Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Thrupenny Bit on July 28, 2023, 04:38:49 PM
-
I was idly looking at the Castagnari catalogue, after recent threads here about some of their melodeons.
I thought struck me - if you are in the market for a 3 row box then the options available are great.
Everything from 3 voice treble, 2 voice, with some melodeons just LM, plus the left hand +/- low bass and thirds, and maybe 18 basses if you fancy.
If like me you've opted for a 2.5 row 12 bass melodeon, you've a choice of 2 - the 'bells and whistles' option of a Mory or the stripped down Dony with 2 voices and no registers ( save a thirds stop if wanted ).
In the UK from my limited experience of sessions and Halsway DG Weekends, if wanting more choices than a 2 row 8 bass can give, the weapon of choice generally seems to be the 2.5 row 12 bass not a 3 row.
Presumably the much larger Continental market is the main buyer of the 3 row boxes and driving such a varied choice of melodeons?
Yours
Curious of Devon.
-
Be careful idly browsing. (:)
The sales that I have are about the same,2.5 row Mory and Handry 18.
The Castagnari Handry 12 gives just that little bit more.
I think that the reason for customers not going for the3 row in its various formats is that in the UK stockists haven't bothered to stock them.
It is only just over a year ago that I was able to stock a full complement in the Castagnari range,Benny,Rik,Handry 13 and 18,Evo,Matris and Mad
-
Yes Pete, I'm very aware of the trouble 'idly browsing' might get me into ;D
I suppose I was more interested in the other side of the argument - there is a limited option if you don't want a full 3 rows.
i.e. you can ( and do ) only stock 2 melodeons with a half row, the Dony and Mory simply because that's all Castagnari make.
Perhaps there is less call for the 2.5 row for diatonic players compared to 3 row boxes and that's reflected in the maker's options?
-
I think that you would need to ask one of the Box ventors about that. The 2-½ rows are popular in Britain, very much because of Andy Cutting 😉 and I bought one initially.
Having experienced both I would personally now recommend 3 full rows. The weight and cost overheads are proportionally small, and the instrument will be chromatic with accidentals and reversals appropriate right across both keyboards. The cutdown version may become frustrating for many people in the long run.
-
I'm aware of the 'Cutting' effect, he seems to have been a good ambassador for the Castagnari Mory.
I realise the 3 row can be only a touch heavier than the 2.5 row, I suppose it is what we here are used to seeing here. Again, maybe Andy has a lot to answer for!
I wonder if our repertoire here has a part to play. Perhaps we are looking for just a full range of accidentals rather than a full compliment of reversals along the entire keyboard...
-
I realise the 3 row can be only a touch heavier than the 2.5 row,
For models that share their design yes, but many 2.5 row boxes that are designed to be more compact eg, Saltarelle Pastourelle and Connemara, Pariselle, Hohner Club II, Liliput etc. These are designed to have only 2 reed blocks on the 2 voice version so the whole instrument is smaller and light than it would be if it had three blocks.
-
Good point Theo
Yes I was thinking of the Mory and Handry who share the same design +/_ a few buttons.
-
Repertoire is definitely a factor. Large numbers of British melodeon tunes … don’t go very far into the upper octave?
A half row covers that nicely and offers accidentals in both octaves. Any 5th button is usually reversed D or E/D
As you start to “extend†your chords, or to play them in different inversions, or to improvise, (that’s traditionally across 2 octaves) the full
extra row really comes into it’s own! Ditto for off-piste keys like C, Cm, Bb, Gm or … most Blues. All of which are rare in English sessions?
I did a Blues in D in a “flat session†once. Nobody joined in! I had picked that key because it is the “built in†Blues scale that’s on every Bb/Eb 🥴
DFGAbACD. See attached. The entire scale is on the pull and is as fluent as … the contents of your pint glass.
(“Built in†Blues scale is always ½-tone flat of your inner row key. Play it in little “trianglesâ€. Your left-end is … of no use at all).
-
I've been thinking about your comments Chris.
