Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: James Fitton on November 20, 2009, 09:17:21 AM
-
I've been reflecting on one aspect of the Witney experience this week. I had a great time, met lots of lovely people, played lots of great music. But it's interesting how very middle-aged it all is (and I've no room at all to talk, being very middle-aged myself). I go to quite a few festivals, which attract plenty of younger people, and I know that there are excellent young players out there. But it did leave me wondering whether we do enough to encourage younger players, not just the really good ones who come out of Folkworks and the like, but the ordinary plugging-away ones. We play a relatively expensive instrument, and lots of us have spares - are there ways we could organise loanable instruments via melnet? could we put together a list of people willing to offer affordable or free tuition locally? Could events like Witney offer strands explicitly targetted at younger people? Any thoughts?
-
Speaking as - I think - a young person (well I'm not middle-aged yet and still got a few years left to get on a youth travelcard so...).
I only stumbled across this genre of music by accident which by a long way round and lots of happy co-incidences led me to the melodeon.
I hadn't seen one before 2008. lol!
I would say the main problem for young people is the cost and transport. A young person subsidy for workshops (of all levels) would be nice. Not nessasarily for my age, more for students who won't have much money or thier parents can't afford to pay.
I'm ok coz I've got a job, but if I was still at school I'd never be able to get my mum to fork out that amount of cash for a workshop especially as most of the time it involves traveling quite far and finding somewhere to stay overnight at least.
-
I've been reflecting on one aspect of the Witney experience this week. I had a great time, met lots of lovely people, played lots of great music. But it's interesting how very middle-aged it all is (and I've no room at all to talk, being very middle-aged myself). I go to quite a few festivals, which attract plenty of younger people, and I know that there are excellent young players out there. But it did leave me wondering whether we do enough to encourage younger players, not just the really good ones who come out of Folkworks and the like, but the ordinary plugging-away ones. We play a relatively expensive instrument, and lots of us have spares - are there ways we could organise loanable instruments via melnet? could we put together a list of people willing to offer affordable or free tuition locally? Could events like Witney offer strands explicitly targetted at younger people? Any thoughts?
My Grandaughter is almost 1 yr old - guess what she is having for her 5th birthday? (at least that my plan).
-
My teenage son is a Rock God in waiting - expecting to be discovered any day now. The one thing he absolutely does not want to do is get involved with anything that his 'uncool' dad is doing. And I don't blame him. I too was exactly the same when I was 17. So I've informed him that eventually when he hits middle age and is casting around for something to do I'll let him have one of my melodeons. His response was predictable:
:>>\
At last I've found a use for the above emote!
AL
-
My teenage son is a Rock God in waiting - expecting to be discovered any day now. The one thing he absolutely does not want to do is get involved with anything that his 'uncool' dad is doing. And I don't blame him. I too was exactly the same when I was 17. So I've informed him that eventually when he hits middle age and is casting around for something to do I'll let him have one of my melodeons. His response was predictable:
:>>\
I have a similar reaction when my mum tries to get me to learn to dance. Its uncool coz she's doing it. I said I'll only learn to dance if I get a handsome young male partner. (that's not going to happen...thus I'm safe). lol!
-
ashley orchard is an amazing box player and hes only 19 i think i know of a few romany young lads taking up the box, but i general i dont know too many others, im 25 so young ish!
-
Yes, he is a great player! It must help having the whole family playing too. He embarassed us by trying our "diminutive" D/G boxes and playing tunes outside the Datmoor/Gypsy tradition with great flair. I doubt his Dad will be too pleased if he buys a smaller box, though... just doesn't fit the family style.
We were lucky enough to happen upon him busking with Simon Ritchie, too!
Rob.
-
Well the young role models are there. I thought two of the Witney Concert players would be going home for an early night as they had their paper rounds to do in the morning ;D
My 8 year old son picks up the pokerwork, not to play it much, but to do fantastic impressions of John Kirkpatrick. :||: I think he is encouraged by us putting him in the folk festival environment. Interesting that he also wants to play with one strap, he is definitely not influenced by his untrendy mum ::)
Cheers
Sandy
(:)
-
I don't think Ashley Orchard will be tempted to buy a smaller melodeon (he started on a Pokerwork). He phoned me the other day looking for a four row, four voice with Stradella bass. Heavy man!
