Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: tip184 on November 21, 2009, 08:34:00 PM
-
Hi everybody. I'm new to the forum - learning Cajun accordion on an old Hohner melodeon, and in the market for a better instrument (and yes - I've read many posts here and elsewhere with people's opinions about brands - no need for a rehash). I just saw a listing on ebay for a Gabbanelli that I had not seen before. it is described as a "CAJUN ZYDECO ACCORDION - GABBANELLI FACTORY DIRECT" and has a Buy-It-Now price of $325. It is apparently different from the Gabbanelli Cajun King, but I have never seen this model anywhere else. Can anyone tell me anything about it?
The link to the ebay listing is:
http://cgi.ebay.com/CAJUN-ZYDECO-ACCORDION_W0QQitemZ150390533553QQcmdZViewItemQQimsxZ20091120?IMSfp=TL091120192003r3159
Thanks in advance for any info.
tip184
-
At that price I would not expect much in terms of quality. Spending the money of getting the Hohner overhauled and cajun tuned might well get you a better result.
-
That is a Chinese made Parrot accordion and practically unplayable!
-
Thanks for the replies. Here's my email exchange with gabbanelliaccordions (through ebay):
-------------------
From: tip184
To: gabbanelliaccordions
Subject: You've received a question about your eBay item, CAJUN ZYDECO ACCORDION
Sent Date: Nov-21-09 12:04:29 PST
Dear gabbanelliaccordions,
I haven't seen this before - how does it differ from the Cajun King? Are the keyboards and sounds similar?
Thanks!
- tip184
Dear tip184,
The body is made in China. Its a copy of Louisiana Cajun Accordion and its upgraded with Italian Reeds. The sound is very Similar too.
- gabbanelliaccordions
-------------------
I think I'll consider something else...
-tip184
-
I think a re-hash is in order
If you are thinking this is an upgrade form a Hohner.. it is not
Second
2 Gabbanelli Kings one in D and one in C mint condition just sold at Elderly instruments for $550 apiece
Though they are decent they do not sound like CAJUN accordeons owing to the construction techniques internally
I am not suggesting that the "Cajun" boxes are superir or inferior or the other way around just not the same
I much prefer the humble HA 114 over the Cajun King
and over many Cajun made accordeons... Cajun made boxes are not all the same quality or value.. and the mostr famous and expensive have butt jointed frames... unsightly, weak and cheap construction
Another option is the Weltmeister style often found under that brand or Regal or Galotta... these are a closer sound and playbility to "CAJUN" if that is what you want.
Hot Rod your Hohner for cheap asuuming it is an HA114.. if it is an Ariette the Gabb box you linked is the same calibre
I have tweaked Ariettes with some success and they are serviceable units..
-
How do the "Baton Rouge" boxes as sold by hobgoblin rate against the weltmeisters?
-
I'm ... learning Cajun accordion on an old Hohner melodeon, and in the market for a better instrument ...
Is your Hohner a 1-row 4-stop? If so, there are still Cajun players who enjoy playing them themselves, and especially recommend them for learners, including Marc Savoy (who I saw playing one a couple of times in January).
-
I think a re-hash is in order
... Cajun made boxes are not all the same quality or value.. and the mostr famous and expensive have butt jointed frames... unsightly, weak and cheap construction
A re-hash Jeff? More like a cracked gramophone record on that score, though I don't remember your claiming they were weak before - making it pretty obvious that you've never looked inside one, to see how much more strongly the corner joints are actually constructed... ::)
I've posted internal and external photos of the corner joints on mine, so people can judge for themselves just how "weak" and "unsightly" they are, and what they'll see is a joint that is much stronger because it's triangular and has 3-times the gluing area - no wonder Marc (who's no featherweight) has famously been filmed standing on one of his accordions!
Anyway, I'd rather judge any instrument by how it sounds, and how it plays, rather than on its appearance or my personal opinion of its maker - whilst my friend Nils Nielsen (a factory-trained tuner) has been known to scathingly dismiss a certain very well-known/highly respected Italian firm of accordion makers (whose melodeons are highly prized by many here) as "furniture manufacturers" because he feels their woodworking skills far outdo their accordion-making ones (and he was most unimpressed with the design of their reed blocks).
So, do you want a beautiful piece of furniture, or the best melodeon you can get?
-
My Hohner is NOT a 114 - it is identical to this one currently listed on ebay:
http://cgi.ebay.com/Antique-HOHNER-ARIETTE-Cajun-Folk-ACCORDION_W0QQitemZ170409722279QQcmdZViewItemQQptZKeyboards_MIDI?hash=item27ad3601a7
although mine appears to be in better shape externally. Internally some reeds buzz, others are clearly out of tune (probably missing their valves) but if I select my stops carefully it sounds okay (on most notes...). I would consider having it tuned/cleaned/repaired but I can't believe that the expense will be worth it over the cost of a new box. I figured that after I get a new box I might teach myself repair on the old Hohner.