As ever, with so many things, repertoire is everything. A rare 'absolute' in the world of melodeons!
In my opinion, our repertoire is changing with more people exploring the 'off piste' tunes as more and more old manuscripts are delved into.
Even tune books such as 'John if the Greeny' has over 40% of the tunes in non DG keys so it opens up the opportunity for either a herd of boxes in other keys or one that can tackle other keys reasonably well - hence the 2.5 row 12 bass option.
Perhaps as, or maybe if such tunes become more mainstream, there might be a move to 3 row boxes as it is undoubtedly more versatile than the half row boxes.
Who knows? ... it'll be interesting to see.
-
for thos ewishing to stay with 2 notes per button it may be worthwhile thinking about a 2 row BC or 3 row bcc#. both are chromatic ie have all thenotes for all keys but the 2row ( like most DG boxes) is somewhat limited on the bass side. a 48 bass BCC# is a good compromise between versatility a nd weight.
Moving away from 2 notes per button the continental chromatic (3,4 and 5 rows ) provided everything you need and in 5 row form all keu=ys can be played with same fingering but its not a melodeon. I play both systems and and as the fingering and bellowing is completely different there is not a problem.
-
Following a great deal of idle browsing I bought a 3 row Benny about 6 weeks ago, so you could say I have made my mind up on this subject.
I’m coming from 2 rows, and I suppose I’m a bit of a morris player with a tendency towards on-the-row playing - I love the “quack†you get with a well timed bellows change - although I have always crossed the rows to find easier or smoother fingerings when I fancy. I own some club boxes but have only ever used those third rows for accidentals. I wanted a full third row to give me more choice of fingerings, and this Benny seems to offer most notes in both bellows directions and in sensible and easy to find positions for my hunt-and-peck method.
I reckon to date I have used 7 or 8 of my extra 10 buttons. I have set myself the task of learning Andy Cutting’s “In Continental/Old Queen / Flatworld “ set in the Blowzabella book keys, and I think that accounts for at least 6 buttons of the third row. (…..how does Andy play it with 5? :)
So ….. the reason I went for 3 full rows was all about choice of fingerings - obviously 10 accs give you more choice than 5 (I’d expect the top one or two to not wear out quickly tho’). I don’t expect to play in every key but this layout seems to make several keys reasonably comfortable and makes the notes I’m looking for easy to find.
Gren
-
a 48 bass BCC# is a good compromise between versatility a nd weight.
You might have that T-shirt, George. Not many of us do 😉
-
I have set myself the task of learning Andy Cutting’s “In Continental/Old Queen / Flatworld “ set in the Blowzabella book keys, and I think that accounts for at least 6 buttons of the third row. (…..how does Andy play it with 5? :)
He has boxes in DG and CF, and more recently BbEb.
-
Weight does become an issue with larger boxes.
I'm at my limit with a Mory, I couldn't handle larger boxes even if I wanted the whole ranges of a BCC# etc.
What is notable, within the Castagnari range is that several of the 3 row boxes without the extra voice options especially on the right hand are lighter than the 2.5 row Mory.
I'm not sure a Benny is for me though I do see it as a very light alternative.
I'm sure if I had Andy's lifetime of squeezing a Mory, I wouldn't notice the weight.
But I haven't, and I do!
-
For a lightweight 2 voice box, there's little better than a ClubII/Erika. 25 buttons. 11/10/4.
If the 4 on the helper row aren't enough, do as Will Allen does and utilise the end buttons.
It has the same capability as my Pariselle 9/10/6 though slightly less conveniently laid out. Yes it's only 8 bass but these are easily converted to 12 - even more so if you have thirdless chords.
Of course there are the larger club boxes like the Victoria already with 30 buttons but these are slightly more unwieldy.
-
Following a great deal of idle browsing I bought a 3 row Benny about 6 weeks ago, so you could say I have made my mind up on this subject.
I’m coming from 2 rows, and I suppose I’m a bit of a morris player with a tendency towards on-the-row playing - I love the “quack†you get with a well timed bellows change - although I have always crossed the rows to find easier or smoother fingerings when I fancy. I own some club boxes but have only ever used those third rows for accidentals. I wanted a full third row to give me more choice of fingerings, and this Benny seems to offer most notes in both bellows directions and in sensible and easy to find positions for my hunt-and-peck method.
I reckon to date I have used 7 or 8 of my extra 10 buttons. I have set myself the task of learning Andy Cutting’s “In Continental/Old Queen / Flatworld “ set in the Blowzabella book keys, and I think that accounts for at least 6 buttons of the third row. (…..how does Andy play it with 5? :)
So ….. the reason I went for 3 full rows was all about choice of fingerings - obviously 10 accs give you more choice than 5 (I’d expect the top one or two to not wear out quickly tho’). I don’t expect to play in every key but this layout seems to make several keys reasonably comfortable and makes the notes I’m looking for easy to find.
Gren
What layout do you have on the Benny?
-
What layout do you have on the Benny?
It’s Bob Ellis, 4th start and goes down a whole octave. It seemed more suitable for D/G than Heim. It might have been different if I’d gone for a low voiced box but I’m fond of the mm sound.
Gren
-
I've got a couple of Bennys - GCAcc & DGG# they aren't much heavier than a two row and offer so much more. The standard Benny is 200g lighter than a Tommy.
-
DGG#? Not come across that tuning before, how does it hold up?
-
Aâ™/Bâ™ C/ C# Eâ™/F Aâ™/G 🤔
You have pull G already. Push C always handy?
The pull B♠and F … don’t help main key minor scales.
The E Blues scale (the one with left end basses) isn’t fluent.
Eâ™ wrong way for E harmonic minor, and A Blues
Not my choice, but as always it depends on what you play
-
As said before, it all depends on repertoire... and perhaps style of playing.
I've been looking at the Heim layout and comparing Paul Young's Mory layout ( that I have ) to one he proposes for a 3 row DG.
In both instances, I simply cannot envisage using the top buttons on the main row let along using the reversals and accidentals available on the 3rd row.
I think we glossed over the answer up a few posts.
I use the half row as a source of accidents relating to the main 2 rows on my 2.5 row box, broadly speaking over 3 octaves from low G below the stave.
I do not right hand chord, so there are several buttons I would have no use for on a 3 row.
From my ( limited ) knowledge of watching a few continental players, they do right hand chord, and one I know is very jazz oriented and uses absolutely every button available.
Perhaps that is the crux of the matter and one that distinguishes between the two sorts of box.
A 2.5 row provides accidentals over a limited range of the keyboard, a range that broadly fits the repertoire used here in the UK.
A 3 row allows for a different style of playing, common on the continent, where right hand chording is used more frequently... and that opens up a larger market.
Maybe? just thinking aloud on a wet sunday afternoon!
-
This might interest somebody looking for 3 a row - I bought this in 2020 dirt cheap(secondhand). It was originally B system. I decided recently that I had to do something with it as it was just shoved in a corner doing nothing.
I converted it to bcc# and fitted an air bar instead of the button.
It weighs 4.9Kg. and is really fun to play.
The buttons just screw in and can be changed/re-arranged easily.
Here's a pic -hopefully.
P.S. This is not for sale at the moment - just saying.🙂
-
I'm in new to the 3 row boxes and coming from mainly playing diatonic systems 1 & 2 rows chromatics mess with my head a bit but keep trying. I often wonder as not seen a shift up on the
BCC# to CC#D making it still chromatic but more akin to the C#D two row with all the naturals on the C & giving a good Am also. Thought about this
Seeing the debates around the BC vrs CC# vrs C# D. Looking at the articles on home page re tunings and rows I see there's a C#D/G option somewhere
-
" I often wonder as not seen a shift up on the
BCC# to CC#D"
Hi Spike, the short answer is because you dont need to - you can play in all keys with a bcc# - however, the fingering might be more akward.
