Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Andy Goldfinch on November 24, 2023, 09:11:01 PM
-
I have a box where the air button doesn't let me get enough air in comparison to the air buttons on my other boxes, so I'm planning to increase the size of the hole that the air button opens, but I thought I would run my plan past this forum to see if anyone can see any issues with it or has any tips.
The mechanism is fine, but the existing pallet is not big enough to cover a hole any larger, so I am planning to make a new pallet (tried ordering the largest pallet available at CGM but it's not wide enough, so I think making my own is the only option). Has anyone got any tips on making a new pallet? Particularly on how to make a raised channel to support the lever like there is on the existing one. I've got some pallet felt/leather from cgm to use.
While I've got the old pallet off, I'm planing to enlarge the air hole using a coping saw (very carefully!)
Does this sound like a sensible plan, or have I overlooked anything important?
Thanks in advance for the help.
-
This has been discussed a few times. I was interested because my Piroulet has an airhole which on the small side and I have considered making it a bit bigger. In the end, I left it and I've more, or less, got used to it.
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=23543.20
-
Common design fault, though more of a problem if you play predominantly on on the pull as “on the row†technique has natural balance wrt the bellows*
it seems to be quite a big job as you will need a new pallet, and probably mechanism. The amount of solid wood around the hole is also critical.
*Or try Glen Miller’s In the Mood, if you dare. The entire tune seems to be on the push!!
-
Rounding the edges of the hole will increase the airflow somewhat without actually increasing the actual hole size and the pad needed. Trace a line around the pad so you don't get too close to the edge.
-
Making a pallet is a fairly straightforward bit of woodwork. You need to consider the following points:
- There is sufficient space to the sides and above so that the larger pallet can move without obstruction.
- The thickness of the pallet matches the original so the geometry is the same.
- The thinning towards the edges is not essential, it makes the pallet a little lighter, and the edge where the lever lies will need to be lowered clear of the lever. See next point.
- The lever should rest on the centre of the pallet so there is even pressure on all the edges, this might require the lever to be bent to the side.
- In this design were the lever is opened from the opposite side to the spring. The post the opens the pallet should also be central to the pallet, so you might need some adjustments after fitting to get it to interact correctly with the thumb button.
- Put the pallet in place and test for airtightness before fixing it to the lever.
After enlarging the hole, smooth of the cut edges, and consider rounding them as described by Kimric.
You don't need to enlarge the hole much to make a big difference.
-
Theo has covered all bases.
I'd just add that you could probably scrounge a scrap of nice dry timber from your local joinery or furniture repair shop. Probably in the offcuts/firewood bin.
People used to call in at my place for all kinds of things. Take a box with you and explain what you are doing.
-
That's all really helpful, thanks everyone!
-
After drawing around the edge of the existing pallet, I realised that there was a spare few millimetres on the tip end, so I very carefully enlarged the hole with a chisel and some files (without even needing to remove the pallet). I’m amazed by the difference adding ~3mm to the length of the hole has made, the air button feels so responsive to my thumb now!
-
I vaguely recall fluid dynamics le true I attended many decades ago that demonstrated fluid flow through a hole was related to the 5th power of the hole size. In everyday terms that means that a small increase in size makes a huge difference in flow.
-
This has been discussed a few times. I was interested because my Piroulet has an airhole which on the small side and I have considered making it a bit bigger. In the end, I left it and I've more, or less, got used to it.
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=23543.20
When I did the mods covered in the link above, I was amazed at the difference a small change to the hole made. It was done all within the bounds of the existing pallet so wasn't major surgery but had a fantastic impact. The Black Pearl has now been sold on to pastures new, but was a great little box after the surgery.
-
this post got me curious. Ive recently been working on a baffetti art 82 i purchased and worked on to my own needs (similar to black pearl 111) amonst other things i wasnt entirely happy with was the air button. so i got to wondering if i needed to modify the hole. I found the air hole to be more than adequate. It was the oval type and let plenty of air through. so then i got to thinking. why wasnt i happy with it. i thought it through and realised the spring was very heavy. it was hard to feather the air release. i had to give it a hard push and then all of a sudden there way too much air release. for me the problem wasnt too little air release it was none and then all of a sudden too much. i set about bending the metal plate to see if i could make it smoother but had no luck. so after reading other posts i tried the credit card / hotel key card replacement folks have used to fix a broken metal plate. mine wasnt broken so could have kept it but a credit card fix was so much better it plays like a different instrument. so for me the credit card upgrade isnt just a solution for a broken "spring" . i also wasnt enirely happy with the way the shared reed plates on the bass end affected the rhythmic pulse but thats a different thread. hope this isnt off topic.