Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Andy in Vermont on November 23, 2009, 04:15:56 PM

Title: Maugein
Post by: Andy in Vermont on November 23, 2009, 04:15:56 PM
I'm wondering whether anyone here has had experience with Maugein's diatonic.
-Andy
Title: Re: Maugein
Post by: Andrel on November 23, 2009, 05:01:33 PM
  I have. Sweet sound and great action. A well-built box made by people who know what they're doing. I am surprised it doesn't get more exposure.  I have never owned one, though. Only tried a couple in France in a shop, and a player from Brittany let me borrow his for a bit. I would put it on a par with a good Castagnari. But I don't know where you can try one in your neck of the woods...
Title: Re: Maugein
Post by: triskel on November 23, 2009, 05:52:50 PM
I've tried a few and liked them, but the only person I know who's got one is Conor Keane.
Title: Re: Maugein
Post by: diatosoldo on March 18, 2011, 08:25:17 AM
I'm wondering whether anyone here has had experience with Maugein's diatonic.
-Andy
I have a 2,5 rows, 12 basses Maugein with 2 switches. Beautiful sound, beautiful box (some videos of mine in YT  I play it).
I'm very surprised here when I read people's writing about french boxes :-\  :
They constantly refer to Gaillard, Loffet etc..  but never to Maugein  :o
Maugein is a manufacture (about 30 people) in the center of France (Massif Central, in Tulle), you can visit them, very friendly. They have great experience in making boxes (since 1919), both chromatic and diatonic and they really make the boxes (no importing pieces from Italy and assemblate them as most do here in France and elsewhere).
The thing is : they don't really communicate properly (no proper website, though below you can see someting) :
http://www.accordeons-maugein.com/instruments/diatoniques/index.html
I would hightly recommand them for small boxes (the one called Luthinier).
Title: Re: Maugein
Post by: diatosoldo on March 18, 2011, 10:02:53 AM
I'm wondering whether anyone here has had experience with Maugein's diatonic.
-Andy
I have a 2,5 rows, 12 basses Maugein with 2 switches. Beautiful sound, beautiful box (some videos of mine in YT  I play it).
I'm very surprised here when I read people's writing about french boxes :-\  :
They constantly refer to Gaillard, Loffet etc..  but never to Maugein  :o
By the way, nor do they know "Les accordéons du Marais" ..
It's another melodeon maker (no importing and assembling of italian pieces). You can watch his website and videos on youtube :
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sTLCu7tZQdo
I have tried his boxes (he lives nearby my place). They sound brilliant and powerfully.
I was also told about Yvus (in the Pyrénées) but I don't much about them. They seem to be relly good makers though.
Title: Re: Maugein
Post by: dahlberg on March 18, 2011, 10:34:52 AM
my playing-pal got one Luthinier,but customized bass,cnc routed alu grill and so on,really great box with a sound i consider more edgy than italian boxes.
Title: Re: Maugein
Post by: diatosoldo on March 18, 2011, 11:14:35 AM
my playing-pal got one Luthinier,but customized bass,cnc routed alu grill and so on,really great box with a sound i consider more edgy than italian boxes.

yes the sound is really profound and beautiful.
But what do you mean by CNC routed (sorry I'm french) ?
Title: Re: Maugein
Post by: Stiamh on March 18, 2011, 12:57:38 PM
A "router" is a woodworking machine - "toupie" in French.

CNC = computerized numerical control (commande numérique par ordinateur).

The "out" in router meaning toupie is pronounced like the English word "out". Whereas the homonym "router" in computer networks ("routeur" in French) has a different etymology and the "out" is pronounced as in the French word "route". Americans have ceased making the distinction and telephone operators will offer to "rout" your call.  ;D
Title: Re: Maugein
Post by: Andy in Vermont on March 18, 2011, 01:35:36 PM
By the way, nor do they know "Les accordéons du Marais" ..
It's another melodeon maker (no importing and assembling of italian pieces).

True, very true.
With Maugein, the reason for our relative ignorance (in the U.S.) is that they are not being marketed in the U.S.. An Irish box importer was bringing them in for a while, but his volume was relatively low and the keyboard style was a hard sell to Irish players.  They were also imported to a price point that was quite a bit higher than comparable instruments.
With Le Lan (accordéons du Marais), it is simply a matter of his very small-scale production and the short time that he has been in business.  It has taken a while for even Gaillard to be known among diato players in the U.S., and even then, you don't see them very often.  Those in the know know them, and most don't.  If Le Lan can get an instrument into the hands of an American player who frequents festivals, perhaps the word would be spread.

However, I once contacted Le Lan for a price list, which he promptly sent.  A while later, I received an email from him, with a very impatient tone.  At the time I thought: "He probably doesn't need the business from the U.S., but if he does have any hope of getting it, he's going to have to work on this kind of interaction."

Add to all this the fact that outside of Cajun and Tex-Mex cultures, in which specific brands are favored, there really aren't that many diato players relative to the population, and we are very spread out. 

