since I touched a Mas, so I have to rely on my field report. It was a pleasure to play. Gaillard’s stall was about 50m away in the Ch.d’Ars woodland, so I think my impression “copy of a Saphir†(other than its 12/11/10 keyboard) should stand.
My saphir is a G/C L/M, and I went for 4th start for compatibility. Bertrand said that I was mad, but I don’t regret it. The head end L reeds are real slugs wrt response. They’re technically bass reeds, and you can see the weights on the xray I posted last week. But the sound is luscious! The whole keyboard vibrates. They are also unstable, and the notes bend easily. As a blues fan … that was my intention 😎 It won’t suit everyone.
I think L/M voicing to be the best thing for a D/G. The reeds synchronise each other and the M ‘wakes up’ the L at head end. Bending is markedly reduced too. My own D/G is a van der Aa, also 4th start, delivered later that year. I went for L/M/M* voiceing, but hardly ever use the 3rd reed bank. A session or band player might see it differently, but using all 3 together uses a lot of air. 2 reeds is also much lighter
Be aware that 4th start on a 12/12/10 layout loses you your top G. There are fudges to play around that, but it might annoy if you play mainly on, rather than across the rows.
The ‘Grenoble’ 18-bass is truly liberating! You don’t get all the chords (I have no C# or Ab) but you do get all 12 basses in both directions. And it’s that bass that determines what mode your ear hears right-end phrases in. Have you ever seen a jazz trio without a bass player?
-
Chris - out of interest, as someone who has spent a lot of time on the continent, I would be interested in your views re the popularity of M/L vs M/M for G/C boxes. Have you seen a shift towards M/L from M/M over the years?
-
I'm not sure what the 'free base selector' means...
-
Free bass is normally an alternative LH system on CBAs. Essentially it replaces chords / basses on the LH with a chromatic system of individual notes - on a CBA they are very popular with classical players as the LH mirrors the layout of the RH. There are some incredible videos of Eastern European and Russian players using it. On the Mas it’s a free bass (ish) system as it does not follow the regular chromatic pattern a CBA would - the notes jump about a bit and are not unisonoric (although it is fully chromatic on the push and pull). But you can play a counterpoint melody to your RH. You just need to learn the layout . It’s fair to say it’s not something that many melodeon players would be looking for but it can be a lot of fun.
-
Thanks for that bit of encouragement, Schnorbitz. That's exactly what I'm pondering doing with a Scandalli C/C# which I've recently got my hands on. The biggest problem I envisage is which positions to have the eight bass notes in on the buttons.
I feel that having only basses (but more of them!) could help in playing (or even learning to play) a half step instrument.
-
Chris - out of interest, as someone who has spent a lot of time on the continent, I would be interested in your views re the popularity of M/L vs M/M for G/C boxes. Have you seen a shift towards M/L from M/M over the years?
I think it’s a matter of taste. Gaillard adores a wet M/M and is horrified that so many of his customers go for L/M following the Milleret Pignol lead. I haven’t been to France in 7 years because of illness, but I would say that M/M is more popular there still. But a G/C box is in the melodeonic sweet spot, everything works!
Over on Britain, mainly D/G we are seven semitones sharp of that sweet spot. that is as far as it goes? I remember Bruno le Tron (and others) pulling faces when they tried to play in the upper octave of my box. hence all our talk about 4th button start; and my own view that L/M is a good thing. Basically it stabilises the upper octave, and makes the whole keyboard play through … without damage to your cat’s ears.
-
Chris - out of interest, as someone who has spent a lot of time on the continent, I would be interested in your views re the popularity of M/L vs M/M for G/C boxes. Have you seen a shift towards M/L from M/M over the years?
I think it’s a matter of taste. Gaillard adores a wet M/M and is horrified that so many of his customers go for L/M following the Milleret Pignol lead. I haven’t been to France in 7 years because of illness, but I would say that M/M is more popular there still. But a G/C box is in the melodeonic sweet spot, everything works!
Over on Britain, mainly D/G we are seven semitones sharp of that sweet spot. that is as far as it goes? I remember Bruno le Tron (and others) pulling faces when they tried to play in the upper octave of my box. hence all our talk about 4th button start; and my own view that L/M is a good thing. Basically it stabilises the upper octave, and makes the whole keyboard play through … without damage to your cat’s ears.
Thanks Chris, interesting to hear. I think I remember a previous post where you commented on Galliards dismay at customers ordering LM. It is all down to personal taste. Fully agree on D/G 4th button start and the value of LM on a D/G.
-
Thanks for that bit of encouragement, Schnorbitz. That's exactly what I'm pondering doing with a Scandalli C/C# which I've recently got my hands on. The biggest problem I envisage is which positions to have the eight bass notes in on the buttons.
I feel that having only basses (but more of them!) could help in playing (or even learning to play) a half step instrument.
Yes, it's an interesting alternative view of the LH. A CBA free bass is essentially a repeating semi tone pattern of notes. On the bigger CBA left hand side this will cover a range of octaves. It's pretty easy to get your head around if you understand the relationship of the notes in a scale / mode. Co-ordinating the right and left hand though is where the complexity comes in (:)
-
Thanks for clarifying what a free bass is... yep, sounds like a lot of fun once you've got your head around it!