Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: nemethmik on November 23, 2009, 09:52:32 PM
-
I was inspired by the number of B/C threads, and here is another one.
I was in Miltown Malbay (Willie Clancy Summer School) last summer, and I was invited to a number of sessions by my piper friends. One of these was a session (mostly) dedicated to B. B is a more and more popular pitch (after D) among Irish (Uilleann) Pipers. The fiddlers had no problem; they retuned their fiddles and they joined the music. There was an excellent B/C accordion player, however, who simply could not join when the pipers played in B. She was great a musician when the pipers changed to their chanters to D but when they played in B she could not play along.
I found this story very interesting, why the Irish box players prefer B/C when they play only in D, G, A, Em, but never in B or C? Wouldn't D/G accordions be much more useful for their music? Why do they need a chromatic box, when the bass side is limited to D, G, A, E chords; and, anyway, they cannot play in a real chromatic way?
Miki
-
You are being a little harsh on the box player. I'm not surprised she didn't want to join in in the key of B.
A two-row halfstep isn't really a chromatic box - for practical purposes - in the way that you seem to assume it is.
If she had experience of playing "melodeon style" then playing any tunes normally in D would be easy enough going up and down the B row, although this would require on the fly transposition, which some musicians are at ease with, others not.
If she hadn't played a D box, it wouldn't be so easy.
Playing in any keys other than D would require not only transposing the tunes, but finding any accidentals in a totally unfamiliar position, on the inside row rather than the outside row. Like playing a D/C# instead of a B/C. Plus, even if she could find the notes, she wouldn't be able to execute the ornaments and other tricks that give Irish music all its style on the box.
A good Irish musician (or any other kind I might suggest) doesn't noodle away, being content to play the skeleton of the tune. Generally, if you can't do a tune justice, you don't join in.
A really gifted or intuitive halfstep player might rise to the challenge and acquit themselves honorably. But the fact that your B/C player didn't does her no discredit.
-
... why the Irish box players prefer B/C when they play only in D, G, A, Em, but never in B or C? Wouldn't D/G accordions be much more useful for their music?
Actually they play in quite a few more keys than the ones you list, including C, but not B.
A D/G accordion would certainly not be more useful, for reasons that I can't be bothered to enumerate here. I'll just say I think you can give the Irish credit for knowing what suits their music.
-
If you want to understand a b/c world better, get an inexpensive chromatic harmonica. It will show you why G is often better than C or C# or even A is can be ok. (Assume a C/C# tuned harmonica...) The push/pull nature of different scales shows you quickly what is easy and what is more difficult, especially once you add embellishments.
DISCLAIMER: I don't play b/c melodeon, but can play chromatic harmonica
-
I don't play a button box yet, but I do play the pipes.
You said it all when you mentioned that the pipers changed their chanters. Okay the range of a chanter is limited, but the fact is that if pipers want to change key, it's simplest to change the chanter and keep the fingering the same (the only option on highland or smallpipes in fact, which are modal). A box might have more notes but I can easily imagine that if a given key requires a whole different fingering style (up and down rather than across the rows), one would either sit those tunes out, or find a box which would allow you to play (in this case B) across the rows.
Since you can't retune reed instruments quickly or easily, you tend to end up with a selection of them for different keys - the evidence for which is all over this site (MAD)...
-
Now I know that this will come as no surprise to any of you - but I'm so stupid, I just don't get this thread.
???
If a tune is played in B why is it that the B/C box player can't play it? The B row on a BC bocs (that's Welsh for box btw ;D) makes playing in B quite easy in my humble (though obviously limited) opinion? Or have I totally misunderstood / misread this thread???
And why would any fiddle player worth their salt need to re-tune their fiddle simply in order to play in B? Ye gods! has it come to this? Are the fiddlers in Ireland all so poor that they struggle to play more than three sharps? The Associated Board Exams require violin students to be able to play B major from memory at only grade 5 which is pretty low.
I've now put up my reflector shields and await the inevitable pounding that's bound to come my way ;)
AL
BTW I frequently play in B on my PA :P
-
It did surprise me to Al, but it seems some B/C players have never played along a row. I find it hard to believe, but I think its just the result of learning in a different musical culture. I recently met someone like that, he could play reels in D on a B/C box, but when I put an A/D box in his hands he genuinely thought there was something wrong with it.
