Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: komat on February 19, 2024, 06:49:04 PM
-
Anybody have any idea what reeds would most likely have been used by Saltarelle in their more recent Nuages? I’m trying to pin down a make to order some replacement middle reeds to swap in for the current low octave set in a LMM C#D. I’ve attached a photo of the current reeds which show no distinctive maker’s markings, just the etch on the corners. Cagnoni?
-
They do indeed have the look of Cagnoni reeds to me
-
The line in the corner is used on most Italian made reeds. Cagnioni are the reeds that Saltarelle have used as standard over many decades. If you look at the low bass reeds you may see a C cast into the metal if they are Cagnoni. The ones in the photo ar tipo a mano.
-
How does one distinguish between tipo a mano and a mano?
-
As a general rule of thumb, a manos have got blued edges on the heel of the reed, while tipos are not blued.
Of course, old school a manos (that were genuinely made entirely by hand and file) will not necessarily have blued edges.
Afaik, the only significance of the bluing is that if you're hand-making them, you're saving yourself a lot of time if you start from appropriately-sized steel strip as opposed to cutting your own strips from sheet steel.
You have to realise that these days it's more of a marketing term and I doubt that reed makers can convincingly explain the difference between 101 grades of their a mano and tipo reeds apart from ones being a lot more expensive than the others, and a manos having tighter reed fit tolerance (not that it matters that much when it comes to a melodeon, imho).
A mano, in general, assumes that more care was taken when making the reed, and the reedmaker's expertise allowed him to perfect the reed response & timbre, but it's just an assumption.
I would have thought that for a mano reeds, each note will have its own reed size and no costs will be cut in grouping reeds and using same size for 3-4notes, but that is not the case in my Excelsior CBA with Cagnoni a mano reeds - i.e. they are still size-grouped. Not that I ever felt that this grouping was affecting their performance, which is an interesting observation.
-
My Cagnoni reeds look similar but mine have the Cagnoni on the second reed plate.
These are Bb A Mano Bombata.
-
if you contact martin quinn he is main agent in ireland for saltarelle he will know what reeds are used in your box
-
For the sake of posterity, I'm posting a link to comments made from Saltarelle's owner regarding the reeds they use in their boxes. According to him, their boxes always use Cagnoni reeds as their standard unless otherwise requested by a client. A-Mano (rather than TAM) is used in their Nuages. He also mentions that Cagnoni generally does not 'sign' their reeds with a label or stamp, despite being asked by Saltarelle to do so.
https://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=21254.100