I would say that there were at least fifteen players under 30 years of age at Witney, including the very young and talented Sam Mabbett. (13 years old at a rough guess).
-
Speaking as - I think - a young person (well I'm not middle-aged yet and still got a few years left to get on a youth travelcard so...).
I only stumbled across this genre of music by accident which by a long way round and lots of happy co-incidences led me to the melodeon.
I hadn't seen one before 2008. lol!
I would say the main problem for young people is the cost and transport. A young person subsidy for workshops (of all levels) would be nice...if I was still at school I'd never be able to get my mum to fork out that amount of cash for a workshop especially as most of the time it involves traveling quite far and finding somewhere to stay overnight at least.
I agree with LDT on this (and not just re. young people - I have always thought of Witney as expensive, due to the time of year and thus lack of cheap camping available). Other weekend workshop events - such as the Folkus one in Clitheroe - offer cheaper rates for 10 -16 year olds, and the availability of 4-bedded 'hostel' type accommodation if coming for the weekend. They also have a separate set of tutors for the young folk.
But as Witney seems to fill itself quite adequately at full price rates, then I doubt there would be any commercial incentive there, to offer cheap rates.
-
I would say that there were at least fifteen players under 30 years of age at Witney, including the very young and talented Sam Mabbett. (13 years old at a rough guess).
Not only is he very young and talented he was a joy to play with on the Sunday morning early, just him and me. Unlike other precocious youngsters I have observed he listened to what we were playing and added to it rather than just displaying his undoubted talent, hopefully he will go far.
-
I'm ok coz I've got a job, but if I was still at school I'd never be able to get my mum to fork out that amount of cash for a workshop especially as most of the time it involves traveling quite far and finding somewhere to stay overnight at least.
Its not just the lack of cash for workshop/lessons etc but the lack of cheap reasonable quality instruments which non box playing ( or non folk cene) parents will compare with chinese violin outfits for less than £100 quid new & much less second hand or cheap guitars. Perhaps if schools gave mouth organ instead of recorder lessons more youngstrs would develop a taste for the push/pull box. The relative few under 18's taht I have had in workshops over many years have all had either box playing parents or folk orientated parents who play another instrument. As far as private lessons go the average starting age is mid fifties ? preparing for retirement or have reached the stage when a box is affordable!
george
-
but the lack of cheap reasonable quality instruments which non box playing ( or non folk cene) parents will compare with chinese violin outfits for less than £100 quid new & much less second hand or cheap guitars. Perhaps if schools gave mouth organ instead of recorder lessons more youngstrs would develop a taste for the push/pull box. The relative few under 18's taht I have had in workshops over many years have all had either box playing parents or folk orientated parents who play another instrument. As far as private lessons go the average starting age is mid fifties ? preparing for retirement or have reached the stage when a box is affordable!
Whenever I tell people how much I paid for my boxes I see the look of disbelief and most often than not they exclaim 'You could get a car for that'. So I don't think parents unless they understand would fork out so much money for a box when the kid might not stick with it.
(going off on a tangent, my sisters friend's little sister had a go on my concertina (she's only tiny - melodeon would be too big for her), loved it, wanted her parents to buy one for her, but was turned down on account of the price. I'm wondering if she's still intrested I might lend her my old one when it comes back from the other person I lent it too.)
-
There are young players around, particularly in the cotswold morris and rapper world, but I get the impression that they prefer to stick with their own age group rather than be seen with old (i.e. anyone over 25) uncool beardy folkie types.
Mike
-
Question is, how many established box players are taking on young protégées ?
I have mine… watch this space… hes gonna be brilliant. :P :P :P
I just hope he keeps it up through his teens … (I didn’t… melodeon doesn’t work when your trying to be a punk/goth)
-
The average age at Witney is relatively high, but then that appears to be the case with most interests which require application, perseverance and a degree of wallet-waving. However, I don't think that the price of the weekend is unusual and I like the fact that, unlike some other events, it is specific to the melodeon.