I really appreciate the comments. I don't like the looks of the HA 114, but from what I've seen (here and elsewhere) it seems that many prefer it to the Gabbanelli Cajun King. I would prefer a hand-made box from the southern US, but the cost is prohibitive.
-tip184
-
I just saw a listing on ebay for a Gabbanelli that I had not seen before. it is described as a "CAJUN ZYDECO ACCORDION - GABBANELLI FACTORY DIRECT" and has a Buy-It-Now price of $325. It is apparently different from the Gabbanelli Cajun King, but I have never seen this model anywhere else. Can anyone tell me anything about it?
I doubt if anybody here has actually seen, or tried, one of this exact model, with the "Reed Block are laying down just like a handmade Cajun Accordion" and "Reeds are Italian made!", but the instrument should be rather better than a Parrot (etc.) if that advertising is correct. I'd be very curious to try one out, but the seller won't ship outside the United States.
My Hohner is NOT a 114 - it is identical to this one currently listed on ebay:
http://cgi.ebay.com/Antique-HOHNER-ARIETTE-Cajun-Folk-ACCORDION_W0QQitemZ170409722279QQcmdZViewItemQQptZKeyboards_MIDI?hash=item27ad3601a7
That one's been wrongly identified by the eBay seller as an Ariette (a modern, Chinese-made, cheap Hohner model), but in fact it''s a nice old late 1920s box, that should sound great after a good overhaul, with a lovely "vintage" sound. Does yours say Genuine Steel Reeds like the eBay one, or Steel Bronze Reeds?
-
Standing on a box is "grand standing and proves nothing.. It's an attention getting device that has zip all to do with quality
A butt joint is unsightly, weak and an expedient.. ie corner and cost cutting.. and takes zero skill ...
glue em up , belt sand em flat... get er dun.. roll the ride.. get the job, get it done, get the money...
In my opinion an Acadian box of 20-30 years ago actually made by Savoy is better than that which is currently produced,
but that is my opinion.. just in case you did not read my 2367 previous posts...
Incidentally if I were to buy a butt jointed box (not likely) I'd buy a Martin
As a professional furniture maker.. I don't compromise on my own work and I won't pay for an obvious compromise which often can be an indicator of other compromises not readily seen.
To each his own.. like em buy em
I like Hohner HA 114 boxes... light, fun, cheap, not pretentious
-
A butt joint is unsightly, weak and an expedient.. ie corner and cost cutting.. and takes zero skill ...
Having personally done both, I fail to see how a mitred joint takes any more skill to achieve than a good butt one, or how a braced butt joint (which takes more work to achieve) is weaker or cost cutting in comparison. ???
It could be seen more as an issue of cosmetics v. structural strength...
In my opinion an Acadian box of 20-30 years ago actually made by Savoy is better than that which is currently produced,
but that is my opinion..
You may be in a minority of one there Jeff.
Marc says he has improved the design and anybody I've spoken to considers those currently produced are even better than previously - with which I'd concur, having got to try out several of his older ones whilst I was in Louisiana.
Mind you, I did get to pull his leg about that too, when (having told me he'd improved them) he then asked why I hadn't got one off him 20 years ago, instead of "messing about" (with other makes), and I replied "But I was waiting for you to get them right!" ::)
(He'd no answer to that... :D)
just in case you did not read my 2367 previous posts...
We need a yawn smiley... ;)
Incidentally if I were to buy a butt jointed box (not likely) I'd buy a Martin
You must like a comparatively dull-sounding box then, judging by those I've seen. One leading Irish player of my acquaintance has told me he visited the Martin workshop, some years ago, and was so unimpressed with what he saw that he came away with a used box made by somebody else...
I like Hohner HA 114 boxes... light, fun, cheap, not pretentious
You have that much in common with Marc Savoy then! ;D
Here's a photo I took of him in January, playing a 114 at one of the Saturday morning jam sessions in the Savoy Music Centre:
-
I had the chance to try an Acadian and a Martin side-by-side and found the Martin to use a lot more air. The difference was like driving a Prius and then a '72 Skylark. FWIW they were both in the same key.
I don't see what joinery has to do with melodeon playing, not much sheer force involved in a typical music session? I understand dovetails look nice and to some are an indication of quality but I think it's an unfair assessment of a musical instrument's overall quality...
I think the same things which are said regarding the pretensions surrounding a box made in Louisiana could also be asserted for a certain set of the Hohner crowd, couldn't they? And if you're talking about mass producing instruments by the boatload in the interest of maximizing profits, then Hohner is the number one example. They were so successful at cutting corners and economizing their production line that they gobbled up the competition in Europe and survived two total wars, and the Cold War (although Hohner "surviving" the Cold War is debatable, given what happened next). They were so effective at outsourcing to various plants in Germany at one time that they can't even tell researchers who built what, where, and when. I agree, though, their boxes were fantastic. ;D ;D ;D I only wish that Savoy, Martin, and others could do business on a similar scale.
