Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Dick Wolff on February 28, 2024, 04:33:06 PM
-
Anyone out there got a Beltuna Samuel 3 A/D/G instrument they might sell - or seen one anywhere else? Beltuna have run out of stock and are having to build from scratch.
I've greatly enjoyed playing my Alex 3 2½ row in D/G for the last 8 years but a few months ago I bought a Hohner A/D/G Rey del Vallenato to play for morris, since it's very much lighter. (The Alex has lovely basses but it makes it far too heavy to play standing up all day.) I had the Hohner bass end customised so that it was (more or less) the same as the Alex's D/G bass end - with a G pull, A push and a Bm pull replacing the F pull (in place of the normal chords for playing in A). But I didn't do anything to the right hand end.
It's been such a success that I've decided to 'upgrade' to a similarly customised three-row A/D/G Beltuna Samuel 3. But this time I can take the time to make sure the right hand end has the accidentals I want, which are not the accidentals that would come with an instrument designed for playing in A as well as D and G. Since I'm largely a session musician I want to play - but with greater flexibility - in D and G major and E minor, but also be able to get by in Dm, Gm and Bm - so F and C naturals and Bb and Eb/D# are essential.
Anyone else done this? I'm attaching the 'work in progress'. And again - anyone seen a Samuel 3 for sale anywhere?
-
Would you keep the Alex as a D/G box ? Are you using the half row of accidentals a lot ?
-
I use the half row of accidentals a fair bit, but mostly for 7ths and 'blue notes' - not to play in different minor keys. Before that I had a Saltarelle Connemara 2½ row whose ½ row was configured differently, and I still get confused. Basically I've not sat down and worked it out properly.
This time I've thought it through and arranged the accidentals so that the pattern for Gm and Dm are the samse is the same for the G and D row.
-
I might be looking to sell my A/D/G Samuel 3 in the next few weeks. In two minds at the moment it is very nice but I don’t play it enough. It’s in very good condition. It currently has a standard layout low note on the G row and accidentals on the D and A row. If it’s any interest let me know and I’ll sort out photos etc.
-
Thanks. I've been communicating with Beltuna and found out yesterday that they would not do a reconfiguration of an existing model if I was able to find one (I had asked them whether they would do that, given the 10 months waiting time). So a few hours ago I placed an order for a new one on the configuration that I have designed. I've never seen a Samuel 3 in the UK so it is interesting to know that they exist. I'm sure you should have no trouble finding a buyer.
-
This time I've thought it through and arranged the accidentals so that the pattern for Gm and Dm are the samse is the same for the G and D row.
I had the impression that the layout tried to be two things at once and would perhaps not achieve these two things equally well (but it also could, it's hard to tell), but as is often the case for our instruments, it's just a matter of compromise: it looks that this set-up will suit you and that's what's matter! And if that doesn't work, any tuner can change the layout at your request if need be, so it's no big deal in any case.
Out of curiosity, what's the expected delivery time these day for Beltuna?
-
I don't know about delivery time for other models but I've been given a 10 month wait for the Samuel 3. They've run out of 'cases' (that is, the structural box of the instruments, presumably including bellows and reed blocks). It seems a bit negligent of them to let it get to the point of running out completely, but perhaps they needed to wait until they had a big enough batch to make it cost effective to make them. I don't know how long Samuel 3s have been around. I've never seen one. Maybe it was a newly introduced model and it has sold better than they expected.