One Maugein Luthinier that I tried was excellent, but it was owned by a Quebecois player who had changed the key from G/C to D/C#, and Marcel Messervier Sr. had done the reedwork, which he had waxed. So I didn't get a good sense of what a Maugein is really like (with the nailed reeds!). 
I think that Maugein could probably do a better job marketing its products in Quebec, where the "Franco-centric" production would be very positively received, but people up there are rather... shall we say... "thrifty," so it might be hard to sell expensive accordions.
Title: Re: Maugein
Post by: dahlberg on March 18, 2011, 06:09:38 PM
A "router" is a woodworking machine - "toupie" in French.

CNC = computerized numerical control (commande numérique par ordinateur).

The "out" in router meaning toupie is pronounced like the English word "out". Whereas the homonym "router" in computer networks ("routeur" in French) has a different etymology and the "out" is pronounced as in the French word "route". Americans have ceased making the distinction and telephone operators will offer to "rout" your call.  ;D
ah thanks for the explanation. im not so good in english so i sometimes write strange.
The grill is made of aluminium and show a black grouse in silouette,really nice.
Finnish bass means that its extended with all minor chords too,so regular 8-bass have 12. and they are unisonic,not change tone when you change bellow direction. The French-Finnish mix.
Title: Re: Maugein
Post by: diatosoldo on March 19, 2011, 06:11:25 PM
By the way, nor do they know "Les accordéons du Marais" ..
It's another melodeon maker (no importing and assembling of italian pieces).

True, very true.
With Maugein, the reason for our relative ignorance (in the U.S.) is that they are not being marketed in the U.S.. An Irish box importer was bringing them in for a while, but his volume was relatively low and the keyboard style was a hard sell to Irish players.  They were also imported to a price point that was quite a bit higher than comparable instruments.
With Le Lan (accordéons du Marais), it is simply a matter of his very small-scale production and the short time that he has been in business.  It has taken a while for even Gaillard to be known among diato players in the U.S., and even then, you don't see them very often.  Those in the know know them, and most don't.  If Le Lan can get an instrument into the hands of an American player who frequents festivals, perhaps the word would be spread.

However, I once contacted Le Lan for a price list, which he promptly sent.  A while later, I received an email from him, with a very impatient tone.  At the time I thought: "He probably doesn't need the business from the U.S., but if he does have any hope of getting it, he's going to have to work on this kind of interaction."

Add to all this the fact that outside of Cajun and Tex-Mex cultures, in which specific brands are favored, there really aren't that many diato players relative to the population, and we are very spread out. 

One Maugein Luthinier that I tried was excellent, but it was owned by a Quebecois player who had changed the key from G/C to D/C#, and Marcel Messervier Sr. had done the reedwork, which he had waxed. So I didn't get a good sense of what a Maugein is really like (with the nailed reeds!). 
I think that Maugein could probably do a better job marketing its products in Quebec, where the "Franco-centric" production would be very positively received, but people up there are rather... shall we say... "thrifty," so it might be hard to sell expensive accordions.
thks for explaining all that.
True that Maugein is a bit expensive, same as Castagnari.
As for "les accordéons du Marais" true too that his produuction is small for the moment .. but I think his accordions are really good. But being alone to make the melodeons, and to sell them (no marketing service, no commercail staff !) is probably an uneasy job.
As for me, I now belong to the tribe of those who are "converted" to Casta .. My Benny completely fullfills my wishes ! 
Diatosoldo
PS : if you come to France one day, you could try my Maugein (with nailed reeds !), but hurry up, because I'm selling it ....
Title: Re: Maugein
Post by: David J on January 24, 2013, 01:53:28 PM
I've been thinking about getting a 2.5 row for over a year and must have now visited every European maker's website for research purposes, so as I was holidaying not far from Tulle last August, I arranged to pay a visit to the Maugein factory (I was lucky, they had just come back from vacances that week). They do a couple of tours for visitors every week, and these are conducted by the boss M. Rene Lacheze (the man who saved Maugein from extinction in the late 70's from what I've read). He doesn't speak English and you do get a very detailed exposition of the history of the accordion and the Maugein manufacturing process which lasts 2 hours, but even if your French isn't up to it, there's much of interest to observe!

Their principal interest is the classic musette chromatic accordion, and very unusually they make pretty much every component for these themselves, including the reeds. As well as these and a few piano accordions they now have a very complete range of diatonics, including the Gavotte 2.5 row in 2 or 3 voice versions which were my interest. They make all the parts for these, except the bellows and reeds which come from Italy (reeds are Voci Armoniche I think) - and the charming porcelain name badge which is made up the road in Limoges. As has been noted elsewhere in this thread, the reeds are nailed on to leather which gives a distinctive, slightly nasal, character to the sound. As a result of M. Lacheze's exhaustive talk, plus the absolute requirement to close the factory promptly for lunch, I only had about 20 minutes to play the Gavotte models. The 2-voice was lovely, light (3.6kg) and easy to play, quite in contrast to the bulky 5kg+ 3 voice version. Cabinetwork and finish is immaculate, and you can specify inlay work, logo style, keyboard layout etc when ordering although you will pay list price from the factory and there are dealers who offer discounts.