-
It did surprise me to Al, but it seems some B/C players have never played along a row
Very strange - I mean the answer's in the name of the box isn't it? But yes, I do begin to understand a little bit better. But if folk haven't recognised that you can go up and down the rows as well as across 'em then there's some learning needed isn't there? Mind you I do know some folk who, come to think of it (John Lennon springs to mind), only ever played cross harp 2nd position. So when they want to play in G major they use a C major harmonica - and when they want to play in C major they get an F harp out???? I'm confoosed. But then that's my usual state ;D
AL
-
It works the other way round too of course. If you learn to play in D and G on a D/G box its another significant learning step to play in A. I'm sure I'm not the only one to have had to put considerable effort into overcoming that particular hurdle.
-
Yes of course - very much agreed there - I think the surprising thing is that the name (i.e B/C) makes it so apparent that the thing can be played in B. Whereas with a D/G it is not always immediately apparent that other keys (A, Eminor etc) are - with a bit of jiggery-pokery - also available.
-
It works the other way round too of course. If you learn to play in D and G on a D/G box its another significant learning step to play in A. I'm sure I'm not the only one to have had to put considerable effort into overcoming that particular hurdle.
but not rocket science as its just down to learning another scale ( with G# or faked G#) which is not different to what players of most other instruments have to do . Oh for a melodeon capo!
george
-
A really gifted or intuitive halfstep player might rise to the challenge and acquit themselves honorably. But the fact that your B/C player didn't does her no discredit.
[/quote]
I would have thought that as many irish players do play from time to time in the key of C playing in B would be just the same if for some odd reason there is a need to use it.
george
-
.
???
? The Associated Board Exams require violin students to be able to play B major from memory at only grade 5 which is pretty low.
I've now put up my reflector shields and await the inevitable pounding that's bound to come my way ;)
AL
BTW I frequently play in B on my PA :P
go for a BC with a turd row & you can have an nice easy Bflat as well! ;)
george
-
go for a BC with a turd row & you can have an nice easy Bflat as well! ;)
george
But some of the buttons can be sticky ...
-
But some of the buttons can be sticky ...
and smelly!!!
-
Now I know that this will come as no surprise to any of you - but I'm so stupid, I just don't get this thread.
???
If a tune is played in B why is it that the B/C box player can't play it?
We aren't talking about hymn tunes here Al >:E
OK, suppose she could play D tunes on the B row. She would still have problems with the rest of the repertoire because, as I explained above, you would effectively be asking her to play a D/C# style instead of a B/C, which wouldn't be much different from sticking a B/C into the hands of someone who had only ever played D/G and saying, OK, off you go now!
-
OK, suppose she could play D tunes on the B row. She would still have problems with the rest of the repertoire because, as I explained above, you would effectively be asking her to play a D/C# style instead of a B/C, which wouldn't be much different from sticking a B/C into the hands of someone who had only ever played D/G and saying, OK, off you go now!
Steve - I'm sorry if I've got it wrong but I thought we were talking about playing tunes in the key of 'B' - hence my consternation that a B/C player couldn't join in?
AL
-
OK Al, let me spell it out for you.
The session the OP referred to was an Irish trad session, and probably a high-level one being in Miltown Malbay for one thing, with the kind of pipers who could afford sets of pipes in B as well as those in D - generally serious players - for another.
When the pipers use their B sets or chanters they play the same tunes with the same fingerings that they would with their D sets. But everything comes out a tone and a half lower. So yes tunes that are normally in D major will come out in B major. But they aren't going to stick only to tunes that would normally be played in D major, they'll play everything else that they normally play - being pipers, this is mainly tunes in keys with one or two sharps. So as well as playing D tunes in B, your box player would have to play G tunes in E, and all the related minors and dorians.
But I put it to you that even playing D tunes along the row in B would be a daunting challenge for many B/C players. If you really want to understand this, go and learn an Irish reel in D on your B/C. Don't pick anything too hard now, but make sure you can play it in Irish style with a good swing at a very good clip and some tasteful ornamentation in the idiom, so that you'd be welcome in a session at Miltown Malbay.
When you've reached that point, in the year 2013 maybe, and without having tried this before, play the same tune in C or B on your B/C at the same speed, with the same panache, in a way that would be welcome in the same hypothetical session.
That's just a D tune. Try the same exercise with a G tune. Then imagine doing the same with any one of maybe 600 tunes or more that might be played at this session.
Hope this helps you get the picture.
Of course had she been a C#/D player she would more likely have been game to take up the challenge. ;)
-
OK Al, let me spell it out for you.