-
My Hohner says "GENUINE STEEL REEDS" - it really looks exactly like the one pictured on ebay (which I knew was not an Ariette). I got it from ebay for about $55, including shipping. Unfortunately it is in the key of A (or maybe Ab, I'm not a musician and I can't recall, and the box is about 5000 miles away from me now) - I would really prefer C. I guess I should consider having it overhauled. I will return home to Michigan (from an extended stay in Poland) in three weeks - who do I contact about an overhaul?
Thanks!
tip184
-
A butt joint is unsightly, weak and an expedient
I dont see the relevance of those attributes to a musical instrument, its not a fashion item or a peice of furniture. If you sit on a Stradivarius it will break so dont sit on it.
Judge instruments on sound and action.
-
Interesting you should mention Strad, the great master whose work is so highly regarded it commands 8 figure sums and that subsequent makers have been imitating and trying in vain to replicate for almost 300 years originally attached the necks to the bodies of his violins with nails...
-
My Hohner says "GENUINE STEEL REEDS" - it really looks exactly like the one pictured on ebay ... I got it from ebay for about $55, including shipping.
It sounds like you got a good deal then, because it'll be worth getting it tuned/overhauled if it's got steel reeds.
Unfortunately it is in the key of A (or maybe Ab, I'm not a musician and I can't recall, and the box is about 5000 miles away from me now) - I would really prefer C.
As I expect you know already, C would be the most usual tuning for Cajun music, and all the instructional material is going to assume you have a C box.
I guess I should consider having it overhauled. I will return home to Michigan (from an extended stay in Poland) in three weeks - who do I contact about an overhaul?
I'm about 4,000 miles away from Michigan, but you could start by checking out this thread: Interesting answer from a PA Tuner in Chicago (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,2977.0.html)
-
Standing on a box is "grand standing and proves nothing.. It's an attention getting device that has zip all to do with quality
If you sit on a Stradivarius it will break so dont sit on it.
And that, Mike, was pretty much Marc's point in standing on his accordion - if you see the video in question you'll find he was actually demonstrating how much sturdier an accordion was than a fiddle, as well as louder, for the oldtime Cajun musicians.
But it also goes to show they don't have weak corners... ;)
-
How do the "Baton Rouge" boxes as sold by hobgoblin rate against the weltmeisters?
I'd go for the Weltmeister.
Generally speaking, the Italians don't really seem to "get" 4-stop melodeons (which are a distinctly German type of box) and the only Italian one I might consider is the Beltuna.
-
Generally speaking, the Italians don't really seem to "get" 4-stop melodeons (which are a distinctly German type of box) and the only Italian one I might consider is the Beltuna.
I think it's horses for courses, really.
I've owned several Castagnari Maxes over the years and they are really lovely instruments, and very responsive. Great for ITM (just listen to John Gannon) and East Anglian music. But - like the Hohner 1-row 4-stop growlers - they are not Cajun boxes, so you will stand to be disappointed if that's what you are expecting. I dare say they could be tuned to Cajun temperament, although I've never heard one.
-
I haven't seen the new Gabbanelli box that started this thread but it looks interesting!
After reading the general discussion, I decided to post an ad offering a "project" cajun box I have here in Miami FL (USA). It's the real deal in the sense of a Lousiana signature handmade cajun box, and the woodwork, action, and bellows are solid (those parts are near-mint condition except for 30 years of storage) but it was built with Hohner reeds (previously used) and I think with Hohner reedblocks so it's not anywhere close to the quality of an Acadian, etc. Actually it might not be as good as the $325 Gabbanelli!
However, since the woodwork and action of this box are nice I thought someone here might want to re-reed it and tweak it up -- maybe you got a working accordion very cheaply with a "nominal" value of a few hundred that I would trade this box for. But I am not looking for any more projects (or I would just complete this one!).
I have a letter with the accordion from Donald Thibodeaux, who built it in the 1970s, stating as Stephen mentions "keep the stops up"!
PG
-
who do I contact about an overhaul?
Thanks!
tip184
I messaged you about the tuner I use here in the states, he has done very good work but is a bit pricey, however I have never regretted having him do the work as he is excellent, my only regret is the sore feeling in my backside from sitting on a too thin wallet.
-
Generally speaking, the Italians don't really seem to "get" 4-stop melodeons (which are a distinctly German type of box) and the only Italian one I might consider is the Beltuna.
I think it's horses for courses, really.
Of course it is.
I've owned several Castagnari Maxes over the years and they are really lovely instruments, and very responsive.
I've owned one myself, but it was too "polite" and too much an accordion maker's version of a melodeon for my own liking, and I found that Italian organetto-style bass box downright painful to use... >:(
Great for ITM (just listen to John Gannon) ...
Haven't I sold them to some of the top players in Ireland myself, including Brendan Begley and Paul Brock (who got my personal one).
But - like the Hohner 1-row 4-stop growlers - they are not Cajun boxes, so you will stand to be disappointed if that's what you are expecting. I dare say they could be tuned to Cajun temperament, although I've never heard one.
My Acadian is only a "Cajun accordion" in that it was built in Louisiana by a Cajun maker - it wouldn't be any use to me if he'd tuned it to Cajun temperament. :(
Mind you, he loved the sound of it himself, when it was finished...