Hands On Music Weekends run courses for other instruments and they seem to fall at the same time each year. Perhaps it would help if they were rotated? Maybe then it would coincide with school holidays etc. Also, if you have younger people going then they will have to be accompanied. This presents problems of extra accommodation costs and poses the question of what the adults will do during the tuition, assuming that they aren't learning melodeons too.
Another factor which may affect the number of younger people learning is schools. Most schools encourage the uptake of orchestral instruments with associated tuition, targets and bands. I shouldn't have thought that many of them have even heard of a melodeon.
The cost of the instruments range from high to astronomical and are a specialised market - trumpets and clarinets are available from Argos! You can get toy melodeons for £15 without sharp edges or disappearing buttons, so it would be nice if there was a sub £100 model which people could have a go on before committing to something more expensive.
Hiring would be another option, but EATMT is the only organisation I know that does this although it seems to work well and be popular.
-
Have a contest for different age groups. If a ten year old wins first or second, that's inspiration to continue, plus other 10 year olds might think, "I could have done that.." Just my .02%
-
I don't want to come across as an old curmudgeon, but all we middle-aged fogies were young once, and faced the same problems as today's youngsters. While it's true that entry-level melodeons are a lot more expensive than starter guitars or violins, they're not expensive compared with many other instruments, and probably cheaper in real terms than when I got started. If you think novice melodeon players have a problem with the cost of instruments, you should read the similar threads on concertina.net
For all the complaints about cost and accessibility of workshops for young people, at least the workshops are there. There was nothing like Whitney or EATMT or Folkworks when I were a lad. When I was at school only classical instruments were permitted. I couldn't even get guitar lessons.
Youngsters will only get into obscure instruments like melodeon if they've already been exposed to the music. The cost of instruments and tuition is always an issue, but it applies whenever a child wants to play any instrument. The biggest obstacle is probably a lack of child-friendly opportunities to play. Most melodeon playing seems to take place in adult environments such as pubs which may not be suitable for children.
-
Entry-level melodeons are only expensive if you are foolish enough to buy new... I bought my first for £180 at Sidmouth and I saw boxes around for similar prices. £250 would buy you a nice box.
-
I would say that there were at least fifteen players under 30 years of age at Witney, including the very young and talented Sam Mabbett. (13 years old at a rough guess).
Not only is he very young and talented he was a joy to play with on the Sunday morning early, just him and me. Unlike other precocious youngsters I have observed he listened to what we were playing and added to it rather than just displaying his undoubted talent, hopefully he will go far.
Yes - I agree. Sam was great. Very talented and also very sensitive. Someone to watch out for!
-
Hi,
Our kids got involved by chance,friends took us to the Teasdale Thrash and we became hooked,eldest daughter played piano then on second year we saw Dave Swarbrick,youngest daughter 5/6 years old,only wanted to play fiddle after that.They both got involved with folkworks,brilliant organisation,they met life long friends,in fact my eldest daughter met her husband there.
They both now have many friends and acquaintances and a gigging band which brings in a bit of extra cash in these difficult times.
My point is, kids want to experience things and not be pushed too hard,if they enjoy it they will do it,peer pressure is however a great problem and many potencialy talented players loose interest when they are hassled,my daughter wouldn't take here PA to school because of this.
Re competitions,these can actually have a bad effect on not as talented players,much better to allow them to play together with guidance.
My daughters are only 26 and 22 now
Pete
-
Yes - I agree. Sam was great. Very talented and also very sensitive.
I'm constantly delighted at how tolerant and inclusive are the highly talented young musicians round here. I play with them in sessions and several superb players are quite happy to dep in my ceilidh band. It could be just the money of course, but they always seem to enjoy themselves.
-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zOAWtph5jYw
-
Well, speaking as one of Rees' 'people under 30 at Witney' (although not for much longer!), I think the folk world as a whole is extremelty encouraging to young people taking up instruments, much more so than the classical world. But of course, to make the most of that, as someone mentioned earlier, you need to be exposed to it - through folkie parents of whatever. Certainly I would never have considered taking up another 'classical' instrument after leaving school, but that same feeling doesn't seem to apply with folk instruments (thank goodness, otherwise I'd not be here!).