That's what I need ;D
Ok - so I begin to understand that whilst the pipers were playing their B chanters they would also sometimes be playing tunes in B plus other keys as well. Fair enough. Still don't really understand why a BC player wouldn't play the B tunes - but I guess there may be sets and things that modulate into other keys which would make things more complex.
Now - what about them fiddlers! Fancy the temerity of retuning their strings!!!
>:E
-
Still don't really understand why a BC player wouldn't play the B tunes...
Well take the little challenge I set you in my previous post and maybe you will understand. ;)
-
as well as playing D tunes in B, your box player would have to play G tunes in E
Just explain to me why playing in E is so difficult on a BC box? I mean, I've done it and I'm rubbish! Admittedly I found it a lot easier on BCC# - but BC is just about fully chromatic.
Why is it so many BC players just don't want to learn to play in any keys than the 'standards' of D, G & A with their variants? Playing any tune in the key of B on a BC box is so simple - it's just up a down a single row - you don't have to bother transposing or anything complicated. It's so simple even I can do it :D
-
Sorry, Steve, but I'm with Al here. A tune in B is a tune in B. You have a B row on your box. Just play it like a one-row. It's probably the case that this particular player NEVER played on one row only. And switching to different keys is a different story. By the way, doesn't Dermot Byrne play Tico Tico in B? (seems like it's something you mentioned a while back).
Andre
-
Tico, Tico in B (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lU7tt8BSe-c) - marvellous playing!
AL
-
A tune in B is a tune in B. You have a B row on your box. Just play it like a one-row. \
Nah, not the same thing as a piper playing a B chanter and a fiddler tuning down to match the pipes, not at all. If the box player had already messed around and learned some of the tunes in B that would be one thing, but unless a person played in B fairly regulary that would be a waste of time and even then you'd be limted.
What -would- be the same thing is flipping a switch and making that B/C into a G#/A-- OR the pipers and fiddlers playing those tunes in B on a D chanter and standard-tuned fiddle. Consider this-- how many B tunes do you hear under those conditons? Not many.
Rick
-
I guess I'll have to borrow a B/C (I'm a former B/C player myself) and give it a shot. It's the only way I can find out. Of course, I also need to find a piper...
-
Al, you seem to be wanting to score points here. As if you are trying to suggest that the player referred to in the original post is some kind of stubbornly obtuse or inadequate musician. Or that B/C players of Irish music are not making proper use of their instruments and therefore to be mocked or derided. Or something. What is it that you are trying to suggest, exactly?
As someone who has played Irish music for over 30 years, and a halfstep box for 5, I understand why the B/C player didn't join in with the B session. You don't. I've tried to explain it you as clearly as possible why I think such a situation would be a problem for most B/C players, even very good ones. You still don't get it. What can I do?
Ah - I know - Hallelujah! - just ask you to have faith. Faith that I know what I'm talking about here. ;D
-
This is a pretty curious thread, I can't help but feel that a few people don't really understand what was going on. It isn't about the relative difficulty of playing B on a B/C accordion.
.
???
? The Associated Board Exams require violin students to be able to play B major from memory at only grade 5 which is pretty low.
Yes, but do they require grade 5 violin students to transpose complex pieces full of ornaments down a minor 3rd on the spot without preparation?
Tunes in Irish trad are usually only in a handful of keys, D and G being most common. C and F are less common but also there. I didn't play any tunes in C for years so would have faced an added challenge of playing in an unfamiliar key as well as trying to transpose on the spot were I in that session.
I found this story very interesting, why the Irish box players prefer B/C when they play only in D, G, A, Em, but never in B or C? Wouldn't D/G accordions be much more useful for their music? Why do they need a chromatic box, when the bass side is limited to D, G, A, E chords; and, anyway, they cannot play in a real chromatic way?
Miki
Who's this "they?" And what exactly is a "real chromatic way?" Try playing Sean Keane's version of the Lads of Laois on a D/G box...go on...
Sorry, Steve, but I'm with Al here. A tune in B is a tune in B.
There are no tunes in B in Irish music. While I'm sure someone's composed at least one recently there aren't any that are properly rooted in the tradition. We're just playing the music that the fiddles and pipes and flutes were playing before boxes showed up.
-
Al, you seem to be wanting to score points here.
Not true at all - throughout this thread I've genuinely been seeking enlightenment as to why a BC box player should struggle to play in a B session. You've endeavoured to explain - I still don't get it. That makes me the stupid guy and no one else. That's ok. I'm just a muggle - and definitely know nothing about Irish music even though it is half of my heritage (my great-grandfather took the King's shilling and left County Cork never to return).
Thanks for reminding me to have faith!
:D
AL
Yes, but do they require grade 5 violin students to transpose complex pieces full of ornaments down a minor 3rd on the spot without preparation?
I'm sorry but if a tune is being played in B on chanters in B then the tune is in B and there is no need for transposition in my world. Yes this is very confusing.
AL
-
I meant a tune *played* in B. Whether it was originally in C or whatever is irrelevant to this discussion. I have been playing Irish music daily for many years, and I have yet to play a tune in B, true. And I defer to Steve's experience. I've been away from the B/C box for too long, but I just want to find out for myself why it's so hard to play in B when you have a B row on your instrument.
-
I'm sorry but if a tune is being played in B on chanters in B then the tune is in B and there is no need for transposition in my world. Yes this is very confusing.
AL
Right, let's simplify it. The two most common keys in ITM are D and G. The chanter on a set of pipes is pitched in D, however flatter sets of pipes were favoured in the past. Occasionally pipers will play on a lower chanter (in this case B) but the fingering is still the same. Fiddlers tune down and maintain the same fingering etc. In this case the tunes that were previously sounding in D and G are sounding in B and E respectively. This is all well and good for our fiddle playing friends but B/C players will know the same tunes in D and G fingerings. Since we can't tune down it is neccesary to transpose on the spot and THAT is the difficulty.
You're right, of course the tune is in B but what I mean is that there are no tunes that are in Bmajor when played on concert pitch instruments.
edit - spelling
-
I meant a tune *played* in B. Whether it was originally in C or whatever is irrelevant to this discussion. I have been playing Irish music daily for many years, and I have yet to play a tune in B, true. And I defer to Steve's experience. I've been away from the B/C box for too long, but I just want to find out for myself why it's so hard to play in B when you have a B row on your instrument.
As I said, this thread isn't about it being difficult to play in B. It is of course easy enough to play in B on a B/C if you've done it before, it's just the on the fly transposition that is difficult.
-
I do not play the B/C tuning but I'm guessing that the difficulty in playing in new keys is that a B/C box is not chromatic in a useful way. On a B/C box each key requires new fingering and ornamentation. If the player mentioned at the beginning was playing a continental chromatic accordion she would simply move to the new position and play with the same fingering. I play the D/G and experience difficulties playing the same tune on the row and cross fingering. Sometimes I feel that I have learned 2 tunes if taking the time to learn both methods. I am considering the semi-tone box system so that I can learn to play any tune I want in any single key. But to switch keys on the fly...I would still carry boxes in different keys.
Thank you, Eric in Montana
-
I'm sorry but if a tune is being played in B on chanters in B then the tune is in B and there is no need for transposition in my world. Yes this is very confusing.
Aaaargh! Luke is talking about the accordion doing the transposing. It's the box player who would have to transpose down a minor third on the fly.
Luke, I think Al must be winding us up.
-
Ha ha, I think you're right man, I've got a funny desire to go and play a few tunes on the B row now tho, maybe something good'll come of it ;D ;)
-
on the fly transposition that is difficult.
Right, and the box player is the only one in that scenario who is having to do it.
-
True. Doing that stuff *on the fly* is hard. Amen. KuuumBAAyaaa...
-
Right, and the box player is the only one in that scenario who is having to do it.
[/quote]
HUZZAH!! ;D ;D ;D
-
A lot of this (and a lot of the surrounding confusion) is to do with pitch - and not key...
With Uilleann Pipes in Bb, B or C, the keynote is regarded as pitch - i.e. it is regarded as D. Not concert pitch D, just as relative pitch D. Everything accompanying a 'flat' piper needs to be able to move relatively, and with the same agility to this pitch. It ain't just a case of scooting up and down the B row... ::)
As regards fiddles... OK so with the relative technical ability one can dash off a reel in B on G-D-A-E stringing, but it's going to sound different. But tuning a fiddle down to E-B-F#-C# or Eb-Bb-F-C or whatever ensures the instrument rings/resounds around the agreed pitch. What is more, it adds a 'half-way-to-a-viola' chocolate profundity to the sound... 8)
Like this... (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uNhkRQB6rwg) then again, all those resonator strings help... 8)
Tico, Tico in B (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lU7tt8BSe-c) - marvellous playing!
AL
Er... well, that's 'cos Dermot's using a C#/D (where the fingering on a B/C puts you a tone lower... in A) so not completely of the wall... ::)
-
chocolate profundity
What a great album that was. Bootsy Collins, Bernie Worrell...
Are ya with me, C.C.?
-
Er... well, that's 'cos Dermot's using a C#/D (where the fingering on a B/C puts you a tone lower... in A) so not completely of the wall...
The recording I linked to sounds like it's in B to me eeJay? I've been wrong before ...go on tell me I'm wrong I can take it ;D
With Uilleann Pipes in Bb, B or C, the keynote is regarded as pitch - i.e. it is regarded as D. Not concert pitch D, just as relative pitch D. Everything accompanying a 'flat' piper needs to be able to move relatively, and with the same agility to this pitch. It ain't just a case of scooting up and down the B row...
AT LAST....I've gotten an answer that sounds good to my cloth ears! So actually the pipes aren't playing the key of B at all? Which makes a bit more sense. Well as much sense as saying that pipes in Bb, B or C, the keynote is...regarded as D
again, this is even more confusing, but interesting?????
;D
-
Er... well, that's 'cos Dermot's using a C#/D (where the fingering on a B/C puts you a tone lower... in A) so not completely of the wall...
The recording I linked to sounds like it's in B to me eeJay? I've been wrong before ...go on tell me I'm wrong I can take it ;D
The fingering for B on a Csharp/D is the same as the fingering for A on a B/C...i.e. not too hard. I used to play tico tico in B on a B/C, it's actually alright to play.
-
Sorry - gotcha now! Lord I'm slow tonight. But it's definately in B isn't it - regardless of what buttons he's pushing???
;D
-
Oh aye, tis surely! :||: (:)
-
I'm guessing that the difficulty in playing in new keys is that a B/C box is not chromatic in a useful way. On a B/C box each key requires new fingering and ornamentation.
Thank you, Eric in Montana
Eric, you understood perfectly my point! (:)
-
Oh aye, tis surely!
Phew thank God for that...thought I was really losing the plot!
;)
-
Bb, B or C, the keynote is...regarded as D
again, this is even more confusing, but interesting?????
No, not confusing. The pipes are fixed pitch... and as such, work best around their pitch centre. Therefore, the compass of the surrounding instruments that can shift (or be made/modified to suit... like a box...) will be moved to suit.
So it sounds like B. But strictly speaking, it isn't B. It's regarded as the pitch of the pipes... and as such, for brevity, the names of keys are used relative to the pitch.
It's a complicated subject, and is related to the long history of musical pitch development / normalisation / notation / etc. For sake of confusing myself I'll shut up now... :Ph
The whole subject drives you bonkers when you have perfect pitch... ::)
Ed J
-
The whole subject drives you bonkers when you have perfect pitch...
Oh I know, I know... 8)
-
I'm guessing that the difficulty in playing in new keys is that a B/C box is not chromatic in a useful way. On a B/C box each key requires new fingering and ornamentation.
Thank you, Eric in Montana
Eric, you understood perfectly my point! (:)
Your point??? Hahaha!
I think if you had the remotest understanding of what any of this is about, you wouldn't have started this thread.
-
I'm guessing that the difficulty in playing in new keys is that a B/C box is not chromatic in a useful way. On a B/C box each key requires new fingering and ornamentation.
Thank you, Eric in Montana
Eric, you understood perfectly my point! (:)
Your point??? Hahaha!
I think if you had the remotest understanding of what any of this is about, you wouldn't have started this thread.
Second that. Apparently Irish box players don't play in C and can't play in a "real" chromatic way. Do you know what that means? I don't.
-
I think if you had the remotest understanding of what any of this is about, you wouldn't have started this thread.
I think I have it now Steve... if you don't understand, don't ask the question....
very helpful... not!
Not everyone is blessed with acquired knowledge but there are folks out there wanting to learn... the last thing they need is having their question rubbished by folks that lack the ability to explain in terms that they can understand.
I think if you do not have the remotest understanding of how people learn and their needs as learners you shouldn't attempt to try and help as you may cause more damage than good
On a lighter note ( :-*) thanks Eric, I found your comment helpful, specifically ...each key requires new fingering and ornamentation.
-
Not everyone is blessed with acquired knowledge but there are folks out there wanting to learn... the last thing they need is having their question rubbished by folks that lack the ability to explain in terms that they can understand.
Yes I could have said something gentler but irritation got the better of me because a) I don't see any indication in the OP that Miklos understood what Eric (quite correctly) said and b) I said more or less the same thing as Eric in the second paragraph of my first response - which was in fact a careful attempt to explain the issue in terms that Miklos could understand. Obviously didn't do a good enough job, but there.
Now instead of acknowledging that attempt on my part Miklos chooses to say, in effect, "ah, at last someone who understands what I'm on about." Whereas, from my point of view, if he did understand what Eric said, he wouldn't have made the original post, because he would have understood why the B/C player didn't join in with the B session.
Enough.
-
Here's a simple example. Suppose I have a C harmonica and the song is in C.. Well unless it's a Melody Maker Lee Oskar, I really don't want to play a C harmonica, it sounds hokey. A special tuned F harmonica will deliver a much better result. A normal one in F will deliver a decent C blues (Or Gm- theres other positions as well) I think our B/C player just doesn't want to play along the row in B any more than I would enjoy playing a B tune on a B harmonica. A lot of the soul of harmonica comes from pull positions, not blowing or push positions.
B/C has nothing to do with implying the main tonality of the instrument, where it's strengths will lie. It's the basic pallet to cross the rows for stronger keys.
Anyway this is my opinion, if I'm wrong, I can take it ;D
ps Each key does require a new pattern on a chromatic harmonica, but once you learn, they are easier. Some are more pull, some or more push, others a mish mosh of both. Adds to the charm.
-
Here's a simple example....(...) ;D
Thanks Steve, I get the picture ;)
-
Maybe the said b/c player didn't know the tunes that were being played??? Did this person actually say " I am not playing because I can't play in B"?
I've spent around 3 seconds browsing through the roundabouts & swings of this thread. I've probably missed a lot.
There is no excuse for not being able to play in any key on a chromatic instrument. If you a want to play any instrument, you should learn to play it right. No matter what the instrument is. If that means going in & out like a $%£* in a *&^&house then thats what you have to do. You choose the instrument, you have to stick it.
There's also absolutly no excuse for fiddlers retuning their fiddles. Cheating sods.
As for anyone who plays B/C, wasn't the first thing you learned the C scale? Same on the other row. Plus you CAN cross rows with B. You have doubles for B and E, use them.
-
There is no excuse for not being able to play in any key on a chromatic instrument. If you a want to play any instrument, you should learn to play it right. No matter what the instrument is. If that means going in & out like a $%£* in a *&^&house then thats what you have to do. You choose the instrument, you have to stick it.
There's also absolutly no excuse for fiddlers retuning their fiddles. Cheating sods.
As for anyone who plays B/C, wasn't the first thing you learned the C scale? Same on the other row. Plus you CAN cross rows with B. You have doubles for B and E, use them.
No, the first thing I learned was the D scale. I was taught it as it's the home scale of Irish music - I play around 15-25 tunes in C and however many hundred in D. The issue in this thread is that the musician in question was unable to transpose on the spot into the key of B from D, which in fairness is a skill in itself. It's not about being able to play in B in general, which isn't really a problem as you say yourself.
To defend fiddlers I think the point has already been made that playing in B in standard tuning doesn't have the same character as playing tuned down, tuning down gives the open strings etc, plus it is once again transposition on the spot that's the problem.
There is no excuse for not being able to play in any key on a chromatic instrument. If you a want to play any instrument, you should learn to play it right. No matter what the instrument is. If that means going in & out like a $%£* in a *&^&house then thats what you have to do. You choose the instrument, you have to stick it.
While I personally can play in any key on the B/C I don't think that amateur musicians who play in a tradition where tunes aren't pitched in certain keys EVER (excepting when using very rare flat or sharp pitched instruments) can be critcised too heavily from not spending all there time learning to play in all keys. After all, it is a skill that will be VERY rarely exercised so maybe the practice time is better spent learning and practicing tunes in the common keys of ITM.
"Play it right?"
edit - typo
-
I like LDBosca's last comment very much, although it took me a minute to realize he was saying that players should not be criticized for not being able to play in unusual keys. It somehow seems difficult to phrase that sentiment so it cannot be read two ways. I don't think I have quite achieved it either.
But speaking of criticism, I do think the tone in some of the postings could be more genial. I love melodeon.net but I love it best when people are gently helpful rather than confrontational. As the old saying goes, we are all on a continuum from ignorance to expertise.
-
Is it just me? I seem to get the feeling from this thread and others that the D/G crowd are much less rule and convention bound than the 1/2 step crowd. We seem more tolerant of each others foibles, even when they are clearly wrong ;)
Not sure if this is a half step thing or an Irish music thing as I get depressed about the rantings on The Session (http://www.thesession.org/) about right and wrong in the music.
So guys, there is no right and no wrong just different!
Will go back to my happy friendly D/G world, bye!
-
Is it just me? I seem to get the feeling from this thread and others that the D/G crowd are much less rule and convention bound than the 1/2 step crowd. We seem more tolerant of each others foibles, even when they are clearly wrong ;)
Not sure if this is a half step thing or an Irish music thing as I get depressed about the rantings on The Session (http://www.thesession.org/) about right and wrong in the music.
So guys, there is no right and no wrong just different!
Funny you should say that, Lester. I was just thinking the same.....
Will go back to my happy friendly D/G world, bye!
See you there, then. Mine's a pint of IPA.
Oh - I'll bring my one-row box too; we can have us some nice East Anglian toons.
-
Will go back to my happy friendly D/G world, bye!
Although I am struggling with BCC# can I join you?
-
So guys, there is no right and no wrong just different!
Too right. ::)
You choose the instrument, you have to stick it.
Oh no you don't. 8)
There's also absolutly no excuse for fiddlers retuning their fiddles. Cheating sods.
Fiddlers have been doing it for donkey's years. And proper violinists occasionally... :o
Ed J
-
Will go back to my happy friendly D/G world, bye!
D/G = UTOPIA! As an examination of all the threads on this forum will undoubtedly prove!
;D
-
Will go back to my happy friendly D/G world, bye!
D/G = UTOPIA! As an examination of all the threads on this forum will undoubtedly prove!
;D
Don't think I said that either, just it's a more forgiving place.
-
See you there, then. Mine's a pint of IPA.
Oh - I'll bring my one-row box too; we can have us some nice East Anglian toons.
I'll drop in too... Bathams Best please... :|glug
One row in C is that? Righto... might drop the 'ol sawhorse down to F-C-G-D for a bit... ;D
Ed J
-
There's also absolutly no excuse for fiddlers retuning their fiddles. Cheating sods.
Back in your box, Graeme.
-
[ ]
Don't think I said that either, just it's a more forgiving place.
Well said Lester! box playing is about enjoyment ( no point in playing otherwise) and in the main box players are a friendly lot . As to the agonising over 'correctness' that may be seen as fun by some individuals but certainly not by me. An important part of the pleasure of playing is to put our own individual stamp on a tune rather than to try & be a clone of Somebuggerorother. What can be the fun in playing session tune number 595 in the way the tune book says and being critical of those who choose to do it a bit differently.
I have no idea whether this waspishness is a BC thing or an Irish session thing but it has definately lowered the tone of this forum which I find a bit sad. Does playing a DG promote a better sense of humour than playing a BC? if so I'm not sure where that puts me as I play both plus the one with the turd row!
keep smiling
george ;D ;D ;D
-
Does playing a DG promote a better sense of humour than playing a BC?
Let's face it you have to have a good sense of humour to play a fourth apart box and try to work around the limitations, some of the members here do it exceedingly well. ;D :||: :M
-
FORMAL APOLOGY:
I would like to formally apologise to my Irish Traditional Music Playing friends for inadvertantly winding them up. My inability to understand why a BC box player doesn't join in a Session that is played mainly in the key of B remains, possibly until I am promoted to Glory or some such other place. But nonetheless I feel I should apologise, especially to my long suffering fellow forum member Steve Jones who despite his very best efforts has been unable to educate me in the fine arts of ITM. Now I don't even remember why I asked such a stupid question in the first place - as I knew darn well that I wouldn't get an answer that I could understand. As I pointed out in a previous post - that's my problem and no-one else's. It's the result of having a distorted musical upbringing.
So I'm sorry if folk got wound up with my musical obtuseness. Perhaps we can now move on with the much happier buiness of this forum of slagging-off PA players talking about and sharing the music and boxes we all love to play?
Kind and Sincere Regards!
AL
-
So I'm sorry if folk got wound up with my musical obtuseness.
In other words - Sorry for being a bit thick...? ;)
Nah, s'alright... ;D It's trying to explain it clearly where the confusion sometimes gets worse... ;D
It's all this asking, quizzing and questioning that does this forum a heap of good... like a petulant 4 year old just keeps asking why why why why?
All the melodeon like objects in the world demand some reason and justification for existence, and understanding of the context in which they were devised, and subsequently come to be used. It's a minefield that I expect no-one would dare claim to have absolute knowledge over...
Come to think of it, there's another arcane pitch (not key) example that springs to mind... which Theo might have more experience/encounters with/of (or SteveD for that matter)... Northumbrian pipes pitched to an indeterminate semi F to F#ish...
Now why this came about... it's back to the arcanities of pitch development / normalisation I'd guess. Certainly, if you're a fiddler, you'd be compelled to retune to play along... and gawd help the box players... ::)
Ed J
-
Come to think of it, there's another arcane pitch (not key) example that springs to mind... which Theo might have more experience/encounters with/of (or SteveD for that matter)... Northumbrian pipes pitched to an indeterminate semi F to F#ish...
Section 4 of this page (http://www.nspipes.co.uk/barry/guide.htm) gives a good summary of the pitches of Northumbrian Smallpipes, and includes my favourite quote from a pipe maker:
Concert G – very good for sessions and band work with intolerant musicians.
-
I play both plus the one with the turd row!
:o ooeeerrr, that would be a bit messy. ;)
Its all this asking, quizzing and questioning that does this forum a heap of good... like a petulant 4 year old just keeps asking why why why why?
What about a petulant 23 year old? I think that's my problem with music..I keep asking Why over and over. lol!
-
Asking why is a good life skill, but with age you sometimes are less likely to ask out loud!
-
I've just read this thread for the first time. To me, Miki's original question was quite involved, and the answer would probably need to be a whole book about Irish box-playing.
I don't think there was any implied criticism of the box-player for not playing in B. This was created in subsequent posts. The question was why Irish box-players play B/Cs.
I don't want to stir things up again, but....to me, the answer lies not in the keys, but in the style. It's possible to play any box, regardless of tuning, in a wide variety of styles, but that doesn't mean everybody learns every style. Most people only learn the style(s) appropriate to their needs, and often that is just one style.
Playing Irish music isn't about playing Irish tunes in certain keys, it's about how you play the tunes with the right expression, ornamentation etc to give the tune the right "feel". Irish players have found semitone boxes to be generally the most suitable, and to understanding the reason for this requires an understanding of Irish music styles. That isn't to say that Irish can only be played on semitone boxes, of course, but most players have found playing "on the row" doesn't produce the best results, and so don't learn it.
As for box-player in the session, she is evidently an expert in her own style, and why does she need to do more? Asking her to play the tunes in B would be a bit like giving some of us on this forum a B/C box and asking them to go out and play with the local morris side! With a bit of practice many of us would pick out the tunes in their usual keys of G,D etc, but would the end result be worth the effort?
-
Without wishing to kick-start any arguing, I think any original animosity was started by the undertone of "why are they using B/C when they really can't do it properly" (real or imagined or interpreted...) and may have been perpetuated by some of the comments that echoed this by saying "well why can't you play in B etc, it's just a one row" etc.... Which is of course fair enough when one genuinely doesn't understand. It's probably defensiveness on the part of B/C players (and to the D/G crowd Irish musicians are very often quite defensive about our music, I suppose that comes with good and bad), the whole confusion over why the original musician did baffle me a bit.
I think there's lesson in language or something here. Maybe the first post wasn't meant to be critical at all and it was just picked up that way, it's a bit tricky with this internet business...like with txts and all that. Also, I didn't realise that I was assuming certain knowledge before I stated tearing into explanations.
Will go back to my happy friendly D/G world, bye!
Ah we're alright when you get to know us... ;) I wouldn't condone the use of D/G accordions to escape is anyway.... hehheh
-
FORMAL APOLOGY ... I feel I should apologise, especially to my long suffering fellow forum member Steve Jones
I think that should read "waspish and irritable," Al! No apology is necessary, except from me to you, Miki and any others whose feathers I've ruffled. I beg your indulgence.
I just spent a good few minutes writing an attempt to explain why my hackles sometimes get raised in the face of attitudes towards Irish music and Irish box playing from all you good-natured D/G players - and then scrapped it. I'll just say that throughout this exchange and in his last contribution LDBosca has said everything I was trying to say, only better, and much more diplomatically too.
Cheers
Steve
PS I'm chuckling to myself since here in this thread I am defending B/C players against the undertones that LD mentioned when most of the time I'm defending C#/D players against the attitudes of certain B/C players. I don't play your instrument but I'll defend your right to play it to the death! ;D
-
Seems like a good place to stop!