All the popular keys eg. D,A,Am,G,Bm,C, etc are fairly straightforward when you get used to playing tunes in these keys - BUT - if you are trying to learn a tune someone else is playing on a c#d box (which is probably in E) then its far easier to drop it down to D to get the same fluid sound.
You can play in E on a bcc# but it would sound different.
As the tunes I play in D use all 3 rows, I would need a c#dd# box for them to come out in E ( I think). Luckily E is not that popular a key up here for Scottish (or any) tunes anyway. I do play tunes like "The burst mattress" in E, but I learned it in E to start with. Good luck, - John.
-
As we've said, it all depends on what you want to play.
I recently went through 2 tune books checking which keys the tunes were in.
John of the Greeny has no tunes in E, only 11 in A and William Winter's Quantock tune book had 1 tune in E with a few more in A.
From my limited poll of a couple of books on my bookcase it seems a lot of the older English manuscripts or tune books favour the flat keys.
A DG box with the additional 4 bass buttons giving F, F#m, Bb and Eb with the ability to remove 3rds takes you a long way in the tunes I wish to play.
-
as othich ers have sugggested instead of adding a row or part row of odds and sods to a 2 row dg it makes a lot of sense to move onto a 3 row BCC# which is chromatic on the treble side i.e it has the wherewithall to play in all keys on the treble side and whic generally have bass that plays in both directions as on a piano box.
or coming at it from a different direction tunes in keys you havnt got on a DG box can be transposed on the hoof to be played in keys you have got on a dg box with perhaps awee bit of faking here and there such as providing a diversion on the bass to take the mind (and ear) away from notes you havnt got.
the art of faking is well worth practicing as it often enables the playing of tunes that contain a note or two that you havnt got!
george
-
Personally, having been learning to play basically D/G for 45 years I reckon having a few more buttons than the five on my Mory and Dony to be an easier step than learning a whole new system. But what those extra buttons should be, for the eclectic range of music I play (never mind what I might like to play next !) remains the question.
No matter the DG acc layout, having a different box in different keys - be it C/F, G/C, Bb/Eb or whatever has advantages, except when trying to carry them round Whitby or wherever - and fit them in the car !
Julian
-
I appreciate the thoughts from previous posts but ...
I have a 2.5 row 12 bass and that is as heavy as I can use. I'm on the absolute limit.
I am aware that there are fewer options for a half row instrument compared with a 3 row instrument, and wondering why is the reason for starting this thread.
I've glanced at a couple of 3 row layouts and simply cannot see the use for the extra buttons on the 3rd row. I don't right hand chord and use the half row as an 'accidental row' which alongside with the layout I use makes it fully chromatic from low G below the stave over 3 octaves of G.
My particular weapons of choice are from Castagnari and as said, it is somewhat frustrating that they do 2 half row instruments and from memory 5- 6 choices for 3 row instruments.
My conclusion being 3 row instruments have a greater market than 2.5 row intruments hence a greater choice.
Which is a tad frustrating!!
-
Personally, having been learning to play basically D/G for 45 years I reckon having a few more buttons than the five on my Mory and Dony to be an easier step than learning a whole new system.
Very much so. I bought my first 3-row 12-base in 2004, when I’d been playing mostly D/G for 18 years. It was a deliberate step into off-piste keys and tonal music. A C#DG Oakwood I was amazed one of the easiest scales was Bb! And that Bb Blues was an absolute belter!!
I don’t think I would recommend buying more than 2½ for anyone who is content to play stuff within the modes of the two main rows, though a 12+ bass is very liberating even in that.
-
I'm in the early stages of going off- piste and playing tunes in C, Am, Bb and Gm.
It is a lovely learning curve and am starting to get the hang of using a larger box and recognising other sounds.
My hands are starting to go to the right places, but still missing buttons and the inevitable 'ouch' sound happens ::)
Certainly at the moment I need nothing more in terms of extra buttons, just work out how to be proficient
( roughly) on what I've got.
I just wish that as my joints get more creaky, that in the future I had more of an alternative 2.5 row box.
An idle thought that started this thread!
-
As with grade 3 piano, it’s mostly about “scales†I’m afraid. Although my buttons are featureless and black, I can see a crooked line, travelling up the keyboard in my head. If I stick to those buttons, I’m alright.
You should also practice the important chords in favoured keys until you can play them without much thought, in both octaves. Once you know both octaves, then you get all the chord inversions for “freeâ€, and sometimes they sound nicer in a melody.
And once you can run the scale through both octaves, getting at chord extensions is just a matter of adding the “other“ note in higher octave using little finger. i.e the method … reinforces itself.
I had a problem playing in B flat, as my Ab note was only on the push. In Bb blues … I simply rocked on my Ab/Bb button 🇪🇺 much as you would playing along the main row.
A good dodge for the chords is to play a sus as a substitute for anything with the awkward note in it 👍 that obviously doesn’t work a Cm … and the trick there is to play push Ab against the C bass. it’s all the “art of the possible.†And a very different way of tackling the instrument, as you say
-
For the first time in my life I'm working on scales.
I think I need to be more rigorous but... I'm starting and that's... a start ;D
I think I too am seeing lines across the keyboard.
Interesting what is going on inside my mind, but that's another massive thread!
-
I appreciate the thoughts from previous posts but ...
I have a 2.5 row 12 bass and that is as heavy as I can use. I'm on the absolute limit.
I am aware that there are fewer options for a half row instrument compared with a 3 row instrument, and wondering why is the reason for starting this thread.
I've glanced at a couple of 3 row layouts and simply cannot see the use for the extra buttons on the 3rd row. I don't right hand chord and use the half row as an 'accidental row' which alongside with the layout I use makes it fully chromatic from low G below the stave over 3 octaves of G.
My particular weapons of choice are from Castagnari and as said, it is somewhat frustrating that they do 2 half row instruments and from memory 5- 6 choices for 3 row instruments.
My conclusion being 3 row instruments have a greater market than 2.5 row intruments hence a greater choice.
Which is a tad frustrating!!
WHen I was looking at getting a smaller 3-row box from Castagnari many years ago (*long* before the Benny) the Rik was too big, the original Dony 2.5 was smaller but only has 2 reed blocks so couldn't be expanded. We were going round their "factory" (in the days when the only sign out front was a slip of paper in the doorbell...) when I saw the treble end of a new 2.5 row on the shelf that I didn't recognise -- when I asked (Sandro?) he said this was the "Dony Nuovo", and it had 3 reed blocks...
After a lot of argument involving phrases like "Non possible!" I persuaded him to add an extra 4 buttons to turn it into a 3-row 12-bass (LM bandoneon tuned) which AFAIK is unique, and I've owned it ever since :-)
Oh yes, I forgot -- button layout (DGacc) came from Emmanuel Pariselle...
P.S. Couldn't cope with a Mory, *far* too big and heavy for me. Here's why...
-
probably Sandro. He’s the only brother that seems to speak much English. To the right, blue shirt.
agree. The sign on the door was ridiculously small!
-
probably Sandro. He’s the only brother that seems to speak much English. To the right, blue shirt.
agree. The sign on the door was ridiculously small!
There wasn't a sign on the door at all when I first went in the early 80s, that appeared later. There was one of those little plastic doorbells with a black button and a clear window though which you could read a slip of paper about 2" x 0.5", which had "Castagnari" typed on it in the same way it would say "Dedic" or "Ryall"...
-
Oh don't... I'm performing at a festival at the beginning of September, an hour's drive away without much free time, or a car :(
-
There wasn't a sign on the door at all when I first went in the early 80s, that appeared later. There was one of those little plastic doorbells with a black button and a clear window though which you could read a slip of paper about 2" x 0.5", which had "Castagnari" typed on it in the same way it would say "Dedic" or "Ryall"...
It was still there in May 1991.