I always thought all the 50-somethings learning to play that I see at workshops were ex-morris-dancers, but perhaps there's another source of new middle-aged players?!
And for the record, I suspect that the Devon Squeezebox foundation also does good work in this area, although I'm not sure if they lend out boxes. (If only there was something like that that covered the rest of England!)
Edit: And now I'm gutted that I didn't hear Sam play. Oh well, there's always next year ::)
-
I always thought all the 50-somethings learning to play that I see at workshops were ex-morris-dancers, but perhaps there's another source of new middle-aged players?!
Quite a lot of us will be looking for new challenges having raised children, or retired, or both.
-
I always thought all the 50-somethings learning to play that I see at workshops were ex-morris-dancers, but perhaps there's another source of new middle-aged players?!
Quite a lot of us will be looking for new challenges having raised children, or retired, or both.
True. Perhaps I'll save learning the fiddle for when I get there then ;D
-
I saw Sam at Sidmouth. Certainly a very talented player.
-
Edit: And now I'm gutted that I didn't hear Sam play. Oh well, there's always next year ::)
Not Witney but earlier this year I think.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zOAWtph5jYw
CHeers
Sandy
(:)
-
I think the folk world as a whole is extremelty encouraging to young people taking up instruments, much more so than the classical world. But of course, to make the most of that, as someone mentioned earlier, you need to be exposed to it - through folkie parents of whatever. Certainly I would never have considered taking up another 'classical' instrument after leaving school, but that same feeling doesn't seem to apply with folk instruments (thank goodness, otherwise I'd not be here!).
I'm with you there, Ellie! I worked my way through a few classical instruments while I was in school and never got on with any of them. I'd just about got used to the idea of never playing anything when I got onto the melodeon earlier this year when I was 19. It's the more laid back attitude of learning a folk instrument I like - most people are self taught, there's not so much of a 'right' way to do it, and you don't have to think about grades, theory etc. Yeah, you tend to get into it through folkie parents or friends, but I don't think there's anything discouraging young people from getting involved in the folk world. Everywhere I've been with the box I've been welcomed with open arms by lovely people, full of advice and delighted to have me join in. Even when I could barely string a tune together I felt welcome. I don't know if the same can be said of other kinds of musical gatherings.
I do agree that workshops could be a little more accessible though - just in terms of logistics. I would have loved to come to Whitney this year but it would be near impossible on a student budget (and timetable!) so I'm only going to be able to go once I've finished my degree. I imagine it would only be more difficult for someone still at home full time. So yeah, student/young people's rates and some affordable accomodation would go a long way.
As for price... to a certain extent I guess you have to accept that you're playing a niche instrument, and that it won't come cheap. Few instruments do. It's a shame though - a friend of mine took to my Hohner and would have bought himself one if not for the price - he's settled for a little chinese toy one! As ukebert says, second hand does help, but even then you're still looking at at least a couple of hundred quid. Some sort of loaning system would be great if it could be pulled off.
-
There are young players around, particularly in the cotswold morris and rapper world, but I get the impression that they prefer to stick with their own age group rather than be seen with old (i.e. anyone over 25) uncool beardy folkie types.
Mike
I'll stick with anyone who wants to play some tunes! (I'm 22 and a bit BTW).
I grew up around middle aged bearded men playing in sessions in the south east, and I learnt a lot from it. I still enjoy going home and playing tunes with them. I also learnt a lot of songs from them.
I hope I don't come across as precocious as a younger player, and it's a shame I haven't been to Witney since 2005. It's a long way to go in the middle of term at uni in Newcastle! Nice to hear about other youngsters being there this year though.
-
I'll stick with anyone who wants to play some tunes! (I'm 22 and a bit BTW).
I'm 23 and a bit ;) and will play with anyone....as long as they'll put up with me and my idiosyncrasies.
I don't think I'd want to be in a class full of youngsters...might be chaos ;)
-
One of the problems I've seen over my playing career, is the lack of exposure that a lot of young people get, unless their parents are heavily involved in either dancing or playing.
There is a generation who are in their 40s & 50s now, who phased out a lot of Scottish dances in the north in favour of discos etc. Their children have no chance in finding an interest in the music if the parents aren't. I blame this generation for the battle that we all face now.
I was lucky being born into the band, we went to dances every weekend as kids all over the country. The tunes were in my head before I even touched an instrument. When I started playing in public at the age of 12, we had a great incentive to keep going by earning pretty good money when our mates were out delivering papers at 2p per copy.
I'm 26 and have been a self employed musician for 6 years. Wouldn't have it anyother way. I have 4 kids, the oldest has started picking up a small PA that I have and is now playing twinkle twinkle, at the age of 5. I'll look into getting him a melodeon soon, B/C of course ;D
One other thing, sessions are usually in pubs (up here anyway)...why not have them somewhere under 18s can get in?
-
Cost of instruments obviously hasn't hampered the young buskers above,a good melodeon and a Tim Philips violin,we were Just as bad,sacrificed quite a lot and bought good gear for the kids,it does pay.
pete
-
I think exposure has a lot to do with it, I agree with Graeme. Take France and Ireland (no, I don't want to talk about that awful soccer match) for instance. Lots of melodeon-playing youngsters. In a place like Brittany, it's extremely popular, and yes, cool. Workshops everywhere year round, and parents who don't hesitate to spend a lot on new instrument for the kiddoes. The demand is there, and the young players are self-propelled, always looking for older ones to emulate. In the UK it seems to be a different story. Lack of appeal ? Encouraging young players is fine, but we need a lot more of them. The music itself needs a lot more dissemination.
Here, in the U.S, at least on the West Coast, you don't come across many *mature* players, let alone young ones, and music shops aren't exactly overflowing with two-row boxes...A diatonic desert. Maybe things are different on the East coast, with tradition-rich Québec across the border.
-
Is this the melodeon fraternity, folk scene, or personally?
If the latter - I purposely had a 'music room' in a series of 3 houses. It was full of playable things from guitar to piano, trombone to hurdy gurdy. Yes there were squeezeboxes. Son Fred now plays a mean guitar and has experimented on concertina and the theremin! #1 daughter piano, all three sing. None have ever had a music lesson they didn't ask for - worked for us.
Similar things seem to be happening on the genral folk scene - but I have to say a very high count of offspring of people I knew in the 70's. The present Liverpool festival is even called 'Family Folk-Up'!
As a melodeonist I've had 2 of my boxes out with that 17 year old cousin since April, but he didn't take to it and has now bought a guitar. I sense melnet and Witney people doing the same things. So I'd say yes. :|glug
-
I don't think there's anything on the folk scene or melodeon fraternity that's hindering or discouraging young players, it's at home where the difficulty is for many young people, especially children and teenagers, if they're not fortunate enough to have parents like Chris and Graeme.
I vividly remember someone bringing his son into the guitar shop with a broken string on his electric guitar. The guitar itself was the cheapest, barely playable wreck imaginable and the strings were god knows how old and had rust and grime all over them, despite being told that the whole set needed to be replaced because as well as being thoroughly past it playing-wise, the strings were so dirty they were actually a health hazard and none of us would even touch them, he refused to pay £5 for a new set of strings and would only shell out £1 for a single replacement string for the one that was broken. That speaks for itself really but to add insult to injury he justified his saving of 4 whole pounds by saying, "he doesn't need them, he's crap anyway". I wonder if that lad's still playing...
World's Best Dad had a wallet full of £20 notes so it wasn't as if he couldn't afford it and I used to see parents mocking their kid's efforts and whinging about having to buy stuff all the time, seeing it only as an expense rather than in terms of the joy it could bring their children and the myriad benefits it would have to their wellbeing. Quite frankly, depressing. There's a lot of stuff out there for young people but without parental interest or support it's not of much use to them.
-
Cost of instruments obviously hasn't hampered the young buskers above,a good melodeon and a Tim Philips violin
pete
Yes, and young Dylan the fiddler was also playing a hurdy-gurdy and a set of bagpipes at the weekend, as well! His dad is very encouraging, though, and plays a mean finger-style guitar himself.
Diane
-
Not Witney but earlier this year I think.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zOAWtph5jYw
CHeers
Sandy
(:)
[/quote]
Great video! It takes a lot of guts to go busking at any age, yet alone at 12 or 13.
The two of them are role models for many.
To pick up on many of the points already raised - cost is always an issue.
However as Chris pointed out, I believe a supporting home environment is the thing which makes the real difference. If children are used to dance and music being part of every day life, they will find the genre they like. My younger daughter (19) is a great dancer (ballet, tap, street) and really enjoyed a trip to watch rapper at DERT last year, and could have been a great judge (she predicted the top three!).
Many people on this forum started out with borrowed instruments, cheap chinese stuff or flea market one rows. If the kid's enthusiasm is there, then parents tend to be supportive. A second hand Hohner is a few hundred quid, but look at the cost of supporting an enthusiatic sports kid, or even just weekly piano lessons. And don't even think about the cost of games for Xbox, Wii etc.
We need to give kids the opportunity to be interested, to be involved. But don't push them. Volunteers not conscripts!
Gets off soap box and returns to my beer. :|glug
Andy
-
I think in Newfoundland there are two ways to enter the accordion world. One is the older one: "I always wanted to play an accordion and now I have the time and money to do it."
The other is the younger one; "I'm a Newfoundlander and this is Newfoundland's music."
It's not that it must be an ethnic game for young people but I think they often come to an instrument like the melodeon from a different angle, unless they are from a family so steeped in it they can't avoid it (my 2 year old gets his toy melodeon this Xmas. his five year old sister is already an accomplished fiddler.)
-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mFG3SiLAtk4
This young lad plays in my band a lot on PA but as you see he's doing very well on the B/C/C# mainly because he's fascinated by the button box. He was 19 in this clip, 35 years younger than me and about 50 years younger than the rest of the band, but totally immersed in the music and interested in the older stuff as well...a rarity indeed.
Ian.
-
Lovely playing.
-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mFG3SiLAtk4 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mFG3SiLAtk4)
Scott's performance is really good - I especially enjoyed the second tune in A major. Gonna crack out my box tonight and give it a go after I've finished listening to young Graeme Mackay of this forum playing on tonight's 'Take the Floor Programme' (http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b00nyxcb). Another great young box player is the second box player in Jim Mackay's Band young Matthew Maclennan - it's a PA he plays but as a PA player myself I generously forgive him that small matter, and would just like to say how much I rated him when I heard him up at Aviemore. There's some great young Scots players out there, who give me much hope for the future of box playing.
It seems to me that there is a concerted effort being undertaken in Scotland to encourage the playing of traditional music amongst school children. It's happened over a number of years and (I think, though others can put me right on this) well funded and promoted - especially in comparison to England - and I wish that there was such top-down support for the playing of traditional musical instruments throughout the United Kingdom. In Scotland the development of traditional music seems to be undertood as a cultural necessity.
This year I attended a relatively small Highland Games (Kenmore) and was just blown away by the amount of young children participating in traditional activities piping, dancing etc, in a relatively small community in Perthshire. Traditional music (fiddles, accordions, pipes) was in the air all over the place, and it was wonderful to be part of it. ;D
AL
-
It seems to me that there is a concerted effort being undertaken in Scotland to encourage the playing of traditional music amongst school children. It's happened over a number of years and (I think, though others can put me right on this) well funded and promoted - especially in comparison to England - and I wish that there was such top-down support for the playing of traditional musical instruments throughout the United Kingdom. In Scotland the development of traditional music seems to be undertood as a cultural necessity.
This year I attended a relatively small Highland Games (Kenmore) and was just blown away by the amount of young children participating in traditional activities piping, dancing etc, in a relatively small community in Perthshire. Traditional music (fiddles, accordions, pipes) was in the air all over the place, and it was wonderful to be part of it. ;D
AL
Quite agree, Al.
We have a holiday cottage up on the North West coast of Scotland and I'd noticed how well traditional music is supported in the schools and in the community. Plus there is the competitive element of the local and regional Mods to give focus and encouragement (trad. music and dance competitions - I'm sure Graeme can elaborate if needed!).
Its also on the radio and television.
I get the impression that traditional music has not been labelled and stuck in a box in Scotland, but is a lot more integrated in the broader music scene.
Andy
-
I would say that there were at least fifteen players under 30 years of age at Witney, including the very young and talented Sam Mabbett. (13 years old at a rough guess).
Not only is he very young and talented he was a joy to play with on the Sunday morning early, just him and me. Unlike other precocious youngsters I have observed he listened to what we were playing and added to it rather than just displaying his undoubted talent, hopefully he will go far.
Yes - I agree. Sam was great. Very talented and also very sensitive. Someone to watch out for!
Not really surprising as his father is the equally talented Dave Jolly.
-
Not really surprising as his father is the equally talented Dave Jolly.
Which underlines the main thrust of this thread I think. Yes there are very gifted and talented youngsters out there - but in the main their access to traditional music and instrumentation is very much gifted from within the family. But is there more that can be done to encourage young players on a wider front?
Putting my work hat on (for a change ;D) I have to say that we in The Salvation Army suffer from a similar problem, in that the majority of young people within our remit are not interested in playing brass. This is seriously affecting the numbers and capabilities of our brass bands for which we quite rightly have an excellent reputation. There are exceptions to the rule of course - a young 5 year old girl was playing top cornet in the Hendon Youth Band not so long ago - but of course (like Dave Jolly's lad) her dad just happened to be the no. 1 cornet player for the International Staff Band (David Dawes). As an organisation we're having to adapt to the changed circumstances we find ourselves in. One of the things I did recently was to help set up a Break Dance Group among a crowd of youngsters that I work with. It was very successful - but Hip-Hop etc was completely NOT the music that I personally wanted to be involved with. Have a look:KINETIC STYLES (http://www1.salvationarmy.org.uk/uki/www_uki.nsf/vw-sublinks/DB0931B23393EB2C802572BF006C76CF?openDocument)
AL
Off to work now - three services to do today - no rest for the wicked so I must have been really bad once upon a time!
;)
-
Hi,
This influence from an early age is important and the work done in the Northeast is brilliant.Folk musicians go into schools.
Obviously there is a strong tradition up there who care and have a very strong pride in their roots.I'me sure Theo will agree.
Pete
-
I'm off to work too. From what I've read the folk scene and its people are doing their best. In places in Scotlanf they surpass this by having traditional music taught in schools. I feel this is a 2-edged sword. Many kids will culturally do anything .. as long as it's not part of the establishment, or what their parents did.
In my day as a spotted youth we had traditional dancing available at school, from about 15 up, and after hours. As in a boys only grammar this was an excellent souce of totty - it was well popular. I personally then drifted into singing, and eventually melodeonism from that initiation. But for real penetration of any youth generation I've long thought we all need to retire to old folks homes, and be 'rediscovered' :|glug (whoops, not on duty)!
-
What I've enjoyed in visits to Ireland is the way that kids are exposed to the music through the family and local musical branches of Comhaltas. For all the arguments about set standards and competitions it does encourage youngsters.
We don't have that structure so most kids get involved in trad music through folkie parents I reckon. They can't really go into pub sessions till they're older by which time they have often gone onto peer influenced music. That's healthy for music but maybe not for producing wunderkind melodeon players.
I do have my doubts about youngsters becoming clones of their parents and English popular music is certainly alive and well.
I've got 5 sons and all are musically involved but non are 'folkies' This weekend two of them are doing remixes as part of a Sheffield local festival at Yellow Arches studios where Jarvis Cocker , Arctic monkeys and Richard Hawley record. When I was young in the 50s I veered off te Irish music my dad played to rock and roll and skiffle and via that to British folk song and music. I suspect a lot did that - just look at the Topic 70th Anniversary book.
Traditional music of the post war revival is is now well established and thriving compared to the post war period and if youngsters take to it that's great.
I'm a bit concerned at all the University folk courses though. Shouldn't they be out there where popular music flourishes.
-
WOW! it's young folks like these that will attract more younger newcomers!!...and less expensive but descent accordions!!. :-)
[]\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/[]
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zOAWtph5jYw
-
Both my wife and myself are musicians (though not exclusively in folk). We have tried to provide an open and tolerant environment in the hope that one or other would rebel and take up[ accountancy or similar - the better to support us in our dotage.
To date, it hasn't worked and I'm losing instruments to the youth in shoals!
At least they understand that father has a better eye than they do.