To secure the future of the business, Maugein has recently become a co-operative, and there were some younger people among the workforce including a very talented paint sprayer doing some multi-coloured pearlescent finishes (not my kind of thing, but goes down well with the cafe musette market apparently). So hopefully when the highly skilled older guys retire, there will be others to carry on making these very distinctive boxes.

Have I bought one? No. They are certainly top of the market price-wise and in the end I wanted a compact 3-voice so I have gone elsewhere (more of this anon I expect). In the meantime, don't bother with the Maugein website for more info as they don't show the full range there; this is better
http://www.laboiteabretelles.fr/7-diatoniques

and if you read French, here's a bit of history
http://www.mdcn.fr/maugein.htm#Maugein

I took some photos of the factory, so will upload to Flickr and post a link soon.

Title: Re: Maugein
Post by: tirpous on January 24, 2013, 05:52:43 PM
Thanks for sharing this information, David.
Title: Re: Maugein
Post by: diatosoldo on January 24, 2013, 08:27:12 PM
hereabove a youtube video (not good quality, but it shows the place) :

http://youtu.be/7WkNIPGvO10

Title: Re: Maugein
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on January 24, 2013, 08:57:51 PM
hereabove a youtube video (not good quality, but it shows the place) :

http://youtu.be/7WkNIPGvO10

And a bit more.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JL0cwMCSlAw

Though this one seems to be concerned with a suggestion to stop making accordions and become cobblers  ::)
Title: Re: Maugein
Post by: Idelone on January 25, 2013, 02:58:11 PM
I have a Luthinier III (G/C + alts), it makes a lovely sound and plays well, although in fairness this is the only box that I have played so have nothing to compare it against. It is also easy on the eye, and well finished; I can highly recommend it, and Maugein as a marque.

Ian
Title: Re: Maugein
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on January 26, 2013, 12:26:09 AM
Are Maugein easy to buy from direct, or would that be more expensive as some one earlier in the thread impled?

Also what about peculiar (possibly in their eyes) tunings like a 4th button start D/G?
Title: Re: Maugein
Post by: David J on January 26, 2013, 11:18:45 AM
Are Maugein easy to buy from direct, or would that be more expensive as some one earlier in the thread impled?

Also what about peculiar (possibly in their eyes) tunings like a 4th button start D/G?

They can do any layout you want, although I think you would need to carefully translate everything into sol-fa notation. The factory price list they gave me showed RRPs. I don't know whether they would charge more for a very bespoke note layout; all the listed extras relate to inlays, bass stops and so on. I think dealer discount prices would probably only be available on standard G/C layouts, but I'm only guessing, as I haven't asked.

Anyway, as promised, some pics of the factory http://www.flickr.com/photos/squeezyboy6/sets/72157632615602438/
Title: Re: Maugein
Post by: Stiamh on January 26, 2013, 12:31:59 PM
If dealing direct isn't possible, I believe Conor Keane in Ireland is a distributor for Maugein. Have no contact details for him but he shouldn't be hard to find.
Title: Re: Maugein
Post by: Idelone on January 26, 2013, 03:49:14 PM
Are Maugein easy to buy from direct, or would that be more expensive as some one earlier in the thread impled?

Also what about peculiar (possibly in their eyes) tunings like a 4th button start D/G?

Andrew, I picked up my box second-hand in France, and as I visit my family on a regular basis, it was easy to arrange one of these to coincide with a potential purchase. I have to say I was very lucky, it took two aborted 'phone calls and one visit to get what I wanted.  I went the second-hand route as I couldn't justify buying new, I was unsure if an accordeon was going to be right for me, but as it turned out the box was almost new, at a very reasonable price bearing in mind it was a 3-row (G/C + alts), and that I needn't have worried, we get along just fine.

As for the keyboard, it is the Corgeron system with 3rd button start and I guess one of the fairly universal layouts available in France.  My brother-in-law has a 2-row Maugein which he bought direct from them, and has recently had them add a couple of buttons, for a vast sum of money; he found the 2-row was restricting his repertoire.  When he originally purchased it, they suggested various layouts but recommended a standard layout, which he went for, although as another poster intimated, they will within reason, put together something to suit your requirements.

If you're looking for a G/C Maugein, and have no objections to buying second-hand, then you will find a number of them for sale on French websites, although I think that you would have to go and collect it.

I Hope this helps, regards, Ian.
Title: Re: Maugein
Post by: diatosoldo on January 26, 2013, 08:37:38 PM
http://www.leboncoin.fr/instruments_de_musique/425143037.htm?ca=18_s

http://www.leboncoin.fr/instruments_de_musique/423986832.htm?ca=18_s

http://www.leboncoin.fr/instruments_de_musique/423986814.htm?ca=18_s

http://www.leboncoin.fr/instruments_de_musique/418424440.htm?ca=18_s

http://www.leboncoin.fr/instruments_de_musique/418170700.htm?ca=18_s
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal